Abstract
Marx's socialism conceives of a society of free producers excluding private property in the means of production, commodity relations, wage labor and state. Lenin's socialism, while excluding commodity production, does not entirely eliminate wage labor and is based on state ownership of the means of production, identified with social ownership. Lenin's socialism thus turns out to be very different from Marx's emancipatory project of Association.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Althusser, L.
1965 . Pour Marx . Paris : Maspero .
2.
Bettelheim, Ch
. 1970 . Calcul 9conomique etformes de propriiel . Paris : Maspero .
3.
della Volpe, G.
1956 . Rousseau e Marx e altri saggi di critica materialistica . Rome : Editori Riuniti .
4.
Dobb, M.
1966 . Political Economy and Capitalism . London : Routledge and K. Paul .
5.
Elliott, J.
1976 . Marx and the contemporary Models of Socialist Economy . History of Political Economy , Summer .
6.
Horvat, B.
1982 . The Political Economy of Socialism . New York : M.E. Sharpe .
7.
Kagarlitsky, B.
1990 . The Dialectic of Change . London : Verso .
8.
Lange, O.
1945 . Marxian Economics in the Soviet Union . American Economic Review , March .
9.
Lenin, V.I.
1962 . Pervonachal nyi variant stati ocherednye zadachi sovetskoi vlasti (1918)
Polnoe Sobranie Sochinenii (hereafter PSS) Vol. 36. Moscow .
10.
Lenin, V.I.
. 1963a . Proekt programmyi RKP (B) (1919) . PSS Vol. 38, Moscow .
11.
Lenin, V.I.
1963b . Doklad o subbotnikakh na Moskovskoi obshchegarodskoikonferentsii RKP (B) (1919)
PSS , Vol. 40, Moscow .
12.
Lenin, V.I.
. 1964a . Nakaz ot STO mestnym sovetskim uchrezhdeniyam (1921)
PSS 43. Moscow .
13.
Lenin, V.I.
. 1964b . VII Moskovskaya Gubpartconferentsiya (1921) . PSS 44. Moscow .
14.
Lenin, V.I.
. 1971 . Tax in Kind (1921) . Selected Works (hereafter SW) 3. Moscow .
15.
Lenin, V.I.
. the Importance of Gold (1921)
SW 3 Moscow .
16.
Lenin, V.I.
. On co-operation (1923)
SW 3 Moscow .
17.
Lenin, V.I.
. 1975 . The State and Revolution (1917) . SWII . Moscow .
18.
Lenin, V.I.
. the Tasks of the Proletariat in Our Revolution (1917) . SW II. Moscow .
19.
Lenin, V.I.
1975. Speech at the First All-Russia Congress of Economic Councils (1918) SW I . Moscow .
20.
Lenin, V.I.
. 1982a . Gosudarstvo i revoliutsia (1917) . Izbrannye Proizvedeniya (hereafter IP) 2. Moscow .
21.
Lenin, V.I.
. Zadachi prolerariata v nashei revoliutsi (1917) , IP 2. Moscow .
22.
Lenin, V.I.
. 1982a . Rech'na I vserossiskom c'ezde sovetov narodnogo khozyaistva (1918) . IP 2 Moscow .
23.
Lenin, V.I.
. 1982b
o prodovol'stvennom naloge (1921)
IP 3 . Moscow .
24.
Lenin, V.I. o znachenii zolota (1921) IP 3. Moscow.
25.
Lenin, V.I. o kooperatsii (1923) IP 3. Moscow.
26.
Lukacs, G. 1971. Zur Ontologie des geselschaftlichen Seins I: Die gegenwartige Problemlage IV: Die ontologischen Grundprinzipien von Manx. Berlin: H. Luchterhand Verlag.
27.
Mandel, E.
1986 . Traite d'Economie Marxiste . Paris : Ch. Bourgeois .
28.
Marx, K. 1953. Grundrisse der Kritik derpolitischen 6konomie. (1857-58) Berlin: Dietz.
29.
Marx, K. 1956, 1962 b. Theorien aber den Mehrwen I , HI, Berlin: Dietz.
30.
Marx, K. 1958a. Zur Kridik der politischen Okonomie. (1859) Berlin: Dietz.
31.
Marx, K.
. 1958b . Die Heilige Familie. (1845) Marx, K., Engels, F. Were (hereafter MEW) 2. Berlin . Dietz .
32.
Marx, K. 1962a, 1973a, 1964. Das Kapital I , H, III. Berlin Dietz.
33.
Marx, K.
1962c . Randglossen zu Adolph Wagners Lehrbuch... (1880)
MEW 19. Berlin : Dietz .
34.
Marx, K. 1965. Oeuvres: Economie I. Paris: Gallimard.
35.
Marx, K. 1966a. Okonomisch-philosophische Manuskripte (1844 ) and Aus den Exzerptheften... (1844). Marx-Engels -Studienausgabe hereinafter MESA ) 2. Frankfurt am Main: Fischer.
36.
Marx, K.
1966b . Kritik des Gothaer Programms (1875) . MESA 3. Frankfurt : Fischer .
37.
Marx, K. 1969. Resultate des unmittelbaren Produkuionsprozesses (1863-65). Frankfurt: Neue Kritik.
38.
Marx, K.
1970 . `Preface' to the `Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy' (1859) and `Critique of the Gotha Programme' (1875) . Marx, K., Engels, F. Selected Works (in one volume). Moscow .
39.
Marx (and Engels)
1971 . On the Paris Commune . Moscow .
40.
Marx, K. 1972. Letter to Engels, January 8, and to Kugelmann July 11 (1868). Marx, K., Engels F. Briefe iaber `Das Kapital' Erlangen. Politladen.
41.
Marx, K.
1973b . Die Deutsche Ideologie(1846) MEW 3. Berlin : Dietz .
42.
Marx, K.
1973c . `Konspekt von Bakunins Buch...' (1875)
MEW 18. Berlin : Dietz .
43.
Marx, K. 1976a. Zur Kritik der politischen Okonomie. (1861-63). Marx, K., Engels, F. Gestamtausgabe 2 Abt. B. 3/1 Berlin: Dietz.
44.
Marx, K.
1976b . `Kritische Randglossen...' (1844)
MEW 1 Berlin : Dietz .
45.
Marx, K.
. 1978a, 1984a, 1984b . Capital I, II, III. Moscow .
46.
Marx, K.
1978b, 1978c , Theories of Surplus Value I, HI. Moscow .
47.
Miliband, R.
1991 . Socialism in Question . Monthly Review:
March .
48.
Nove, A.
1983 . The Economics of Feasible Socialism . London : George Allen and Unwin .
49.
Oilman, B.
1978 . Marx's Vision of Communism . Critique , No. 8 .
50.
Rosdolsky, R. 1968. Zur Enstehungsgeschichte des Marxchen `Kapital' El. Frankfurt am Main: Europaische Verlagsanstalt.
51.
Scott-Arnold, N.
and
D. Schweikart
. 1987 . In, Economics and Philosophy: No. 3 .
52.
Shkredov, V.V. 1973. Metod issledovaniya sobtvennost v `Kapitale' K. Marksa. Moscow.
53.
Sweezy, P.M.
1980 . Post Revolutionary Society . New York : MR. Press .
54.
Szamuely, L.
1974 . First Models of the Socialist Economic System . Budapest : Akademiai Kiado .
55.
Weeks, J.
1981 . Capital and Exploitation . Princton : Princeton University Press .
56.
Wiles, P.
1962 . The Political Economy of Communism . Oxford .