A Monetary Labor Theory of Value

Abstract

A critical survey of the recent literature on the labor theory of value is offered, focusing upon the view of Marnian labor theory of value as a macroeconomic theory of exploitation within the money circuit of capita L The traditional and the 'new" solutions of the so-called transformation problem are rejected, and it is argued that the purely monetary reading of value and the revived clasical Marxist approach have mirror-like weaknesses. The paper claims that Rubin's insight - that in the end value is created in exchange but that the substance of value is latently present in production - can be pursued within a theory of money as a symbol. In this perspective the concept of exploitation as the extraction of surplus labor can be seen to be compatible with the concept of a non-commodity money. This reading of abstract labor theory of value argues that the quantitative aspect of Manes argument is relevant not for the setting of prices of production but rather for shedding light on the actual process of incessant change in the economic structure.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Backhaus, Hans Geor& 1969. Zur Dialektik der Wertform. Gesellschaft. Beitraege zur Marxstischen Erkmentnistheoric I(1).

Bellofiore, Riccardo . 1985a. Marx after Schumpeter. Capital and Class VIII(24): 60-74.

Bellofiore, Riccardo . 1985b. Money and Development in Schumpeter. Review of Radical Political Economics XVII(1-2): 21-40.

Bellofiore, Riccardo (ed.). 1986. Tra teoria economics e grande cultura europea: Piero Sraffa. Milan: Angeli.

Bellofiore, Riccardo . 1987. Teoria del valore e circuito monetario. Un percorso ed una proposta. Metamorfosi 11(4): 131-159.

Bellofiore, Riccardo . 1988. Wickse I l4 Keynes, Schumpeter. The conceptual roots of the monetary theory of production. (mimeo)

Bellofiore Riccardo . 1989. Intervento. In WVAA., Piero Sraffa e l'economia politica degli anni ottanta. Milan: Bocconi-Comunicazione.

Benetti, Carlo. 1975. Valeur et repartition. Paris: PUG-Maspero.

Benetti, Carlo. 1987. La teoria della moneta-merce in Marx Metamorfosi 11(5): 37-65. French version as: La theorie de la monnaie-marchandise chez Marx. Cahiers deconomie politique (13): 19-46.

10.

Benetti, Carlo , Berthomieu, Claude and Cartelier, Jean . 1975. Economic classique, economic vulgaire. Paris: PUG-Maspero.

11.

Benetti, Carlo, Cartelier, Jean and de Brunhoff, Suzanne. 1976. Elements pour une critique marxiste de P. Sraffa. Cahiers d'economic politique 11(3): 29-35.

12.

Benetti, Carlo - Cartelier, Jean. 1980. Marchands, salariat et capitalistes. Paris: Maspero.

13.

Bidet, Jacques. 1985. Que faire du Capital? Materiaux pour une refondation. Paris: Klinsieck.

14.

Bidet, Jacques. 1986. Socialisation et abstraction. Cahiers d'economie politique (12): 175-182

15.

Chavance, Bernard (ed.). 1985. Marx en perspective. Paris: Editions de l'Ecole des Haute Etudes en Sciences Sociales.

16.

Chiodi, Guglielmo and Messori, Marcello . 1984. Marx's Analysis of the Relationship Between the Rate of Interest and the Rate of Profits: A Comment. Cambridge Journal of Economics VIII (1): 93-97.

17.

Ciccone, Roberto . 1987. Accumulation and Capacity Utilization. Some Critical Considerations on Joan Robinson's Theory of Distribution. Political Economy II(1): 17-35.

18.

Colletti, Lucio . 1977. Some Comments on Marx's Theory of Value. In Schwartz ed. 458-473.

19.

de Brunhoff, Suzanne . 1967. La monnaic chce Marn Paris: Editions Sociales.

20.

de Brunhoff, Suzanne . 1973. Marx as an A-Ricardian: Value, Money and Price at the Beginning of Capital. Economy and Society 11(4): 421-430.

21.

de Brunhoff, Suzanne . 1979. Lea rapports d'argent Paris: Maspero.

22.

Desai, Meghnad . 1981. Testing Monetarism. London: Pinter.

23.

Desai, Meginad . 1987. Profit and Profit Theory. In, The New Palgrave Dictionary of Politicol Economy. London: Macmillan. III: 1014-1021.

24.

De Vroey, Michel . 1981. Value, Production and Exchange. In Steedman et al. 173-201.

25.

De Vroey, Michel. 1985. La t W eorie marxiste de la valeur, version travail abstrait. Un bilan critique. In Chavance ed. 385-417 and in Dostaler, Laguex eds. 31-57. Italian translation in W.AA.: 143-176.

26.

Dobb, Maurice . 1955. A Note on the Transformation Problem. In, On Economic Theory and Socialism. London.

27.

Dobb, Maurice . 1961. An Epoch-Making Book Labor Monthl, October.

28.

Dobb, Maurice . 1973. Theories of Value and Distribution since Adam Smith Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

29.

Dostaler, Gilles. 1978. Vakur et pnxi Histoire d'un debatL Paris: PUG-Maspero.

30.

Dostaler, Gilles and Laguex, Maurice (eds.). 1985. Un echiquier centenair& Paris: La Decouverte.

31.

Dumenil, Gerard. 1980. De la valeur aux prir de production. Paris: Economica.

32.

Dumdnil, Gerard . 198344. Beyond the Transformation Riddle: A Labor Theory of Value. Science and Society XLVII(4): 427-450.

33.

Duminil, Gerard . 1984. The So-Called 'Transformation Problem' Revisited: A Brief Comment. Journal of Economic Theory XXXIII (2): 340-348.

34.

Ehrbar, Hans and Glick, Mark . 1986-87. The Labor Theory of Value and Its Critics. Science and Society L(4): 464-478

35.

Eldred, Michael and Hanlon, Marnie . 1981. Reconstructing Value-Form Analysis. Capital and Class V(13): 24-60.

36.

Eldred, Michael . 1984. Reply to Gleicher. Capital and Class (21): 135-140.

37.

Elson, Diane (ed.). 1979. Value, The Representation of Labor in Capitalism. London: CSE Books.

38.

Fischer, Norman . 1982. The Ontology of Abstract Labor. A Discussion of Labor: The Representation of Value under Capitalism, edited by Diane Elson . In W.AA. 27-35.

39.

Flaschel, Peter . 1984. The So-Called "Transformation Problem" Revisited: A Comment Journal of Economic Theoey XXXIII(2): 349-351.

40.

Foley, Duncan . 1982a. Realization and Accumulation in a Marxian Model of the Circuit of Capital. Journal of Economic Theory XXVIII(2): 300-319.

41.

Foley, Duncan . 1982b. The Value of Money, The Value of Labor Power, and the Marxian Transformation Problem. In W.AA 37-47.

42.

Foley, Duncan . 1983a. On Mares Theory of Money. In W.AA. 5-19.

43.

Foley, Duncan . 1983b. Money and Effective Demand in Marx's Scheme of Expanded Reproduction. In, Marxsm, Central Planning and the Soviet Economy: Essays in Honor of A lexander Erlich P. Desai ed. Cambridge: MIT Press, 19-33.

44.

Foley, Duncan . 1986a. Money, Accumulation and Crisis. New York: Harwood Academic.

45.

Foley, Duncan . 1986b. Understanding Capital Mawx's Economic Theory. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

46.

Garegnani, Pierangelo . 1981. Mar e gli economisti clossici Turin: Einaudi.

47.

Garegnani, Pierangelo . 1984. Value and Distribution in the Classical Economists and Marx Oxford Economic Papers XXXVI(2): 291-325.

48.

Garegnani, Pierangelo. 1985. La th W orie de la valeur-travail chez Marx et dans la tradition marxiste. In Chavance ed. 311-350.

49.

Garegnani, Pierangelo. 1986. Valore-lavoro e rapporto tra l'opera di Marx e quella di Ricardo: alcune riflessioni. In Mancina ed. 173-187.

50.

Gleicher, David . 1983. An historical approach to the question of abstract labor. Capital and Class (21): 97-122.

51.

Gleicher, David . 1985. Note: A Rejoinder to Eldred. Capital and Class (25): 147-155.

52.

Gleicher, David . 1986. The Ontology of Labor Values. Remarks on the Science and Society Value Symposium. Science and Society XLIX(4): 463-471.

53.

Glick, Mark and Ehrbar, Hans . 1987. The Transformation Problem: An Obituary. Australian Economic Papers XLVI(4): 294-317.

54.

Glick, Mark and Hunt, EK 1987. Transformation Problem. In, The New Palgrave Dictionary of Political Economy. London: Macmillan IV: 688-691.

55.

Graziani Augusto. 1978. L'analisi marxista e la struttura del capitalismo moderno. In W.AA., Storia del manrsmo. Turin: Einaudi. IV: 701-741.

56.

Graziani, Augusto. 1983a. Riabilitiamo la teoria del valore. In VV.AA, Marx alla fine del XX secolo. Suppl. a L'Unita (27.2 1983): iv.

57.

Graziani Augusto. 1983b. Moneta e credito. In, VV.AA., Kar M =a 1983-1883. n Contemporaneo. Suppl. di Rinascita (50-51): 26-27.

58.

Graziani Augusto . 1984. Keynes' Finance Motive. Economic Notes (1) 5-34.

59.

Graziani Augusto. 1986. La teoria della moneta in Mam In Mancina ed. (1986: 207-231.)

60.

Graziani Augusto . 1988a. Il circuito monetario. In, Marcello Messori ed. Moneta eproduzione. Turin: Einaudi: xi-xliii.

61.

Graziani, Augusto . 1988b. Schumpeter and Italian Economic Thought in the Inter-War Period.

62.

Graziani Augusto . 1989. The Theoiy of the Monetary Circuit. Thames Papers in Political Economy. Spring.

63.

Himmelweit and Mohun . 1978. The Anomalies of Capital. Capital and Class (7): 67-105.

64.

Hunt, Edward K. 1983. Joan Robinson and the Labor Theory of Value. Cambridge Journal of Political Economy VII(34): 331-342

65.

Itoh, Makoto . 1980. Value and Crisis. Essays in MAarian Economics in Japam London: Pluto Press.

66.

Krause, Ulrich . 1982 Money and Abstract Labor. London: Verso.

67.

Lipielz, Alain . 1982a. Credit Money: A Condition Permitting Inflationary Crisis. In WVAA 49-57.

68.

Lipietz, Alain . 1982b. The So-Called 'Transformation Problem" Revisited. Journal of Economic Theory XXVI(1): 59-48.

69.

Lipietz, Alain . 1984. The So-Called "Transformation Problem' Revisited: A Brief Reply to Brief Comments. Journal of Economic Theory XXXIII(2): 352-355.

70.

Lipielz, Main . 1985. The Enchanted World London: Verso.

71.

Lippi, Marco. 1975. Man t valore come costo sociae r P eal Milan: Etas Libri. English Translation: Value and Naturalism in Mamn London: New Left Books. 1979.

72.

Lunghini, Giorgio. 1975. Teoria economica ed economia politica. Note su Sraffa. In W.AA. Produzione, capitals e distribuzione. Milan: Isedi XI-XXVIII.

73.

Mandel, Ernest and Freeman, Alan (eds.). 1984. Ricardo, Man, Sraffa London: Verso.

74.

Mancina, Claudia (ed.). 1986. Marx e il mondo contempno. Rome: Editori Riuniti.

75.

May, Kenneth . 1948. Value and Price of Production: A Note on Winternitz's Solution. Economic Journal LVIII(4): 596-599.

76.

Medio, Alfredo . 1972 Profits and Surplus Value: Appearance and Reality in Capitalist Production. In, EK Hunt-Jesse G. Schwartz, A Cifique of Economic Themoy London: Penguin, 312-346.

77.

Medio, Alfredo . 1974. Neoclassicals, Neo-Ricardians, and Marn In Schwartz (ed.) (1977).

78.

Meek, Ronald . 1956. Some Notes on the Transformation Problem.'Economic J ournal LXVI(2): 94-107.

79.

Meek, Ronald . 1961. Mr Sraffa's Rehabilitation of Classical Economics. Science and Society. XXV(2): 139-156.

80.

Meek, Ronald . 1973. Studies in the Labor Theory of Value. London: Lawrence and Wishart

81.

Messori, Marcello. 1978. Sraffa la critica del'econornia politica. Milan: Angeli.

82.

Messori, Marcello. 1984. Teoria del valore senza merce-denaro? Considerazioni preliminari sull'analisi monetaria di Mar L Quadtemi di storia dell'economia politica II(1-2): 185-232.

83.

Messori, Marcello. 1986. Innovation et profit chez Marx, Schumpeter et Keynes. Cahiers de l'economie politique (10-11): 229-256.

84.

Napoleoni, Claudio. 1970. Saggio del profitto e quantita di lavoro. In, Napoleoni Claudio, Smith Ricardo Ma M s, 1 ed., Turin: Boringhieri, 210-214; and in Napoleoni (1974).

85.

Napoleoni Claudio. 1972a. Quale funzione ha avuto la "Rivista Trimestrale"?. Rinascita. (6 ottobre 31-32.

86.

Napoleoni, Claudio. 1972b. Lezioni sul Capitolo sesto inedito. Turin: Boringhieri. German translation as Napoleoni (1974).

87.

Napoleoni Claudio. 1973. "Prefazione alla seconda edizione." In Bianchi, Marina. La teoria del valore dai classici a Marx Bari: Laterza. xi-xii.

88.

Napoleoni, Claudio. 1974. Ricardo und Mam Frankfurt: Suhrkamp Verlag

89.

Napoleoni, Claudio . 1975. Smith Ricardo Mam Observations on the history of economic thought. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.

90.

Napoleoni Claudio . 1976. Valore. Milan: Isedi.

91.

Napoleoni, Claudio . 1978. Sraffa's Tabula Rasa. New Left Review (112): 75-77.

92.

Napoleoni, Claudio . 1985. Discorso sull'economia politica Turin: Boringhieri.

93.

Napoleoni, Claudio . 1989. The Place of Max in the History of Economic Thought. In, Giovanni Caravale (ed.), Marx and Moden Economic Analysis. Aldershot: Edward Elgar (forthcoming).

94.

Reuten Geert . 1988a. The Money Expression of Value and the Credit System: A Value-Form Theoretic Outline. Capial and Class (35): 121-141.

95.

Reuten Geert . 1988b. Value as Social Form. In Williams 42-61.

96.

Rowthorn, Bob . 1974. Neo-Classicism, Neo-Ricardianism and Marxism. New Left Review (86). In Rowthorn, Bob, Capitalism, Conflict & Inflation. London: Lawrence and Wishart, 14-47.

97.

Rubin, Isaac Il'ich . 1978. Abstract Labor and Value in Marx's System. Cpital and CZass (5): 107-138.

98.

Salama, Pierre. 1975. Sur la vaeur. Paris: Maspero.

99.

Schumpeter, Joseph A. 1942 Capita L ism, Socialm and Danoaacy. New York: Harper & Bros.

100.

Schumpeter, Joseph A. 1954. History of economic analuisr London: Allen & Unwin.

101.

Schwartz, Jesse (ed.). 1977. The Subtk Anatomy of Capitali Santa Monica: Goodyear Publishing Company.

102.

Schwartz, Nancy . 1982 The Time of Our Being T ogether. An Inquiry into the Meaning of Marx's Labor Theory of Value. New Political Science (8): 73-87.