The argument that there will be an inevitable fall in the profit rate is most often made without reference to interventions by the state, which can use a myriad of instrument to offset a profit rate decline. In this paper I examine, by using intervention analysis techniques, the effects of changes in tax laws on the posttax profit rate in the United States. It is shown that changes in the tax laws thought to be favorable to capital did not have the desired effect of raising the posttax profit rates. Several explanations for this finding are suggested, all of which constrain the ability of the state to intervene in the market.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Alberro, Jose
and Joseph Persky. 1981. The Dynamics of Fixed Capital Revaluation and Scrapping. Review of Radical Political Economics, 13(2)32-37.
2.
Asimakopoulos, A.
and J.B. Burbidge. 1974. The Short-Term Incidence of Taxation. Economic Journal84:267-288.
3.
Atkinson, Anthony
and Joseph Stiglitz. 1980. Lectures on Public Economics. New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company.
4.
Ballentine, J.G.1978. The Incidence of a Corporation Income Tax in a Growing Economy. Journal of Political Economy86:863-876.
5.
Blinder, A.1980. The CPI and Measurement of Recent Inflation. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity2-2.
6.
BMDP1981. BMDP Statisticfal Software. 1981 Edition. Berkeley: University of California Press.
7.
Bowles, Samuel
and Herbert Gintis. 1982. The Crisis of Liberal Democratic Capitalism: The Case of the United States. Politics and Society11:51-93.
8.
Box, G.E.P.
and G.M. Jenkins. 1970. Time-Series Analysis: Forecasting and Control. San Francisco: Holden-Day.
9.
Box, G.E.P
and G.C. Tiao. 1975. Intervention Analysis with Applications to Economic and Environmental Problems. Journal of the American Statistical Association70:70-79.
10.
Bradford, David
. 1981. The Incidence and Allocation Effects of a Tax on Corporate Distributions. Journal of Public Economics15:1-22.
11.
Eatwell, John
. 1971. On the Proposed Reform of the Corporate Tax. Bulletin of the Oxford University Institute of Economics and Statistics33:267-274.
12.
Felstein, Martin
. 1979. Taxes, Inflation and Capital Formation. National Tax Journal32:347-349.
13.
Feldstein, M.
, L. Dicks-Mireaux and James Poterba. 1983. The Effective Tax Rate and the Pretax Rate of Return. Journal of Public Economics21:129-158.
14.
Feldstein, Martin
and Lawrence Summers. 1977. Is the Rate of Profit Falling?Brookings Papers on Economic Activity1:211-227.
15.
Franz, Michael
, Clausio Katz and Vincent Mahlter. 1983. The Impact of Taxes on Growth and Distribution in Developed Capitalist Countries: A Cross-National Study. American Political Science Review77:871-886.
16.
Glass, G.V.
, VL. Wilson and J.M. Gottman. 1975. Design and Analysis of Time-Series Experiments. Boulder, CO: Colorado University Associated Press.
17.
Glyn, Andrew
and Bob Sutcliffe. 1972. Brittish Capitalism, Workers and the profit Squeeze. New York: Penguin Books, Inc.
18.
Gordon, David
. 1981. Capital-Labor Conflict and the Productivity Slowdown. American Economic Review712:30-35.
19.
Gordon, Robert
. 1980. Postwar Macroeconomics: The Evolution of Events and Ideas. In, The American Economy in Transition, Martin Feldstein (ed.). pp. 101-162. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
20.
Gottman, John
. 1981. Time-Series Analysis. New York: Cambridge University Press.
21.
Grim, Bruce
. 1982. Domestic Nonfinancial Corporate Profits. Survey of Business Research62:30-42.
Harberger, Arnold
. 1962. The Incidence of the Corporate Income Tax. Journal of Political Economy70:215-240.
24.
Hirsch, Joachim
. 1978. The State Apparatus and Social Reproduction: Elements of a Theory of the Bourgeois State. In, State and Capital: A Marxist Debate, John Holloway and Sol Picciotto, (eds.). pp. 57-107. Austin: University of Texas Press.
25.
Holland, Daniel
and Stewart Myers. 1979. Trends in Corporate Profitability and Capital Costs. In, The Nation's Capital Needs, Robert Lindsay (ed.). U.S.A.: Committee for Economic Development.
26.
Holland, Daniel
and Stewart Myers. 1984. Trends in Corporate Profitability and Capital Costs in the United State. In, Measuring Profitability and Capital Costs, Daniel Holland (ed.). Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
27.
Jankowski, Richard. 1987. Profits, Wages and the State. Unpublished MS.
28.
Kaldor, Nicholas
. 1955. An Expenditure Tax. London: Allen and Unwin.
29.
Kalecki, Michael
. 1937. A Theory of Commodity Income and Capital Taxation. Economic Journal47:444-450.
30.
Krzyzaniak, Marion
and Richard Musgrave. 1963. The Shifting of the Corporate Income Tax. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Press.
31.
Kregel, J.A.1971. Rate of Profit, Distribution and Growth: Two Views. Chicago: Aldine Press.
32.
Liu, Lon-Mu
, Gregory Hudak, George Box, Mervin Muller, and George Tiao. 1985. The SCA System For Univariate-Multivariate Time Series. DeKalb, Illinois: Scientific Computing Associates.
33.
Lovell, Michael
. 1978. The Profit Picture: Trends and Cycles. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity3:769-789.
34.
McCleary, Richard
and Richard Hay, Jr.1980. Applied Timne Series Analysis for the Social Sciences. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications.
35.
Moseley, Fred
. 1985. The Rate of Surplus Value in the Postwar US Economy: A Critique of Weisskopf's Estimates. Cambridge Journal of Economics9:57-79.
36.
Musgrave, Richard
and Peggy Musgrave. 1976. Public Finance in Theory and Practice. New York: McGraw-Hill Company.
37.
O'Connor, James
. 1973. The Fiscal Crisis of the State. New York: St. Martins Press.
38.
Offe, Claus
. 1975. Theses on the Theory of the State. New German Critique6:137-147.
39.
Offe, Claus
. 1984. John Keane (ed.). Contradictions of the Welfare State. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
40.
Okishio, N.1961. Technical Changes and the Rate of Profit. Koabe University Economic Review7:85-99.
41.
Pechman, Joseph
. 1983. Federal Tax Policy. Fifth Edition. Washington, D.C.: The Brookings Institute.
42.
Perlo, V.1976. The New Propaganda of Declining Profit Shares and Inadequate Investment. Review of Radical Political Economics83:53-64.
43.
Persky, Joseph
and Jose Alberro. 1978. Technical Innovation and the Dynamics of the Profit Rate. University of Illinois, Department of Economics.
44.
Poulantzas, Nicos
. 1975. Political Power and Social Classes. English Edition. London, New Left Books.
45.
Roemer, John
. 1981. Analytical Foundations of Marxian Economic Theory. New York: Cambridge University Press.
46.
SAS1980. SASIETS User's Guide. Cary, North Carolina: SAS Institute.
47.
Shoven, John
and Jeremy Bulow. 1976. Inflation Accounting and Nonfinancial Corporate Profits: Financial Assets and Liabilities. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity1:15-66.
48.
Sunley, Emil
. 1976. Effective Corporate Tax Rates: Toward A More Precise Figure. Tax Notes4:15-24.
49.
URPE
. 1978. U.S. Capitalism in Crisis. New York, Union for Radical Political Economics.
50.
Weisskopf, Thomas
. 1979. Marxian Crisis Theory and the Rate of Profit in the Postwar U.S. Economy. Cambridge Journal of Economics34:341-378.
51.
Weisskopf, Thomas
. 1981. Wages, Salaries and the Profit Share: A Rejoinder. Cambridge Journal of Economics52:175-182.
