The Changing Mode of Production in American Agriculture: Emerging Conflicts in Agriculture's Role in the Reproduction of Advanced Capitalism

Abstract

This paper has two major objectives: (1) to present and contrast the perception of certain policy issues associated with United States agricultural structure from both the neoclassical and neo-Marxist paradigms, and (2) to trace out the broad contours of United States agricultural structural change in terms of interpretations from the neo-Marxist paradigm.

Although populist ideology has dominated progressive discussion of American agricultural de-velopment such discussion has been confused by the populist failure to recognize the distinction between independent production, independent commodity production and capitalist production. The result has been poor understanding of the basic factors causing agricultural structural change and largely ineffective policy prescriptions to deal with the change.

While the structural change characterizing American agriculture is not well described by the Marxist model, the reasons can be located in peculiar circumstances of the post World War II American and world economies. This led to the phenomenon of part-time farming which in the United States disguised the emergence of capitalist agriculture. It now seems likely that the basis on which part-time farming flourished in its commodity aspects is being eliminated; in which case the destruction of independent commodity production in agriculture will become more apparent.

It is clear that as a result of the transformation of United States agriculture its role in the smooth reproduction of United States capitalism must change and may be characterized by increasing conflict. At one time agriculture could function as an important source and regulator of industrial labor supply. Now, due to the long-run substitution of capital for labor in agriculture, the agricultural sector is no longer able to absorb or release important quantities of surplus labor. Additionally, increases in agricultural surplus, an important source of industrial profits, are going to be harder to achieve.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Batie, Sandra S. and Robert G. Healy . 1983. The Future of American Agriculture. Scientific American Vol. 248, No. 2:27-35.

Berry, Wendell . 1977. The Unsettling of America: Culture and Agriculture. Sierra Club Books.

Buttel, Frederick H. 1982. The Political Economy of Part-Time Farming. Geo Journal 6, No. 2.

Buttel, Frederick H. and Howard Hewby (eds.). 1980. TheRural Sociology ofAdvanced Societies. Montclair, NJ: Allanheld, Osmum and Co.

Congressional Budget Office . 1978. Public Policy and the Changing Structure of American Agriculture. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.

deJanvry, Alain . 1980. Social Differentiation in Agriculture and the Ideology of Neopopulism. In, The Rural Sociology of Advanced Societs, F. H. Buttel and H. Newby , eds. Montclair NJ: Allanheld, Osmum and Co.

deJanvry, A. , P. LeVeen and D. Runsten . 1980. Mechanization in California Agriculture: The Case of Canning Tomatoes. Costa Rica: IICA.

Goldschmidt, Walter . 1978. As You Sow. Montclair, NJ: Allanheld, Osmum and Co.

Gordon, David . 1972. Theories of Poverty and Underemployment. Washington, D.C.: Heath and Company.

10.

Heilbroner, Robert . 1980. Marxism: For and Against. New York: W. W. Norton and Company.

11.

Hightower, Jim . 1973. Hard Tomatoes, Hard Times. Cambridge, MA: Schenkman.

12.

Holland, David . 1980. Energy and the Structure of Agriculture: A Political-Economic Analysis. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 62 (5):972-975.

13.

Holland, David . 1984. Energy and Agriculture: Conflict and Potentials for Structural Reform. In, Land Reform, American Style, G. C. Geisler and F. J. Popper , eds., Totowa, NJ: Rowman and Allanheld.

14.

Johnston, Paul H. 1941. Old Ideals Versus New Ideas in Farm Life. 1940 Yearbook ofAgriculture. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.

15.

Kelly, K. 1979. The Independent Mode of Production. Review of Radical Political Economics II(l):33-48.

16.

LeVeen, E. Phillip and Daryl McLeod. 1979. American Agricultural Policy in an Inflationary Era. Unpublished manuscript, Agricultural Policy Project.

17.

Madden, J. Patrick and H. T. Baker . 1981. An Agendafor Small Farms Research. National Rural Center Monograph.

18.

Marx, Karl . Capital. Vol. 1. 1967. New York: International Publishers.

19.

Massey, Doreen and Alejandrina Catalano . 1978. Capital and Land. London: Edward Arnold.

20.

McConnell, Grant . 1953. The Decline of Agrarian Democracy. Los Angeles: University of California Press.

21.

Merrill, Richard (ed.). 1976. Radical Agriculture. San Francisco: Harper and Row.

22.

Milk, Richard G. 1972. The New Agriculture in the United States: A Dissenter's View. Land Economics 48(3):226-239.

23.

Nikolitch, Radoje . 1972. Family Sized Farms in U.S. Agriculture. U.S. Dept. of Agriculture, ERS 499. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.

24.

Palmer, Bruce . 1980. Man Over Money. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.

25.

Rodefeld, Richard D. 1978. Trends in Farm Organizational Structure and Type. In, Change in Rural America, Rodefeld et al. (eds.). pp. 158-177. St. Louis: L. V. Mosby.

26.

Small Farm Viability Project . 1977. The Family Farm in California. The State of California.

27.

Tweeten, L. and E.S.C.S. 1978. Status of the Family Farm. A Report to the Congress.

28.

U.S. Department of Agriculture . 1981a. A Time to Choose: Summary Report of the Structure of Agriculture. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.

29.

U.S. Department of Agriculture . 1981b. Structural Issues of American Agriculture. Ag. Ec. Report 438. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.

30.

U.S. Department of Commerce , Bureau of the Census . 1981a. 1978 Census of Agriculture: State and Country Data, Washington. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.

31.

U.S. Department of Commerce . 1981b. 1978 Census of Agriculture Preliminary Report, United States. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.

32.

Weisskopf, Thomas . 1981. The Current Economic Crisis in Historical Perspective. Socialist Review Vol. II, No. 3.

33.

Wright, E. 1976. Class Boundaries in Advanced Capitalism. New Left Review 98: 3-42.