This article estimates the net social wage ratio, in a panel of nine European countries for the 1995–2018 period. Assuming that indirect taxes are partly paid by labor, it is found that the net fiscal position of the working class is negative in eight of the nine countries. On the contrary, when indirect taxes are assumed to be entirely paid out of surplus value the net social wage ratio is positive and substantial in all countries. Using this panel in order to econometrically investigate the determinants of the net social wage ratio, both when indirect taxes are partly paid by labor and when they are paid entirely by capital, we find that the economic cycle (unemployment rate), labor strength (the adjusted wage share), and the age structure of the population (the share of people over 70 years old in the total population) appear to influence it positively.
Akram-LodhiHaroon. 1996. The public finances of the United Kingdom: A reinterpretation. International Review of Applied Economics10 (2): 173–93.
2.
BlankSarah Elliott. 2014. A Historical-Institutional Study of the Welfare Systems in the United States and Sweden: Net Social Wage Approach. Bucknell University Honor’s Thesis.
3.
BowlesSamuelGintisHerbert. 1982a. The crisis of liberal democratic capitalism: The case of the United States. Politics & Society11 (1): 51–93.
4.
BowlesSamuelGintisHerbert. 1982b. The welfare state and long-term economic growth: Marxian, neoclassical, and Keynesian approaches. American Economic Review72 (2): 341–45.
5.
Esping-AndersenGosta. 1990. The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
6.
FerreraMauricio. 1996. The “southern model” of welfare in Social Europe. Journal of European Social Policy6 (1): 17–37.
7.
FreemanAlan. 1991. National accounts in value terms: The social wage and profit rate in Britain, 1950–1986. In Quantitative Marxism, ed. PaulDunne. London: Polity.
GlynAndrew. 1975. Notes on the profit squeeze. Bulletin of the Conference of Socialist Economists4: 1–11.
10.
GlynAndrewSutcliffeTony. 1972. British Capitalism, Workers, and the Profits Squeeze. Harmondsworth, UK: Penguin.
11.
GuerreroDiego. 1992. Labor, capital, and state redistribution: The evolution of net taxes in Spain (1970–1987). International Journal of Political Economy22 (3): 46–71.
12.
ManiatisThanasis. 2003. The net social wage in Greece, 1958–1995. International Review of Applied Economics17 (4): 377–98.
13.
ManiatisThanasis. 2014. Does the state benefit labor? A cross-country study of the net social wage. Review of Radical Political Economics46 (1): 15–34.
14.
ManiatisThanasisPassasCostas. 2019. The net social wage in different welfare regimes. Capital and Class43 (2): 227–50.
15.
MillerJohn. 1989. Social wage or social profit? The net social wage and the welfare state. Review of Radical Political Economics21 (3): 82–90.
16.
MoosKatherine. 2019. Neoliberal redistributive policy: The US net social wage in the early twenty-first century. Review of Radical Political Economics51 (4): 581–605.
17.
MoosKatherineQiHao. 2022. The state’s response to the crisis of neoliberalism: A comparison of the net social wage in China and the United States, 1992–2017. International Review of Applied Economics37 (1): 23–49.
ReveleyJames. 2006. Taxing times: State-led income redistribution in New Zealand’s “golden age.”Australian Economic History Review46 (3): 195–214.
20.
SepehriArdeshirChernomasRobert. 1992. Who paid for the Canadian welfare state between 1955–1988?Review of Radical Political Economics24 (1): 71–88.
21.
ShaikhAnwar. 2003. Who pays for the “welfare” in the welfare state? A multi-country study. Social Research70 (2): 531–50.
22.
ShaikhAnwarTonakE. Ahmet. 1987. The welfare state and the myth of the social wage. In The Imperiled Economy, volume 1, ed. RobertCherry. New York: Union for Radical Political Economy.
23.
ShaikhAnwarTonakE. Ahmet. 1994. Measuring the Wealth of Nations: The Political Economy of National Accounts. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
24.
ShaikhAnwarTonakE. Ahmet. 2000. The rise and fall of the US welfare state. In Political Economy and Contemporary Capitalism: Radical Perspectives on Economic Theory and Policy, eds. RonBaimanBousheyHeatherSaundersDawn. Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe.
25.
TonakE. Ahmet. 1987. The US welfare state and the working class, 1952–1980. Review of Radical Political Economics19 (3): 47–72.
26.
TretheweyMark. 1994. A political economy of the social wage: The net social wage in Australia, 1964–65 to 1991–92. Australian Journal of Social Issues29 (4): 365–76.
