These are comments on David McNally’s 2024 David Gordon Memorial Lecture. In this response, I point to the immanent critique present in Professor McNally’s remarks. I then show the potential usefulness of immanent critique for an engagement with neoclassical economics, and I consider the consequences for Marxist economics of characterizing the critique of political economy as a critical theory of economic categories.
BackhausHans-Georg. 1992. Between philosophy and science: Marxian social economy as critical theory. In Open Marxism, volume 1: Dialectics and History, eds. WernerBonefeldGunnRichardPsychopedisKosmas, trans. GordonFinlaysonHaaseUlrich, 54–92. London: Pluto.
2.
BackhausHans-Georg. 2005. Some aspects of Marx’s concept of critique in the context of his economic-philosophical theory. In Human Dignity: Social Autonomy and the Critique of Capitalism, eds. WernerBonefeldPsychopedisKosmas, 13–29. Aldershot, UK: Ashgate.
3.
BellofioreRiccardoRivaTommaso Redolfi. 2015. The Neue Marx-Lektüre: Putting the critique of political economy back into the critique of society. Radical Philosophy189: 24–36.
4.
BestBeverley. 2021. Wages for housework redux: Social reproduction and the utopian dialectic of the value-form. Theory & Event24 (4): 896–921.
5.
BonefeldWerner. 2001. Kapital and its subtitle: A note on the meaning of critique. Capital & Class25 (3): 53–63.
6.
BonefeldWerner. 2004. “Critical economy” and social constitution: A reply to Bieler and Morton. The British Journal of Politics and International Relations6 (2): 231–37.
7.
BonefeldWerner. 2011. Primitive accumulation and capitalist accumulation: Notes on social constitution and expropriation. Science & Society75 (3): 379–99.
8.
BonefeldWerner. 2014. Critical Theory and the Critique of Political Economy: On Subversion and Negative Reason. London: Bloomsbury.
9.
CarsonRebecca. 2022. Immanent Externalities: The Reproduction of Life in Capital. Leiden: Brill.
10.
CarsonRebecca. 2023. The uses of Marx’s value-theoretical concept of reproduction for social reproduction theory. In Critical Theory in (a Time of) Crisis, eds. TomBunyardBosseauDenis C., 101–123. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
11.
ClarkeSimon. 1991. Marx, Marginalism, and Modern Sociology: From Adam Smith to Max Weber. 2nd ed.London: Macmillan.
12.
De’AthAmy. 2018. Reproduction. In Bloomsbury Companion to Marx, eds. AndrewPendakisSzemanImreFiamantiJeff, 395–404London: Bloomsbury Academic.
13.
FanonFrantz. 1961. Les Damnés de la Terre. Paris: Éditions La Découverte/Poche.
14.
FanonFrantz. (1961) 1965. The Wretched of the Earth, trans. ConstanceFarrington. London: MacGibbon & Kee.
15.
FriedmanMilton. 1970. A Friedman doctrine—The social responsibility of business is to increase its profits. The New York TimesSeptember13: 17.
16.
HartmannHeidi. 1981. The unhappy marriage of Marxism and feminism: Towards a more progressive union. In Women and Revolution: A Discussion of the Unhappy Marriage of Marxism and Feminism, ed. LydiaSargent, 1–41. Montreal: Black Rose Books.
17.
HeinrichMichael. (2018) 2021. How to Read Marx’s Capital: Commentary and Explanations on the Beginning Chapters, trans. AlexanderLocascio. New York: Monthly Review Press.
18.
HeinrichMichael. (2004) 2012. An Introduction to the Three Volumes of Karl Marx’s Capital. Trans. AlexanderLocascio. New York: Monthly Review Press.
MattickPaul. 2018. Theory as Critique. Essays on Capital. Leiden: Brill.
28.
MunroKirstin. 2019. “Social Reproduction Theory,” social reproduction, and household production. Science & Society83 (4): 451–68.
29.
MunroKirstin. 2021a. The welfare state and the bourgeois family-household. Science & Society85 (2): 199–206.
30.
MunroKirstin. 2021b. Unproductive workers and state repression. Review of Radical Political Economics53 (4): 623–30.
31.
MunroKirstin. 2023. Socially reproductive workers, “life making,” and state repression. In Marxism and the Capitalist State: Towards a New Debate, eds. RobHunterKhachaturianRafaelNanopoulosEva, 165–83. Cham, Switzerland: Palgrave-Macmillan.
32.
MunroKirstin. 2024. Social reproduction. In Marx: Key Concepts, eds. RiccardoBellofioreRivaTommaso Redolfi, 203–216. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.
33.
O’KaneChrisMunroKirstin. 2022. Marxian economics and the critique of political economy. In Adorno and Marx: Negative Dialectics and the Critique of Political Economy, eds. WernerBonefeldO’KaneChris, 78–95. London: Bloomsbury Academic.
34.
PostoneMoishe. 1993. Time, Labor, and Social Domination. A Reinterpretation of Marx’s Critical Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
35.
QuickPaddy. 2022. Social reproduction and household production. Socialism and Democracy36 (3): 14–35.
36.
QuickPaddy. 2023. Capitalism and household production: A Marxist-feminist critique of social reproduction theory. Science & Society87 (4): 447–74.
37.
ReicheltHelmut. 2002. Die Marxsche Kritik ökonomischer Kategorien. In Emanzipation als Versöhnung: Zu Adornos Kritik der ‘Warentausch’-Gesellschaft und Perspektiven der Transformation, eds. IringFetscherSchmidtAlfred, 142–88. Frankfurt: Neue Kritik.
38.
Rey-AraújoPedro. 2024. Social reproduction theory and the capitalist “form” of social reproduction. New Political Economy29 (3): 432–46.
39.
RosdolskyRoman. 1974. Comments on the method of Marx’s Capital and its importance for contemporary Marxist scholarship. New German Critique3 (3): 62–72.
40.
SchmidtAlfred. 1968. On the concept of knowledge in the criticism of political economy. In Karl Marx: 1818|1968, ed. MannGolo, 92–102. Bad Godesberg: Inter Nationes.
41.
SchmidtAlfred. (1962) 2014. The Concept of Nature in Marx, trans. FowkesBen. London: Verso.
42.
VischmidtMarinaSutherlandZoë. 2020. Social reproduction: New questions for the gender, affect, and substance of value. In The New Feminist Literary Studies, ed. JenniferCooke, 143–54. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
43.
VischmidtMarinaSutherlandZoë. 2022. (Un)making value: Reading social reproduction through the question of totality. In Totality Inside Out: Rethinking Crisis and Conflict under Capital, eds. KevinFloydPhillisJen HedlerChandraSarika, 67–90. New York: Fordham University Press.
44.
Yung Walken (@as_a_worker). 2022. Marx never considered an invasive species of spider the size of a child’s hand that parachutes down from the sky. X (formerly known as Twitter)March9. Accessed at: https://x.com/as_a_worker/status/1501595677977202691?s=20.
