Contrary to his theoretical expectations, Veblen provided various reasons as to why a revolutionary overturn by the technicians was a remote possibility in America. In contrast to the American engineers, the engineers of Turkey have constructed an engineering outlook commensurate with Veblen’s abstract line of reasoning and participated in a political struggle against business interests. In this paper, using Veblen’s cumulative causation methodology, a theoretical answer for the origin, growth, persistence, and variation of the anti-business engineering outlook in Turkey is suggested.
AralB.2004. The idea of human rights as perceived in the Ottoman Empire. Human Rights Quarterly26 (2): 454-482.
2.
BretteO.2003. Thorstein Veblen’s theory of institutional change: Beyond technological determinism. European Journal of History of Economic Thought10 (3): 455-477.
3.
DowdD. F.2000. Thorstein Veblen. New Brunswick and London.
4.
ErŞ.1993. Türkiye’de Mühendislik ve İTÜ Yüksek Mühendisler Birliği (Engineering in Turkey and the ITU Union of Master Engineers). Ankara: Afşaroğlu Matbaası.
5.
FaroqhiS.2010. The Ottoman ruling group and the religions of its subjects in the early modern age: A survey of current research. Journal of Early Modern History14: 239-266.
6.
FaroqhiS.2009. Artisans of empire: Crafts and craftspeople under the Ottomans. London, New York, and Melbourne: I. B. Tauris.
7.
GöleN.1986. Mühendisler ve İdeoloji: Öncü Devrimcilerden Yenilikçi Seçkinlere (Engineers and Ideology: from Vanguard Revolutionaries to Reformist Elites). Istanbul: İletişim.
8.
HodgsonG. M.2004. Veblen and Darwinism. International Review of Sociology/Revue Internationale de Sociologie14 (3): 343-361.
9.
İnalcıkH.1969. Capital formation in the Ottoman Empire. The Journal of Economic History29 (1): 97-140.
10.
LewisB.1937. The Islamic guilds. The Economic History Review8 (1): 20-37.
11.
KöseA. H.ÖncüA.2002. A class analysis of the professional and political ideologies of engineers in Turkey. In The ravages of neo-liberalism: Economy, society and gender in Turkey, ed. BalkanN.SavranS.New York: Nova Scientific Publishers.
12.
KunarA.1991. ‘TMMOB ve “Mühendislerin” in Oturma “Odaları” (UCTEA and the sitting “chambers” of “engineers”). Birikim29 (9): 29-34.
13.
MardinŞ.1988. Freedom in an Ottoman perspective. In State, democracy and the military: Turkey in the 1980s, eds. HeperM.EvinA.Berlin: Walter de Gruyter.
14.
MardinŞ.1994. Cultural transitions in the Middle East. Leiden: E. J. Brill.
15.
MeiksinsP.SmithC.1996. Engineering labour: Technical workers in comparative perspective. London and New York: Verso.
16.
ÖncüA.2009. Wither business ideology: Revisiting Veblen’s theory of engineers as revolutionary actors. Review of Radical Political Economics41 (2): 196-216.
17.
ÖncüA.2003. A sociological inquiry into the history of the Union of Turkish Chambers of Engineers and Architects: Engineers and the state. New York: The Edwin Mellen.
18.
RafeqA.1991. Craft organization, work ethics, and the strains of change in Ottoman Syria. Journal of the American Oriental Society111 (3): 495-511.
19.
RutherfordM. H.1998. Veblen’s evolutionary programme: A promise unfulfilled. Cambridge Journal of Economics22 (4): 463-477.
TilmanR.1996. The intellectual legacy of Thorstein Veblen: Unresolved issues. Westport: Greenwood Publishing.
22.
TilmanR.2004. Ferdinand Tönnies, Thorstein Veblen and Karl Marx: From community to society and back?European Journal of History of Economic Thought11 (4): 579-606.
23.
VeblenT.1994[1899]. The theory of the leisure class: An economic study of institutions. New York: Dover Publications.
24.
VeblenT.1958[1904]. The theory of business enterprise. New York: Mentor Books.
25.
VeblenT.2012[1919]. The place of science in modern civilization and other essays. Fairford: The Echo Library.
26.
VeblenT.1921 (reprint). The engineers and the price system. Montana: Kessinger Publishing.
27.
VeblenT.1997[1923]. Absentee ownership: Business enterprise in recent times: The case of America. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Books.
28.
WenzlerJ.1998. The metaphysics of business: Thorstein Veblen. International Journal of Politics, Culture and Society11 (4): 541-578.
29.
WhalleyP.1986. The social production of technical work: The case of British engineers. Albany: State University of New York Press.
30.
YiE.2004. Guild dynamics in seventeenth-century Istanbul. Leiden and Boston: Brill.
31.
ZussmanR.1985. Mechanics of the middle class: Work and politics among American engineers. Berkeley: University of California Press.
