This paper is an immanent critique of Robert Brenner's writings on the transition from feudalism to capitalism. The concept "immanent" is defined as a logic of implication, according to which a text or theory is evaluated within the terms that it sets for itself, to determine whether its objectives and assumptions are true in the way they are said to be true. Using this method of critique, the paper shows how Brenner's concept of "political accumulation" undermines his own initial claim that the balance of class forces between lords and peasants determined the long-term trends of preindustrial Europe, in that this concept points toward intralord struggles dominated by military interests. The paper also discusses why Brenner's account of France's tax/office state seriously weakens his postulate that "surplus extracting relations" were the "fundamental" relation of fuedalism, on the grounds that office-holding reflected an unequal distribution of property based upon status. Finally, the paper draws out the theoretical implications of these contradictory instances, to delineate ways in which Brenner's basic theory may be sublated within a more comprehensive account.
Adorno, T. (1973). Negative diatectics.Trans. E. B. Ashton. New York: Continuum.
2.
Adorno, T. (1993). Hegel: three studies. Trans. S. W. Nicholsen. Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press.
3.
Albritton, R. (1993). Did agrarian capitalism exist. Journal of Peasant Studies, 20 (3).
4.
Anderson, P. (1974/1979). Lineages of the absolutist state. London: Verso.
5.
Aston, T. H., & Philpin, C. H. E. (1987). The Brenner debate: agrarian class structure and economic development in pre-industrial Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
6.
Bloch, M. (1961). Feudal society: volume 1-the growth of ties of dependence. Trans. Manyon, L. A. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
7.
Brenner, R. (1976/1987). Agrarian class structure and economic development in pre-industrial Europe. In The Brenner debate. Aston, T. H., et al. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
8.
Brenner, R. (1977). The origins of capitalist development: a critique of neo-Smithian Marxism. New Left Review (104).
9.
Brenner, R. (1978). Dobb on the transition from feudalism to capitalism. Cambridge Journal of Economics II.
10.
Brenner, R. (1982/1987). The agrarian roots of European capitalism. In The Brenner Debate. Aston, T. H., et al. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
11.
Brenner, R. (1986). The social basis of economic development. In Analytical Marxism. Roemer, J. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
12.
Brenner, R. (1987). Feudalism. In The New Palgrave Marxian Economics. Eatwell, J. London: Macmillan.
13.
Brenner, R. (1989). Bourgeois revolution and transition to capitalism. In The First Modem Society, Beier, A. L., et al. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
14.
Briggs, R. (1977/1989). Early modem France 1560-1715. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
15.
Callinicos, A. (1995). Theories and narrative: reflections on the philosophy of history. Durham: Duke University Press.
16.
Carling, A. (1991). Social division. London: Verso Press.
17.
Critchley. J. (1978). Feudalism. London: Allen & Unwin.
18.
Dobb, M. (1968). Studies in the development of capitalism. New York: International Publishers.
19.
Duchesne, R. (1994). All contraries confounded: historical materialism and the transition-to-capitalism debate. Ph.D. diss., York University, Toronto.
20.
Duchesne, R. (1996). Maurice Dobb: between a Marxist and a Smithian interpretation of the transition to capitalism. Research in Political Economy, 15..
21.
Duchesne, R. (2000). Barry Hindess and Paul Hirst: the origins of capitalism and the origins of post-Marxism. Current Perspectives in Social Theory, 20..
22.
Giddens, A. (1987). The nation-state and violence. Berkeley: University of California Press.
23.
Gregson, N. (1989). Tawney revisited: custom and the emergence of capitalist class relations in northeast Cumbria, 1600-1830. Economic History Review, 2nd ser, XLII.
24.
Grigg, D. (1980). Population growth and agrarian change: an historical perspective. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
25.
Habermas, J. (1976). A positivistically bisected rationalism. In The Positivist Dispute in German Sociology. Adorno et al. Trans. Adey, G., & Frisby, D. London: Heinemann Educational Books.
26.
Habermas, J. (1989). On the logic of the social sciences. Trans. Nicholsen, S., & Stark, J. Cambridge: MIT Press.
27.
Hegel, G. W. F. (1806/1979). The phenomenology of spirit. Trans. Miller, A. V. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
28.
Hilton, R. (1990). Class conflict and the crisis offeudalism. London: New Left Books.
29.
Hilton, R. (1969). The decline of serfdom in medieval England. London: Macmillan.
30.
Hilton, R. (1976/1982). The transition from feudalism to capitalism. London: Verso.
31.
Holton, R. J. (1988). The transition from feudalism to capitalism. London: Macmillan.
32.
Hopcroft, R. (1994). The social origins of agrarian change in late medieval England. American Journal of Sociology, 99 (6).
33.
Horkheimer, M. (1982). Critical theory, selected essays. Trans. M. O'Connell. New York: Continuum.
34.
Hoyle, R. W. (1990). Tenure and the land market in early modem England: or a late contribution to the Brenner debate. Economic History Review, (2nd series), 43-43.
35.
Katz, C. (1993). Karl Marx on the transition from feudalism to capitalism. Theory and Society, 22..
36.
Kaye, H. (1984). The British Marxist historians. Oxford: Polity Press.
37.
Kosminsky, E. (1956). Studies in the agrarian history of England. Trans. Kisch, R. Oxford: Blackwell.
38.
Kriedte, P. (1983). Peasants, landlords, and merchant capitalists: Europe and the world economy, 1500-1800. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
39.
Lachman, R. (1985). Feudal elite conflict and the origins of English capitalism. Politics and Society, 14 (3).
40.
Mann, M. (1992). States, war and capitalism: studies in political sociology. Cambridge, Mass: Blackwell.
41.
Mooers, C. (1991). The making of bourgeois Europe. New York: Verso.
42.
Moore, B. (1966/1993). Social origins of dictatorship and democracy: lord and peasant in the making of the modem world. Boston: Beacon Press.
43.
Parkin, F. (1979). Marxism and class theory: a bourgeois critique. New York: Columbia University Press.
44.
Poggi, G. (1978). The development of the modem state: a sociological introduction. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
45.
Postan, M. M. (1976). The medieval economy and society: an economic history of Britain in the middle ages. Middlesex, England: Penguin Books Ltd.
46.
Reiman, J. (1987). Exploitation, force, and the moral assessment of capitalism: thoughts on Roemer and Cohen. Philosophy & Public Affairs, 16 (1).
47.
Roemer, J. (1986). New directions in the Marxian theory of exploitation and class. In Analytical Marxism. Roemer, J. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
48.
Roemer, J. (1988). Free to lose. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
49.
Tawney, R. H. (1912/1967). The agrarian problem in the sixteenth century. New York: Harper Torchbooks.
50.
Tilly, C. (1992). Coercion, capital, and European states, ad 990-1992. Cambridge, Mass: Blackwell Press.
51.
Tucker, R. (1978). The Marx-Engels reader. New York: W.W. Norton.
52.
Wickham, C. (1985). The uniqueness of the East. Journal of Peasants Studies, 12.
53.
Wood, E. (1981). The separation of the economic and the political in capitalism. New Left Review (127).
54.
Wood, E. (1989). Rational choice Marxism: is the game worth the candle?New Left Review (177).
55.
Wood, E. (1999). The origin of capitalism. New York: Monthly Review Press.
56.
Wordie, J. R. (1983). The chronology of English enclosure, 1500-1914. Economic History Review, XXXVI (4).
57.
Wright, E. O. (1979). Class structure and income determination. New York: Academic Press.
58.
Wright, E. O. (1987). Classes. London: Verso.
59.
Wright, E. O., Levine, A., & Sober, E. (1992). Reconstructing Marxism: essays on explanation and the theory of history. London: Verso.
60.
Wright, E. 0. (1986). What is middle about the middle class? In Analytical Marxism: studies in Marxism and social theory. Roemer, J. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
61.
Wrightson, K. (1990). English society 1580-1680. London: Unwin Hyman.
