This paper evaluates the five most popular analytical approaches to the East Asian "miracle" economies: neoliberal, structural-institutional, "flying geese," Greater China, and dependency perspectives. Distinguishing between national and regional development visions, we specify the key forces that each approach sees driving industrialization and growth, as well as the most likely barriers each sees to continued growth and development in East Asia. In pointing out the main analytical shortcomings of the five perspectives in light of the East Asian crisis, we sketch some key elements of a Marxist framework capable of overcoming these difficulties in a politically useful way.
Akamatsu, Kaname. 1961. A Theory of Unbalanced Growth in the World Economy. Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv86 (1): 196-217.
2.
Akamatsu, Kaname. 1962. A Historical Pattern of Economic Growth in Developing Countries. Developing Economies1(1): 3-25.
3.
Amsden, Alice H.1989. Asia's Next Giant. New York, N.Y.: Oxford University Press.
4.
Amsden, Alice H.1991. Diffusion of Development: The Late-Industrializing Model and Greater East Asia. American Economic Review81(2): 282-286.
5.
Amsden, Alice H.1994. Why Isn't the Whole World Experimenting with the East Asian Model to Develop?World Development22(4): 627-633.
6.
Amsden, Alice H.1996. Late Industrialization: Can More Countries Make It? In Political Economy for the 21st Century. Charles V. Whalen (ed.). Pp. 245-261. Armonk, N.Y.: M.E. Sharpe.
7.
Amsden, Alice and Yoon-Dae Euh. 1997. Behind Korea's Plunge. New York Times (November 27): A23-A23.
8.
Associated Press. 1997. China's New Threat: Army of Unemployment Creating Wave of Protests Across Nation. New York Times (December 26): B4-B4.
9.
Associated Press. 1998. Retirees Block Trains in a Protest in China. New York Times (April 19): Section 1: 10-10.
10.
Athukorala, Prema-Chandra and Jayant Menon. 1997. AFTA and the Investment-Trade Nexus in ASEAN. World Economy20(2): 159-174.
11.
Beach, Sophie. 1999. China's Unseen Unemployed. The Nation (February 15): 20-23.
12.
Bello, Walden. 1992. People and Power in the Pacific. London: Pluto Press.
13.
Bello, Walden. 1996a. Neither Market Nor State: The Development Debate in South-East Asia. The Ecologist26(4): 167-175.
14.
Bello, Walden. 1996b. Japan's Strategy of Attrition in APEC. Documentation for Action Groups in Asia, distributed worldwide on APC networks, September 4.
15.
Bello, Walden. 1996c. ASEAN and APEC: The Making of a Geo-Economic Rivalry. Documentation for Action Groups in Asia, distributed worldwide on APC networks, November 4.
16.
Bello, Walden and Stephanie Rosenfeld. 1990. Dragons in Distress. San Francisco, Calif.: Institute for Food and Development Policy.
17.
Bernard, Mitchell and John Ravenhill. 1995. Beyond Product Cycles and Flying Geese. World Politics47(2): 171-209.
18.
Blomqvist, Hans C.1995. Intraregional Foreign Investment in East Asia. ASEAN Economic Bulletin11(3): 280-297.
19.
Bowles, Paul and Brian MacLean. 1996. Regional Trading Blocs: Will East Asia Be Next?Cambridge Journal of Economics20(4): 393-412.
20.
Brohman, John. 1996. Postwar Development in the Asian NICs: Does the Neoliberal Model Fit Reality?Economic Geography72(2): 107-130.
21.
Burkett, Paul. 1997. Democracy and Economic Transitions. Studies in Political Economy No.52: 111-136.
22.
Burkett, Paul. 1999. Marx and Nature. New York, N.Y.: St. Martin's Press.
23.
Burkett, Paul and Martin Hart-Landsberg. 1996. The Use and Abuse of Japan as a Progressive Model. In Socialist Register 1996: Are There Alternatives?Leo Panitch (ed.). Pp. 62-92. London: Merlin.
24.
Burkett, Paul. 1998. East Asia and the Crisis of Development Theory. Journal of Contemporary Asia28(4): 435-456.
25.
Cassen, Robert and Sanjaya Lall. 1996. Lessons of East Asian Development. Journal of the Japanese and International Economies10(3): 326-334.
26.
Chang, Ha-joon. 1997. Perspective on Korea: A Crisis from Underregulation. Los Angeles Times, on-line edition (December 31).
27.
Cheng, Eva. 1999. China: Is Capitalist Restoration Inevitable?Links (11): 44-66.
28.
Clarke, Simon. 1988. Overaccumulation, Class Struggle and the Regulation Approach. Capital and Class No. 36: 59-92.
29.
Clarke, Simon. 1990-91. The Marxist Theory of Overaccumulation and Crisis. Science and Society54(4): 442-467.
30.
Cleeve, Emmanuel. 1994. Transnational Corporations and Internalisation: A Critical Review. British Review of Economic Issues16 (October): 1-23.
31.
Cumings, Bruce. 1981. The Origins of the Korean War, Volume I. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
32.
Cumings, Bruce. 1997a. Korea's Labor War. The Nation (January 27): 6-7.
33.
Cumings, Bruce. 1997b. Japan and Northeast Asia into the Twenty-first Century. In Network Power: Japan and Asia. Peter Katzenstein and Takashi Shiraishi, (eds.). Pp. 136-168. Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press.
34.
Eckholm, Erik. 1997. Chinese Democracy Campaigners Push for Free Labor Unions. New York Times (December 24): A3-A3.
35.
Eckholm, Erik. 1998. Joblessness: A Perilous Curve On China's Capitalist Road. New York Times (January 20): A1-A1, A8-A8.
36.
Economist. 1996. Into China. (March 16): 63-64.
37.
Economist. 1997a. The Asian Miracle: Is it Over? (March 1): 23-25.
38.
Economist. 1997b. When China and India Go Down Together. (November 22): 41-42.
39.
Economist. 1998. East Asia's New Faultlines. (March 14): 16-17.
40.
Engardio, Peter. 1996. Is the East Asian Juggernaut Sputtering?Business Week (August 26): 44-44.
41.
Faison, Seth. 1997. China's Economic Boss Resists Pressure to Devalue Currency. New York Times (December 1): A5-A5.
42.
Fallows, James. 1994. Looking at the Sun. New York, N.Y.: Pantheon.
43.
Fumio, Kaneko. 1993. Funds for the World. AMPO Japan-Asia Quarterly Review24(4): 28-31.
44.
Goldstein, Don. 1997. Financial Structure and Corporate Behavior in Japan and the U.S.International Review of Applied Economics11(1): 27-48.
45.
Goodno, James B.1996. Capitalism's Latest Success: Social Progress and Social Problems in Southeast Asia. Discussion Paper, Freedom from Debt Coalition, Manila, Philippines.
46.
Greenfield, Gerard. 1998a. Transnational Capital and the State in China: Partners in Exploitation. Against the Current13(1): 34-38.
47.
Greenfield, Gerard. 1998b. TNCs, Flexibility, and Workers in Asia. Paper presented at the ASEM Conference on "The Asian Crisis: People's Realities, People's Responses,"London, March 31-April 1.
48.
Greenfield, Gerard and Apo Leong. 1997. China's Communist Capitalism: The Real World of Market Socialism. In Socialist Register 1997: Ruthless Criticism of All That Exists. Leo Panitch (ed.). Pp. 96-122. London: Merlin.
49.
Halliday, Jon. 1975. A Political History of Japanese Capitalism. New York, N.Y.: Pantheon Books.
50.
Hamashita, Takeshi. 1997. The Intra-regional System in East Asia in Modem Times. In Network Power: Japan and Asia. Peter Katzenstein and Takashi Shiraishi (eds.). Pp. 113-135. Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press.
51.
Hart-Landsberg, Martin. 1993. The Rush to Development. New York, N.Y.: Monthly Review Press.
Hart-Landsberg, Martin. 1998a. Inside the Asian Crisis: Causes and Consequences. Against the Current13(1): 26-29.
54.
Hart-Landsberg, Martin. 1998b. Korea: Division, Reunification, and U.S. Foreign Policy. New York, N.Y.: Monthly Review Press.
55.
Hart-Landsberg, Martin and Paul Burkett. 1998. Contradictions of Capitalist Industrialization in East Asia. Economic Geography74(2): 87-110.
56.
Hatch, Walter and Kozo Yamamura. 1996. Asia in Japan's Embrace. Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press.
57.
Henwood, Doug. 1998. The Bull's Sour 16. The Nation (September 7): 5-5.
58.
Hiroshi, Kanda, Fuke Yosuke, Nagase Riei, and Murai Yoshinori. 1993. Snaring the World in Debt. AMPO Japan-Asia Quarterly Review24(4): 32-38.
59.
Hsing, Y.1996. Blood, Thicker Than Water: Interpersonal Relations and Taiwanese Investment in Southern China. Environment and Planning, Series A 28(12): 2241-2261.
60.
Huff, W.G.1995. What is the Singapore Model of Economic Development?Cambridge Journal of Economics19(6): 735-759.
61.
Hughes, Helen (ed.) 1988. Achieving Industrialization in East Asia. Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press.
62.
Hymer, Stephen. 1970. The Efficiency (Contradictions) of Multinational Corporations. American Economic Review60(2): 441-448.
63.
letto-Gillies, Grazia. 1988. Internationalisation of Production: An Analysis Based on Labour. British Review of Economic Issues23(Autumn): 19-47.
64.
International Monetary Fund. 1997. World Economic Outlook, Interim Assessment: Crisis in Asia. Washington, D.C.: International Monetary Fund, December.
Jeong, Seongjin and Jo-Young Shin. 1998. Debates on the Current Economic Crisis within the Korean Left. Paper Presented at the summer conference of the Union for Radical Political Economics, Bantam, CT, August 22-25.
67.
Kim, June Dong. 1994. Incidence of Protection: The Case of Korea. Economic Development and Cultural Change42(3): 617-629.
68.
Korhonen, Pekka. 1994. The Theory of the Flying Geese Pattern of Development and Its Interpretations. Journal of Peace Research31(1): 93-108.
69.
Kristof, Nicholas D.1997a. Battered Economies in Asia Raise Fears of Unrest. New York Times (November 30): A1-A1, A6-A6.
70.
Kristof, Nicholas D.1997b. Asian Democracy Has Two Masters. New York Times (December 21): Section 4: 4-4.
71.
Kristof, Nicholas D. and Sheryl WuDunn. 1998. A Lot of Talk about Russia, but the Numbers Shout Japan. New York Times (August 29): A1-A1, B2-B2.
72.
Lazonick, William. 1998. The Japanese Financial Crisis, Corporate Governance and Sustainable Prosperity. Working Paper No. 227, Gerome Levy Economics Institute. February.
73.
Lee, Jaymin. 1997. The Maturation and Growth of Infant Industries: The Case of Korea. World Development25(8): 1271-1281.
74.
Lever-Tracy, Constance, David Ip, and Noel Tracy. 1996. The Chinese Diaspora and Mainland China: An Emerging Economic Synergy. London: Macmillan.
75.
Limqueco, Peter, Bruce McFarlane, and Jan Odhnoff. 1989. Labor and Industry in ASEAN. Manila, Philippines: Journal of Contemporary Asia Publishers.
76.
Lippit, Victor D.1993. But What About China?Rethinking Marxism6(1): 128-138.
77.
Mandel, Michael J. (with Pete Engardio, Emily Thornton, and Chris Farrell). 1997. The Threat of Deflation. Business Week (November 10): 55-55, 58-59.
78.
Marx, Karl. 1967. Capital, Vol. i. New York, N.Y.: International Publishers.
79.
McNally, David. 1998. Globalization on Trial: Crisis and Class Struggle in East Asia. Monthly Review50(4): 1-14.
80.
Medley, Joseph. 1997. (Post-)Modern Imperialism: Class Relations in the North Pacific Political Economy. Paper presented at the annual meetings of the Union for Radical Political Economics, New Orleans, La., January 4-6.
81.
Meisner, Maurice. 1997. The Other China. Current History96 (September): 264-269.
82.
Miller, John A. 1997. Does Capitalisi Growth Alleviate Poverty? Lessons from Southeast Asia about Rapid Growth, the Capitalist State, and Social Movements. Paper Presented at the Annual Meetings of the Union for Radical Political Economics, New Orleans, La, January 4-6.
83.
Moore, Joe. 1983. Japanese Workers and the Struggle for Power, 1945-1947. Madison, Wis.: University of Wisconsin Press.
84.
Mydans, Seth. 1997a. In Thailand, Once Asia's Tiger, Anger Boils. New York Times (September 17): A3-A3.
85.
Moore, Joe. 1997b. Thousands of Thais Protest Bangkok Inaction in Crisis. New York Times (October 22): A8-A8.
86.
O'Connor, James. 1998. Natural Causes. New York, N.Y.: Guilford.
87.
Ozawa, Terutomo. 1993. Foreign Direct Investment and Structural Transformation: Japan as a Recycler of Market and Industry. Business and the Contemporary World5(2): 129-150.
88.
Pempel, T.J.1996/97. Gulliver in Lilliput: Japan and Asian Economic Regionalism. World Policy Journal13(4): 13-26.
89.
Petras, James. 1998a. The Asian Crisis. Z Magazine11(1): 10-11.
90.
Pempel, T.J.1998b. The Americanization of Asia: The Rise and Fall of a Civilization. Journal of Contemporary Asia28(2): 149-158.
91.
Pitelis, Christos N. and Roger Sugden. 1991. On the Theory of the Transnational Firm. In The Nature of the Transnational Firm. Christos N. Pitelis and Roger Sugden (eds.). Pp. 9-15. London: Routledge.
92.
Rodrik, Dani. 1994. Getting Interventions Right: How South Korea and Taiwan Grew Rich. Working Paper No. 4964, National Bureau of Economic Research, December.
93.
Rowley, Chris and Mark Lewis. 1996. Greater China at the Crossroads?Asia Pacific Business Review2(3): 1-22.
94.
Rytting, James. 1989. Class Struggles in Japan. Against the Current4(1): 26-29.
95.
Sanger, David E.1997. The Overfed Tiger Economies. New York Times (August 3): Section 4: 3-3.
96.
Sapsford, Jathan. 1997. Japanese Banks 'Dumping' Loans in Asia. Wall Street Journal (May 9): A14-A14.
97.
Schive, Chi. 1993. Cross Investment in the Asia-Pacific: The Case of Taiwan's Inward and Outward Investment. Business and the Contemporary World5(2): 89-104.
98.
Schuman, Michael. 1996. Korea Inc. Speeds its Global Expansion As Life Grows Tougher in Home Market. Wall Street Journal (May 14): A13-A13.
99.
Seki, Mitsuhiro. 1995. The Destruction of the Full-Set Industrial Structure -East Asia's Tripolar Structure. Japanese Economic Studies23(1): 3-28.
100.
Selden, Mark. 1997. China, Japan, and the Regional Political Economy of East Asia, 1945-1995. In Network Power: Japan and Asia. Peter Katzenstein and Takashi Shiraishi (eds.). Pp. 306-340. Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press.
Smith, Richard. 1997. Creative Destruction: Capitalist Development and China's Environment. New Left Review (222): 3-41.
106.
Steven, Rob. 1990. Japan's New Imperialism. Armonk, N.Y.: M.E. Sharpe.
107.
Steven, Rob. 1997. Japanese Investment in Thailand, Indonesia and Malaysia: A Decade of JASEAN. In The Other Japan, New Edition. Joe Moore (ed.). Pp. 199-245. Armonk, N.Y.: M.E. Sharpe.
108.
Strom, Stephanie. 1998. South Koreans Protest Spread of Layoffs in I.M.F. Plan. New York Times (May 28): A7-A7.
109.
Sung, Yun-Wing. 1993. China's Impact on the Asian Pacific Regional Economy. Business and the Contemporary World5(2): 105-128.
110.
Sweezy, Paul M.1980. Japan in Perspective. Monthly Review31(9): 1-14.
111.
Tabb, William K.1992. Vampire Capitalism. Socialist Review22(1): 81-93.
112.
Tabb, William K.1994. Japanese Capitalism and the Asian Geese. Monthly Review45(10): 29-40.
113.
Tabb, William K.1996. The East and the World Today. Social Justice23(1-2): 250-261.
114.
Teranishi, Juro. 1996. Shared Growth and the East Asian Miracle. Journal of the Japanese and International Economies10(3): 312-317.
115.
Terry, Edith. 1996. An East Asian Paradigm?Atlantic Economic Journal24(3): 183-198.
116.
United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD). 1995. World Investment Report 1995. New York, N.Y.: United Nations.
117.
United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD). 1996a. Trade and Development Report 1996. New York, N.Y.: UNCTAD.
118.
United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD). 1996b. World Investment Report 1996. New York, N.Y.: United Nations.
119.
Updike, Edith and Laxmi Nakarmi. 1995. A Movable Feast for Mitsubishi. Business Week (August 28): 50-51.
120.
Van Der Meulen Rodgers, Yana. 1996. Indonesia's Macroeconomic and Trade Performance. Journal of Developing Areas30(2): 149-166.
121.
Wade, Robert. 1990. Governing the Market. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
122.
Wade, Robert. 1992. East Asia's Economic Success: Conflicting Perspectives, Partial Insights, Shaky Evidence. World Politics44(2): 270-320.
123.
Wade, Robert. 1993. The Visible Hand: The State and East Asia's Economic Growth. Current History92(December): 431-440.
124.
Wade, Robert. 1996. Japan, the World Bank, and the Art of Paradigm Maintenance. New Left Review No.217: 3-36.
125.
Wade, Robert and Frank Veneroso. 1998. The Asian Crisis: The High Debt Model Versus the Wall Street-Treasury-IMF Complex. New Left Review No. 228: 2-23.
126.
World Bank. 1993. The East Asian Miracle. New York: Oxford University Press.
127.
WuDunn, Sheryl. 1998. Asia's Tigers Lick Wounds and Worry. New York Times (September 16): C1-C1, C6-C6.
128.
Yam, Tan Kong. 1995. China and ASEAN: Rivals for Foreign Direct Investment. Asia Pacific Business Review2(1): 50-67.
129.
Yamin, Mohammad. 1991. A Reassessment of Hymer's Contribution. In The Nature of the Transnational Firm. Christos N. Pitelis and Roger Sugden (eds.). Pp. 64-80. London: Routledge.
130.
Yeung, Henry Wai-chung. 1997. Business Networks and Transnational Corporations: A Study of Hong Kong Firms in the ASEAN Region. Economic Geography73(1): 1-25.
131.
Yue, Chia Siow. 1993. Foreign Direct Investment in ASEAN Economies. Asian Development Review11 (1): 60-102.
132.
Zhao, Suisheng. 1997. Power Competition in East Asia. New York, N.Y.: St. Martin's Press.
