An Optimised Data Analysis for the Balb/c3T3 Cell Transformation Assay and its Application to Metal Compounds

Abstract

The Balb/c3T3 cell transformation assay (CTA) is an available in vitro system to detect the carcinogenic potential of chemicals. Currently, the European Centre for the Validation of Alternative Methods (ECVAM) is validating this test, assessing its reliability and relevance. Its endpoint is the formation of type III foci, which is, when using clone A31-1-1, a very rare event that usually does not occur at all for negative controls. The carcinogenic potential of a compound tested is assessed by comparing the number of foci in treated and untreated cells. The objective of the present work is to optimise the data analysis for this endpoint by applying the most commonly used approach by a t-test and the Fisher's exact test as an alternative approach. For this purpose selected metal compounds classified as carcinogenic (NaAsO₂, CdCl₂ cisPt), as suspected carcinogenic (C₆H₅)₄AsCl, CH₃HgCl), or as compounds without evidence of carcinogenic properties in humans ((NH₄)₂PtCl₆, NaVO₃) as well as a non-carcinogenic (AgNO₃) were analysed. Our evaluation revealed that the t-test approach, which assumes normality of data, is not appropriate. The results demonstrated that the statistical analysis by Fisher's exact test better reflects the data properties and greatly facilitates the interpretation of Balb/c3T3 CTA data regarding carcinogenic potential.

Keywords

Balb/c3T3 Cell Transformation Assay Fisher's exact test t-test metal compounds alternative methods

References

Mao

Ugnat

A.M.

and White

. 2000. Non-Hodgkin's lymphoma and occupational exposure to chemicals in Canada. Canadian Cancer Registries Epidemiology Research Group. Ann. Oncol. 11:69.

Elci

O.C.

Akpinar-Elci

Alavanja

and Dosemeci

. 2003. Occupation and the risk of lung cancer by histologic types and morphologic distribution: a case control study in Turkey. Monaldi Arch. Chest. Dis. 59:183.

Lee

W.J.

Hoppin

J.A.

Blair

Lubin

J.H.

Dosemeci

Sandler

D.P.

and Alavanja

M.C.

. 2004. Cancer incidence among pesticide applicators exposed to alachlor in the Agricultural Health Study. Am. J. Epidemiol. 159:373.

Samanic

Hoppin

J.A.

Lubin

J.H.

Blair

and Alavanja

M.C.

. 2005. Factor analysis of pesticide use patterns among pesticide applicators in the Agricultural Health Study. J. Expo. Anal. Environ. Epidemiol. 15:225.

Doll

1998. Epidemiological evidence of the effects of behaviour and the environment on the risk of human cancer. Recent Results Cancer Res. 154:3.

Kakunaga

1973. A quantitative system for assay of malignant transformation by carcinogens using a clone derived from Balb-3T3. Int. J. Cancer. 12:463.

Reznikoff

C.A.

Bertram

J.S.

Brankow

D.W.

and Heidelberger

. 1973. Quantitative and qualitative studies of chemical transformation of cloned C3H mouse embryo cells sensitive to postconfluence inhibition of cell division. Cancer Res. 33:3239.

Reznikoff

C.A.

Brankow

D.W.

and Heidelberger

. 1973. Establishment and characterization of a cloned line of C3H mouse embryo cells sensitive to postconfluence inhibition of division. Cancer Res. 33:3231.

Sivak

and Tu

A.S.

. 1980. Factors influencing neoplastic transformation by chemical carcinogens in Balb/c-3T3 cells. In The predictive value of short-term screening tests in carcinogenicity evaluation, Williams

G.M.

Kroes

Waaijers

H.W.

Van de Poll

K.W.

, eds. Elsevier/North Holland Biomedical Press, Amsterdam, New York, Oxford, p. 177.

10.

Sivak

Charest

M.C.

Rudenko

Silveira

D.M.

Simons

and Wood

A.M.

. 1980. Balb/c-3T3 cells as target cells for chemically induced neoplastic transformation. In Advances in modern environmental toxicology, mammalian cell transformation by chemical carcinogens, Vol I. Mishra

N. J.

Dunkel

Mehlman

, eds. Senate Press, Princeton Junction, p. 133.

11.

Heidelberger

Freeman

A.E.

Pienta

R.J.

Sivak

Bertram

J.S.

Casto

B.C.

Dunkel

V.C.

Francis

M.W.

Kakunaga

Little

J.B.

and Schechtman

L.M.

1983. Cell transformation by chemical agents - a review and analysis of the literature: a report of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Gene-Tox Program. Mutat. Res. 114:283.

12.

IARC/NCI/EPA Working Group. 1985. Cellular and molecular mechanisms of cell transformation and standardization of transformed assays of established cell lines for the prediction of carcinogenic chemicals: Overview and recommended protocols. Cancer Res. 45:2395.

13.

Dunkel

V.C.

Rogers

Swierenga

S.H.

Brillinger

R.L.

Gilman

J. P.

and Nestmann

E.R.

. 1991. Recommended protocols based on a survey of current practice in genotoxicity testing laboratories: III. Cell transformation in C3H/10T1/2 mouse embryo cell, Balb/c3T3 mouse fibroblast and Syrian hamster embryo cell cultures. Mutat. Res. 246:285.

14.

Environmental Protection Agency. 1996. Morphologic Transformation of Cells in Culture. Health Effects Test Guidelines OPPTS 870.8800, United States Environmental Protection Agency, Office for Prevention, Pesticides and Toxic Substances, EPA712-C-96-260, June 1996.

15.

Combes

Balls

Curren

Fischbach

Fusenig

Kirkland

Lasne

Landolph

LeBoeuf

Marquardt

McCormick

Muller

Rivedal

Sabbioni

Tanaka

Vasseur

and Yamasaki

. 1999. Cell Transformation Assays as Predictors of Human Carcinogenicity. In The Report and Recommendations of ECVAM Workshop 39. ATLA 27:745.

16.

EEC. 1981. Commission Decision of 11 May 1981 laying down the criteria in accordance with which information relating to the inventory of chemical substances is supplied by the Member States to the Commission 81/437/EEC, Official Journal of the European Communities, No L 167/31.

17.

Di Paolo

J.A.

Takano

and Popescu

N.C.

. 1972. Quantisation of chemically induced neoplastic transformation of BALB/3T3 cloned cell lines. Cancer Res. 32:2686.

18.

Casto

B.C.

Pieczynski

W.J.

Nelson

R.L.

and Dipaolo

J.A.

. 1976. In vitro transformation and enhancement of viral transformation with metals. Proc. Am. Assoc. Cancer Res. 17:12.

19.

Popescu

and Dipaolo

. 1982. The relevance of sister-chromatid exchange to the induction of neoplastic cell transformation. In Sister Chromatid Exchange, ed. Liss

A. R.

, New York, p. 425.

20.

Bertolero

Pozzi

Sabbioni

and Saffiotti

. 1987. Cellular uptake and metabolic reduction of pentavalent to trivalent arsenic as determinants of cytotoxicity and morphological transformation. Carcinogenesis 8:803.

21.

LeBoeuf

R.A.

Kerckaert

G.A.

Poiley

J.A.

and Raineri

. 1989. An interlaboratory comparison of enhanced morphological transformation of Syrian hamster embryo cells cultured under conditions of reduced bicarbonate concentration and pH. Mutat. Res. 222:205.

22.

Sabbioni

Pozzi

Pintar

Casella

and Garattini

. 1991. Cellular retention, cytotoxicity and morphological transformation by vanadium(IV) and vanadium(V) in BALB/3T3 cell lines. Carcinogenesis 12:47.

23.

Sabbioni

Pozzi

Devos

Pintar

Casella

and Fischbach

. 1993. The intensity of vanadium(V)-induced cytotoxicity and morphological transformation in BALB/3T3 cells is dependent on glutathione-mediated bioreduction to vanadium(IV). Carcinogenesis 14:2565.

24.

Sabbioni

Fischbach

Pozzi

Pietra

Gallorini

and Piette

J.L.

. 1991. Cellular retention, toxicity and carcinogenic potential of seafood arsenic. I. Lack of cytotoxicity and transforming activity of arsenobetaine in the BALB/3T3 cell line. Carcinogenesis 12:1287.

25.

Mazzotti

Sabbioni

Ponti

Ghiani

Fortaner

and Rossi

G.L.

. 2002. In vitro setting of dose-effect relationships of 32 metal compounds in the Balb/3T3 cell line as a basis for predicting their carcinogenic potential. ATLA 30:209.

26.

Saffiotti

Bertolero

Bignami

M. F.

Cortesi Ficarella

and Kaighn

M.E.

. 1984. Studies on chemically induced neoplastic transformation and mutation in the Balb/3T3 Cl A31-1-1 cell line in relation to the quantitative evaluation of carcinogens. Toxicol. Pathol. 12:383.

27.

Bailey Norman

T.J.

1959. In Statistical Methods in Biology, ed. Wiley and Sons, Inc., N.Y. p. 50.

28.

Agresti

1992. A Survey of Exact Inference for Contingency Tables. Statistical Science 7:131.

29.

Matthews

E.J.

Spalding

J.W.

and Tennant

R.W.

. 1993. Transformation of BALB/c-3T3 cells: IV. Rank-ordered potency of 24 chemical responses detected in a sensitive new assay procedure. Environ. Health Perspect. 101:319.

30.

NTP (National Toxicology Program). 1993. NTP technical report on the toxicology and carcinogenesis of mercuric chloride (CAS No. 7487-94-7) in F344 rats and B6C3F1 mice (gavage studies). NTP TR 408. National Toxicology Program, U.S. Dept. Health Human serv., Public Health Service, National Institutes of Health, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina.

31.

Hirano

Mitsumori

Maita

and Shirasu

. 1986. Further carcinogenicity study on methylmercury chloride in ICR mice. Jpn. J. Vet. Sci. 48:127.

32.

Mitsumori

Takahashi

Matano

Goto

and Shirasu

. 1983. Chronic toxicity of methylmercury chloride in rats: clinical study and chemical analysis. Japan. J. Vet. Sci. 45:747.

33.

Mitsumori

Maiata

and Shirasu

. 1984. Chronic toxicity of methylmercury chloride in rats: pathological study. Japan. J. Vet. Sci. 46:549.

34.

Mitsumori

Hiarano

Ueda

Maiata

and Shirasu

. 1990. Chronic toxicity and carcinogenicity of methylmercury chloride in B6C3F1 mice. Fundam. Appl. Toxicol. 14:179.

35.

Matthews

E.J.

1993. Transformation of BALB/c-3T3 Cells: II. Investigation of Experimental Parameters That Influence Detection of Benzo(a)pyrene-Induced Transformation. Environ. Health Perspectives, 101:293.

36.

Berwald

and Sachs

. 1965. In vitro transformation of normal cells to tumor cells by carcinogenic hydrocarbons. J. Natl. Cancer Inst. 35:641.

37.

Gottmann

Kramer

Pfahringer

and Helma

. 2001. Data quality in predictive toxicology: reproducibility of rodent carcinogenicity experiments. Environ. Health Perspectives. 109:509.

38.

Gold

L.S.

de Veciana

Backman

G.M.

Magaw

Lopipero

Smith

Blumenthal

Levinson

Gerson

and Bernstein

. 1986. Chronological supplement to the Carcinogenic Potency Database: standardized results of animal bioassays published through December 1982. Environ. Health Perspect. 67:161.

39.

Gaylor

D.W.

and Chen

J.J.

. 1986. Relative potency of chemical carcinogens in rodents. Risk Anal. 6:283.

40.

Matthews

E.J.

1993. Transformation of BALB/C-3T3 cells: I. Investigation of experimental parameters that influence detection of spontaneous transformation. Environ. Health Perspect. 101:277.

41.

Anon. 1996. Morphologic Transformation of Cells in Culture. Health Effects Test Guidelines. OPPTS 870.8800. United States Environmental Protection Agency, Prevention, Pesticides and Toxic Substances (7101), EPA712-C-96-260, June 1996.

42.

Whorton

E.B.

Ward

J.B.

and Morris

D. L.

Jr . 1982. Experimental design and statistical analysis considerations for in vitro mammalian cell transformation assays with Balb/3T3 cells. Environ. Mutagen. 4:595.

43.

Nishiyama

Tsuchiya

Yoshimura

and Umeda

. 2002. Three-step method of data analysis, incorporating multiple contrast method to detect carcinogenic substances in cell transformation assay. Fourth World Congress on Alternatives and Animal Use in the Life Sciences, Aug. 10–15, New Orleans, LA (USA), Poster abstract E21.

44.

Schechtman

L.M.

1985. Balb/c3T3 cell transformation: protocols, problems and improvements. In Transformation assay of established cell lines: mechanisms and application, International Agency for Research on Cancer, ed. Oxford University Press p. 165.

45.

Matthews

E.J.

1986. Assessment of chemical carcinogen-induced transforming activity using BALB/C-3T3 cells. J. Tiss. Cult. Meth. 10:157.

46.

Casto

B.C.

Meyers

and Dipaolo

J.A.

. 1979. Enhancement of viral transformation for evaluation of the carcinogenic or mutagenic potential of inorganic metal salts. Cancer Res. 39:193.