Concurrent two surgeon approach for bilateral synchronous percutaneous nephrolithotomy: Initial experience at a University Teaching Hospital

Abstract

Percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PNL) has long been considered the bench-mark intervention for complicated urinary stones and has undergone important advancements since it was first described. Given the proven safety and efficacy of PNL, simultaneous bilateral PNL has been attempted for bilateral renal calculi to cut down on total procedure costs. To further cut down on operative time, concurrent bilateral synchronous PNL (BS-PNL) has been performed involving two surgeons, each operating concurrently on one renal unit. We performed a retrospective study to evaluate the safety and efficacy of BS-PNL in patients who consented for the procedure. Mean operative time taken from percutaneous access to skin closure was 78 min which was lower than that taken during the single surgeon approach for simultaneous bilateral PNL. Two (12%) out of 16 renal units required multiple punctures for stone clearance. Sheath size varied between 26Fr to 30Fr depending on the stone burden. Mean duration of hospital stay was 2 days. Fourteen (88%) out of 16 renal units had complete stone clearance. Fifteen (94%) out of 16 renal units had a double J stent placed for drainage. Only two patients had complications in the form of postoperative fever. In the background of already proven safety and efficacy of SB-PNL, the concurrent two surgeon approach appears to be feasible and safe with additional advantage of reduced operative time. However, the number of patients in this series were limited and a bigger and preferably multi-institutional study would be required before we can come to a definitive conclusion.