To test whether the demonstrated correlation between Kt/V urea and normalised protein catabolic rate (NPCR) is caused by a mathematical artifact, we examined 12 adult and 8 paediatric haemodialysis patients. Kt/V was determined by the classical method. As an equivalent of NPCR we measured normalised urea generation rate (NUGR) by a one-week collection of dialysate and urine using total body water estimated by bioelectrical impedance for normalisation. The correlation between Kt/V and NUGR was 0.58 (all), 0.55 (adults), and 0.62 (children). Since the determination of Kt/V and NUGR are not interdependent, we conclude that the correlation between Kt/V and protein catabolism is not artifactual.
LairdN.M., BerkeyC.S., LowrieE.G.. Modeling success or failure of dialysis therapy: The National Cooperative Dialysis Study.Kidney Int.1983; 23(suppl 13): S101–6.
2.
GotchF.A., SargentJ.A.. A mechanistic analysis of the National Cooperative Dialysis Study (NCDS).Kidney Int1985; 28: 526–34.
3.
LowrieE.G., LewN.L.. Death risk in hemodialysis patients: the predictive value of commonly measured variables and an evaluation of death rate differences between facilities.Am J Kidney Dis1990; 15: 458–82.
4.
LindsayR.M., SpannerE.. A hypothesis: the protein catabolic rate is dependent upon the type and amount of treatment in dialyzed uremic patiants.Am J Kidney Dis1989; 13: 382–9.
5.
LindsayR.M., SpannerE., HeidenheimA.P., LindsayS., LeFebvreJ.M.. The influence of dialysis membrane upon protein catabolic rate.ASAIO Trans1991; 37: M134–5.
6.
LindsayR.M., SpannerE., HeidenheimR.P.. Which comes first, Kt/V or PCR - Chicken or egg?Kidney Int1992; 38(suppl): S-32–S-36.
7.
MovilliE., MombelloniS., GaggiottiM., MaiorcaR.. Effect of age on protein catabolic rate, morbidity, and mortality in uraemic patients with adequate dialysis.Nephrol Dial Transplant1993; 8: 735–9.
8.
VenningM.C., FaragherE.B., HartyJ.C.. The relationship between KT/V and NPCR in haemodialysis patients in cross-sectional studies is mathematical coupling (Abstract).Am Soc Nephrol, 26th Annual Meeting Boston 1993.
9.
BuurT., LarssonR.. Accuracy of hemodialysis urea kinetic modeling. Comparison of different models.Nephron1991; 59: 358–63.
10.
LukaskiH.C., BolonchukW.W.. Estimation of body fluid volumes using tetrapolar bioelectrical impedance measurements.Aviat Space Environ Med1988; 59: 1163–9.
11.
DelmezJ.A., WindusD.W., BanderS.. Hemodialysis prescription and delivery in a metropolitan community.Kidney Int1992; 41: 1023–8.
12.
BuurT., TimpkaT.. Improvement of decisions regarding hemodialysis patients by urea kinetic modelling.Med Decis Making1990; 10: 274–82.
13.
MorgensternA., WinklerJ., NarkisR.. Adequacy of dialysis and nutritional status in hemodyalisis patients.Nephron1994; 66: 438–41.
