Stainless steel is a metallic alloy largely employed in orthopedics, maxillofacial surgery and orthodontic therapy. However, the presence in its composition of a high quantity of nickel, an agent known to trigger toxic, allergic and cancerogenous responses in humans, is cause of some concern. In this study, we have investigated the in vitro mutagenicity and genotoxicity of a new nickel-free stainless steel, namely P558, in comparison to the conventional stainless steel AISI 316L. The cytogenetic effects were evaluated by studying the frequency of Sister Chromatid Exchanges (SCE) and chromosomal aberrations. Ames test was performed to detect the mutagenic activity. Both P558 and AISI 316L did not cause any significant increase in the average number of SCE and in chromosomal aberrations, either with or without metabolic activation. Furthermore, the Ames test showed that the extracts of both P558 and of AISI 316L are not mutagenic. Overall, these findings prove that P558 is devoid of genotoxicity and mutagenicity. The present results, together with other previous interesting observations that P558 promotes osseointegration, suggest that this new nickel-free stainless steel can represent a better alternative to other conventional steel alloys.
SmithD.C.Tissue reaction to noble and base metal alloys. In: SmithD.C., WilliamsD.F., eds. Biocompatibility of dental materials. Volume IV. Boca Raton, Florida: CRC Press, Inc., 1982; pp. 51–74.
2.
WilliamsD., CahnR.W., BeverM.B.Concise encyclopaedia of medical and dental materials.Oxford, New York, Beijing Frankfurt, Sào Paulo, Sydney, Tokyo, Toronto: Pergamon Press, 1990; pp. 4–70.
3.
SchmidtC., IgnatiusA., ClaesL.E.Proliferation and differentiation parameters of human osteoblasts on titanium and steel surfaces. J Biomed Mater Res2001; 54: 209–15.
4.
JacobsJ.J., GilbertJ.L., UrbanR.M.Corrosion of metal orthopaedic implants. J Bone Joint Surg (Am)1998; 80-A: 268–82.
5.
WoodmanJ.L., BlackJ., JimenezS.Organometallic corrosion products of 316L SS and HS-21 in serum: In vitro and in vivo comparison in an acute rat model. In: WinterG.D., GibbonD.F., PlenkH.Jr, eds. Biomaterials1980. Chichester, New York, Brisbane, Toronto, Singapore: John Wiley & Sons, 1982; pp. 245–53.
6.
TracanaR.B., PereiraM.L., AbreuA.M., SousaJ.P., CarvalhoG.S.Stainless steel corrosion products cause alterations on mouse spleen cellular. J Mater Sci Mater Med1995; 6: 56–61.
7.
WeberG.W., ReidB.L.Nickel toxicity in young growing mice. J Animal Sci1969; 28: 620–3.
8.
O'DellG.D., MillerW.J., KingW.A., MooreS.L., BlackmonD.M.Nickel toxicity in the young bovine. J Nutr1970; 100: 1447–53.
9.
LouriaD.B., JoselowM.M., BrowderA.A.The human toxicity of certain trace elements. Ann Intern Med1972; 76: 307–19.
10.
WhangerP.D.Effects of dietary nickel on enzyme activities and mineral contents in rats. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol1973; 25: 323–31.
11.
CookS.D., RenzE.A., BarrackR.L., ThomasK.A., HardingA.F., HaddadR.J., MilicicM.Clinical and metallurgical analysis of retrieved internal fixation devices. Clin Orthop1985; 194: 236–47.
12.
JacobsJ.J., SkiporA.K., PattersonL.M., HallabN.J., PaproskyW.G., BlackJ., GalanteJ.O.Metal release in patients who have had a primary total hip arthroplasty. A prospective, controlled, longitudinal study. J Bone Joint Surg (Am)1998; 10-A: 1447–58.
13.
RostokerG., RobinJ., BinetO., BlamoutierJ., PaupeJ., Lessana-LeibowitchM., BedouelleJ., SonneckJ.M., GarrelJB, and MilletP.Dermatitis due to orthopedic implants. J Bone Joint Surg (Am)1987; 69-A: 1408–12.
14.
LindenJ.V., HoplerS.M., GosslingH.R., SundermanF.W.JrBlood nickel concentrations in patients with stainless-steel hip prostheses. Ann Clin Lab Sci1985; 15: 459–64.
15.
CramersM., LuchtU.Metal sensitivity in patients treated for tibial fractures with plates of stainless steel. Acta Orthop Scand1977; 48: 245–9.
16.
PerrenS.M., AllgowerM., BrunnerH.The concept of biological plating using the Limited Contact-Dynamic Compression Plate (LC-DCP). Scientific background, design and application. Injury1991; 22: 1–41.
17.
GennartJ.P., BaleuxC., Verellen DumoulinC., BuchetJ.P., De MeyerR.Increased sister chromatid exchanges and tumor markers in workers exposed to elemental chromium, cobalt and nickel containig dusts. Mutat Res1993; 299: 55–61.
18.
MoulinJ.J., WildP., MantoutB., Fournier BetzM., MurJ.M., SmaggheG.Mortality from lung cancer and cardiovascular diseases among stainless steel producing workers. Cancer Cause Control1993; 4: 75–81.
19.
SjogrenB., HansenK.S., KjuusH., PerssonP.G.Exposure to stainless steel welding fumes and lung cancer: A meta analysis. Occup Env Med1994; 51: 335–6.
20.
TorricelliP., FiniM., BorsariV., LengerH., BernauerJ., TschonM., BonazziV., GiardinoR.Biomaterials in orthopedic surgery: Effects of a nickel-reduced stainless steel on in vitro proliferation and activation of human osteoblasts. Int J Artif Organs2003; 26: 952–7.
21.
ÖrnhagenC., NilssonJ.O., VannevikH.Characterization of a nitrogen-rich austenitic stainless steel used for osteo-synthesis devices. J Biomed Mater Res1996; 31: 97–103.
22.
BernauerJ., HochörtlerG.A new carbon alloyed nickel-free corrosion resistant austenitic steel grade: Metallurgical design and properties. Proceedings of “Stainless Steel 99 Science and Market”. Associazione Italiana di Metallurgia 1999: 473–6.
23.
HochörtlerG., BernauerJ., KrisztK.Corrosion behaviour and nickel release of alloys with various nickel contents. Materials for Medical Engineering.Weinheim: Wiley-VCH, 2000; pp. 204–9.
24.
DisegiJ.A., EschbachL.Stainless steel in bone surgery. Injury2000; 31: 2–6.
25.
FiniM., Nicoli AldiniN., TorricelliP., GiavaresiG., BorsariV., LengerH., BernauerJ., GiardinoR., ChiesaR., CigadaA.A new austenitic stainless steel with negligible nickel content: An in vitro and in vivo comparative investigation. Biomaterials2003; 24: 4929–39.
26.
SO 10993 - 3: 2003Biological evaluation of medical devices -Part 3: Tests for genotoxicity, carcinogenicity and reproductive toxicity.
27.
AmesB.N., Mc CannJ., YamasakiE.Methods for detecting carcinogens and mutagens with the Salmonella/mammalian microsome mutagenicity test. Mutat Res1975; 31: 347–64.
28.
MaronD.M., AmesB.N.Revised methods for the Salmonella mutagenicity test. Mutat Res1983; 113: 173–215.
29.
VeramR.S., BabuA.Human chromosome - Manual of basic techniques. Pergamon Press, Oxford: 1989; pp. 47–8.
30.
SchwarzacherH.G., WolfU.Metodi nella Citogenetica Umana1978; Piccin Editore, Padova.
31.
AshbyJ., TennantR.W.Definitive relationships among chemical structure, carcinogenicity and mutagenicity for 301 chemicals tested by the U.S. NTP. Mutat Res1991; 3: 229–306.
32.
SgourasD., DuncanR.Methods for the evaluation of biocompatibility of soluble synthetic polymers which have potential for biomedical use. Use of the tetrazolium-based colorimetric assay as a preliminary screen for evaluation of in vitro cytotoxicity. J Mater Sci Mater Med1990; 1: 61–8.
33.
ISO 10993 - 1: 2003.Biological evaluation of medical devices - Part 1: Evaluation and testing.
34.
PohlerO.E.Unalloyed titanium for implants in bone surgery. Injury2000; 31(suppl 4): S7–13.
35.
Brayda-BrunoM., FiniM., PieriniG., GiavaresiG., RoccaM., GiardinoR.Evaluation of systemic metal diffusion after spinal pedicular fixation with titanium alloy and stainless steel system: A 36-month experimental study in sheep. Int J Artif Organs2001; 24: 41–9.
36.
RoccaM., FiniM., GreggiT., ParisiniP., CarpiA., GiardinoR.Biomaterials in spinal fixation. An experimental animal study to improve the performance. Int J Artif Organs2000; 23: 824–30.
37.
JonesD.M., MarshJ.L., NepolaJ.V., JacobsJ.J., SkiporA.K., UrbanR.M., GilbertJ.L., BuckwalterJ.A.Related articles, links Focal osteolysis at the junctions of a modular stainless-steel femoral intramedullary nail. J Bone Joint Surg (Am)2001; 83-A: 537–48.
38.
CancilleriF., De GiorgisP., VerdoiaC., ParriniL., LodiA., CroastiC.Allergy to components of total hip arthroplasty before and after surgery. Ital J Orthop Traumatol1992; 18: 407–10.
39.
Milavec-PureticV., OrlicD., MarusicA.Sensitivity to metals in 40 patients with failed hip endoprosthesis. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg1998; 117: 383–6.
