Microfracture and drilling are bone marrow–stimulation techniques that initiate cartilage repair by providing access to cell populations in subchondral bone marrow. This study examined the effect of hole depth and of microfracture versus drilling on subchondral bone repair and cartilage repair in full-thickness chondral defects.
Hypotheses
Repaired subchondral bone does not reconstitute its native structure and exhibits atypical morphologic features. Drilling deeper induces greater bone remodeling and is related to improved cartilage repair.
Study Design
Controlled laboratory study.
Methods
Trochlear cartilage defects debrided of the calcified layer were prepared bilaterally in 16 skeletally mature rabbits. Drill holes were made to a depth of 2 mm or 6 mm and microfracture holes to 2 mm. Animals were sacrificed 3 months postoperatively, and joints were scanned by micro–computed tomography before histoprocessing. Bone repair was assessed with a novel scoring system and by 3-dimentional micro–computed tomography and compared with intact controls. Correlation of subchon-dral bone features to cartilage repair outcome was performed.
Results
Although surgical holes were partly repaired with mineralized tissue, atypical features such as residual holes, cysts, and bony overgrowth were frequently observed. For all treatment groups, repair led to an average bone volume density similar to that of the controls but the repair bone was more porous and branched as shown by significantly higher bone surface area density and connectivity density. Deeper versus shallower drilling induced a larger region of repairing and remodeling subchondral bone that positively correlated with improved cartilage repair.
Conclusion
Incomplete reconstitution of normal bone structure and continued remodeling occurred in chondral defects 3 months after bone marrow stimulation. Deep drilling induced a larger volume of repairing and remodeling bone, which appeared beneficial for chondral repair.
Clinical Relevance
Bone marrow stimulation does not reconstitute normal bone structure. Strategies that increase subchondral bone involvement in marrow stimulation could further benefit cartilage repair.
BrownWE, PotterHG, MarxRG, WickiewiczTL, WarrenRF. Magnetic resonance imaging appearance of cartilage repair in the knee. Clin Orthop Relat Res.2004; 422: 214–223
4.
BuschmannMD, HoemannCD, HurtigMB, ShiveMS. Cartilage repair with chitosan/glycerol-phosphate stabilised blood clots. In: WilliamsRJ, ed. Cartilage Repair: Analysis and Strategies.Totowa, NJ: Humana Press;2007.
5.
ChenG, SunJ, Lascau-ComanVAcute osteoclast activity following subchondral drilling is promoted by chitosan and associated with improved cartilage repair tissue integration. Cartilage.2011; 2(2): 173–185.
6.
ChenH, HoemannCD, SunJDepth of subchondral perforation influences the outcome of bone marrow stimulation cartilage repair. J Orthop Res.2011 (in press)
7.
ChenH, SunJ, HoemannCDDrilling and microfracture lead to different bone structure and necrosis during bone-marrow stimulation for cartilage repair. J Orthop Res.2009; 27(11): 1432–1438.
8.
ChevrierA, HoemannCD, SunJ, BuschmannMD. Chitosan-glycerol phosphate/blood implants increase cell recruitment, transient vascu-larization and subchondral bone remodeling in drilled cartilage defects. Osteoarthritis Cartilage.2007; 15(3): 316–327.
9.
ChevrierA, RossomachaE, BuschmannMD, HoemannCD. Optimization of histoprocessing methods to detect glycosaminoglycan, collagen type II, and collagen type I in decalcified rabbit osteochondral sections. J Histotechnology.2005; 28(3): 165–175.
10.
ColeBJ, Pascual-GarridoC, GrumetRC. Surgical management of articular cartilage defects in the knee. J Bone Joint Surg Am.2009; 91(7): 1778–1790.
11.
DingM, DanielsenCC, HvidI. The effects of bone remodeling inhibition by alendronate on three-dimensional microarchitecture of sub-chondral bone tissues in guinea pig primary osteoarthrosis. Calcif Tissue Int.2008; 82(1): 77–86.
12.
FrisbieDD, TrotterGW, PowersBEArthroscopic subchondral bone plate microfracture technique augments healing of large chon-dral defects in the radial carpal bone and medial femoral condyle of horses. Vet Surg.1999; 28(4): 242–255.
13.
GomollAH, MadryH, KnutsenGThe subchondral bone in articular cartilage repair: current problems in the surgical management. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc.2010; 18(4): 434–447.
14.
HendersonIJP, La ValetteDP. Subchondral bone overgrowth in the presence of full-thickness cartilage defects in the knee. Knee.2005; 12(6): 435–440.
15.
HildebrandT, LaibA, MullerR, DequekerJ, RuegseggerP. Direct three-dimensional morphometric analysis of human cancellous bone: microstructural data from spine, femur, iliac crest, and calca-neus. J Bone Miner Res.1999; 14(7): 1167–1174.
16.
HoemannCD, ChenG, MarchandCScaffold-guided subchon-dral bone repair: implication of neutrophils and alternatively activated arginase-1+ macrophages. Am J Sports Med.2010; 38(9): 1845–1856.
17.
HoemannCD, HurtigMB, RossomachaEChitosan-glycerol phosphate/blood implants improve hyaline cartilage repair in ovine microfracture defects. J Bone Joint Surg Am.2005; 87(12): 2671–2686.
18.
HoemannCD, SunJ, McKeeMDChitosan-glycerol phosphate/ blood implants elicit hyaline cartilage repair integrated with porous subchondral bone in microdrilled rabbit defects. Osteoarthritis Cartilage.2007; 15(1): 78–89.
19.
JacksonDW, LalorPA, AbermanHM, SimonTM. Spontaneous repair of full-thickness defects of articular cartilage in a goat model: a preliminary study. J Bone Joint Surg Am.2001; 83(1): 53–64.
KellettCF, BoscainosPJ, GrossAE. Surgical options for articular defects of the knee. Expert Rev Med Devices.2006; 3(5): 585–593.
22.
KreuzPC, SteinwachsMR, ErggeletCResults after microfracture of full-thickness chondral defects in different compartments in the knee. Osteoarthritis Cartilage.2006; 14(11): 1119–1125.
23.
MarchandC, ChenH, BuschmannMD, HoemannCD. Standardized three-dimensional volumes of interest with adapted surfaces for more precise subchondral bone analyses by micro-computed tomography. Tissue Eng Part C Methods.2011; 17(4): 475–484.
24.
MatsunagaD, AkizukiS, TakizawaT, YamazakiI, KuraishiJ. Repair of articular cartilage and clinical outcome after osteotomy with microfracture or abrasion arthroplasty for medial gonarthrosis. Knee.2007; 14(6): 465–471.
25.
MenetreyJ, Unno-VeithF, MadryH, Van BreuseghemI. Epidemiology and imaging of the subchondral bone in articular cartilage repair. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc.2010; 18(4): 463–471.
26.
MinasT, GomollAH, RosenbergerR, RoyceRO, BryantT. Increased failure rate of autologous chondrocyte implantation after previous treatment with marrow stimulation techniques. Am J Sports Med.2009; 37(5): 902–908.
27.
MithoeferK, McAdamsT, WilliamsRJ, KreuzPC, MandelbaumBR. Clinical efficacy of the microfracture technique for articular cartilage repair in the knee: an evidence-based systematic analysis. Am J Sports Med.2009; 37(10): 2053–2063.
28.
MithoeferK, WilliamsRJ3rd, WarrenRFThe microfracture technique for the treatment of articular cartilage lesions in the knee: a prospective cohort study. J Bone Joint Surg Am.2005; 87(9): 1911–1920.
29.
NewmanAP. Articular cartilage repair. Am J Sports Med.1998; 26(2): 309–324.
30.
NishitaniK, ShiraiT, KobayashiMPositive effect of alendronate on subchondral bone healing and subsequent cartilage repair in a rabbit osteochondral defect model. Am J Sports Med.2009; 37:139S–147S.
31.
PascarellaA, CiattiR, PascarellaFTreatment of articular cartilage lesions of the knee joint using a modified AMIC technique. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc.2010; 18(4): 509–513.
32.
PridieKH. A method of resurfacing osteoarthritic knee joints. J Bone Joint Surg Br.1959; 41(3): 618–619.
33.
PughJW, RadinEL, RoseRM. Quantitative studies of human sub-chondral cancellous bone: its relationship to state of its overlying cartilage. J Bone Joint Surg Am.1974; 56(2): 313–321.
34.
QiuYS, ShahgaldiBF, RevellWJ, HeatleyFW. Observations of sub-chondral plate advancement during osteochondral repair: a histomor-phometric and mechanical study in the rabbit femoral condyle. Osteoarthritis Cartilage.2003; 11(11): 810–820.
35.
RadinEL. Subchondral bone changes and cartilage damage. Equine Vet J.1999; 31(2): 94–95.
36.
RadinEL, RoseRM. Role of subchondral bone in the initiation and progression of cartilage damage. Clin Orthop Relat Res.1986; 213: 34–40
37.
SarisDBF, DhertWJA, VerboutAJ. Joint homeostasis: the discrepancy between old and fresh defects in cartilage repair. J Bone Joint Surg Br.2003; 85(7): 1067–1076.
38.
SarisDBF, VanlauweJ, VictorJTreatment of symptomatic cartilage defects of the knee: characterized chondrocyte implantation results in better clinical outcome at 36 months in a randomized trial compared to microfracture. Am J Sports Med.2009; 37 Suppl 1: 10S–19S.
39.
SchlichtingK, SchellH, KleemannRUInfluence of scaffold stiffness on subchondral bone and subsequent cartilage regeneration in an ovine model of osteochondral defect healing. Am J Sports Med.2008; 36(12): 2379–2391.
40.
ShapiroF, KoideS, GlimcherM. Cell origin and differentiation in the repair of full-thickness defects of articular cartilage. J Bone Joint Surg Am.1993; 75(4): 532–553.
41.
SimonTM, JacksonDW. Articular cartilage: injury pathways and treatment options. Sports Med Arthrosc Rev.2006; 14(3): 146–154.
42.
SolomonDJ, WilliamsRIII, WarrenRF. Marrow stimulation and microfracture for the repair of articular cartilage lesions. In: WilliamsRJ, ed. Cartilage Repair: Analysis and Strategies.Totowa, NJ: Humana Press;2007.
43.
SteadmanJ, RodkeyW, SingletonS, BriggsK. Microfracture technique for full-thickness chondral defects: technique and clinical results. Oper Tech Orthop.1997; 7(4): 300–304.
44.
VasaraAI, HyttinenMM, LammiMJSubchondral bone reaction associated with chondral defect and attempted cartilage repair in goats. Calcif Tissue Int.2004; 74(1): 107–114.
45.
WeiXC, GaoJZ, MessnerK. Maturation-dependent repair of untreated osteochondral defects in the rabbit knee joint. J Biomed Mater Res.1997; 34(1): 63–72.
46.
WeiXC, MessnerK. Maturation-dependent durability of spontaneous cartilage repair in rabbit knee joint. J Biomed Mater Res.1999; 46(4): 539–548.
47.
WeitzelPP. Complications of articular cartilage surgery. Sports Med Arthrosc Rev.2004; 12(3): 160–166.
