Background: Tibial tunnel preparation may contribute to improved soft tissue graft fixation.
Hypothesis: Step dilation produces greater tunnel wall bone volume than does extraction drilling and increases fixation strength. Bioabsorbable interference screw divergence decreases fixation strength, regardless of tunnel preparation method.
Study Design: Controlled laboratory study.
Methods: Twenty porcine tibias were divided into 2 groups of 10 with matching mean apparent bone mineral density. One group received 9-mm-diameter extraction-drilled tunnels, and the other group received 7-mm-diameter extraction-drilled tunnels followed by step dilation to 9 mm. High-resolution quantitative computerized tomography scans and voxel analysis techniques determined tunnel wall bone volume fraction. Screws secured 8.5-mm-diameter porcine grafts in the tunnels. Repeat scans were used to determine screw divergence. Cyclic loading was performed in a servohydraulic device before load to failure testing.
Results: The step dilation group had greater tunnel wall bone volume/total volume than did the extraction drilled group; however, a significant increase in fixation strength was not detected. Specimens with screw divergence angles less than 15° had superior fixation and insertion torques compared with specimens with angles 15° or more. Screw divergence correlated more strongly with fixation strength than did mean apparent bone mineral density or screw insertion torque.
Conclusion: Step dilation increased tunnel wall bone volume/total volume, but fixation strength did not improve. Screw divergence ≥15° decreases graft-bone tunnel fixation whether or not step dilation is performed.
Clinical Relevance: Screw alignment plays a greater role in anterior cruciate ligament graft fixation than does extraction drilling or step dilation tunnel preparation methods in healthy bone.
Adam F, Pape D, Schiel K, Steimer O, Kohn D, Rupp S.Biomechanical properties of patellar and hamstring graft tibial fixation techniques in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Am J Sports Med.2004;32: 71-78.
2.
Bailey SB, Grover DM, Howell SM, Hull ML.Foam-reinforced elderly human tibia approximates young human tibia better than porcine tibia. Am J Sports Med.2004;32: 755-764.
3.
Beynnon BD, Amis AA.In vitro testing protocols for the cruciate ligaments and ligament reconstructions. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc.1998;6(suppl 1): S70-S76.
4.
Brand JC Jr, Caborn DNM, Johnson DL.Biomechanics of soft-tissue interference screw fixation for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Orthopedics.2003;26: 432-439.
5.
Brand JC Jr, Pienkowski D, Steenlage E, Hamilton D, Johnson DL, Caborn DN.Interference screw fixation strength of a quadrupled hamstring tendon graft is directly related to bone mineral density and insertion torque. Am J Sports Med.2000;28: 705-710.
6.
Brand JC Jr, Weiler A, Caborn DNM, Brown CH Jr, Johnson DL.Graft fixation in cruciate ligament reconstruction. Am J Sports Med.2000; 28: 761-774.
7.
Brandsson S, Faxen E, Eriksson BI, Sward L, Lundin O, Karlsson J.Reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament: comparison of outside-in and all-inside techniques. Br J Sports Med. 1999;33: 42-45.
8.
Caborn DNM, Coen M, Neef R, Hamilton D, Nyland J, Johnson DL.Quadrupled semitendinosus-gracilis autograft fixation in the femoral tunnel: a comparison between a metal and a bioabsorbable interference screw. Arthroscopy.1998;14: 241-245.
Cain EL, Phillips BB, Charlebois SJ, Azar FM.Effect of tibial tunnel dilation on pullout strength of semitendinosus-gracilis graft in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Orthopedics.2005;28: 779-783.
11.
Charlick DA, Caborn DNM.Alternative soft-tissue graft preparation technique for cruciate ligament reconstruction. Arthroscopy.2000;16: 3-5.
12.
Frank CB, Jackson DW.The science of reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament. J Bone Joint Surg Am.1997;79: 1556-1576.
13.
Friedlander AL, Genant HK, Sadowsky S, Byl NN, Gluer CC.A two-year program of aerobics and weight training enhances bone mineral density of young women. J Bone Miner Res.1995;10: 574-585.
14.
Fu FH, Bennett CH, Ma CB, Menetrey J, Lattermann C.Current trends in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, part II: operative procedures and clinical correlations. Am J Sports Med.2000;28: 124-130.
15.
Graham SM, Parker RD.Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using hamstring tendon grafts. Clin Orthop Relat Res.2002;402: 64-75.
16.
Green JR, Nemzek JA, Arnoczky SP, Johnson LL, Balas MS.The effect of bone compaction on early fixation of porous-coated implants. J Arthroplasty. 1999;14: 91-97.
17.
Heinonen A, Oja P, Kannus P, et al.Bone mineral density in female athletes representing sports with different loading characteristics of the skeleton. Bone.1995;17: 197-203.
18.
Howell SM, Clark JA.Tibial tunnel placement in anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions and graft impingement. Clin Orthop Relat Res.1992;283: 187-195.
19.
Järvinen TLN, Nurmi JT, Sievänen H.Bone density and insertion torque as predictors of anterior cruciate ligament graft fixation strength. Am J Sports Med.2004;32: 1421-1429.
20.
Johnson LL.Bone compaction techniques in knee ligament reconstruction. Tech Orthop.1998;13: 341-352.
21.
Johnson RJ, Beynnon BD, Nichols CE, Renstrom PA.Current concepts review: the treatment of injuries of the anterior cruciate ligament. J Bone Joint Surg Am.1992;74: 140-151.
22.
Kato T, Terashima T, Yamashita T, Hatanaka Y, Honda A, Umemura Y.Effect of low-repetition jump training on bone mineral density in young women. J Appl Physiol.2006;100: 839-843.
23.
Klein SA, Nyland J, Caborn DN, Kocabey Y, Nawab A.Comparison of volumetric bone mineral density in the tibial region of interest for ACL reconstruction. Surg Radiol Anat.2005;27: 372-376.
24.
Kousa P, Järvinen TL, Vihavainen M, Kannus P, Järvinen M.The fixation strength of six hamstring tendon graft fixation devices in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, part I: femoral site. Am J Sports Med.2003;31: 174-181.
25.
Kousa P, Järvinen TL, Vihavainen M, Kannus P, Järvinen M.The fixation strength of six hamstring tendon graft fixation devices in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, part II: tibial site. Am J Sports Med.2003;31: 182-188.
26.
Lemos MJ, Jackson DW, Lee TQ, Simon TM.Assessment of initial fixation of endoscopic interference screw fixation. Arthroscopy.1995; 11: 37-41.
27.
Leppala J, Kannus P, Natri A, et al.Effect of anterior cruciate ligament injury of the knee on bone mineral density of the spine and affected lower extremity: a prospective one-year follow-up study. Calcif Tissue Int.1999;64: 357-363.
28.
Liu-Ambrose TY, Khan KM, Eng JJ, Heinonen A, McKay HA.Both resistance and agility training increase cortical bone density in 75- to 85-year-old women with low bone mass: a 6-month randomized controlled trial. J Clin Densitom.2004;7: 390-398.
29.
Magen HE, Howell SM, Hull ML.Structural properties of six tibial fixation methods for anterior cruciate ligament soft tissue grafts. Am J Sports Med.1999;27: 35-43.
30.
Miller CM, Tibone JE, Hewitt M, Kharrazi FD, El Attrache NS.Interference screw divergence in femoral tunnel fixation during endoscopic anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using hamstring grafts. Arthroscopy.2002;18: 510-514.
31.
Miyata K, Yasuda K, Ishida H, et al.Fixation strength of the polyester tape-hamstring tendons-tape graft in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Trans Orthop Res Soc.1996;21: 783-783.
32.
Nakano H, Yasuda K, Tohyama H, Yamanaka M, Wada T, Kaneda K.Interference screw fixation of doubled flexor tendon graft in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: biomechanical evaluation with cyclic elongation. Clin Biomech (Bristol, Avon).2000;15: 188-195.
33.
Nordstrom A, Olsson T, Nordstrom P.Bone gained from physical activity and lost through detraining: a longitudinal study in young males. Osteoporos Int. 2005;16: 835-841.
34.
Noyes FR, Butler DL, Grood ES, Zernicke RF, Hefzy MS.Biomechanical analysis of human ligament grafts used in knee-ligament repairs and reconstructions. J Bone Joint Surg Am.1984;66: 344-352.
35.
Numazaki H, Tohyama H, Nakano H, Kikuchi S, Kikuchi K.The effect of initial graft tension in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction on the mechanical behaviors of the femur-graft-tibia complex during cyclic loading. Am J Sports Med.2002;30: 800-805.
36.
Nurmi JT, Järvinen TLN, Kannus P, Sievanen H, Toukosalo J, Jarvinen M.Compaction versus extraction drilling for fixation of the hamstring graft in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Am J Sports Med.2002;30: 167-173.
37.
Nurmi JT, Kannus P, Sievänen H, Jarvela T, Jarvinen M, Jarvinen TL.Interference screw fixation of soft tissue grafts in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, part 1: Effect of tunnel compaction by serial dilators versus extraction drilling on the initial fixation strength. Am J Sports Med.2004;32: 411-417.
38.
Nurmi JT, Kannus P, Sievänen H, Järvinen M, Järvinen TLN.Compaction drilling does not increase the initial fixation strength of the hamstring graft in ACL reconstruction in a cadaver model. Am J Sports Med.2003;31: 353-358.
39.
Nurmi JT, Sievänen H, Kannus P, Järvinen M, Järvinen TLN.Porcine tibia is a poor substitute for human cadaver tibia for evaluating interference screw fixation. Am J Sports Med.2004;32: 765-771.
40.
Nurmi J, Suuriniemi N.The fixation strength of the biodegradable Hexalon™ interference screw. In: Proceedings of the 12th ESSKA 2000 Congress. Innsbruck, Austria: European Society of Sports Traumatology, Knee Surgery and Arthroscopy; 2006:P-82-P-82.
41.
Nurmi-Lawton JA, Baxter-Jones AD, Mirwald RL, et al.Evidence of sustained skeletal benefits from impact-loading exercise in young females: a 3-year longitudinal study. J Bone Miner Res.2004;19: 314-322.
42.
Otsu N.A threshold selection method from gray-level histogram. IEEE Trans Syst Man Cybern.1979;9: 62-66.
43.
Pierz K, Baltz M, Fulkerson J.The effect of Kurosaka screw divergence on the holding strength of bone-tendon-bone grafts. Am J Sports Med.1995;23: 332-335.
44.
Pitukcheewanont P, Safani D.Extremely low-level, short-term mechanical stimulation increases cancellous and cortical bone density and muscle mass of children with low bone density: a pilot study. Endocrinologist.2006;16: 128-132.
45.
Portney LG, Watkins MP.Foundations of Clinical Research. 2nd ed.Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall; 2000.
46.
Rittmeister ME, Noble PC, Bocell JR Jr, Alexander JW, Conditt MA, Kohl HW III.Interactive effects of tunnel dilation on the mechanical properties of hamstring grafts fixed in the tibia with interference screws. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc.2001;9: 267-271.
47.
Robbe R, Johnson DL.Graft fixation alternatives in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Univ Pa Orthop J.2002;15: 21-28.
48.
Robertson DB, Daniel DM, Biden E.Soft tissue fixation to bone. Am J Sports Med.1986;14: 398-403.
49.
Rodin D, Ley IM.The use of intraoperative fluoroscopy to reduce femoral interference screw divergence during endoscopic anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Arthroscopy.2003;19: 314-317.
50.
Selby JB, Johnson DL, Hester P, Caborn DN.Effect of screw length on bioabsorbable interference screw fixation in a tibial bone tunnel. Am J Sports Med.2001;29: 614-619.
51.
Steenlage E, Brand JC, Johnson DL, Caborn DN.Correlation of bone tunnel diameter with quadrupled hamstring graft fixation strength using a biodegradable interference screw. Arthroscopy.2002;18: 901-907.
52.
Steiner ME, Hecker AT, Brown CH Jr, Hayes WC.Anterior cruciate ligament graft fixation: comparison of hamstring and patellar grafts. Am J Sports Med.1994;22: 240-246.
53.
Tetsumura S, Fujita A, Nakajima M, Abe M.Biomechanical comparison of different fixation methods on the tibial side in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a biomechanical study in porcine tibial bone. J Orthop Sci.2006;11: 278-282.
54.
Vuori I, Heinonen A, Sievänen H, Kannus P, Pasanen M, Oja P.Effects of unilateral strength training and detraining on bone mineral density and content in young women: a study of mechanical loading and deloading on human bones. Calcif Tissue Int.1994;55: 59-67.
55.
Weiler A, Hoffman RFG, Siepe CJ, Kolbeck SF, Sudkamp NP.The influence of screw geometry on hamstring tendon interference fit fixation. Am J Sports Med.2000;28: 356-359.
56.
Weiler A, Hoffmann RFG, Stahelin AC, Bail HJ, Siepe CJ, Sudkamp NP.Hamstring tendon fixation using interference screws: a biomechanical study in calf tibial bone. Arthroscopy.1998;14: 29-37.
57.
Westerlind KC, Fluckey JD, Gordon SE, Kraemer WJ, Farrell PA, Turner RT.Effect of resistance exercise training on cortical and cancellous bone in mature male rats. J Appl Physiol.1998;84: 459-464.
58.
Yamanaka M, Yasuda K, Tohyama H, Nakano H, Wada T.The effect of cyclic displacement on the biomechanical characteristics of anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions. Am J Sports Med.1999;27: 772-777.
