Comparative Sensitivity Analysis on Intersection Crash Prediction Models by Control Type: Highway Safety Manual Approach

Abstract

A comprehensive, in-depth investigation into the comparative safety of different intersection control types is presented, specifically signalized and minor road stop-controlled intersections across facility types. Employing a rigorous sensitivity analysis, the study scrutinizes intersection crash prediction models (CPMs) rooted in the Highway Safety Manual (HSM) methodology. Through meticulous data analyses and thorough comparisons of predictive models across a range of major and minor road traffic volumes, the paper critically examines the portrayal of signalized and stop-controlled intersections within the default HSM Part C CPMs. Additionally, the study delves into the effects of certain crash modification factors on CPMs, further exploring the impacts of calibration factors and locally developed models on crash prediction results. CPMs for signalized intersections do not uniformly lead to fewer crashes compared with stop-controlled intersections, especially under certain traffic volumes and when considering fatal and injury crashes. Therefore, the choice of intersection control should be based on more nuanced criteria than traffic volume alone. Additionally, the research emphasizes the role of intersection geometry and operations, for example, the benefits of adding turn lanes and varying left-turn phasing, in influencing safety outcomes. This study significantly contributes to the understanding of intersection safety and HSM modeling approaches, providing a valuable resource for transportation professionals dedicated to advancing intersection safety. Examining strengths and limitations of existing models provides valuable input for researchers developing future intersection CPMs, and offers essential insights for transportation planners and engineers, informing decision-making for optimizing intersection control strategies and enhancing overall intersection safety and traffic management.

Keywords

safety calibration crash frequency crash modification factors (CMFs)crash prediction models Highway Safety Manual (HSM)

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

AASHTO. Highway Safety Manual. American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHTO), Washington, D.C., 2010.

Highway Safety Manual - Supplement. American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHTO), Washington, D.C., 2014.

Transportation Research Board (TRB). NCHRP 17-71A - Proposed AASHTO Highway Safety Manual, Second Edition. 2023. https://apps.trb.org/cmsfeed/TRBNetProjectDisplay.asp?ProjectID=5043. Accessed July 21, 2023.

Federal Highway Administration (FHWA). Intersection Control Evaluation. 2023. https://highways.dot.gov/safety/intersection-safety/ice. Accessed July 21, 2023.

Lord

Geedipally

Pratt

M. P.

Park

E. S.

Khazraee

S. H.

Fitzpatrick

NCHRP Web-Only Document 318: Safety Prediction Models for Six-Lane and One-Way Urban and Suburban. The National Academies Press, Washington, D.C., 2022.

Torbic

D. J.

Cook

D. J.

Bauer

K. M.

Grotheer

J. R.

Harwood

D. W.

Potts

I. B.

Porter

R. J.

, et al. NCHRP 17-68 (Web-Only Document 297) - Intersection Crash Prediction Methods for the Highway Safety Manual. Transportation Research Board (TRB) of The National Academies, Washington, D.C., 2021.

Jenior

Butsick

Haas

Ray

Safety Performance for Intersection Control Evaluation (SPICE) Tool User Guide. Federal Highway Administration (FHWA), Washington, D.C., 2018.

Porter

Dunn

Soika

Huang

Coley

Gross

Kumfer

Heiny

A Safe System-Based Framework and Analytical Methodology for Assessing Intersections. Federal Highway Administration (FHWA), Washington, D.C., 2021.

Florida DOT. Intersection Operations and Safety. 2023. https://www.fdot.gov/traffic/trafficservices/intersection-operations.shtm. Accessed July 26, 2023.

10.

Bonneson

Laustsen

Rodegerdts

Beaird

NCHRP Web-Only Document 204: Crash Experience Warrant for Traffic Signals. The National Academies Press, Washington, D.C., 2014.

11.

Ferguson

Bonneson

Rodegerdts

Foster

Persaud

Lyon

Rhoades

NCHRP Research Report 888: Development of Roundabout Crash Prediction Models and Methods. The National Academies Press, Washington, D.C., 2019.

12.

Srinivasan

Lan

Carter

Safety Evaluation of Signal Installation With and Without Left Turn Lanes on Two Lane Roads in Rural and Suburban Areas. North Carolina Department of Transportation (NCDOT), Raleigh, 2014.

13.

Northmore

Hildebrand

Intersection Characteristics that Influence Collision Severity and Cost. Journal of Safety Research, Vol. 70, 2019, pp. 49–57.

14.

Federal Highway Administration (FHWA). CMF Clearinghouse. 2023. https://www.cmfclearinghouse.org/. Accessed July 26, 2023.

15.

Federal Highway Administration (FHWA). Interactive Highway Safety Design Model (IHSDM). 2023. https://highways.dot.Gov/research/safety/interactive-highway-safety-design-model/interactive-highway-safety-design-model-ihsdm-overview. Accessed June 2, 2023.

16.

Federal Highway Administration (FHWA). Summary of State SPF Calibration and Development Efforts. 2020. https://www.cmfclearinghouse.org/collateral/StateSPFCalibrationandDevelopmentEfforts_11_2020.xlsx. Accessed July 27, 2023.

17.

Federal Highway Administration (FHWA). Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices (MUTCD). 2023. https://mutcd.fhwa.dot.gov/. Accessed December 31, 2023.

18.

Stamatiadis

Kirk

Hartman

Jasper

Wright

King

Chellman

NCHRP Research Report 855 - An Expanded Functional Classification System for Highways and Streets. Transportation Research Board (TRB) of The National Academies, Washington, D.C., 2018.