Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2019-7
“You Are Really at Their Mercy”: Examining the Relationship between Transportation Disadvantage and Social Exclusion among Older Adults through the Use of Innovative Technology
This study investigates transportation disadvantage (TD) and its impact on social exclusion among lower-income older adults (n = 10) through the use of a custom-designed daily transportation diary app, MyAmble. The study utilized an ecological momentary assessment design using the Travel Buddy, which was the qualitative feature of MyAmble. The Travel Buddy allowed study participants to share their transportation experiences as they relate to the following domains of social exclusion: quality of life, participation, and resources. Conventional content analysis revealed five primary themes related to TD and social exclusion: constrained autononmy and flexibility, safety concerns, dimished emotional well-being, barriers to community engagement, and burdensome. The Travel Buddy produced qualitative data that contextualize lost opportunities and how characteristics of economic justice exacerbate the risk of TD, as well as how individuals manage within these intersections of disadvantage. Study findings provide insight for expanded conversations about how to transform transportation planning from mobility to equity. Finally, the use of ecological momentary assessment through digital platforms such as the Travel Buddy offer an innovative way to collect holistic data related to TD that will lead to better opportunities for transportation planners, engineers, and social service providers to work together to address the needs of environmental justice populations, including lower-income older adults.
AndersonK. A.Dabelko-SchoenyH.FieldsN. L.Home- and Community-Based Services for Older Adults: Aging in Context. Columbia University Press, N. Y., 2018.
BallM. S.LawlerK.Changing Practice and Policy to Move to Scale: A Framework for Age-Friendly Communities across the United States. Journal of Aging and Social Policy, Vol. 26, 2014, pp. 19–32.
5.
U.S. Government Accountability Office (U.S. GAO). Transportation Disadvantaged Populations: Nonemergency Medical Transportation Not Well Coordinated, and Additional Federal Leadership Needed. 2004. https://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-15-110. Accessed March 30, 2018.
6.
RashidK.YigitcanlarT.BunkerJ. M.Minimizing Transport Disadvantage to Support Knowledge City Formation: Applying the Capability Approach to Select Indicators. 2010. https://eprints.qut.edu.au/38739/1/c38739.pdf. Accessed March 30, 2018.
7.
ZeitlerE.BuysL.Mobility and Out-of-Home Activities of Older People Living in Suburban Environments: ‘Because I’m a driver, I don’t have a problem’. Ageing and Society, Vol. 35, 2015, pp. 785–808.
8.
AdornoG.FieldsN.CronleyC.ParekhR.MagruderK.Ageing in a Low-Density Urban City: Transportation Mobility as a Social Equity Issue. Ageing and Society, Vol. 38, No. 2, 2016, pp. 1–25.
9.
CurrieG.StanleyJ.StanleyJ.No Way to Go: Transport and Social Disadvantage in Australian Communities. Monash University Press, Melbourne, 2007.
10.
CurrieG.RichardsonT.SmythP.Vella-BrodrickD.HineJ.LucasK.StanleyJ.MorrisJ.KinnearR.StanleyJ.Investigating Links between Transport Disadvantage, Social Exclusion and Well-Being in Melbourne – Preliminary results. Transport Policy, Vol. 16, 2009, pp. 97–105.
11.
CurrieG.RichardsonT.SmythP.Vella-BrodrickD.HineJ.LucasK.StanleyJ.MorrisJ.KinnearR.StanleyJ.Investigating Links between Transport Disadvantage, Social Exclusion and Well-Being in Melbourne – Updated results. Transport Policy, Vol. 29, 2010, pp. 287–295.
12.
AdornoG.FieldsN.CronleyC.ParekhR.MagruderK.Ageing in a Low-Density Urban City: Transportation Mobility as a Social Equity Issue. Ageing and Society, Vol. 38, 2018, pp. 296–320.
LiH.RaesideR.ChenT.McQuaidR.W. Population Ageing, Gender and the Transportation System. Research in Transportation Economics, Vol. 34, 2012, pp. 39–47.
15.
SanchezT. W.StolzR.MaJ. S.Moving to Equity: Addressing Inequitable Effects of Transportation Policies on Minorities. The Civil Rights Project at Harvard University, Cambridge, Mass., 2003.
16.
ShayE.CombsT. S.FindleyD.KolosnaC.MadeleyM.SalvesenD.Identifying Transportation Disadvantage: Mixed-Methods Analysis Combining GIS Mapping with Qualitative Data. Transport Policy, Vol. 48, 2016, pp. 129–138.
17.
The Relative Risks of School Travel: A National Perspective and Guidance for Local Community Risk Assessment. National Academies, Transportation Research Board, Washington, D.C., 2002.
18.
SchulzA. J.WilliamsD. R.IsraelB. A.LempertL. B.Racial and Spatial Relations as Fundamental Determinants of Health in Detroit. The Milbank Quarterly, Vol. 80, 2002, pp. 766–707.
19.
NostikasariD.Representations of Everyday Travel Experiences: Case study of the Dallas-Fort Worth Metropolitan Area. Transport Policy, Vol. 44, 2015, pp. 96–107.
20.
TurnbullJ.MuckleW.MastersC.Homelessness and Health. Canadian Medical Association Journal, Vol. 177, 2007, pp. 1065–1066.
21.
LucasK.JonesP.Social Impacts and Equity Issues in Transport: An Tntroduction. Journal of Transportation Geography, Vol. 21, 2012, pp. 1–3.
22.
HuiV.HabibK. N.Homelessness Vis-à-Vis Transportation-Induced Social Exclusion: An Economic Investigation of Travel Behavior of Homeless Individuals in Toronto, Canada. Transportation Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 2017. 2665: 60–68.
23.
JocoyC. L.Del CasinoV.Jr.Homelessness, Travel Behavior, and the Politics of Transportation Mobilities in Long Beach, California. Environment and Planning, Vol. 42, 2010, pp. 1943–1963.
24.
PrestonJ.RajeF.Accessibility Mobility and Transport-Related Social Exclusion. Journal of Transport Geography, Vol. 15, 2007, pp. 151–160.
25.
LattmanK.FrimanM.OlssonL. E.Perceived Accessibility of Public Transport as a Potential Indicator of Social Inclusion. Social Inclusion, Vol. 4, 2016, pp. 36–45.
26.
KenyonS.LyonsG.RaffertyJ.Transport and Social Exclusion: Investigating the Possibility of Promoting Inclusion through Virtual Mobility. Journal of Transport Geography, Vol. 10, 2002, pp. 207–219.
27.
MandanipourA.CarsG.AllenJ. A.Social Exclusion in European Cities: Processes, Experiences, and Responses. Jessica Kingsley Publishers, London, 1998.
28.
BurchardtT.Le GrandJ.PiachaudD.Understanding Social Exclusion. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2002.
29.
MayesD. G.BerghmanJ.SalaisR.Social Exclusion and European Policy. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, UK, 2001.
30.
Percy-SmithJ.Policy Responses to Social Exclusion: Towards Inclusion?Open University Press, Buckingham, England, 2000.
31.
BradtX.The City as an Agent for European Integration: Tackling Social Exclusion in Greater Paris. ProQuest Dissertations Publishing, Kansas, 2007.
32.
LevitasR.PantazisC.FahmyE.GordonD.LloydE.PatsiosD.The Mutli-Dimensional Analysis of Social Exclusion. Department for Communities and Local Government, Social Exclusion Unit, Bristol, England, 2007. https://roar.uel.ac.uk/1781/1/multidimensional.pdf. Accessed March 30, 2018.
NicholsonL.CooperS.Social Exclusion and People with Intellectual Disabilities: A Rural-Urban Comparison. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research, Vol. 57, 2013, pp. 333–346.
35.
Van RegenmortelS.De DonderL.SmetcorenA.LambotteD.De WitteN.VerteD.Accumulation of Disadvantages: Prevalence and Categories of Old-Age Social Exclusion in Belgium. Social Indicators Research, Vol. 8, 2017, pp. 1–12.
36.
CurrieG.StanleyJ.Investigating Links between Social Capital and Public Transport. Transport Reviews, Vol. 28, 2008, pp. 529–547.
37.
KenyonK.Understanding Social Exclusion and Social Inclusion. Municipal Engineer, Vol. 156, 2003, pp. 97–104.
38.
ChurchA.FrostM.SullivanK.Transport and Social Exclusion in London. Transport Policy, Vol. 7, 2000, pp. 195–205.
39.
McCrayT.BraisN.Exploring the Role of Transportation in Social Exclusion through the Use of GIS to Support Qualiltative Data. Networks and Spacial Economics, Vol. 7, 2007, pp. 397–412.
40.
GreicoM.Accessibility, Mobility and Connectivity: The Changing Frontiers of Everyday Routine. European Spatial Research and Policy, Vol. 78, 2006, pp. 1360–1380.
41.
SheppardM.Social Work and Social Exclusion: The Idea of Practice. Ashgate Publishing Company, Burlington, 2012.
FoleyD. J.HeimovitzH. K.GuralnikJ. M.BrockD. B.Driving Life Expectancy of Persons Aged 70 years and Older in the United States. American Journal of Public Health, Vol. 92, 2002, pp. 1284–1289.
44.
MorencyM.PaezA.RoordaM. J.MercadoR.FarberS.Distance Traveled in Three Canadian Cities: Spatial Analysis from the Perspective of Vulnerable Population Segments. Journal of Transport Geography, Vol. 19, 2011, pp. 39–50.
45.
PaezA.ScottD.PotoglouD.KanaroglouP.NewboldK.Elderly Mobility: Demographic and Spatial Analysis of Trip Making in the Hamilton CMA, Canada. Urban Studies, Vol. 44, 2007, pp. 123–146.
46.
AndersonM.Who Relies on Public Transportation?Pew Research Center, Washington, D.C., 2017.
47.
BlumenbergE.Why Low-Income Women in the U.S. Still Need Automobiles. Town Planning Review, Vol. 87, 2016, pp. 525–545.
48.
BoschmannE. E.Job Access, Location Decision, and the Working Poor: A Qualitative Study in the Columbus, Ohio Metropolitan Area. Geoforum, Vol. 42, 2011, pp. 671–682.
49.
HenryM.WattR.RosenthalL.ShivjA.The 2016 Annual Homeless Assessment Report to Congress. The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, Office of Community Planning and Development, Washington, D.C., 2016.
50.
HillE. W.GeyerB.O’BrienK.RobeyC.BrennanJ.PuentesR.Slanted Pavement: How Ohio’s Highway Spending Shortchanges Cities and Suburbs. Brookings Institutions, Washington, D.C., 2003.
51.
PuentesR.R.PrinceFueling Transportation Finance: A Primer on the Gas Tax. Brookings Institution, Washington, D.C., 2003.
52.
RobertsonJ.EmersonE.PinkneyL.CaesarE.FelceD.MeekA.CarrD.LoweK.KnappM.HallamA.Community-Based Residential Supports for People with Intellectual Disabilities and Challenging Behaviour: The Views of Neighbors. Journal of Applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities, Vol. 18, 2005, pp. 85–92.
53.
Impact of the 2001-2002 Economic Slowdown on Public Transportation. American Public Transportation Association, Washington, D.C., 2002.
54.
Driven to Spend: The Impact of Sprawl on Household Transportation Expenses. Surface Transportation Policy Project and Center for Neighborhood Technology, Washington, D.C., 2000.
55.
Social Exclusion Unit. Bringing Britain together: A National Strategy for Neighbourhood Renewal. Social Exclusion Unit, London, 1998.
56.
Social Exclusion Unit. Making the Connections: Final Report on Transport and Social Exclusion. Office of the Deputy Prime Minister, London, 2003.
57.
CornwellE.WaiteL.Social Disconnectedness, Perceived Isolation, and Health among Older Adults. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, Vol. 50, 2009, pp. 31–48.
58.
KnealeD.Is Social Exclusion Still Important for Older People?International Longevity Centre, London, England, 2012.
59.
LofqvistC.GranbomM.HimmelsbachI.IwarssonS.OswaldF.HaakM.Voices on Relocation and Aging in Place in Very Old Age–A Complex and Ambivalent Matter. The Gerontologist, Vol. 53, 2013, pp. 919–927.
60.
TruongL. T.SomenahalliS. C.Exploring Frequency of Public Transport Use among Older Adults: A Study in Adelaide, Australia. Travel Behaviour and Society, Vol. 2, 2015, pp. 148–155.
61.
Torres-DavisA. I.The Need for Improved Transportation Options for the Elderly and the Elder Advocate’s Role. Clearinghouse Review, Vol. 42, 2008, pp. 281.
62.
JocoyC. L.Del CasinoV.Jr.Homelessness, Travel Behavior, and the Politics of Transportation Mobilities in Long Beach, California. Environment and Planning, Vol. 42, 2010, pp. 1943–1963.
63.
LättmanK.FrimanM.OlssonL. E.Perceived Accessibility of Public Transport as a Potential Indicator of Social Inclusion. Social Inclusion, Vol. 4, 2016, pp. 36–45.
64.
RajeF.The Lived Experience of Transport Structure: An Exploration of Transport’s Role in People’s Lives. Mobilities, Vol. 2, 2007, pp. 51–74.
FieldsN. L.CronleyC.MattinglyS.Leveraging App Technology to Measure the Impact of Transportation Disadvantage: A Methodological Case Study. Presented at 96th Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board, Washington, D.C., 2017.
67.
FieldsN. L.CronleyC.MattinglyS.LevineD.MillerV. E.MurphyE.CrawfordC.GwakL.Ramezanpour NargesiS.RahmanZ.BalasubramanianM.Transportation Mobility Among Low-Income, Transportation Disadvantaged Older Adults Living in a Low Density Urban Environment Using Innovative Data Collection Methods. 2018. https://wmich.edu/sites/default/files/attachments/u883/2018/TRCLC_RR_16-09_0.pdf. Accessed November 13, 2018.
68.
Committee on Facilitating Interdisciplinary Research, Committee on Science, Engineering, and Public Policy. Facilitating Interdisciplinary Research. National Academy Press, Washington, D.C., 2004.
69.
StoneA. A.ShiffmanS.Ecological Momentary Assessment in Behavioral Medicine. Annuals of Behavioral Medicine, Vol. 16, 1994, pp. 199–202.
70.
StoneA. A.ShiffmanS.AtienzaA.NebelingL.The Science of Real-Time Data Capture: Self-Reports in Health Research. Oxford University Press, New York, 2007.
BirdD. C.FreundK.FortinskyR. H.StaplinL.WestB. A.BergenG.DownsJ.Driving Self-Regulation and Ride Service Utilization in a Multicommunity, Multistate Sample of U.S. Older Adults. Traffic Injury Prevention, Vol. 18, 2017, pp. 267–272.
76.
ShenS.KoechW.FengJ.RiceT. M.ZhuM.A Cross-Sectional Study of Travel Patterns of Older Adults in the USA During 2015: Implications for Mobility and Traffic Safety. BMJ Open, 2017, pp. 1–7.
77.
ChurchA.FrostM.SullivanK.Transport and Social Exclusion in London. Transport Policy, Vol. 7, 2000, pp. 195–205.
78.
DelboscA.CurrieG.Exploring the Relative Influences of Transport Disadvantage and Social Exclusion on Well-Being. Transport Policy, Vol. 18, 2011a, pp. 555–562.
79.
StanleyJ. K.HensherD. A.StanleyJ. R.Vella-BrodrickD.Mobility, Social Exclusion and Well-Being: Exploring the Links. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, Vol. 45, 2011, pp. 789–801.
80.
Holt-LunstadJ.SmithT. B.BakerM.HarrisT.StephensonD.Loneliness and Social Isolation as Risk Factors for Mortality: A Meta-Analytic Review. Perspectives on Psychological Science, Vol. 10, 2015, pp. 227–237.
81.
ShankarA.McMunnA.DemakakosP.HamerM.SteptoeA.Social Isolation and Loneliness: Prospective Associations with Functional Status in Older Adults. Health psychology, Vol. 36, 2017, pp. 179.
82.
JonesV. C.JohnsonR. M.RebokG. W.RothK. B.GielenA.MolnarL. J.PittsS.DiGuiseppiC.HillL.StrogatzD.MielenzT.EbyD. W.LiG.Use of Alternative Sources of Transportation among Older Adult Drivers. Journal of Transport & Health, Vol. 10, 2018, pp. 284–289.
83.
LevasseurM.GénéreuxM.BruneauJ. F.VanasseA.ChabotE.BeaulacC.BédardM. M.Importance of Proximity to Resources, Social Support, Transportation and Neighborhood Security for Mobility and Social Participation in Older Adults: Results from a Scoping Study. BMC Public Health, Vol. 15, 2015, pp. 503.
