Parametric Ordinal Logistic Regression and Non-Parametric Decision Tree Approaches for Assessing the Impact of Weather Conditions on Driver Speed Selection Using Naturalistic Driving Data

Abstract

The impact of adverse weather conditions on transportation operation and safety is the focus of many studies; however, comprehensive research detailing the differences in driving behavior and performance during adverse conditions is limited. Many previous studies utilized aggregate traffic and weather data (e.g., average speed, headway, and global weather information) to formulate conclusions about the impact of weather on network operation and safety; however, research into specific factors associated with driver performance and behavior are notably absent. A novel approach, presented in this paper, fills this gap by considering disaggregate trajectory-level data available through the SHRP2 Naturalistic Driving Study and Roadway Information Database. Parametric ordinal logistic regression and non-parametric classification tree modeling were utilized to better understand speed selection behavior in adverse weather conditions. The results indicate that the most important factors impacting driver speed selection are weather conditions, traffic conditions, and the posted speed limit. Moreover, it was found that drivers are more likely to significantly reduce their speed in snowy weather conditions, as compared with other adverse weather conditions (such as rain and fog). The purpose of this study was to gather insights into driver speed preferences in different weather conditions, such that efficient logic can be introduced for a realistic variable speed limit system—aimed at maximizing speed compliance and reducing speed variations. This study provides valuable information related to drivers’ interaction with real-time changes in roadway and weather conditions, leading to a better understanding of the effectiveness of operational countermeasures.