Although operational research traditionally has concerned itself with quantitative and technical aspects of managerial problem solving, it has gradually built up a capacity to deal with “softer” issues, and broader societal problems. This paper considers the notion of “enhanced” operational research within the context of the practical and philosophical difficulties brought about through combining problem solving methodologies from different theoretical traditions. The paper argues that separate paradigm development for EOR may be justified on theoretical grounds and on the basis of its cultural feasibility.
Ackoff, R., 1979, The future of operational research is past, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 30, 2, February, 93–104.
2.
Ackoff, R.L., 1982, On the hard-headedness and soft-heartedness of M.C. Jackson, Journal of Applied Systems Analysis, 9, 1, 31–33.
3.
Banathy, B.H., 1987, Choosing design methods, Proceedings of the 31st Annual Meeting of ISGSR, Budapest, 54–63.
4.
Beer, S., 1972, Brain of the Firm (London, Allen Lane).
5.
Beer, S., 1979, Heart of Enterprise (Chichester, Wiley).
6.
Beer, S., 1986, Designing the System for Organisation (London, Wiley).
7.
Boothroyd, H., 1977, Basic for sovereign minds, in: The King is Dead, Long Live the King, Conference Proceedings, University of Aston Dec.
8.
Brocklesby, J., 1992, The critical perspective in enhanced operational research—A critique of total systems intervention, NZORS Conference Proceedings, Canterbury University, August.
9.
Brocklesby, J., S. Cummings, and J. Davies, 1991, Towards a better understanding of Beers viable systems model, Graduate School of Business and Government Management Working Paper, Victoria University, Wellington, New Zealand.
10.
Bryant, J., 1988, Frameworks of enquiry: OR practice across the hard-soft divide, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 39, 5, May, 423–435.
11.
Burrell, G., and G. Morgan, 1979, Sociological Paradigms and Organisational Analysis (London, Heinemann).
12.
Checkland, P., 1981, Systems Thinking, Systems Practice (Chichester, Wiley).
13.
Checkland, P., 1982, Soft systems methodology as process: a reply to M.C. Jackson, Journal of Applied Systems Analysis, 9, 1, 37–39.
14.
Checkland, P., and J. Scholes, 1990, Soft Systems Methodology in Action (London, Wiley).
15.
Churchman, C.W., 1982, Reply to M.C. Jackson, Journal of Applied Systems Analysis, 9, 1, 35.
16.
Dando, M.R., and P.G. Bennett, 1981, A Kuhnian crisis in management science?Journal of the Operational Research Society, 32, 2, 91–104.
17.
Flood, R., and M.C. Jackson, 1991, Creative Problem Solving—Total Systems Intervention (Chichester, Wiley).
18.
Friend, J.K., M.E. Norris, and J. Stringer, 1988, The institute for operational research: an initiative to extend the scope of OR, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 39, 8, August, 705–713.
19.
Habermas, J., 1974, Knowledge and Human Interests (London, Heinemann).
20.
Hales, M., 1974, Management Science and the Second Industrial Revolution, Radical Science Journal, 1, 1, 5–28.
21.
Jackson, M.C., 1982, The nature of soft systems thinking, the work of Churchman, Ackoff, and Checkland, Journal of Applied Systems Analysis, 9, 1, 17–28.
22.
Jackson, M.C., 1988, Some methodologies for community operational research, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 39, 8, August, 715–724.
23.
Jackson, M.C., 1989, Evaluating the managerial significance of the VSM, in: R. Espejo and R. Harnden, eds., The Viable Systems Model (Chichester, Wiley).
24.
Jackson, M.C., 1990a, Beyond a systems of system methodologies, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 41, 8, August, 657–668.
25.
Jackson, M.C., 1990b, The critical kernal in modern systems thinking, Systems Practice, 3, 4, August, 357–364.
26.
Jackson, M.C., 1991, Systems Methodology for the Management Sciences (New York, Plenum).
27.
Jackson, M.C. and P. Keys, 1984, Towards a system of systems methodologies, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 35, 6, June, 473–485.
28.
Jackson, N. and P. Carter, 1989, In defence of paradigm incommensurability, School of Management Work Paper No. HUSM/PC/2, Hull University.
29.
Keys, P., 1988, A methodology for methodology choice, Systems Research, 5, 1, 65–76.
30.
Keys, P., 1987, Traditional management science and the emerging critique, in: M.C. Jackson and P. Keys, eds., New Directions in Management Science (Aldershot, Gower).
31.
Mingers, J., 1992, Recent developments in critical management science, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 43, 1, January, 1–10.
32.
Oliga, J.C., 1988, Methodological foundations of systems methodologies, Systems Practice, 1, 1, February, 87–112.
33.
Rosenhead, J., 1989, Rational Analysis for a Problematic World (Chichester, Wiley).
34.
Rosenhead, J. and C. Thunhurst, 1982, A materialist analysis of operational research, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 33, 2, February, 111–122.
35.
Sayer, A., 1984, Method in Social Science (London, Hutchinson).
36.
Schoderbek, P.P., C.G. Schoderbek, and A.G. Kefalas, 1985, Management Systems: Conceptual Considerations (Dallas, Business Publications).
37.
Tsoukas, H., 1992, The road to emancipation is through organisational development: a critical evaluation of total systems intervention, Warwick Business School Research Paper No.50, University of Warwick.
38.
Ulrich, W., 1981, A critique of pure cybernetic reason: the Chilean experience with cybernetics, Journal of Applied Systems Analysis, 8, 1, 33–59.
39.
Ulrich, W., 1982, Critical Heuristics of Social Planning: A New Approach to Practical Philosophy (Berne, Haupt).
40.
Wood, S. and J. Kelly, 1978, Towards a critical management science, Journal of Management Studies, 15, 1, February, 1–24.
