This paper addresses three methodological problems in previous studies of bankruptcy models using MDA and logit/probit techniques: (i) the use of choice-based and equally distributed samples in model estimation and validation; (ii) the use of arbitrary cut-off probabilities; and, (Hi) the assumption of equal costs of errors in prediction tests. Corrected MDA and probit models are estimated for a sample of Australian companies from 1966 to 1986.
In contrast to previous studies our results show that first, bankruptcy prediction models based upon publicly available financial statement infor Mation possess insignificant predictive power; and second, the variables chosen for such models are characterised by non-multivariate normality and heteroskedasticity.
Altman, E.I., 1978, Financial application of discriminant analysis: a clarification, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 13, 1, 188–197.
6.
Altman, E.I., R.B. Avery, R. A. Eisenbeis, and J.F. Sinkey Jr., 1981, Application of Classification Techniques in Business, Banking and Finance (Greenwich, Conn.: JAI Press Inc).
7.
Altman, E.I., and H. Y. Izan, 1983, Identifying corporate distress in Australia: an industry relative analysis, Australian Graduate School of Management, Working Paper No. 83–013.
8.
Altman, E.I., H. Frydman and Li-Kao Duen, 1985, Introducing recursive partitioning for financial classifications, Journal of Finance, 40, 1, 269–289.
9.
Avery, W., and R. Eisenbeis, 1972, Discriminant Analysis: Theory and Applications (Lexington, Mass.: D.C. Heath & Co).
10.
Barnes, P., 1987, The analysis and use of financial ratios: a review article, Journal of Business Finance and Accounting, 14, 449–461.
11.
Beaver, W., 1968, Financial ratios as predictors of failure, Journal of Accounting Research, Supplement, 71–102.
12.
Blum, M., 1974, Failing company discriminant analysis, Journal of Accounting Research, 12, 1–25.
13.
Castagna, A.D., and Z.P. Matolscy, 1981, The prediction of corporate failure: testing the Australian experience, Australian Journal of Management, 6, 1, 23–50.
14.
Chen, K.H., and T.A. Shimerda, 1981, An empirical analysis of useful financial ratios, Financial Management, 10, 1, 51–60.
15.
Cochran, M., 1964, On the perfor Mance of the linear discriminant function, Technometrics, 6, 179–180.
16.
Cosslett, S.R., 1981, Efficient estimation of discrete-choice models, C.F. Manski and D. McFadden, eds., Structural Analysis of Discrete Data with Econometric Applications (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press)
17.
Crapp, H.R. and M. Stevenson, 1987, Development of a method to assess the relevant variables and the probability of financial distress, Australian Journal of Management, 12, 221–236.
18.
Dambolena, C., and J. Khoury, 1980, Ratio stability and corporate failure, Journal of Finance, 35, 4, 1017–1026.
19.
Deakin, E.B., 1977, Business Failure Prediction: An Empirical Analysis, E.I. Altman and A.W. Sametz, eds., Financial Crisis: Institutions and Markets in a Fragile Environment (New York, NY: John Wiley & Sons).
20.
Dunn and Bradstreet (Australia) Pty. Ltd., Johnson's Year Book of Public Companies in Australia and New Zealand, various issues.
21.
Eisenbeis, R. A., 1977, Pitfalls in the application of discriminant analysis in business, finance, and economics, Journal of Finance, 32, 3, 875–900.
22.
Eisenbeis, R.A., G.G. Gilbert, and R.B. Avery, 1973, Investigating the relative importance of individual variables and variable subsets in discriminant analysis. Communications in Statistics, 2, 3, 205–219.
23.
Ezzamel, M.et al., 1987, On the distributional properties of financial ratios, Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, 14, 463–481.
24.
Fieldsend, S.et al., 1987, Industry effects and the proportionality assumption in ratio analysis: a variance component analysis, Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, 14, 497–517.
25.
Gentry, J.A., et al., 1987, Funds flow components, financial ratios, and bankruptcy, Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, 14, 595–606.
26.
Gombola, M.J., and J.E. Ketz, 1983, A note on cash flow and classification patterns of financial ratios, The Accounting Review, 58, 1, 103–114.
27.
Gombola, M.J. and. J.E. Ketz, 1983, Financial ratio patterns in retail and manufacturing organisations, Financial Management, 12, 2, 45–56.
28.
Houghton, K.A. and D.R. Woodliff, 1987, Financial ratios: the prediction of corporate 'success' and failure, Journal of Business Finance and Accounting, 14, 537–554.
29.
Johnson, W.B., 1979, The cross sectional stability of financial patterns, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 15, 5, 1035–1048.
30.
Joy, O.M., and J.D. Tollefson, 1975, On the financial applications of discriminant analysis, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 10, 5, 723–739.
31.
Joy, O.M. and J.D. Tollefson, 1978, Some clarifying comments on discriminant analysis, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 12, 1, 197–203.
32.
Karels, G.V., and A.J. Prakash, 1987, Multivariate normality and forecasting of business bankruptcy, Journal of Business Finance and Accounting, 14, 573–593.
33.
Kendall, M.G., and A. Stuart, 1977, Advanced Theory of Statistics (New York, NY: Macmillan).
34.
Klecka, W.R., 1980, Discriminant Analysis (Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publication).
35.
Lachenbruch, P.A., 1975, Discriminant Analysis (New York, NY: Haffner Press).
36.
Lachenbruch, P. A., C. Sneeringer, and L.T. Revo, 1973, Robustness of the linear and quadratic discriminant function to certain types of non-normality, Communications in Statistics, 1, 1, 39–56.
37.
Lincoln, M., 1984, An empirical study of the usefulness of accounting ratios to describe different levels of insolvency risk, Journal of Banking and Finance, 8, 2, 321–339.
38.
Manski, C.F. and S.R. Lerman, 1977, The estimation of choice probabilities from choice based samples, Econometrica, 45, 8, 1977–1988.
39.
Manski, C., and D. McFadden, 1981, Alternative estimators and sample designs for discrete choice analysis, in: C. Manski and D. McFadden, eds., Structural analysis of discrete data with econometric applications (Cambridge, MA: MTT Press).
40.
Martin, D., 1977, Early warning of bank failure, Journal of Banking and Finance, 1, 3, 231–275.
41.
Moyer, D., 1977, Forecasting failure prediction: a reexamination, Financial Management, 6, 1, 11–19.
42.
Ohlson, J., 1980, Financial ratios and the probabilistic prediction of bankruptcy, Journal of Accounting Research, 18, 1, 109–131.
43.
Palepu, K., 1983, The determinants of acquisition likelihood, Working Paper 83–86, Harvard Business School, Cambridge, MA.
44.
Palepu, K., 1986, Predicting takeover targets: a methodological and empirical analysis, Journal of Accounting and Economics, 8, 1, 3–35.
45.
Pham, T., 1988, A further empirical investigation of the bankruptcy cost question: a correction and extension, Working Paper No. 15, School of Banking and Finance, University of New South Wales.
46.
Pham, T., and D. Chow, 1989, Some estimates of direct and indirect bankruptcy costs in Australia: September 1978-May 1983, Australian Journal of Management, 14, 1, 75–95.
47.
Pham, T., and L. Wan, 1988, A reexamination of the predictive power of takeover screening models: Australian evidence, Working Paper No. 18, School of Banking and Finance, University of New South Wales.
48.
Pinches, G.E., K.A. Mingo, and J.K. Caruthers, 1973, The stability of financial patterns in industrial organisations, Journal of Finance, 28, 2, 389–396.
49.
Pindyck, R.S., and D.L. Rubinfield, 1981, Econometric Models and Economic Forecast (New York, NY: McGraw Hill) 2nd edition, International Student Edition.
50.
Santomero, A., and J.D. Vinso, 1977, Estimating the probability of failure for commercial banks and the banking system, Journal of Banking and Finance, 1, 2, 185–206.
51.
Scott, J., 1981, The probability of bankruptcy: a comparison of empirical predictions and theoretical models, Journal of Banking and Finance, 5, 3, 317–344.
So, J.C., 1987, Some empirical evidence on the outliers and the non-normal distribution of financial ratios, Journal of Business Finance and Accounting, 14, 483–497.
54.
Sydney Stock Exchange, 1985, Delisted Companies.
55.
Watson, P.L., 1974, Choice of estimation procedure for models of binary choice: some statistical and empirical evidence, Regional and Urban Economics, 4, 2, 187–200.
56.
Whittred, G., and I. Zimmer, 1985, The implications of distress prediction models for corporate lending, Accounting and Finance, 25, 1, 1–13.
57.
Zavgren, C.V., 1983, The prediction of corporate failure: the state of the art, Journal of Accounting Literature, 2, 1–38.
58.
Zmijewski, M.E., 1984, Methodological issues related to the estimation of financial distress prediction models, Journal of Accounting Research, suppl., 59–82.
