The crafting of budgets by accountants with users for enhanced acceptance in public healthcare

Abstract

This study presents a contemporary account of budgeting in a public hospital setting. Qualitative semi-structured interviews and observations of information systems and documentation are utilised to form an assessment of the relationship between accountants and users. This study finds that budgets form ongoing products requiring an iterative process of building collaborative relationships between accountants and users. Transparency and ongoing dialogue are pivotal for durability of the budgeting process. The results challenge stereotypical views of budgets being divorced from user needs. In fact, the results indicate that both the perspectives of accountants and users are broadened when they are involved in co-creating a budgeting system that fulfills their needs.

JEL Classification: M4, M40

Keywords

Accountants budgets collaboration enabling healthcare personal interaction

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abernethy

Bouwens

(2005) Determinants of accounting innovation implementation. Abacus: A Journal of Accounting Finance and Business Studies 41: 220–236.

Abernethy

Stoelwinder

(1990) Physicians and resource management in hospitals: An empirical investigation. Financial Accountability and Management 6: 17–31.

Abernethy

Chua

Grafton

et al . (2007) Accounting and control in healthcare. In: Chapman

Hopwood

Shields

(eds) Handbook of Management Accounting Research. Amsterdam: Elsevier, pp. 805–829.

Ahrens

Chapman

(2004) Accounting for flexibility and efficiency: A field study of management control systems in a restaurant chain. Contemporary Accounting Research 21: 271–301.

Ahrens

Chapman

(2007) Management accounting as practice. Accounting, Organizations and Society 32: 1–27.

Ahrens

Dent

(1998) Accounting and organizations: Realizing the richness of field research. Journal of Management Accounting Research 9: 1–39.

Arnaboldi

Lapsley

(2004) Modern costing innovations and legitimation: A health care study. Abacus: A Journal of Accounting Finance and Business Studies 40: 1–20.

Baxter

Chua

(2008) Be(com)ing the chief financial officer of an organisation: Experimenting with Bourdieu’s practice theory. Management Accounting Research 19: 212–230.

Bryer

(2014) Participation in budgeting: A critical anthropological approach. Accounting, Organizations and Society 39: 511–530.

10.

Ciborra

(2002) The Labyrinths of Information: Challenging the Wisdom of Systems. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

11.

Ciborra

(2009) Bricolage, Care and Information. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

12.

Coombs

(1987) Accounting for the control of doctors: Management information systems in hospitals. Accounting, Organizations and Society 12: 389–404.

13.

Cooper

Morgan

(2008) Case study research in accounting. Accounting Horizons 22: 159–178.

14.

Covaleski

Dirsmith

(1983) Budgeting as a means for control and loose coupling. Accounting, Organizations and Society 8: 323–340.

15.

Covaleski

Dirsmith

(1986) The budgetary process of power and politics. Accounting, Organizations and Society 11: 193–214.

16.

Covaleski

Dirsmith

Weiss

(2013) The social construction, challenge and transformation of a budgetary regime: The endogenization of welfare regulation by institutional entrepreneurs. Accounting, Organizations and Society 38: 333–364.

17.

Denzin

(1989a) Interpretive Interactionism, vol. 16 (Applied social research methods series). Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

18.

Denzin

(1989b) The Research Act: A Theoretical Introduction to Sociological Methods. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.

19.

Denzin

Lincoln

(2000) The discipline and practice of qualitative research. In: Denzin

Lincoln

(eds) Handbook of Qualitative Research. 2nd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, pp. 1–28.

20.

Ekanem

(2014) Zero-based budgeting as a management tool for effective university budget implementation in University of Calabar, Nigeria. European Journal of Business and Social Sciences 2: 11–19.

21.

Fallan

Pettersen

Stemsrudhagen

(2010) Multilevel framing: An alternative understanding of budget control in public enterprises. Financial Accountability and Management 26: 190–212.

22.

Faure

Rouleau

(2011) The strategic competence of accountants and middle managers in budget making. Accounting, Organizations and Society 36: 167–182.

23.

Ferreira

Merchant

(1992) Field research in management accounting and control: A review and evaluation. Accounting Auditing & Accountability Journal 5: 3–34.

24.

Geertz

(1988) Works and Lives: The Anthropologist as Author. Cambridge, MA: Polity Press.

25.

Goretski

Messner

(2016) The ‘business partner’ as a fragile aspirational identity: A field study of management accountants’ identity work. Working paper, University of Innsbruck, Innsbruck, 9 March.

26.

Goretski

Strauss

Weber

(2013) An institutional perspective on the changes in management accountants’ professional role. Management Accounting Research 24: 41–63.

27.

Grafton

Abernethy

Lillis

(2011) Organisational design choices in response to public sector reforms: A case study of mandated hospital networks. Management Accounting Research 22: 242–268.

28.

Granlund

Lukka

(1998) Towards increasing business orientation: Finnish management accountants in a changing cultural context. Management Accounting Research 9: 185–211.

29.

Gray

(1989) Collaborating: Finding Common Ground for Multiparty Problems. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

30.

Groen

Wouters

Wilderom

(2012) Why do employees take more initiatives to improve their performance after co-developing performance measures? A field study. Management Accounting Research 23: 120–141.

31.

Hall

(2010) Accounting information and managerial work. Accounting, Organizations and Society 35: 301–315.

32.

Hansen

Otley

Van der Stede

(2003) Practice developments in budgeting: An overview and research perspective. Journal of Management Accounting Research 15: 95–116.

33.

Hitt

Beamish

Jackson

et al . (2007) Building theoretical and empirical bridges across levels: Multilevel research in management. Academy of Management Journal 50: 1385–1399.

34.

Hood

(1991) A public management for all seasons? Public Administration 69: 3–19.

35.

Independent Pricing and Regulatory Tribunal of New South Wales (IPART) (1998) A Review of NSW Health: Report to the NSW Treasurer and the Minister for Health. Sydney, NSW, Australia: IPART.

36.

Independent Pricing and Regulatory Tribunal of New South Wales (IPART) (2003) NSW Health – Focusing on Patient Care. Sydney, NSW, Australia: IPART.

37.

Jacobs

(1995) Budgets: A medium of organizational transformation. Management Accounting Research 6: 59–75.

38.

Janin

(2016) When being a partner means more: The external role of football club management accountants. Management Accounting Research. Epub ahead of print 7 June. DOI: 10.1016/j.mar.2016.05.002.

39.

Johnson

(2015) National Health Service staff most stressed public sector workers, survey finds. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/healthcare-network/2015/jun/12/nhs-staff-most-stressed-public-sector-workers-survey-finds (accessed 3 November 2016).

40.

Jordan

Messner

(2012) Enabling control and the problem of incomplete performance indicators. Accounting, Organizations and Society 37: 544–564.

41.

Kurunmaki

(2004) A hybrid profession: The acquisition of management accounting expertise by medical professionals. Accounting, Organizations and Society 29: 327–348.

42.

Kurunmaki

Lapsley

Melia

(2003) Accountingization v. legitimation: A comparative study of the use of accounting information in intensive care. Management Accounting Research 14: 112–139.

43.

Lapsley

(2001) The accounting-clinical interface – Implementing budgets for hospital doctors. Abacus: A Journal of Accounting Finance and Business Studies 37: 79–109.

44.

Lapsley

(2009) New public management: The cruellest invention of the human spirit? Abacus: A Journal of Accounting Finance and Business Studies 45: 1–21.

45.

Lincoln

(1985) The substance of the emergent paradigm: Implications for research. In: Lincoln

(ed.) Organizational Theory and Inquiry. Beverly Hills, CA: SAGE, pp. 137–157.

46.

Lincoln

Guba

(1985) Naturalistic Inquiry. Beverly Hills, CA: SAGE.

47.

Llewellyn

(1998) Boundary work: Costing and caring in the social services. Accounting, Organizations and Society 23: 23–47.

48.

Lowe

Doolin

(1999) Casemix accounting systems: New spaces for action. Management Accounting Research 10: 181–201.

49.

Macinati

(2010) NPM reforms and the perception of budget by hospital clinicians: Lessons from two case-studies. Financial Accountability and Management 26: 422–442.

50.

Malmmose

(2015) Management accounting versus medical profession discourse: Hegemony in a public health care debate: A case from Denmark. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 27: 144–159.

51.

Meyer

Rowan

(1977) Institutionalized organizations: Formal structure as myth and ceremony. American Journal of Sociology 83: 340–363.

52.

Miles

Huberman

(1994) Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook. 2nd ed. Beverly Hills, CA: SAGE.

53.

Modell

(2001) Performance measurement and institutional processes: A study of managerial responses to public sector reform. Management Accounting Research 12: 437–464.

54.

Morales

Lambert

(2013) Dirty work and the construction of identity. An ethnographic study of management accounting practices. Accounting, Organizations and Society 38: 228–244.

55.

Mouritsen

(1996) Five aspects of accounting departments’ work. Management Accounting Research 7: 283–303.

56.

Mundy

(2010) Creating dynamic tensions through a balanced use of management control systems. Accounting, Organizations and Society 35: 499–523.

57.

NSW Health Council Report (2000) Report of the NSW Health Council – A Better Health System for NSW. Sydney, NSW, Australia: NSW Health.

58.

Ring

Van de Ven

(1994) Developmental processes of cooperative interorganizational relationships. The Academy of Management Review 19: 90–118.

59.

Rubin

(1995) Qualitative Interviewing: The Art of Hearing Data. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

60.

Shields

(1997) Research in management accounting by North Americans in the 1990s. Journal of Management Accounting Research 9: 3–62.

61.

Tessier

Otley

(2012) A conceptual development of Simons’ levers of control framework. Management Accounting Research 23: 171–185.

62.

Thomson

(2001) Collaboration: Meaning and measurement. PhD Dissertation, Indiana University, Bloomington, IN.

63.

Thomson

Perry

(2006) Collaboration processes: Inside the black box. Public Administration Review 66: 20–32.

64.

Vaivio

(1999) Examining ‘the quantified customer’. Accounting, Organizations and Society 24: 689–715.

65.

Vaivio

(2006) The accounting of “The Meeting”. Examining calculability within a “Fluid” local space. Accounting, Organizations and Society 31: 735–762.

66.

Vollmer

(2007) How to do more with numbers: Elementary stakes, framing, keying, and the three-dimensional character of numerical signs. Accounting, Organizations and Society 32: 577–600.

67.

Williams

Newton

Morgan

(1985) The integration of zero-base budgeting with management-by-objectives: An empirical inquiry. Accounting, Organizations and Society 10: 457–476.

68.

Wouters

Wilderom

(2008) Developing performance-measurement systems as enabling formalization: A longitudinal field study of a logistics department. Accounting, Organizations and Society 33: 488–516.

69.

Yin

(1994) Case Study Research: Design and Methods, vol. 5 (Applied social research methods services). 2nd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

70.

Yin

(2003) Case Study Research: Design and Methods. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.