The recent Global Financial Crisis has focused our attention on the integrity of rating agencies. Often condemned for being too slow to act, rating agencies have been blamed during many financial crises. This impression opens some research questions addressed in this paper. What are the determinants of banks ratings? How do they differ across ratings agencies? This paper analyses the quantitative determinants of bank ratings, provided by Standard & Poor’s, Moody’s, and Fitch in the United Kingdom and Australia. The main finding is that quantitative factors that reflect asset quality, liquidity risk, capital adequacy and operating performance are the key determinants of bank ratings across the rating agencies. However, macroeconomic variables and market risk factors do not seem to be contributing factors in explaining bank ratings in either country.
AltmanEIKaoDL (1992) The implication of corporate bond rating drift. Financial Analysts Journal48(3): 64–75.
2.
BarronMJClareADThomasSH (1997) The effect of bond rating changes and new ratings on UK stock returns. Journal of Business Finance & Accounting24: 497–509.
3.
BermanGFryTRL (2001) A charitable ranking. Economic Papers20: 67–80.
4.
Bissoondoyal-BheenickE (2005) An analysis of the determinants of sovereign ratings. Global Finance Journal15: 251–280.
5.
BrooksRDFaffRWSokulskyD (2002) An ordered response model of test cricket performance. Applied Economics34: 2353–2365.
6.
CantorRPackerF (1996) Determinants and Impact of Sovereign Credit Rating. Federal Reserve Bank of New York Economic Policy Review, October, pp. 1–15.
7.
CornellBLandsmanWShapiroAC (1989) Cross-sectional regularities in the response of stock prices to bond rating changes. Journal of Accounting, Auditing, and Finance4: 460–479.
8.
CurryJTFisselGSHandweckGA (2008) Is there cyclical bias in bank holding company risk ratings?Journal of Banking & Finance32: 1297–1309.
9.
DichevIPiotroskiJ (2001) The long-run stock returns following bond rating changes. Journal of Finance55: 173–203.
10.
GohJCEderingtonH (1993) Is a bond rating downgrade bad news, good news, or no news for stockholders?Journal of Finance48: 2001–2008.
11.
GohJCEderingtonH (1998) Bond rating agencies and stock analysts: Who knows what when?Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis33: 569–583.
12.
GohJCEderingtonH (1999) Cross-sectional variation in the stock market reaction to bond rating changes. Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance39: 101–112.
GriffinPASanvicenteAZ (1982) Common stock returns and rating changes: A methodological comparison. Journal of Finance47: 733–752.
15.
HillPBrooksRDFaffRW (2010) Variations in sovereign credit quality assessments across rating agencies. Journal of Banking & Finance34: 1327–1343.
16.
HolthausenRWLeftwichRW (1986) The effect of bond rating changes on common stock prices. Journal of Business Research24: 57–89.
17.
ImpsonCMKarafiathIGlascockJ (1992) Testing beta stationarity across bond rating changes. Financial Review27: 607–618.
18.
LindenFMcNamaraGVaalerP (1998) Idiosyncratic region and rater effects on sovereign credit ratings. A paper submitted for presentation in the International Management Division of the Academy of Management Annual Meeting, San Diego, California, August 9–11.
19.
LiuPSeyyedFJSmithSD (1999) The independent impact of credit rating changes – The case of Moody’s rating refinement on yield premiums. Journal of Business Finance & Accounting26: 337–363.
20.
MatolcsyZPLiantoT (1995) The incremental information content of bond rating revisions: The Australian evidence. Journal of Banking & Finance19: 891–902.
21.
McKelveyRCZavionaW (1975) A statistical model for the analysis of ordinal level dependent variables. Journal of Mathematical Sociology4: 103–120.
22.
MoonCGStotskyJG (1993) Testing the differences between the determinants of Moody’s and Standard & Poor’s ratings. Journal of Applied Econometrics8: 51–69.
23.
TrevinoLThomasS (2000) Systematic differences in the determinants of foreign currency sovereign ratings by rating agency. Discussion papers in accounting and management science, No. 00-153, University of Southampton.
24.
WansleyJWGlascockJLClauretieTM (1992) Institutional bond pricing and information arrival: The case of bond rating changes. Journal of Business Finance & Accounting19: 733–750.
25.
ZaimaJKMcCarthyJ (1988) The impact of bond rating changes on common stocks and bonds: Tests of the wealth redistribution hypothesis. Financial Review23: 486–498.
