Contamination of the anaesthetic machine and breathing system by the environment and by patient exposure has been shown to occur. Outside the intensive care setting, however, it is difficult to demonstrate that the anaesthetic machine and breathing system are a vector for patient cross-infection. Bacterial and viral filters for use within the breathing system have been shown to be very effective for filtration, yet their use has not been demonstrated to be of benefit in the prevention of cross-infection between patients. Several instances of patient morbidity are a direct consequence of filter use. The use of bacterial/viral filters may represent another step towards defensive medical practice.
ChantK, KociubaK, MunroR, et al. Investigation of possible patient-to-patient transmission of Hepatis C in a hospital. New South Wales Public Health Bulletin1994; 5:47–51.
2.
MagathT.Method for preventing cross-infection with gas machines. Anesth Analg1938; 17:215–217.
3.
LuttroppH, BerntmannNL.Bacterial filters protect anaesthetic equipment in a low flow system. Anaesthesia1993; 48:520–523.
4.
ShiotaniG, NicholesP, BallingerC, ShawL.Prevention of contamination of the circle system and ventilators with a new disposable filter. Anesth Analg1971; 50:844–855.
5.
du MoulinG, SaubermannA.The anesthesia machine and circle system are not likely to be sources of bacterial contamination. Anesthesiology1977; 47:353–358.
6.
GallagherJ, StrangewaysJ, Allt-GrahamJ.Contamination control in long-term ventilation. Anaesthesia1987; 42:476–481.
7.
IbrahimJ, PercevalA.Contamination of anaesthetic tubing— A real hazard?Anaesth Intens Care1992; 20:317–321.
8.
DuigoodJP.The numbers and the sites of origin of the droplets expelled during respiratory activities. Edinburgh Med J1945; 52:385–401.
9.
WellsW.Airborne contagion and air hygiene: An ecological study of droplet infection. Cambridge, Harvard University Press1955; pp 1–7.
10.
DuigoodJP.Expulsion of pathogenic organisms from the respiratory tract. Br Med J1946; 1:265–268.
11.
AndersenAA.New sampler for the collection, sizing and enumeration of viable airborne particles. J Bacteriol1958; 76:471–484.
12.
MurphyP, FitzgeorgeR, BarrettR.Viability and distribution of bacteria after passage through a circle anaesthetic system. Br J Anaesth1991; 66:300–304.
13.
LeitjenD, RejgerV, MoutonR.Bacterial contamination and the effect of filters in anaesthetic circuits in a simulated patient model. J Hospital Infection1992; 24:51–60.
14.
MacCallumF, NobleW.Disinfection of anaesthetic face masks. Anaesthesia1960; 15:307.
15.
PanditS, MehtaS, AgarwalS.Risk of cross infection from inhalation anaesthetic equipment. Br J Anaesth1967; 39:838–844.
16.
JenkinsJ, EdgarW.Sterilisation of anaesthetic equipment. Anaesthesia1964; 19:197–198.
17.
CravenD, DriksM.Nosocomial pneumonia in the intubated patient. Seminars Respir Infect1987; 2:20–30.
18.
Malecka-GriggsB, ReinhardtD.Direct dilution sampling, quantitation and microbial assessment of open-system ventilation circuits in Intensive Care Units. J Clin Microbiol1983; 17:870–877.
19.
CravenD, GoularteT, MakeB.Contaminated condensate in mechanical ventilator circuits. A risk factor for nosocomial pneumonia?Am Rev Resp Dis1984; 129:825–828.
20.
BygdemanS, von EulerC, NystromB.Moisture exchangers do not prevent patient contamination of ventilators. A microbiological study. Acta Anaesth Scand1984; 28:591–594.
21.
VesleyD, AndersonJ, HalbertM, WymanL.Bacterial output from three respiratory therapy humidifying devices. Resp Care1979; 24:228.
22.
EhrlichR, MillerS, WalkerR.Effects of atmospheric humidity and temperature on the survival of airborne flavo-bacterium. Appl Microbiol1970; 20:884–887.
23.
HatchM, DimmickR.Physiological responses of airborne bacteria to shifts in relative humidity. Bacteriol Rev1966; 30:597–603.
24.
WebbS.Factors affecting the viability of airborne bacteria. III. The role of bonded water and protein structure in the death of airborne cells. Can J Microbiol1960; 6:89–105.
25.
MorrowP.Physics of airborne particles and their deposition in the lung. Ann NY Acad Sci1980; 353:71–80.
26.
du MoulinG, Hedley-WhyteJ.Bacterial interactions between anesthesiologists, their patients and equipment. Anesthesiology1982; 57:37–41.
27.
JosephD.Disease transmission by inefficiently sanitised anesthetising apparatus. JAMA1952; 149:1196–1198.
28.
StarkD, GreenC.Anaesthetic machines and cross-infection. Anaesthesia1962; 17:12–20.
29.
AyliffeG, LowburyE.Airborne infection in hospital. J Hospital Infection1982; 3:217–240.
30.
AdrianiJ, RovenstineE.Experimental studies on carbon dioxide absorbers for anesthesia. Anesthesiology1941; 2:1–19.
31.
FoxC, WhyteA.Walker G, Wedgewood J. The antibacterial effect of halothane. J Hospital Infection1993; 23:73–75.
32.
KnightP.Bedows E, Nahrwold M, Maassab H, Smitka C, Busch M. Alterations in influenza virus pulmonary pathology induced by diethyl ether, halothane, enflurane and pentobarbital anesthesia in mice. Anesthesiology1988; 58:209–215.
33.
MehtaS, BehrG, KenyonD.The effect of volatile anaesthetics on common respiratory pathogens. Anaesthesia1974; 29:280–289.
34.
JohnsonB, EgerE.Bactericidal effects of anesthetics. Anesth Analg1979; 58:136–138.
35.
BengstonJ, BrandbergA, BrinkhoffB, SonanderH, StenqvistO.Low-flow anaesthesia does not increase the risk of microbial contamination through the circle absorber system. Acta Anaesth Scand1987; 31:127–131.
36.
PhillipsI, SpencerG.Pseudomonas aeruginosa cross-infection due to a contaminated respiratory apparatus. Lancet1965; 2:1325–1327.
37.
SealD, StrangewaysJ.Epidemiology and prevention of pseudomonas aeruginosa chest infection in an Intensive Care Unit. Anaesth Intens Care1981; 9:260–265.
38.
ImS, FungJ, SoS, YuD.Unusual dissemination of pseudo-monas by ventilators. Anaesthesia1982; 37:1074–1077.
39.
OldsJ, KischA, EberleB.Wilson J. Pseudomonas aeruginosa respiratory tract infection acquired from a contaminated anesthesia machine. Am Rev Resp Dis1972; 105:628–632.
NielsonH, JacobsenJ, StokkeD, BrinklovM, ChristensenK.Cross-infection from contaminated anaesthetic equipment. A real hazard? Anaesthesia1980; 35:703–708.
42.
FeeleyTW, HamiltonWK, XavierB, MoyersJ, EgerE.Sterile anesthesia breathing circuits do not prevent postoperative pulmonary infection. Anesthesiology1981; 54:369–372.
43.
GaribaldiR, BrittM, WebsterC, PaceN.Failure of bacterial filters to reduce the incidence of pneumonia after inhalation anesthesia. Anesthesiology1981; 54:364–368.
44.
DyerE, PetersonD.How far do bacteria travel from the exhalation valve of IPPV equipment?Anesth Analg1972; 51: 516–519.
45.
ChristopherK, SaravolatzL, BushT, ConwayW.The potential role of respiratory therapy equipment in cross infection. Am Rev Resp Dis1983; 128:271–275.
46.
CulverDH, HoranTC, GaynesRP, et al. Surgical wound infection rate by wound class, operative procedure, and patient risk index. Am J Med1991; 91(3B):1525–1575.
47.
AlbrechtW, DrydenG.Five year experience with the development of an individually clean anesthesia system. Anesth Analg1974; 53:24–28.
48.
GoldbergL, WatkinsH, DolmatzM.Studies on the experimental epidemiology of respiratory infections. VI. The relationship between dose of micro-organisms and subsequent infection or death of a host. J Infect Dis1954; 94:9–21.
49.
SladeM, SimmonsR, YunisE, GreenbergL.Immunodepression after major surgery in normal patients. Surgery1975; 78:363–372.
50.
CooperA, IrvineJ, TurnbullA.Depression of immunological responses due to surgery. Immunology1974; 27:395–399.
51.
Hedley-WhiteJ, du MoulinG.The environment of endotracheal tubes: Role of tracheal tubes in the colonisation of the upper airway and development of pneumonia. Proceedings of the Workshop on Tracheal Tubes, HFK 310, Bureau of Medical Devices. Department of Health and Human Services, U.S.A.1982; pp. 91–102.
52.
BishopC, RoperW, WilliamsS.The use of an absolute filter to sterilise the inspiratory air during intermittent positive pressure respiration. Br J Anaesth1963; 35:32–34.
53.
LloydG, RoeJ.Filtration and humidification. Problems in Respiratory Care1991; 4:474–486.
54.
Bacterial Filtration Efficiency Laboratory No. 29526. Nelson Laboratories Inc, Salt Lake City, Utah, U.S.A. April 1990.
55.
QueraltM.Microbiological tests on the bact-trap filter. University of Barcelona, Faculty of Pharmacy, Microbiology Laboratory, January 1991.
56.
JohanssonN.Long-term bacterial challenge test (48 h) of an Edith Flex HME/Engtrom Y-Filter in a test ventilation system simulating clinical conditions. Engstrom Laboratory Report1994; 4:1–3.
57.
Viral Filtration Efficiency Laboratory No. 29525. Nelson Laboratories Inc, Salt Lake City, Utah, U.S.A. April 1990.
58.
Bacterial Filtration Efficiency Laboratory No. 29526. Nelson Laboratories Inc, Salt Lake City, Utah, U.S.A. April 1990.
59.
Bacterial Filtration Efficiency Laboratory No. 29527.Nelson Laboratories Inc, Salt Lake City, Utah, U.S.A. April 1990.
60.
Virus Filtration Efficiency Laboratory No. 41960.Nelson Laboratories Inc, Salt Lake City, Utah, U.S.A. April 1992.
61.
Cross Contamination Study (Bacterial Filtration Efficiency Procedure) Laboratory No. 38594. Nelson Laboratories Inc, Salt Lake City, Utah, U.S.A. October 1991.
62.
MebiusC.Heat and moisture exchangers with bacterial filters: A laboratory evaluation. Acta Anaesth Scand1992; 36:572–576.
63.
Product Information Bulletin for the Pro Tec PF-30S Device.Pall Biomedical Products Corp, U.S.A.1987.
64.
HedleyR, Allt-GrahamJ.Heat and moisture exchangers and breathing filters. Br J Anaesth1994; 73:227–236.
65.
HedleyR, Allt-GrahamJ.A comparison of filtration properties of heat and moisture exchangers. Anaesthesia1992; 47:414–420.
66.
LeeM, FordJ, HuntP, IrelandD, SwansonP.Bacterial retention properties of heat and moisture exchange filters. Br J Anaesth1992; 69:522–525.
