In a prospective study of 300 young orthopaedic in-patients (< 40 years) given spinal anaesthesia through a 22-gauge Whitacre (n = 150) or a 25-gauge Quincke spinal needle (n = 150), we found a 5.3% and a 9.3% incidence of post-spinal headache (PSH) respectively. Females (10.6%) had a higher overall incidence of post-spinal headache than males (5.6%) with more than twice as many females being affected in the 25 than in the 22-gauge group (14.5% vs 6.1%). The average duration of post-spinal headache was less in the 22-gauge group (36 h vs 42.4 h) as was the incidence of severe headache. It is concluded that the Whitacre 22-gauge needle is more suited for spinal analgesia in young female patients due to its ease of handling and its lower incidence of post-spinal headache.
FlaatenH., RodtS., RoslandJ., VamnesJ.Postoperative headache in young patients after spinal anaesthesia.Anaesthesia1987; 42: 20.
2.
GerardK.W., FagraeusL.Postspinal Headache.Seminars in Anesthesiology1990; 9: 68–74.
3.
LesserP., BembridgeM., LyonsG., MacdonaldR.An evaluation of a 30-gauge spinal needle for spinal anaesthesia for caesarean section.Anaesthesia1990; 45: 767–768.
4.
GielenM.Post Dural Puncture Headache (PDPH): A Review.Reg Anesth1989; 14: 101–106.
5.
FlaatenH., RaederJ.Spinal anaesthesia for outpatient surgery.Anaesthesia1985; 40: 1108–1111.
6.
ThornberryE.A., ThomasT.A.Posture and post-spinal headache. A controlled trial in 80 obstetric patients.Br J Anaesth1988; 60: 195–197.
7.
RasmussenB.S., BlomL., HansenP., MikkelsenS.S.Postspinal headache in young and elderly patients. Two randomised, double-blind studies that compare 20- and 25-gauge needles.Anaesthesia1989; 44: 571–573.
8.
BarkerP.Headache after dural puncture.Anaesthesia1989; 44: 696–697.
9.
NealJ.M., BridenbaughM.D., MulroyM.F., PalmenB.D.Incidence of post-dural puncture headache is similar between 22G Greene and 26G Quincke spinal needles.Anesthesiology1989; 71: A678.
10.
CarrieL.E.Whitacre and pencil-point spinal needles: some points to consider.Anaesthesia1990; 45: 1097–1098.
11.
KreuscherH., SandmannG.Relief of headache following spinal anesthesia by use of a Whitacre cannula. Experimental investigations.Reg Anaesth1989; 12: 43–45.
12.
SamiH.M., SkaredoffM.N.In-hospital incidence of post-lumbar puncture headache in caesarean section patients associated with the 22G Whitacre needle.Reg Anesth1989; 14: 2S: 44.
13.
BridenbaughP.O.Complications of local anesthetic neural blockade. In: CousinsM.J., BridenbaughPO eds. Neural Blockade.Philadelphia: JB Lipincott, 1988; 713–714.
14.
DriessenA., MauerW., FrickeM., KossmannB., SchleinzerW.Prospective studies of the post-spinal headache.Reg Anaesth1980; 3: 38–41.
15.
GreeneH.M.Lumbar puncture and the prevention of postpuncture headache.JAMA1926; 86: 391–392.
16.
HartJ.R., WhitacreR.J.Pencil-point needle in prevention of postspinal headache.JAMA1951; 147: 657–658.
17.
HaraldsonS.Headache after spinal anesthesia: experiments with a new spinal needle.Anesthesiology1951; 12: 321–327.
18.
EcksteinK.L., RogacevZ., Vincente-EcksteinA., GrahovacZ.Prospective comparative study of postspinal headaches in young patients (< 51 years).Reg Anaesth1982; 5: 57–61.
19.
SamiH.M., McNultyJ.A., SkaredoffM.N., FoxL.M.The effect of spinal needle shape and bevel orientation on the size and shape of the dural defect: An SEM study in dogs.Anesthesiology1989; 71: A674.
20.
CruikshankR.H., HopkinsonJ.M.Fluid flow through dural puncture sites. An in vitro comparison of needle point types.Anaesthesia1989; 44: 415–418.
21.
ReadyL.B., CuplinS., HaschkeR.H., NesslyM.Spinal needle determinants of rate of transdural fluid leak.Anesth Analg1989; 69: 457–460.
22.
KreuscherH., SandmannG.Relief of headache following spinal anesthesia by use of a Whitacre cannula. Clinical study.Reg Anaesth1989; 12: 46–49.
23.
ThomasT.A., NobleH.A.A re-evaluation of the Whitacre spinal needle in obstetric anaesthesia — a pilot study.Anaesthesia1990; 45: 489.
24.
PerzR.R., JohnsonD.L., ShinozakiT.Spinal anesthesia for outpatient surgery.Anesth Analg1988; 67: S168.
25.
MartinY.N., Guiavarc'HM., OlivierJ., DucrotP.Rôle du calibre, 22G et 25G de l'aiguille dans l'apparition des cephalées après rachianesthesie.Cahiers d’ Anesth1987; 35: 535–537.
26.
SarmaV.J., BoströmU.Intrathecal anaesthesia for day-care surgery. A retrospective study of 160 cases using 25- and 26-gauge spinal needles.Anaesthesia1990; 45: 769–771.
27.
LynchJ., ArhelgerS., Krings-ErnstI.Post-Dural Puncture Headache In Young Orthopaedic In-Patients. A comparison of a 0.33 mm (29-gauge) Quincke with a 0.7 mm (22-gauge) Whitacre spinal needle.Acta Anaesth Scand1992; 36: 58–61.
28.
LynchJ., Krings-ErnstI., StrickK., TopalidisK., SchaafH., FiebigM.Use of a 25-gauge Whitacre needle to reduce the incidence of postdural puncture headache.Br J Anaesth1991; 67: 690–693.
29.
DixonC.L.The Sprotte, Whitacre and Quincke spinal needles.Anesthesiology Review1991; 15(5): 42–47.
