A diagram based on in-vivo relationships between arterial hydrogen ion activity (H+) and carbon dioxide tension (PCO2) in primary abnormalities of acid base homeostasis is presented.
It is designed to facilitate the interpretation of pH data by including the 95% confidence limits described in patients with simple metabolic and respiratory acid base disorders. These bands have been formulated from observation of simple acid base abnormalities and indicate the appropriate respiratory or renal compensatory response to the primary pH defect. A plot which falls outside these limits therefore indicates the presence of a mixed acid base disorder.
The diagram presents a physiological approach to clinical disorders of pH regulation demonstrating maintenance of intra-cellular fluid homeostasis during primary extracellular fluid disturbances.
Diagnostic and therapeutic advantages are further illustrated and discussed in six case reports.
References
1.
AdlerS., RoyA., RelmanA. S. (1965): “Intracellular Acid-base Regulation, II. The Interaction Between CO2 Tension and the Extracellular Bicarbonate in the Determination of Muscle Cell pH”, J. Clin. Invest., 44, 21.
2.
AlbertM. S., DellR. B., WintersR. W. (1967): “Quantitative Displacement of Acid Base Equilibrium in Metabolic Acidosis”, Ann. Intern. Med., 66, 312.
3.
ArbusG. S., HebertL. A., LevesqueP. R., EtstenB. E., SchwartzW. B. (1969): “Characterization and Clinical Application of the Significance band for Acute Respiratory Alkalosis”, New Engl. J. Med., 280, 117.
4.
ArbusG. S. (1973): “An in vivo Acid Base Nomogram for Clinical Use”, Can. Med. Assoc. J., 109, 291.
5.
AstrupP., JorgensenK., AndersenO. S., EngelK. (1960): “The Acid Base Metabolism: A New Approach”, Lancet, 1, 1035.
6.
BrackettN. C.Jnr., CohenJ. J., SchwartzW. B. (1965): “Carbon Dioxide Titration Curve of Normal Man: Effect of Increasing Degrees of Acute Hypercapnoea on Acid-base Equilibrium”, Sew Engl. J. Med., 272, 6.
7.
BrackettN. C.Jnr., WingoC. F., MurenO., SolanoJ. T. (1968): “Acid Base Response to Chronic Hypercapnoea in Man”, Sew Eng. J. Med., 280, 124.
8.
BoneJ. M.CowieJ., LambieA. T., RobsonJ. S. (1974): “The Relationship Between Arterial pCO2 and Hydrogen Ion Concentration in Chronic Metabolic Acidosis and Alkalosis”, Clin. Set., 46, 539.
9.
BunkerJ. P. (1965): “The Great Trans-Atlantic Acid-base Debate”, Anesthesiology, 26, 591.
10.
BurnettR. W., NoonanD. C. (1974): “Calculations and Correction Factors Used in Determination of Blood pH and Blood Gases”, Clin. Chem., 20, 1506.
11.
ButlerT. C. (1973): “pH Another View”, Science, 179, 854.
12.
CampbellM. (1962): “RlpH”, Lancet, 1, 681.
13.
ChazanJ. A., StensonR., KurlandG. S. (1968): “The Acidosis of Cardiac Arrest”,. V. Engl. J. Med., 278, 360.
14.
CohenJ. J. (1967): “A New Acid-base Nomogram Featuring Hydrogen Ion Concentration”, Ann. Intern. Med.66, 159.
15.
DavenportH. W. (1958): The ABC of Acid Base Chemistry. 4th Ed. University Chicago Press, Chicago.
16.
DavisR. P. (1967): “Logland: A Gibbsian View of Acid-base Balance”, Amer. J. Med., 42, 159.
17.
ElkintonJ. R. (1966). “Clinical Disorders of Acid-base Regulation”, Med. Clin. S. Amer., 50, 1325.
18.
EngelK. (1968): “Quantitative Displacement of Acid Base Equilibrium in Chronic Respiratory Acidosis”, J. Appl. Physiol., 24, 288.
19.
FilleyG. F. (1971): Acid Base and Blood Gas Regulation.Lea Febiger, Philadelphia. p. 163.
20.
FillmoreS. J., ShapiroM., KillipT. (1970): “Serial Blood Gas Studies During Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation”. Ann. Int. Med., 72, 465.
21.
FlenleyD. C. (1971): “Another Non-logarithmic Acid-base Diagram”, Lancet, 1, 961.
22.
FulopM., FulopM. (1974): “Acid Base Diagrams. Maths, Myths and Measurements”, Lancet, 1, 637.
23.
FulopM., DreyerN., TannenbaumH. (1974): “The Ventilatory Response in Diabetic Ketoacidosis”, Clin. Sci., 46, 539.
24.
GennariF. J., GoldsteinM. B., SchwartzW. B. (1972): “The Nature of the Renal Adaptation to Chronic Hypocapnoea”, J. Clin. Invest., 51, 1722.
25.
GoldbergM.” (1973): “Computer-based Instruction and Diagnosis of Acid-base Disorders”, J. Amer. Med. Ass., 223, 269.
26.
GoldringR. M.el al. (1968): “Respiratory Adjustment to Chronic Metabolic Alkalosis in Man”, J. Clin. Invest., 47, 188.
27.
HillsA. G., ReidE. L. (1966): “pH Defended—is it Defensible? “Ann. Intern. Med., 65, 1150.
28.
HillsA. G. (1973): “pH and the Henderson-Hasselbalch Equation”, Am. J. Med., 55, 131.
29.
HoworthP. J. N. (1974): “RlpH Revisited”, Lancet.1, 253.
30.
HuckabeeW. E. (1961): “Henderson vs Hasselbalch”, Clin. Res., 9, 110.
31.
JarboeT. M., PenmanR. W., LukeR. G. (1972): “Ventilatory Failure Due to Metabolic Alkalosis”. Chest (Suppl)., 61, 61.
32.
KassirerJ. P. (1974): “Serious Acid Base Disorders”, N. Eng. J. Med., 291, 773.
33.
KidsonW., CaseyJ., KaraegenE., LazarusL. (1974): “Treatment of Severe Diabetes Mellitus by Insulin Infusion”, Br. Med. Jul., 2, 691.
34.
LemannJ.Jnr., LennonE., GoodmanA. D., LitzowJ. R., RelmanA. S. (1965): “The Nett Balance of Acid in Subjects (liven Large Loads of Acid or Alkali”, J. Clin. Invest., 44, 507.
35.
LennonE. J., LemannJ. Jnr. (1966): “Defence of Hydrogen Ion Concentration in Chronic Metabolic Acidosis: A New Evaluation of an Old Approach”, Ann. Intern. Med., 65, 265.
36.
LevesqueP. R. (1975): “Acid-base Disorders: Application of Total Body Carbon Dioxide Titration in Anaesthesia”, Anesth. Analg. Curr. Res., 54, 299.
37.
LifschitzM. D., BraschR., CuomoA. J., MenuS. T. (1972): “Marked Hypercapnoea Secondary to Severe Metabolic Alkalosis”, Ann. Int. Med., 77, 405.
38.
MattarJ. A., WeilM. H., ShubinH., SteinL. (1974): “Cardiac Arrest in the Critically Ill”, Amer. J. Med., 56, 162.
39.
McCurdyD. K. (1972): “Mixed Metabolic and Respiratory Acid-base Disturbances: Diagnosis and Treatment”. Chest (Suppl.).62, 35.
40.
MongeC., LozanoR., CarcelénD. (1964): “Renal Excretion of Bicarbonate in High Altitude Natives and in Natives with Chronic Mountain Sickness”, J. Clin. Invest., 43, 2303.
41.
MontiM., Rooth (1970): “Respiratory Compensation to Metabolic Acid-base Disturbances”, Scand. J. Clin. Lab. Invest., 26, 381.
42.
NeffT. A., PettyT. L. (1972): “Tolerance and Survival in Severe Chronic Hypercapnoea”, Arch. Intern. Med., 129, 591.
43.
OlivaP. B. (1972): “Severe Alveolar Hypoventilation in a Patient with Metabolic Alkalosis”, Amer. J. Med., 52, 817.
44.
PetersJ. P., Van SlykeD. D. (1931): Quantitative Clinical Chemistry, Vol. 1, p. 868, Williams and Wilkins, Baltimore.
45.
PierceN. F., FedsonD. S., BrighamK. L., MitraR. C., SackR. B., MondalA. (1970): “The Ventilation Response to Acute Base Deficit in Humans”, Ann. Intern. Med., 72, 633.
46.
PosnerJ. B., PlumF. (1967): “Spinal Fluid pH and Neurological Symptoms in Systemic Acidosis”, N. Engl. J. Med., 277, 605.
47.
RahnH., ReevesR. B., HowellB. J. (1975): “Hydrogen Ion Regulation, Temperature and Evolution”, Amer. Rev. Resp. Dis., 112, 165.
48.
RelmanA. S. (1966): “The Participation of Cells in Disturbances of Acid Base Balance”, Ann. S.Y. Acad. Sci., 133, 160.
49.
SaundersN. A., CarterJ., ScampP., VandenbergR. (1974): “Severe Hypercapnoea Associated with Metabolic Alkalosis Due to Pyloric Stenosis”, Aust. N.Z. J. Med., 4, 385.
50.
SchwartzW. B., RelmanA. S. (1963): “A Critique of the Parameters Used in the Evaluation of Acid-base Disorders”, N. Engl. J. Med., 268, 1362.
51.
SchwartzW. B., BrackettN. C.Jnr., CohenJ. J. (1965): “The Response of Extracellular Hydrogen Ion Concentration to Graded Degrees of Chronic Hypercapnoea. The Physiological Limits of the Defence of pH”, Jnl. Clin. Invest., 44, 291.
52.
SeveringhausJ. W. (1965): “Blood Gas Concentrations”, Handbook on Physiology, Washington DC, Amer. Physiol. Soc., Section 3, V.II, Ch. 61, p. 1475.
53.
SeveringhausJ. W., ChiodiH., EgerE. I., BrandstaterB., HornbeinT. F. (1966): “Cerebral Blood Flow in Man at High Altitude”, Circ. Res., 19, 274.
54.
ShockN. W., HastingsA. B. (1934): “Studies of the Acid Base Balance of the Blood”, J. Biol. Chem., 104, 575.
55.
SiegelP. D. (1973): “The Physiological Approach to Acid-base Balance”, Med. Clin. N. Amer., 57, 863.
56.
Siggaard-AndersenO., Engel (1960): “A New Acid-base Nomogram: An Improved Method for the Calculation of the Relevant Blood Acid Base Data”, Scand. J. Clin. Lab. Invest., 12, 177.
57.
StrandgaardS., NielsenP. E., BitschV., LyngsoeJ. (1971): “Blood Lactate and Ketone Bodies in Diabetic Keto-acidosis”, Acta. Med. Scand., 190, 17.
58.
TullerM. A., Medi (1971): “Compensatory Hypoventilation and Hypercapnoea in Primary Metabolic Alkalosis”, Amer. J. Med., 50, 281.
59.
Van BiervleitJ. P., Van StekelenburgG. J., DuranM., WadmanS. K. (1974): “Base Excess and Organic Acidaemia”, Lancet, 2, 1518.
60.
Van Ypersele de StrihouC., BrasseurL., DeConinckJ. (1966): “The Carbon Dioxide Response Curve for Chronic Hypercapnoea in Man”, N. Engl. J. Med., 275, 117.
WeilW. B. Jnr. (1973): “Acid-base Phenomenon and the Hydrogen Ion”, J. Pediatrics, 83, 359.
63.
WintersW. R., DellR. B. (1973): “From Henderson-Hasselbalch to Henderson: A Better Way to Teach”, J. Pediatrics, 83, 372.
64.
WorthleyL. I. G. (1975): (Unpublished Observations).
65.
ZimmetP. Z., TaftP., EnnisG. C., SheathJ. (1970): “Acid Production in Diabetic Acidosis: A More Rational Approach to Alkali Replacement”, Brit. Med. J., iii, 610.
