Many operating theatre staff believe that the surgical face mask protects the healthcare worker from potentially hazardous biological infections. A questionnaire-based survey, undertaken by Leyland1in 1993 to assess attitudes to the use of masks, showed that 20% of surgeons discarded surgical masks for endoscopic work. Less than 50% did not wear the mask as recommended by the Medical Research Council. Equal numbers of surgeons wore the mask in the belief they were protecting themselves and the patient, with 20% of these admitting that tradition was the only reason for wearing them.
Policies relating to the wearing of surgical masks by operating theatre staff are varied. This indicates some confusion about the role of the surgical mask in modern surgical and anaesthetic practice. This review was undertaken to collate current evidence and make recommendations based on this evidence.
LeylandM., McCloyR.Surgical Face Masks: Protection of self or patient?Ann R Coll Surg Engl1993; 75: 1.
2.
Australian Standard 1668.2.Mechanical ventilation for acceptable indoor air quality.1991.
3.
StreiferA.J.Design and maintenance of Hospital ventilation systems and the prevention of Airborne Nosocomial Infection.Infect Control Hospital Epidemiol1995; 959–964.
4.
McLawsM.J., IrwigL., MockP., BerryG., GoldJ.Predictors of surgical wound infection in Australia. A National Study.Med J Aust1988; 149: 591–595.
LaufmanH.Current status of air handling systems in operating rooms.J Assoc Adv Med Instrum1973; 7–15.
7.
CharnleyJ.Post operative infection after total hip replacements with special reference to air contamination in the operating room.Clin Orthop1973; 96: 195.
8.
DuguidJ., WallaceA.Air infection with dust liberated from clothing.Lancet1948; 2: 285–849.
9.
HareA., ThomasC.The transmission of Staphylococcus aureus.Br Med J1956; 232: 840–844.
10.
ShooterR.A., SmithM.A., HunterC.J.W.A study of surgical masks.Br J Surg1959; 47: 246–249.
11.
MitchellN.J., HuntS.Surgical face masks in modern operating rooms.A costly and unnecessary ritual? J Hosp Infect1991; 18: 239–242.
12.
DavisR., NobleW.Dispersal of bacteria on desquamated skin.Lancet1962; 2: 1295–1297.
13.
RitterM.A.The operating room environment as affected by people and the surgical mask.Clin Orthop1975; 111: 147–150.
SchweizerR.T.Mask wiggling as a potential cause of wound contamination.Lancet1976; 2.
16.
OrrN.M.W.Is a mask necessary in the operating theatre?Ann R Coll Surg Engl1981; 63: 390–392.
17.
ChamberlainG.V., HouangE.Trial of the use of masks in the gynaecological operating theatre.Ann R Coll Surg Engl1984; 66: 431–433.
18.
RuthmanJ.C., HendricksonD., MillerR.F., QuiggD.Effect of cap and mask on infection rates.Ill Med J1984; 165: 397–399.
19.
LaslettL.J., SabinA.Wearing of caps and masks not necessary during cardiac catheterisation.Cathet Cardiovasc Diagn1989; 17: 158–160.
20.
BergerS.A., KramerM., NagarH., FinkelsteinA., FrimmermanA., MillerH.I.Effect of surgical mask position on bacterial contamination of the operative field.J Hosp Infect1993; 23: 51–44.
21.
PhillipsB.J., FergussonS., ArmstrongP., AndersonF.M., WildsmithJ.A.W.Surgical face masks are effective in reducing bacterial contamination caused by dispersal from the upper airway.Br J Anaesth1992; 69: 407–408.
22.
WildsmithJ.A.W.Regional anaesthesia requires attention to detail.Br J Anaesth1991; 67: 224–225.
23.
LeeJ.J., ParryH.Bacterial meningitis following spinal anaesthesia for Caesarian section.Br J Anaesth1991; 66: 383–386.
24.
TunevallT.G.Postoperative wound infection and surgical face masks: A controlled study.World J Surg1991; 15: 383–388.
25.
TunevallT.G., Jörbeck. Influence of wearing masks on the density of airborne bacteria in the vicinity of the surgical wound.Eur J Surg1992; 158: 263–266.
26.
HullerD.A., ColwellR.C.The protective qualities of the gauze face mask.JAMA1918; 71: 1213–1215.
27.
WeaverG.H.Droplet infection and its prevention by the face mask.J Infect Dis1919; 24: 218–230.
28.
Kellog, and MacMillan. An experimental study of the efficiency of gauze masks.Am J Public Health1920; 10: 34–42.
29.
GB, WileyA.M.The efficiency of standard surgical face mask: An investigation using tracer particles.Clin Orthop1980; 160–162.
30.
VesleyD., LangholtzA.C., LaverJ.C.Clinical implications of surgical mask retention efficiency for viable and total particles.Infections in surgery1983; 571–536.
31.
PippinD.J., VerderameR.A., WeberK.K.Efficacy of face masks in preventing inhalation of airborne contaminants.J Oral Maxillofac Surg1987; 45(4): 319–323.
32.
WalkerN.P.J., MathewsJ., NewsomeS.W.B.Possible Hazards from irradiation with CO2 Laser.Lasers Surg Med1986; 6: 84–86.
33.
NezhatC., WinerW.K., NezhatF., NezhatC., ForrestD., ReevesW.G.Smoke from laser surgery: is there a health hazard?Lasers Surg Med1987; 1: 376–382.
34.
SawchunkW.S., WeberP.J., LowryD.R., DzubowL.M.Infectious papillomavirus in the vapors of warts treated with CO2 laser and electrocoagulation. Detection and protection.J Am Acad Dermatol1989; 21: 41–49.
35.
HeiwsohnP., JewettD.C., BlazertL., BennettC.A., SeipelP., RosenA.Aerosol created by some surgical power tools: Particle size distribution and qualitative Haemoglobin content.Appl Occ Environ Hyg1991; 6: 773–776.
36.
WeberA., WillekeK., MarchioniR.. Aerosol penetration and leakage characteristics of masks used in the health care industry.Am J Infect Control1993; 21(4): 167–173.
37.
KouriD.L., ErnestJ.M.Incidence of perceived and actual face shield contamination during vaginal and Caesarian delivery.Am J Obstet Gynecol1993; 169: 312–315.
38.
Norman.A comparison of face masks and visors for the scrub team.Br J Theatre Nursing1995; 5(2).
39.
National Health and Medical Research Council Policy.Infection control in Health care.1996; 47.
40.
MathiasJ.M.Experts discuss merits of surgical masks.OR Manager1993; 9: 1–4.
