This article argues that far from containing an anti-ecological bias, Marx's ‘free appropriation’ category clarifies the contradictions between the true sources of wealth (the combination of nature and social labor) and capitalism's monetary representation of wealth as abstract labor time. On this basis, it is shown that some of the most popular ecological criticisms of Marx's value analysis fail to grasp Marx's basic demarcation of value, exchange value, and use value. Properly understood, Marx's analysis provides much keener insights into capitalism's environmental problems than do the essentially ahistorical approaches of those who would uncritically ascribe ‘value’ to nature.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Altvater, Elmar (1990) ‘The Foundations of Life (Nature) and the Maintenance of Life (Work),’International Journal of Political Economy, Vol.20, No.1, Spring: 10–34.
2.
Altvater, Elmar (1993) The Future of the Market: An Essay on the Regulation of Money and Nature after the Collapse of ‘Actually Existing Socialism’. Verso, London.
3.
Burkett, Paul (1996a) ‘Value, Capital and Nature: Some Ecological Implications of Marx's Critique of Political Economy,’ in Science & Society, Vol.60, No.3, Fall: 332–59.
4.
Burkett, Paul (1996b) ‘On Some Common Misconceptions About Nature and Marx's Critique of Political Economy,’ in Capitalism, Nature, Socialism, Vol.7, No.3, September: 57–80.
5.
Burkett, Paul (1997) ‘Nature in Marx Reconsidered: A Silver Anniversary Assessment of Alfred Schmidt's Concept of Nature in Marx,’ in Organization & Environment, Vol.10, No.2, June: 164–83.
6.
Burkett, Paul (1999) Marx and Nature: A Red and Green Perspective. St. Martin's Press, New York.
7.
Campbell, Robert W (1974) The Soviet-Type Economies: Performance and Evolution, 3rd Edn. Houghton Mifflin, Boston.
8.
Campbell, Robert W (1991) The Socialist Economies in Transition. Indiana University Press, Bloomington, IN.
9.
Carchedi, Guglielmo (1991) Frontiers of Political Economy. Verso, London.
10.
Carpenter, Geoffrey P (1997) ‘Redefining Scarcity: Marxism and Ecology Reconciled,’ in Democracy & Nature, Vol.3, No.3: 129–53.
11.
Deléage, Jean-Paul (1994) ‘Eco-Marxist Critique of Political Economy,’ in Martin O'Connor (ed.) Is Capitalism Sustainable?.Guilford, New York: 37–52.
12.
Devine, James (1993) ‘The Law of Value and Marxian Political Ecology,’ in Jesse Vorst, Ross Dobson and Ron Fletcher (eds.) Green On Red: Evolving Ecological Socialism, Fernwood Publishing in Association with the Society for Socialist Studies, Winnipeg/Halifax, Canada: 133–54.
13.
Georgescu-Roegen, Nicholas (1971) The Entropy Law and the Economic Process. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
14.
Marx, Karl (1963) Theories of Surplus Value, Part 1. Progress Publishers, Moscow.
15.
Marx, Karl (1966) Critique of the Gotha Programme. International Publishers, New York.
16.
Marx, Karl (1967) Capital, Volumes I-III. International Publishers, New York.
17.
Marx, Karl (1968) Theories of Surplus Value, Part 2. Progress Publishers, Moscow.
18.
Marx, Karl (1973) Grundrisse. Vintage, New York.
19.
Marx, Karl (1985) ‘The Civil War in France,’ in Karl Marx and Frederick EngelsOn the Paris Commune.Progress Publishers, Moscow: 48–181.
20.
Marx, Karl (1987) ‘References to My Own Notebooks,’ in Karl Marx and Frederick EngelsCollected Works, Vol.29. International Publishers, New York: 518–32.
21.
Marx, Karl (1991) ‘Economic Manuscript of 1861-63, Continuation,’ in Karl Marx and Frederick EngelsCollected Works, Vol.33. International Publishers, New York: 9–252, 372–501.
22.
Marx, Karl (1994) ‘Economic Manuscript of 1861-63, Conclusion,’ in Karl Marx and Frederick EngelsCollected Works, Vol.34. International Publishers, New York: 7–354.
23.
Orton, David (1993) ‘Envirosocialism: Contradiction or Promise?,’ in Jesse Vorst, Ross Dobson and Ron Fletcher (eds.) Green On Red: Evolving Ecological Socialism, Fernwood Publishing in Association with the Society for Socialist Studies, Winnipeg/Halifax, Canada: 189–203.
24.
Schmidt, Alfred (1971) The Concept of Nature in Marx. New Left Books, London.
25.
Skirbekk, Gunnar (1994) ‘Marxism and Ecology,’ in Capitalism, Nature, Socialism, Vol.5, No.4, December: 95–104.
26.
Smith, Neil (1984) Uneven Development: Nature, Capital, and the Production of Space. Basil Blackwell, Oxford, UK.
