This article argues that Marx's transformation procedure has been turned into a nonexistent transformation ‘problem’ by abolishing time, i.e. by implicitly applying the methodology of neo-classical general equilibrium theory. It then depicts the real transformation process from individual into social values both when technological change is abstracted from and when it is explicitly taken into consideration. Finally the article ends with a critique of the thesis according to which value is created in the act of exchange.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Arthur, C. (1994) Engels. Logic and History, Unpublished paper.
2.
Carchedi, G. (1991) Frontiers of Political Economy, Verso, London.
3.
Carchedi, G. (1992) ‘On the use of national accounts in value analysis’, International Journal of Political EconomyVol. 22, No. 3, Fall: 72–103.
4.
Carchedi, G. (1993) ‘Marx's Logic of Inquiry and Price Formation’, in F. Moseley (ed.), Marx's Method in ‘Capital’, Humanity Press, New Jersey: 185–217.
5.
Carchedi, G. and W. De Haan (1995) ‘The transformation procedure: a non-equilibrium approach’, in Freeman and Carchedi (eds), The alternative to equilibrium: a reappraisal of classical economics, Edward Elgar, forthcoming.
6.
Freeman, A. (1984) ‘The logic of the transformation problem’, in E. Mandel and A. Freeman, Ricardo, Marx and Sraffa, Verso, London: 221–64.
7.
Freeman, A. (1992) The mathematical construction of a value measure, Working paper, Economics division, University of Greenwich.
8.
Freeman, A., and G. Carchedi (eds), The alternative to equilibrium: a reappraisal of classical economics, Edward Elgar, forthcoming.
9.
Ganssmann, H. (1988) ‘Abstract labour as a metaphor? A comment on Steedman’, History of Political EconomyVol. 20, No. 3: 461–470.
10.
Giussani, P. (1991) ‘The determination of prices of production’, International Journal of Political EconomyVol. 21, Winter: 67–87.
11.
Horverak, O. (1988) ‘Marx's view of competition and price determination’, History of Political EconomyVol. 20, No. 2: 275–297.
12.
Kliman, A. and T. McGlone (1988) ‘The transformation non-problem and the non-transformation problem’. Capital&Class35: 56–83.
13.
Kristjanson, D. (1994) Effective demand and the value of credit money: a Marxian approach, unpublished paper.
14.
Mandel, E. and A. Freeman (1984) Ricardo, Marx and Sraffa, Verso, London.
15.
Marx, K. (1967) Capital, Vol. III, International Publishers, New York.
16.
Marx, K. (1973) Grundrisse, Penguin Books Ltd, Harmondsworth.
17.
Marx, K. (1976) Capital, Vol. I, Penguin Books, Harmondsworth.
18.
Marx, K. (1992) Karl Marx Okonomische Manuscripte, 1863–1867, Karl Marx Friederich Engels Gesamtausgabe (MEGA), Dietz Verlag, Berlin.
19.
Moseley, F. (ed.) (1993) Marx's Method in ‘Capital’, Humanity Press, New Jersey.
20.
Moseley, F. (ed.) (1993) ‘Marx's Logical Method and the ‘Transformation Problem’’, in F. Moseley (ed.), Marx's Method in ‘Capital’, Humanity Press, New Jersey: 157–185.
21.
Ohno, S (1993) ‘Marx's Hauptmanuskript zum III. Buch des ‘Kapitals’ und die Verwandlung des Wertes in den Produktionspreis’, Marx-Engels-Forsgung im historischen Spannungsfeld, Argument: 165–175.
22.
Reuten, G. (1988) Value as a social form, in M. Williams (ed) Value, Social form and the state, St. Martin Press, New York.
23.
Saad-Filho, A. (1995) ‘The value of money, the value of labour power and the net product: an appraisal of the ‘new approach’ to the transformation problem’, in Freeman and Carchedi (eds), The alternative to equilibrium: a reappraisal of classical economics, Edward Elgar, forthcoming.
24.
Steedman, I. (1985) ‘Heterogeneous labour, money wages and Marx's theory’, History of Political EconomyVol. 17, No. 4: 551–573.
25.
Sweezy, P. (1968) The theory of capitalist development, Monthly Review Press, New York.
26.
Sweezy, P.(ed.) (1973) Karl Marx and the close of his system, A.M. Kelley.
27.
Von Bortkiewicz, L. (1973) ‘On the correction of Marx's fundamental theoretical construction in the third volume of Capital’, in P. Sweezy (ed.) Karl Marx and the close of his system, A.M. Kelley.
28.
Williams, M. (ed.) (1988) Value, Social form and the state, St. Martin Press, New York.
29.
Wolff, R.D, A. Callari and B. Roberts (1984) ‘A Marxian Alternative to the Traditional ‘Transformation Problem’’, Rethinking Marxism:115–135.
