Evidence from Japan, West Germany and the UK shows that there is no generalisable trend toward technology driven flexible craft work. Insofar as it exists, workplace flexibility does not guarantee the benefits for labour implied by some of its proponents. Rather flexibility strategies have been used to weaken worker constraints on management prerogatives and to intensify work.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abernathy, W., K. Clark, A. Kantrow, (1983) Industrial Renaissance: producing a competitive future for AmericaNew York, Basic Books.
2.
ACAS (1988) ‘Labour flexibility in Britain: the 1987 ACAS survey’ Occasional paper 41, London, Arbitration, Conciliation and Advice Service.
3.
Aglietta, M. (1979) A theory of capitalist regulation: the us experience, London, NLB
4.
Aguren, S., C. Bredbacka, R. Hansson, K. Ihregren, K. Karlsson (1984) Volvo, Kalmar Revisited: Ten years of experience, Stockholm, Efficiency and Participation Development Council (SAF, LO, PTK).
5.
Atkinson, J. (1987) Flexibility or fragmentation? The United Kingdom labour market in the eighties’Labour and Society12, 1.
6.
Atkinson, J., N. Meager (1987) ‘Is flexibility just a flash in the pan?’ Personnel Management, September.
7.
Auer, P. (1985) ‘Industrial relations, work organisation and new technology: the Volvo case’ Discussion paper IIM/LMP 85–10, Berlin: Wissenschaftszentrum.
8.
Bean, C., J. Symons (1989) ‘Ten years of Mrs T’ Centre for Labour Economics’, London, London School of Economics.
9.
Berggren, C. (1989) ‘‘New roduction concepts’ in final assembly — the Swedish experience’ in S. Wood (ed.) The Transformation of Work?, London, Unwin Hyman.
10.
Bosquet, M.Capitalism in Crisis and Everyday Life, Brighton, Harvester.
11.
Boyer, R. (1987) ‘Labour flexibilities: many forms, uncertain effects’, Labour and Society, 12, 1.
12.
Braverman, H. (1974) Labor and Monopoly Capital, New York, Monthly Review Press.
13.
Chandler, K. (1978) ‘MINOS — a system for central control at collieries’ 2nd International Conference on Centralised Control Systems, London, Institution of Electrical Engineers.
14.
Cleary, J. (1981) ‘FIDO at Bold colliery’, Mining Engineer, November.
15.
Communist Party (1989) Manifesto for new times, London, CPGB.
16.
Coriat, B. (1980) ‘The restructuring of the assembly line: a new economy of time and control’Capital and Class, 11.
17.
Coriat, B. (1981) ‘L'atelier Fordien automatise’ Non!, 10, November-December.
18.
Coriat, B. (1984) ‘Labor and capital in the crisis: France 1966–82’ in M. Kesselman (ed.) The French workers’ movement: economic crisis and political change, Boston, Ma, Allen and Unwin.
19.
Coriat, B. (1987) ‘Information technology, productivity and job content’, Paper to BRIE meeting on comparative production, Berkeley, September 11–13.
20.
Cross, M. (1985) Towards the flexible craftsman, London, Technical Change Centre.
21.
Cusumano, M. (1984) The Japanese automobile industry, Cambridge Ma, Harvard University Press.
22.
Dohse, K., U. Jurgens, T. Malsch (1985) ‘From Fordism to Toyotism? The social organisation of the labor process in the Japanese automobile industry’Politics and Society, 14, 2.
23.
Eaton, J. (1987) ‘The flexible firm in Wales: a consideration of its impact on trade unions’, Welsh Economic Review, 1, 2.
24.
Economist (20.5.89) ‘The end of the beginning’, (Special Report).
25.
Foster, J., C. Woolfson (1989) ‘Post-fordism and business unionism’, New Left Review, 174.
26.
Garrahan, P., P. Stewart (1989) ‘Post-Fordism, Japanisation and the local economy: Nissan in the north-east’, Conference of Socialist Economists, Sheffield Polytechnic, 7–9 July.
27.
Gronblad, S. (1987) ‘Production supervision of automatic assembly line at the Volvo Skovde plant’, Electronics in Measurement, Automation and Control, April.
28.
Heizmann, J. (1983) ‘Work structuring in automated manufacturing systems exemplified by the use of industrial robots for body assembly’ in T. Martin (ed.) Design of work in automated manufacturing systems, (IFAC seminar Karlsruhe, FRG) Oxford: Pergamon.
29.
Hirst, B., J. Zeitlin (1988) ‘Crisis, what crisis?’ New Statesman 18 March.
30.
Hirst, B., J. Zeitlin (1989) ‘Flexible specialisation and the competitive failure of UK manufacturing’, Political Quarterly, 60 (2).
31.
Holloway, J. (1987) ‘The red rose of Nissan’, Capital and Class, 32.
32.
Ichiyo, M. (1984) ‘Class struggle on the shopfloor — the Japanese case, 1945–84’Ampo, Japan Asia Quarterly Review, 16, 3.
33.
IDS (1984) ‘Craft flexibility’, IDS Study 322, London, Incomes Data Services Ltd.
34.
IDS (1985) ‘Improving productivity’, IDS Study 331, London, Incomes Data Services Ltd.
35.
IDS (1986) ‘Flexibility at work’IDS Study 360, London, Incomes Data Services Ltd.
36.
IDS (1988a) ‘Flexible working’IDS Study 407, London, Incomes Data Services Ltd.
37.
IDS (1988b) ‘Teamworking’IDS Study 419London, Incomes Data Services Ltd.
38.
Industrial Relations Journal, (1987) Special issue on Japanization, 19, 1.
39.
Jurgens, U., K. Dohse, T. Malsch (1988) ‘New production and employment concepts in West German car plants’ in S. Tolliday and J. Zeitlin (eds) The automobile industry and its workers, Oxford, Polity Press.
40.
Jurgens, U. (1989) ‘The transfer of Japanese management concepts in the international automobile industry’ in S. Wood (ed.) The Transformation of Work?, London, Unwin Hyman.
41.
Kamata, S. (1980) Japan in the Passing Lane, London, Counterpoint.
42.
Katz, H., C. Sabel (1985) ‘Industrial relations and industrial adjustment in the car industry’, Industrial relations, 24, 3.
43.
Kern, H., M. Schumann (1984) Das ende der Arbeitsteilung?, Munich, CH Beck.
44.
Kern, H., M. Schumann (1987) ‘Limits of the division of labour: new production concepts in West German industry’, Economic and Industrial Democracy, 8.
45.
Kern, H., M. Schumann (1989) ‘New concepts of production in German plants’ in P. Katzenstein (ed.) Industry and Politics in West Germany: Towards the Third Republic, Ithaca, NY, Cornell University Press.
46.
Kochan, T., H. Katz, R. McKersie (1986) The transformation of American industrial relations, New York, Basic Books.
47.
Lane, C. (1988) ‘Industrial change in Europe: the pursuit of flexible specialisation in Britain and West Germany’, Work, Employment and Society, 2, 2.
48.
Lindholm, R., J-P Norstedt (1975) The Volvo Report, Stockholm, SAF (Swedish Employers Confederation).
49.
Malsch, T., K. Dohse, U. Jurgens (1984) Industrial robots in the automobile industry. A leap toward ‘automated fordism’? IIVG/dp 84–222 Berlin, Wissenscahftszentrum.
50.
Marglin, S. (1974) ‘What do bosses do?’ in A. Gorz (ed.) The Division of Labour, Brighton, Harvester.
51.
Marx, K. (1974) Capital, Vol 1, London, Lawrence and Wishart.
52.
Moore, J. (1983) Japanese workers and the struggle for power 1945–47, Madison, Wi, University of Wisconsin Press.
53.
Murray, R. (1985) ‘Bennetton Britain’, Marxism Today, November.
54.
Murray, R. (1988) ‘Life after Henry (Ford)’, Marxism Today, October.
55.
Negri, A. (1989) Revolution Retrieved: Selected Writings, London, Red Notes.
56.
OECD (1988) Economic survey: United Kingdom, Paris, OECD.
57.
Oliver, N., B. Wilkinson (1988) The Japanization of British Industry, Oxford, Basil Blackwell.
58.
Piore, M., C. Sabel (1984) The second industrial divide, New York: Basic Books.
59.
Pollert, A. (1988) ‘Dismantling flexibility’Capital and Class, 34.
60.
Robertson, D., J. Wareham (1987) Technological change in the auto industry: CAW technology project, Willowdale, Ontario, Canadian Auto Workers Union.
61.
Sabel, C. (1982) Work and politics, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
62.
Sayer, A. (1985) ‘New developments in manufacturing: the just in time system’, Capital and Class, 30.
63.
Scarbrough, H. (1986) ‘The politics of technological change at British Leyland’ in O Jacobi et al. (eds) Technological Change, Rationalisation and Industrial Relations, Beckenham, Croom Helm.
64.
Scarbrough, H., P. Moran (1985) ‘How new tech won at Longbridge’ New Society, 7 February.
65.
Schonberger, R. (1982) Japanese manufacturing techniques: nine hidden lessons in simplicity, New York, Free Press.
66.
Shaiken, H., S. Herzenberg, S. Kuhn (1986) ‘The work process under more flexible production’, Industrial Relations, 25, 2.
67.
Sohn-Rethel, A. (1978) Intellectual and manual labour: a critique of epistemology, Atlantic Highlands, NJ, Humanities Press.
68.
Steel, W. (1988) ‘The development of management information systems for running machines at full potential’, Colliery Guardian, August.
69.
Taylor, F. (1947) Scientific management, New York, Harper.
70.
Thompson, E.P. (1967) ‘Time, work-discipline and industrial capitalism’, Past and Present, 38.
71.
Turnbull, P. (1987) ‘The limits to Japanisation - just in time, labour relations and the UK automotive industry’, New Technology, Work and Employment, 3, 1.
72.
Wainwright, H. (1987) ‘The friendly mask of flexibility’, New Statesman, 17 December.
73.
Wickens, P. (1987) The Road to Nissan, London, MacMillan.
74.
Wilkinson, B., N. Oliver (1989) ‘Power, control and Kanban’, Journal of Management Studies, 26, 1.
75.
Windolf, P. (1984) ‘Industrial robots in West German industry’, Politics and Society, 14, 4.
76.
Wolf, M. ‘Is there a British miracle’, Financial Times, 16.6.88.
