Nationalism: the instrumental passion

Abstract

Marxists and Communist parties have had difficulty understanding nationalism and dealing with nationalist movements. Neither they, nor Weberian theorists, have been able to understand the ‘passion’ engendered by nationalism—a passion which drives people to die for their nation.

In this review of two books on nationalism, one by a Weberian, the other within the Marxist tradition, Gavin Kitching identifies the beginnings of a materialist theory of consciousness which partially explains the power of nationalist passions.

The two books are: Imagined communities: reflections on the origin and spread of nationalism by Benedict Anderson (London, Verso, 1983) and Nations and nationalism by Ernest Gellner (Oxford, Basil Blackwell, 1983).

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

R. Meek , 1967, ‘The Rehabilitation of Sir James Steuart’, in his Economics and Ideology and Other Essays, London, Chapman and Hall.

‘Stepniak’ (Sergius Kravchinsky), 1888, The Russian Peasantry: Their Agrarian Conditions, Social Life and Religion, New York, Harper & Brothers.

Geoffrey Kay , 1975, Development and Underdevelopment: A Marxist Analysis, London, Macmillan.

Stanley Cavell , 1976, Must we Mean what we Say?, Chapter 2, Cambridge University Press.

Friedrich List , 1904, The National System of Political Economy, translated by Sampson Lloyd , London, Longman.