This article looks at two related labour market policies that have persisted and even proliferated across Europe both before and after the financial crisis: wage restraint and punitive workfare programmes. It asks why these policies, despite their weak empirical records, have been so durable. Moving beyond comparative-institutionalist explanations which emphasise institutional stickiness, it draws on Marxist and Kaleckian ideas around the concept of ‘class discipline’. It argues that under financialisation, the need for states to implement policies that discipline the working class is intensified, even if these policies do little to enable (and may even counteract) future stability. Wage restraint and punitive active labour market policies are two examples of such measures. Moreover, this disciplinary impetus has subverted and marginalised regulatory labour market institutions, rather than being embedded within them.
AgliettaM (2000) A Theory of Capitalist Regulation: The US Experience. London: Verso.
2.
AlesinaAPerottiR (1996) Income distribution, political instability, and investment. European Economic Review40(6): 1203–1228.
3.
AtkinsonABPikettyTSaezE (2011) Top incomes in the long run of history. Journal of Economic Literature49(1): 3–71.
4.
BaccaroLBenassiC (2014) Softening industrial relations institutions, hardening growth model: The transformation of the German political economy. Stato e Mercato34(3): 369–396.
5.
BaccaroLHowellC (2011) A common neoliberal trajectory: The transformation of industrial relations in advanced capitalism. Politics & Society39(4): 521–563.
6.
BergAOstryJZettelmeyerJ (2012) What makes growth sustained?Journal of Development Economics98(2): 149–166.
7.
BhaduriAMarglinS (1990) Unemployment and the real wage: The economic basis for contesting political ideologies. Cambridge Journal of Economics14(4): 375–393.
8.
BlankR (2002) Evaluating Welfare Reform in the United States. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.
9.
BoyerR (2015) Politics of financial crisis management. Paper presented at Society for the Advancement of Socio-Economics Conference, London, July 2015.
10.
BrinkmannUDörreKKrämer RöbenackSet al (2006) Prekäre Arbeit. Ursachen, Ausmaß, soziale Fogen, und subjektive Verarbeitungsformen unsicherer Beschäftigungsverhältnisse. Bonn: FES.
11.
CampbellJPedersenO (2014) The National Origins of Policy Ideas: Knowledge Regimes in the United States, France, Germany and Denmark. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
12.
CardDKluveJWeberA (2010) Active labour market policy evaluations: A meta-analysis. The Economic Journal120(548): F452–F477.
13.
CastelR (2003) From Manual Workers to Wage Laborers: Transformation of the Social Question. Piscataway, NJ: Transaction Publishers.
14.
CinganoF (2014) Trends in income inequality and its impact on economic growth. OECD Social, Employment and Migration Working Papers, No 163. Paris: OECD.
15.
ClarkeS (1977) Marxism, sociology and Poulantzas’s theory of the state. Capital & Class1(2): 1–31.
16.
CrouchCFarrellH (2004) Breaking the path of institutional development? Alternatives to the new determinism. Rationality and Society16(1): 5–43.
17.
DaguerreA (2014) New corporate elites and the erosion of the Keynesian social compact. Work, Employment and Society28(2): 323–334.
18.
DarcillonT (2015) How does finance affect labour market institutions? An empirical analysis in 16 OECD countries. Socio-Economic Review13(3): 477–504.
19.
De BrunhoffS (2015) Marx on Money. London: Verso.
20.
DoellgastV (2012) Disintegrating Democracy at Work: Labour Unions and the Future of Good Jobs in the Service Economy. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
21.
DoellgastVGreerI (2007) Vertical disintegration and the disorganization of German industrial relations. British Journal of Industrial Relations45(1): 55–76.
22.
DörreKScherschelKBoothMet al (2013) Bewährungsproben für die Unterschicht?Frankfurt: Campus Verlag.
23.
DwyerPEllisonN (2009) ‘We nicked stuff from all over the place’: Policy transfer or muddling through?Policy & Politics37(3): 389–407.
24.
EpsteinGA (2005) Introduction: Financialization and the world economy. In: EpsteinGA (ed.) Financialization and the World Economy. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp. 3–16.
25.
Esping-AndersenG (1990) The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism. Cambridge: Polity Press.
FichtnerJ (2013) Hedge funds: Agents of change for financialisation. Critical Perspectives on International Business9(4): 358–376.
29.
Fourcade-GourinchasMBabbS (2002) The rebirth of the liberal creed: Paths to neoliberalism in four countries. American Journal of Sociology108(3): 553–579.
30.
FroudJHaslamCJohalSet al (2000) Shareholder value and financialisation: Consultancy promises, management motives. Economy and Society29(1): 80–110.
31.
GalorOZeiraJ (1993) Income distribution and macroeconomics. The Review of Economic Studies60(1): 35–52.
32.
GodaTOnaranÖStockhammerE (2014) A case for redistribution? Income inequality and wealth concentration in the recent crisis. University of Greenwich Business School Working Paper, WERU 9 2014. London: University of Greenwich.
33.
GoughI (1975) State expenditure in advanced capitalism. New Left ReviewI/92, pp. 53–94.
34.
GreerI (2016) Welfare reform, precarity and the re-commodification of labour. Work, Employment and Society30: 162–173.
35.
GuschanskiAOnaranÖ (2016) Determinants of the wage share: A cross-country comparison using sectoral data. Greenwich Papers in Political Economy, University of Greenwich, No. 41, #GPERC41, London: University of Greenwich.
36.
HallP (1993) Policy paradigms, social learning, and the State: The case of economic policymaking in Britain. Comparative Politics25(3): 275–296.
37.
HallP (2014) Varieties of capitalism and the Euro crisis. West European Politics37(6): 1223–1243.
38.
HallPSoskiceD (2001) Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantage. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
39.
HarveyD (2013) A Companion to Marx’s Capital, vol. 2. London: Verso Books.
40.
HasselASchillerC (2010) Der Fall Hartz IV: Wie es zur Agenda 2010 kam und wie es weitergeht. Frankfurt: Campus Verlag.
41.
HassinkR (2005) How to unlock regional economies from path dependency? From learning region to learning cluster. European Planning Studies13(4): 521–535.
42.
HauptmeierMVidalM (2014) Comparative Political Economy of Work. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
43.
HeinEVogelL (2008) Distribution and growth reconsidered – Empirical results for six OECD countries. Cambridge Journal of Economics32: 479–511.
44.
HeyesJ (2011) Flexicurity, employment protection and the jobs crisis. Work, Employment and Society25(4): 642–657.
45.
HolstH (2014) ‘Commodifying institutions’: Vertical disintegration and institutional change in German labour relations. Work, Employment and Society28(1): 3–20.
46.
HolzerHStollM (2001) Employers and Welfare Recipients: The Effects of Welfare Reform in the Workplace. San Francisco: Public Policy Institute of California.
47.
International Labour Organization (ILO)/International Institute for Labour Studies (IILS) (2011) World of Work Report. Geneva: ILO/IILS.
48.
IngoldJStuartM (2014) The demand-side of active labour market policies: A regional study of employer engagement in the Work Programme. Journal of Social Policy44(3): 443–462.
49.
JayadevA (2007) Capital account openness and the labour share of income. Cambridge Journal of Economics31(3): 423–443.
50.
KaleckiM (1943) Political aspects of full employment. Political Quarterly4: 322–331.
51.
KayA (2005) A critique of the use of path dependency in policy studies. Public Administration83(1): 553–571.
52.
KnuthM (2011) Widersprüchliche Dynamiken im deutschen Arbeitsmarkt. Wsi-Mitteilungen64(11): 580–587.
53.
KochSSpiesCStephanGet al (2011) Kurz vor der Reform: Arbeitsmarktinstrumente auf dem Prüfstand. Iab-Kurzbericht 11/2011. Available at: http://doku.iab.de/kurzber/2011/kb1111.pdf
54.
KristalT (2010) Good times, bad times: Postwar labor’s share of national income in capitalist democracies. American Sociological Review75(5): 729–763.
55.
LapavitsasC (2013) Profiting without Producing: How Finance Exploits Us All. London: Verso.
56.
LarsenCVesanP (2012) Why public employment services always fail: Double-sided asymmetric information and the placement of low-skill workers in six European countries. Public Administration90(2): 466–479.
57.
LazonickWO’SullivanM (2000) Maximising shareholder value: A new ideology for corporate governance. Economy and Society29(1): 13–35.
58.
LethbridgeJGreerIKretsosLet al (2014) Industrial Relations in Central Public Administration: Recent Trends and Features. Dublin: Eurofound.
59.
McGurkPMeredithR (2015) Local enterprise partnerships: Putting employers in the driving seat – to nowhere. Paper presented at the SASE conference, 2015. London: London School of Economics: 2-4 July 2015.
60.
MartinC (2004) Reinventing welfare regimes: Employers and the implementation of active social policy. World Politics57(01): 39–69.
61.
MarxK (1981) Capital, vol. III. London: Penguin Books.
62.
MilibandR (1969) The State in Capitalist Society. London: The Camelot Press.
63.
MoreiraALodemelI (2014) Activation or Workfare? Governance and Neo-liberal Convergence. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
64.
MudgeS (2008) What is neo-liberalism?Socio-Economic Review6(4): 703–731.
NickellS (1997) Unemployment and labor market rigidities: Europe versus North America. The Journal of Economic Perspectives11: 55–74.
67.
OffeC (1975) The theory of the capitalist state and the problem of policy formation. In: LindbergLAlfordRCrouchCet al(eds) Stress and Contradiction in Modern Capitalism: Public Policy and the Theory of the State. Lexington: Lexington Books, pp. 125–144.
68.
OnaranÖ (2009) Wage share, globalization and crisis: The case of the manufacturing industry in Korea, Mexico and Turkey. International Review of Applied Economics23(2): 113–134.
69.
OnaranÖ (2014) State Intervention for Wage-Led Development. Centre for Labour and Social Studies Policy Paper. London: Centre for Labour and Social Studies.
70.
OnaranÖBöschV (2014) The effect of globalization on the distribution of taxes and social expenditures in Europe: Do welfare state regimes matter?Environment and Planning A46(2): 373–397.
71.
OnaranÖGalanisG (2014) Income distribution and growth: A global model. Environment and Planning A46(10): 2489–2513.
72.
OnaranÖObstT (2016) Wage-led growth in the EU15 member states: The effects of income distribution on growth, investment, trade balance and inflation. Cambridge Journal of Economics40: 1517–1551.
73.
OvendenK (2015) Syriza: Inside the Labyrinth. London: Pluto Press.
74.
PeckJ (2002) Political economies of scale: Fast policy, interscalar relations, and neoliberal workfare. Economic Geography78(3): 331–360.
75.
PerssonTTabelliniG (1994) Representative democracy and capital taxation. Journal of Public Economics55(1): 53–70.
76.
PetersBGuyJKingD (2005) The politics of path dependency: Political conflict in historical institutionalism. Journal of Politics67(4): 1275–1300.
77.
PiersonP (2000) Increasing returns, path dependence, and the study of politics. American Political Science Review94(2): 251–267.
78.
PikettyT (2014) Capital in the Twenty-first Century. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press.
79.
PlehweDWalpenBNeunhofferG (2006) Introduction: Reconsidering neoliberal hegemony. In: PlehweDWalpenBNeunhofferG (eds) Neoliberal Hegemony: A Global Critique. London: Routledge, pp. 1–25.
80.
ReesJWhitworthACarterE (2014) Support for all in the UK Work Programme? Differential payments, same old problem. Social Policy & Administration48(2): 221–239.
81.
RodriguezFJayadevA (2010) The declining labor share of income. Journal of Globalization and Development3(2): 1–18.
82.
RossmanP (2009) Financialization and casualization of labour: Building a trade union and regulatory response. Paper presented at the Global Labour University Conference, Mumbai, India, February 2009.
83.
ScherschelKKrennMStreckeisenP (eds) (2012) Neue Prekarität: die Folgen aktivierender Arbeitsmarktpolitik-europäische Länder im Vergleich. Frankfurt: Campus Verlag.
84.
SchmidG (2008) Full Employment in Europe: Managing Labour Market Transitions and Risks. London: Edward Elgar Publishing.
85.
SinclairT (1994a) Between state and market: Hegemony and institutions of collective action under conditions of international capital mobility. Policy Sciences27(4): 447–466.
86.
SinclairT (1994b) Passing judgement: Credit ratings processes as regulatory mechanisms of governance in the emerging world order. Review of International Political Economy1(1): 133–159.
87.
SinclairT (2000) Reinventing authority: Embedded knowledge networks and the new global finance. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy18(4): 487–502.
88.
SkocpolT (1980) Political response to capitalist crisis: Neo-Marxist theories of the state and the case of the New Deal. Politics & Society10(2): 155–200.
89.
SossJSchramS (2007) A public transformed? Welfare reform as policy feedback. American Political Science Review101(01): 111–127.
90.
StiglitzJE (2012) The Price of Inequality. London: Penguin Books.
91.
StockhammerE (2013) Why have wage shares fallen? Conditions of Work and Employment Series No. 35. Geneva: ILO.
92.
StockhammerEOnaranÖEdererS (2009) Functional income distribution and aggregate demand in the Euro area. Cambridge Journal of Economics33(1): 139–159.
93.
StockhammerEOnaranÖ (2012) Rethinking wage policy in the face of the Euro crisis: Implications of the wage-led demand regime. International Review of Applied Economies26(2): 191–203.
94.
SydowJSchreyöggGKochJ (2009) Organizational path dependence: Opening the black box. Academy of Management Review34(4): 689–709.
95.
ThelenK (1999) Historical institutionalism in comparative politics. Annual Review of Political Science2(1): 369–404.
96.
ThompsonP (2003) Disconnected capitalism: Or, why employers can’t keep their side of the bargain. Work, Employment and Society27(3): 472–488.
97.
Van der KlaauwBVan OursJ (2013) Carrot and stick: How re-employment bonuses and benefit sanctions affect exit rates from welfare. Journal of Applied Econometrics28(2): 275–296.
98.
VennD (2012) Eligibility criteria for unemployment benefits. OECD Working Paper. Paris: OECD.
99.
VidalM (2013) PostFordism as a dysfunctional accumulation regime: A comparative analysis of the USA, the UK and Germany. Work, Employment and Society27(3): 451–471.
100.
WigganJ (2015) Reading active labour market policy politically: An autonomist analysis of Britain’s Work Programme and Mandatory Work Activity. Critical Social Policy35: 369–392.
