Between 6 and 10 August 2011, acts of violence and civil disobedience occurred in 66 locations across London and other cities in England. Initial responses from politicians and the press sought to explain why the riots were happening and what responses were necessary. This paper shows how the depoliticised actions of rioters were redefined as a politicised problem, symbolic of a sick society that could be cured by Conservative social policy. This paper explores the nuanced discursive and paradoxical mechanisms of right-wing newspapers. I argue that ideological consistencies operating beyond the foreground and immediacy of individual texts override the appearance of discursive contradiction across longitudinal contexts.
AngelH (2012) Governmental responses to the riots. Criminal Justice Matters87(1): 24–5.
2.
BallRDruryJ (2012) Representing the riots: The (mis)use of statistics to sustain ideological explanation. Radical Statistics106: 4–21.
3.
BatmanghelidjhC (2011) Camila Batmanghelidjh: Caring costs – but so do riots. These rioters feel they don’t actually belong to the community. For years, they’ve felt cut adrift from society. The Independent, 9August.
4.
BenyonJ (2012) England’s urban disorder: The 2011 riots. Political InsightApril2012: 12–20.
5.
BracchiP (2001) A star pupil from £1m home. How did she end up in the dock?Daily Mail12August.
6.
BridgesL (2012) Four days in August: The UK riots. Race & Class54(1): 1–12
7.
CarragherJ (2011) Rioting kids need help to change. Daily Mirror11August.
Crick. (2011) Rabble without a cause. The Sun9August.
10.
Daily Mail (2011) The anarchy spreads. 9August.
11.
Daily Mail (2011) Daily Mail comment: No excuses for this wanton criminality. 9August.
12.
Daily Mail (2011) A broken society that needs a strong leader. 11August.
13.
Daily Mail (2011) You’re a disgrace to your country. 12August.
14.
Daily Mail (2011) Bankers, looters and the politics of envy. 12August.
15.
Daily Mirror (2011) Yob rule. 9August.
16.
Daily Star (2011) Anarchy in the UK. 9August.
17.
Daily Telegraph (2011) Rule of the mob. 9August.
18.
Daily Telegraph (2011) The real community must be protected. 9August.
19.
Daily Telegraph (2011) Back on the streets. 12August.
20.
CavanaghADennisA (2012) Framing the riots. Capital & Class36: 375–81.
21.
JohnsL (2011) Apologists for these thugs should hang their heads in shame. Daily Mail, 9August.
22.
FaircloughN (1995) Critical Discourse Analysis: The Critical Study of Language. Essex: Longman.
23.
FaircloughN (2003) Analysing Discourse: Textual Analysis for Social ResearchLondon: Routledge.
24.
FowlerR (1991) Language in the News: Discourse and Ideology in the Press. London: Routledge.
25.
FuchsC (2012) Social Media, riots and revolutions. Capital & Class36: 383–91.
26.
GilliganA (2011) Our sick society; As Cameron condemns riots, suspected looters in court include a boy of 11, a grammar school girl, and a teaching assistant: Swift justice for ‘sick society’. Daily Telegraph11August.
27.
GreenwoodC (2011) Postman, school mentor, charity worker, lifeguard, boy of 11. the unlikely rioters hauled to court. Daily Mail11August.
28.
Guardian (2011) The battle for London. 9August.
29.
Independent (2011) Mob rule. 9August.
30.
JeffersonT (2012) Policing the riots: From Bristol and Brixton to Tottenham, via Toxteth.
31.
i-newspaper (2011) Out of control: Riots reach crisis point. 9August.
32.
KavanaghT (2011) Blame politics, not our brave police: Anarchy in the UK two views of riots that shame nation. The Sun10August.
33.
KirkupJWhiteheadT (2011) Back on the streets: Despite tough action promised by Cameron, child looters are freed by the courts… and they even keep their anonymity. Sentences dismay police chiefs and MPs. Daily Telegraph12August.
34.
KirkupJPorterA (2011) We will make rioters suffer, say MPs: Emergency debate. Daily Telegraph11August.
35.
KelseyD (2012) Remembering to forget: Supporting and opposing the war on terror through the myth of the blitz spirit after the July 7th bombings. Critical Approaches to Discourse Analysis across Disciplines6(1): 23–37.
36.
KelseyD (2015) Media, Myth and Terrorism. London: Palgrave.
37.
LagrangeH (2012) Youth unrest and riots in France and the UK. Criminal Justice Matters. 87(1): 32–3.
38.
LeaJHallsworthS (2012) Understanding the riots. Criminal Justice Matters87(1): 30–1.
39.
MalcolmD (2012) The origins of penal populism. Criminal Justice Matters87(1): 44–5.
40.
MayrA (Ed.) (2008) Language and Power: An Introduction to Institutional Discourse. London: Continuum International.
41.
LittlejohnR (2011) Red sky at night: Tottenham’s alight. Daily Mail, 9August.
42.
MilburnK (2012) The August riots, shock and the prohibition of thought. Capital & Class36: 401–09.
43.
NarainJ (2011) Shameless! Jailing of a TV lookalike. Daily Mail, 12August.
44.
PalmerS (2012) ‘Dutty Babylon’: Policing black communities and the politics of resistance. Criminal Justice Matters87(1): 26–7.
45.
PorterAKirkupJ (2011) We will make rioters suffer, says MP. Daily Telegraph, 11August.
46.
ReicherSStottC (2011) Mad mobs and Englishmen? Myths and realities of the 2011 riots. Guardian, 18November. Online at < http://www.guardian.co.uk>, accessed 7 September 2012.
47.
RichardsonJ (2007) Analysing Newspapers: An Approach from Critical Discourse Analysis. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
48.
RiddellM (2011) The underclass is lashing out at a Britain that has turned its back: Ignored by Left and Right, the rioters were inevitable products of a crumbling nation. Daily Telegraph9August.
49.
Sabey. (2011) Lifeguard, postman, hairdresser, teacher, millionaire’s daughter, chef and schoolboy 11. The Sun, 11August.
50.
ShipmanT (2011) Left wing cynics blame the Tory cuts for the mayhem. Daily Mail, 9August.
51.
SimpsonP (1993) Language, Ideology and Point of View. London: Routledge.
52.
SlackJ (2011) Rudderless met crippled by liberalism. Daily Mail.
53.
SmithW (2011) Tough sentences? Forget it. These teen yobs will be treated as if they are the victims. Daily Mail, 12August.
54.
Sun (2011) Be decisive. 9August.
55.
Sun (2011) New law will evict riot thugs. 11August.
Times (2011) Mobs rule as police surrender streets. 9August.
62.
TaylorP (2012) The Just Do It riots: A critical interpretation of the media’s violence. Capital & Class36: 393–9.
63.
van DijkT (1998) Opinions and ideologies in the press. In BellAGarrettP (eds.) Approaches to Media Discourse. West Sussex: Wiley-Blackwell
64.
van DijkT (2001) Discourse, ideology and context. Folia Linguistica35(1-2): 11–40.
65.
WaddingtonD (2012a) The law of moments: Understanding the flashpoint that ignited the riots. Criminal Justice Matters87(1): 6–7.
66.
WaddingtonPAJ (2012b) Explaining the riots. Criminal Justice Matters87(1): 10–11.
67.
WatertonSSesayK (2012): Out of touch: A youth perspective. Criminal Justice Matters87(1): 28–9
68.
WhiteheadTWattH (2011) Girl who has it all is accused of theft. Daily Telegraph, 11August.
69.
WilsonG (2011) PM vow: I will cure sick UK. Sun, 11August.
70.
WodakR (2001) What CDA is about: A summary of its history, important concepts and its developments. In WodakRMeyerM (eds.) Methods of Critical Discourse Analysis. London: Sage.
71.
YoungeG (2011) These riots were political. They were looting, not shoplifting. Guardian, 14August2011. Online at <www.guardian.co.uk>, accessed 9 September 2012.
72.
WodakRde CilliaRReisiglMLiebhartK (1999) The Discursive Construction of National Identity. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
73.
WodakR (2008) Introduction: Discourse studies: Important concepts and terms. In WodakRKrzyzanowskiM (eds.) Qualitative Discourse Analysis in the Social Sciences. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
