This paper offers a new ‘position’ in the distinction between productive and unproductive labour, using two opposing approaches to the matter. Shaikh and Tonak ground their argument on the concept of productive labour in general, and support the need for an ‘extensive’ classification of unproductive labour. In Laibman's view, on the other hand, the distinction should be abandoned. In this paper, I argue that both approaches are founded on the same use-value criterion. This non-capitalist criterion is inappropriate for the analysis. In contrast, I offer a distinction based on specifically capitalist criteria; the relevance of the analysis is placed on the production of value rather than use value.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Cámara, Sergio (2002) ‘La rentabilidad del capital y sus componentes: El caso de España (1964-2000)’ in Economía: Teoría y Práctica, no. 17, pp. 45–74.
2.
Cámara, Sergio (2003) ‘Tendencias de la rentabilidad y de la acumulación de capital en España, 1954-2001’, Ph.D. thesis, Universidad Complutense de Madrid.
3.
Carchedi, Guglielmo (1991) Frontiers of Political Economy (Verso).
4.
Gouverneur, Jacques (1990) ‘Productive labour, price/value ratio and the rate of surplus value: Theoretical viewpoints and empirical evidence’ in Cambridge Journal of Economics, vol. 14, no. 1, pp. 1–27.
5.
Guerrero, Diego (1989) ‘Acumulación de capital, distribución de la renta y crisis de rentabilidad en España (1954-1987)’, Ph. D. thesis, Universidad Complutense de Madrid.
6.
Guerrero, Diego (1997) ‘Unproductive labour’, unpublished paper, New School for Social Research.
7.
Houston, David (1997) ‘Productive-unproductive labour: Rest in peace’ in Review of Radical Political Economics, vol. 29, no. 1, pp. 131–139.
8.
Laibman, David (1992) Value, Technical Change and Crisis: Explorations in Marxist Economic Theory (M. E. Sharpe).
9.
Laibman, David (1999) ‘Productive and unproductive labour: A comment’ in Review of Radical Political Economics, vol. 31, no. 2, pp. 61–73.
10.
Leadbeater, David (1985) ‘The consistency of Marx's categories of productive and unproductive labour’ in History of Political Economy, vol. 17, no. 4, pp. 591–618.
11.
Marx, Karl (1969 [1861]-3) Theories of Surplus Value, Part I (Lawrence and Wishart).
12.
Marx, Karl (1864) Capítulo VI [inédito]: Resultados Del Proceso Inmediato de Producción (Siglo XXI editores), English translation taken from <www.marxist.org> [Ch. VI]
13.
Marx, Karl (1906 [1867]) Capital, Volume I: The Process of Capitalist Production (Charles H. Kerr & Company).
14.
Marx, Karl (1909 [1885]) Capital, Volume II: The Process of Capitalist Circulation (Charles H. Kerr & Company).
15.
Mohun, Simon (1996) ‘Productive and unproductive labour in the labour theory of value’ in Review of Radical Political Economics, vol. 28, no. 4, pp. 30–54.
16.
Mohun, Simon (2000) ‘Productive and unproductive labour in the US economy: Does the distinction matter? A reply to Houston and Laibman’, paper presented to the mini-conference of the International Working Group on Value Theory (IWGVT), Washington, 24-26 March 2000.
17.
Moseley, Fred (1991) The Falling Rate of Profit in the Post-War United States Economy (Macmillan Press).
18.
Savran, Sungur & Ahmet Tonak (1999) ‘Productive and unproductive labour: An attempt at clarification and classification’ in Capital & Class, no. 68, Summer, pp. 113–152.
19.
Shaikh, Anwar & Ahmet Tonak (1994) Measuring the Wealth of Nations: The Political Economy of National Accounts (Cambridge University Press).
