This article provides an ontological as well as methodological evaluation of recent progress in terrain analysis. It focuses on six topographic factors, or existences, that are important in characterizing the biophysical functions of topography: elevation, surface shape, topographic position, topographic context, spatial scale, and landform object. Terrain analysis approaches are assessed according to what they really deal with, as well as how they work. Important trends are consequently identified, in which spatial scale plays critical but non-uniform roles. An index-based approach to the compound function of multiple topographic existences is recognized as successful in modelling surface/subsurface moisture and mass movement potential, but not mountain temperature. A classification scheme categorises defined landforms in the literature according to the way they exist in human knowledge rather than their morphological properties and derivation methods. Five categories are outlined: bona fide objects, prototypical objects, fiat objects, landform classes, and multiscale objects. Peak object delineation is lastly assessed as an example demonstrating some of the recent trends in terrain analysis. Representations of higher-scale landscape context are identified to have great potential of linking vastly different spatial scales, as well as bridging field- versus object-based treatments of the terrain surface.
Albani, M. , Klinkenberg, B. , Andison, D.W. and Kimmins, J.P.2004: The choice of window size in approximating topographic surfaces from digital elevation models . International Journal of Geographic Information Science18, 577—93 .
2.
Armstrong, R.N. and Martz, L.W.2003: Topographic parameterization in continental hydrology: A study in scale . Hydrological Processes17, 3763—81 .
3.
Band, L.E.1986: Topographic partition of watersheds with digital elevation models . Water Resources Research22, 15—24 .
4.
Band, L.E. , Patterson, P. , Nemani, R. and Running, S.1993: Forest ecosystem processes at the watershed scale: incorporating hillslope hydrology . Agriculture, Forestry and Meteorology63, 93—126 .
5.
Band, L.E. , Tague, C. , Brun, S.E. , Tenenbaum, D.E. and Fernandes, R.A.2000: Modelling watersheds as spatial object hierarchies: structure and dynamics . Transactions in GIS4, 181—96 .
6.
Beven, K.J. and Kirkby, M.J.1979: A physically based variable contributing area model of basin hydrology. Hydrology ScienceBulletin24, 43—69 .
7.
Bian, L.1997: Multiscale nature of spatial data in scaling up environmental models. In Quattrochi, D.A. and Goodchild, M.F. , editors, Scale in remote sensing and GIS, New York: Lewis Publishers , 13—26.
8.
Blaszczynski, J.S.1997: Landform characterization with geographic information systems . Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sensing63, 183—91 .
9.
Bolstad, P.V. and Stowe, T.1994: An evaluation of DEM accuracy: elevation, slope and aspect . Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sensing23, 387—95 .
10.
Bolstad, P.V. , Swank, W. and Vose, J.1998: Predicting Southern Appalachian overstay vegetation with digital terrain data . Landscape Ecology13, 271—83 .
11.
Brasington, J. and Richards, K.1998: Interactions between model predictions, parameters and DTM scales for TOPMODEL . Computers and Geosciences24, 299—314 .
12.
Burrough, P.A. and McDonnell, R.A.1998: Principles of Geographical Information Systems. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
13.
Burrough, P.A. , Wilson, J.P. , van Gaans, P.F.M. and Hansen, A.J.2001: Fuzzy k-means classification of digital elevation models as an aid to forest mapping in the Greater Yellowstone Area, USA. LandscapeEcology16, 523—46 .
14.
Carrara, A. , Cardinali, M. , Detti, R. , Guzzetti, F. , Pasqui, V. and Reichenbach, P.1991: GIS techniques and statistical models in evaluating landslide hazard . Earth Surface Processes and Landforms16, 427—45 .
15.
Chang, K. and Tsai, B.1991: The effect of DEM resolution on slope and aspect mapping . Cartography and Geographic Information Systems18, 69—77 .
16.
Chaplot, V. and Walter, C.2003: Subsurface topography to enhance the prediction of the spatial distribution of soil wetness . Hydrological Processes17, 2567—80 .
17.
Chuvieco, E.2003: Wildland fire danger estimation and mapping: the role of remote sensing data. Singapore: World Scientific Publishing .
18.
Cochrane, T.A. and Flanagan, D.C.1999: Assessing water erosion in small watersheds using WEPP with GIS and digital elevation models . Journal of Soil and Water Conservation54, 678—85 .
19.
Cova, T.J. and Goodchild, M.F.2002: Extending geographical representation to include fields of spatial objects. International Journal of GeographicalInformation Science16, 509—32 .
20.
Dehn, M. , Gärtner, H. and Dikau, R.2001: Principles of semantic modeling of landform structures . Computers & Geosciences27, 1005—10 .
21.
Deng, Y.X. and Wilson, J.P.2007: Multi-scale delineation of mountain peaks as fuzzy spatial objects . International Journal of Geographical Information Science, in press.
22.
Deng, Y.X. , Chen, X.F. , Chuvieco, E. , Warner, T.A. and Wilson, J.P.2007a: Multi-scale linkages between topographic attributes and vegetation indices in a mountainous landscape . Remote Sensing of Environment, in press.
23.
Deng, Y.X. , Wilson, J.P. and Bauer, B.O.2007b: DEM resolution dependencies of terrain attributes across a landscape . International Journal of Geographic Information Science21, 187—213 .
24.
Deng, Y.X. , Wilson, J.P. and Sheng, J.2006: Effects of variable attribute weights on landform classification . Earth Surface Processes and Landforms31, 1452—62 .
25.
Desmet, P.J.J. and Govers, G.1996: Comparison of routing algorithms for digital elevation models and their implications for predicting ephemeral gullies . International Journal of Geographical Information Systems10, 311—31 .
26.
Dikau, R.1989: The application of a digital relief model to landform analysis in geomorphology. In Raper, J. , editor, Three dimensional applications in geographic information systems , London: Taylor and Francis , 51—77.
27.
Dubayah, R.1992: Estimating net solar radiation using Landsat Thematic Mapper and digital elevation data . Water Resources Research28, 2469—84 .
28.
Dubayah, R. and Rich, P.M.1995: Topographic solar radiation models for GIS. International Journal of GeographicalInformation Science9, 405—19 .
29.
Dymond, J.R. , Derose, R.C. and Harmsworth, G.R.1995: Automated mapping of land components from digital elevation data . Earth Surface Processes and Landforms20, 131—37 .
30.
Evans, I.S.1972: General geomorphometry, derivatives of altitude, and descriptive statistics. In Chorley, R.J. , editor, Spatial analysis in geomorphology, London: Methuen , 17—90.
31.
— 2003: Scale-specific landforms and aspects of the land surface . In Evans, I.S. , Dikau, R. , Tokunaga, E. , Ohmori, H. and Hirano, M. , editors, Concepts and modelling in geomorphology: international perspectives, Tokyo: Terrapub , 61—84.
32.
Fisher, P.F.1993: Algorithm and implementation uncertainty in viewshed analysis . International Journal of Geographical Information Systems7, 331—47 .
33.
— 2000: Sorites paradox and vague geographies . Fuzzy Sets and Systems113, 7—18 .
34.
Fisher, P.F. , Cheng, T. and Wood, J.2007: Higher order vagueness in geographical information: Empirical geographical population of type n fuzzy sets . Geoinformatica , DOI: 10.1007/s10707-006-0009-5.
35.
Fisher, P.F. , Wood, J. and Cheng, C.2004: Where is Helvellyn? Fuzziness of multi-scale landscape morphology . Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers NS 29, 106—28 .
36.
— 2005: Fuzziness and ambiguity in multi-scale analysis of landscape morphometry. In Petry, F.E. , Robinson, V.B. , and Cobb, M.A. , editors, Fuzzy modelling with spatial information for geographic problems, New York: Springer , 209—32.
37.
Flood, M.2001: Laser altimetry: from science to commercial LIDAR mapping . Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sensing67, 1209—18 .
38.
Florinsky, I.V.1998a: Combined analysis of digital terrain models and remotely sensed data in landscape investigations . Progress in Physical Geography22, 33—60 .
39.
— 1998b: Accuracy of local topographic variables derived form digital elevation models . International Journal of Geographic Information Science12, 47—61 .
40.
Florinsky, I.V. and Kuryakova, G.A.2000: Determination of grid size for digital terrain modelling in landscape investigations: exemplified by soil moisture distribution at a micro-scale. International Journal of GeographicalInformation Science14, 815—32 .
41.
Franklin, J.1995: Predictive vegetation mapping: geographic modelling of biospatial patterns in relation to environmental gradients . Progress in Physical Geography19, 474—99 .
42.
Franklin, J. , McCullough, P. and Gray, C.2000: Terrain variables used for predictive mapping of vegetation communities in Southern California. In Wilson, J.P. and Gallant, J.C. , editors, Terrain analysis: principles and applications, New York : Wiley , 331—54.
43.
Gallant, J.C. and Dowling, T.I.2003: A multiresolution index of valley bottom flatness for mapping depositional areas . Water Resources Research39, 1347—59 .
44.
Gandolfi, C. and Bischetti, G.B.1997: Influence of the drainage network identification method on geomorphological properties and hydrological response . Hydrological Processes11, 353—75 .
45.
Garbrecht, J. and Martz, L.1994: Grid size dependency of parameters extracted from digital elevation models . Computers and Geosciences20, 85—87 .
46.
Geiger, R.1965: The climate near the ground. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
47.
Giles, P.T. and Franklin, S.E.1998: An automated approach to the classification of the slope units using digital data . Geomorphology21, 251—64 .
48.
Goodchild, M.F. and Mark, D.M.1987: The fractal nature of geographic phenomena . Annals of Association of American Geographers77, 265—78 .
49.
Gorsevski, P.V. , Gessler, P.E. and Jankowski, P.2003: Integrating a fuzzy k-means classification and a Bayesian approach for spatial prediction of landslide hazard . Journal of Geographical Systems5, 223—51 .
50.
Graff, L.H. and Usery, E.L.1993: Automated classification of generic terrain features in digital elevation models . Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sensing59, 1409—17 .
51.
Graham, S.T. , Famiglietti, J.S. and Maidment, D.R.1999: Five minute, 1/2°, and 1° data sets of continental watersheds and river networks for use in regional and global hydrologic and climate system modelling studies . Water Resources Research35, 583—87 .
52.
Hill, J.M. , Graham, L.A. and Herry, R.J.2000: Wide-area topographic mapping and applications using Airborne Light Detection and Ranging (LIDAR) technology . Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sensing66, 901—906 .
53.
Hunter, G.J. and Goodchild, M.F.1997: Modelling the uncertainty of slope and aspect estimates derived from spatial databases . Geographical Analysis29, 35—49 .
54.
Hutchinson, M.F.1995: Interpolating mean rainfall using thin plate smoothing splines . International Journal of Geographical Information Systems9, 385—404 .
55.
— 2007: Adding the Z Dimension. In Wilson, J.P. and Fotheringham, A.S. , editors, Handbook of geographic information science, Oxford: Blackwell , 144—68.
56.
Irvin, B.J. , Ventura, S.J. and Slater, B.K.1997: Fuzzy and isodata classification of landform elements from digital terrain data in Pleasant Valley, Wisconsin . Geoderma77, 137—54 .
57.
Jones, K.H.1998: A comparison of algorithms used to compute hill slope as a property of the DEM . Computers and Geosciences24, 315—23 .
58.
Kheir, R.B. , Wilson, J.P. and Deng, Y.X.2007: Use of terrain variables for mapping gully erosion susceptibility in Lebanon . Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, DOI: 10.1002/esp.1501.
59.
Lindsay, J.B.2005: The terrain analysis system: a tool for hydro-geomorphic applications . Hydrological Processes19, 1123—30 .
60.
Lookingbill, T.R. and Urban, D.L.2003: Spatial estimation of air temperature differences for landscape-scale studies in montane environments. Agricultural and ForestMeteorology114, 141—51 .
61.
Lucieer, A. and Stein, A.2005: Texture-based landform segmentation of LiDAR imagery . International Journal of Applied Earth Observation and Geoinformation6, 261—70 .
62.
Mackay, D.S. and Band, L.E.1998: Extraction and representation of nested catchment areas from digital elevation models in lake-dominant topography . Water Resources Research34, 897—901 .
63.
MacMillan, R.A. , Jones, R.K. and McNabb, D.H.2004: Defining a hierarchy of spatial entities for environmental analysis and modelling using digital elevation models (DEMs) . Computers, Environment and Urban Systems28, 175—200 .
64.
MacMillan, R.A. , Pettapiece, W.W. , Nolan, S.C. and Goddard, T.W.2000: A generic procedure for automatically segmenting landforms into landform elements using DEMs, heuristic rules and fuzzy logic. Fuzzy Sets andSystems113, 81—109 .
65.
Mark, D.M. and Aronson, P.B.1984: Scale-dependent fractal dimensions of topographic surfaces: an empirical investigation, with applications in geomorphology and computer mapping. MathematicalGeology16, 671—83 .
66.
Mark, D.M. and Smith, B.2004: A science of topography: from qualitative ontology to digital representations. In Bishop, M.P. and Shroder, J.F. , editors, Geographic information science and mountain geomorphology, Chichester : Springer-Praxis , 75—100.
67.
Marks, K. and Bates, P.2000: Integration of highresolution topographic data with floodplain flow models . Hydrological Processes14, 2109—22 .
68.
McClean, C.J. and Evans, I.S.2000: Apparent fractal dimensions from continental scale digital elevation models using variogram methods . Transactions in GIS4, 361—78 .
69.
McCune, B. and Keon, D.2002: Equations for potential annual direct incident radiation and heat load . Journal of Vegetation Science13, 603—606 .
70.
McCutchan, M.H. and Fox, D.G.1986: Effects of elevation and aspect on wind, temperature and humidity . Journal of Climate and Applied Meteorology25, 1996—2013 .
71.
McKenney, D.W. , Mackey, B.G. and Zavitz, B.L.1999: Calibration and sensitivity analysis of a spatiallydistributed solar radiation model. International Journal of GeographicalInformation Science13, 49—65 .
72.
Menduni, G. and Riboni, V.2000: A physically based catchment partitioning method for hydrological analysis . Hydrological Processes14, 1943—62 .
73.
Mitasova, H.L. , Hofierka, J. , Zlocha, M. and Iverson, L.R.1996: Modelling topographic potential for erosion and deposition using GIS . International Journal of Geographical Information Systems10, 629—41 .
74.
Montgomery, D.R. and Dietrich, W.E.1994: A physically based model for the topographic control on shallow landsliding . Water Resources Research30, 1153—71 .
75.
Moore, I.D.1992: SRAD: direct, diffuse, reflected short wave radiation, and the effects of topographic shading. Terrain Analysis Programs for Environmental Sciences (TAPES) Radiation Program Documentation. Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies , Australia National University, Canberra .
76.
Moore, I.D. and Wilson, J.P.1992: Length-slope factors for the revised universal soil loss equation: simplified method of estimation . Journal of Soil and Water Conservation47, 423—28 .
77.
Moore, I.D. , Gessler, P.E. , Nielsen, G.A. and Peterson, G.A.1993a: Soil attribute prediction using terrain analysis . Soil Science Society of America Journal57, 443—52 .
78.
Moore, I.D. , Grayson, R.B. and Ladson, A.R.1991: Digital terrain modelling: a review of hydrological, geomorphological, and biological applications . Hydrological Processes5, 3—30 .
79.
Moore, I.D. , Lewis, A. and Gallant, J.C.1993b: Terrain attributes: estimation methods and scale effects . In Jakeman, A.J. , Beck, M.B. and McAleer, M.J. , editors, Modelling change in environmental systems, New York: Wiley , 189—214.
80.
Moore, I.D. , Turner, A.K. , Wilson, J.P. , Jenson, S.K. and Band, L.E.1993c: GIS and land surfacesubsurface modelling. In Goodchild, M.F. , Parks, B.O. and Steyaert, L.T. , editors, Environmental modelling with GIS, New York: Oxford University Press , 196—230.
81.
Nikolov, N.T. and Zeller, K.F.1992: A solar radiation algorithm for ecosystem dynamic models . Ecological Modelling61, 149—68 .
82.
Pfeffer, K. , Pebesma, E.J. and Burrough, P.A.2003: Mapping alpine vegetation using vegetation observation and topographic attributes. LandscapeEcology18, 759—76 .
83.
Pierce, K.B. , Lookingbill, T. and Urban, D.2005: A simple method for estimating potential relative radiation (PRR) for landscape-scale vegetation analysis . Landscape Ecology20, 137—47 .
84.
Pike, R.J.1988: The geometric signature: quantifying landslide-terrain types from digital elevation models. MathematicalGeology20, 491—511 .
85.
— 2000: Geomorphometry — diversity in quantitative surface analysis . Progress in Physical Geography24, 1—20 .
86.
Plewe, B.1997: A representation-oriented taxonomy of gradation. In Hirtle, S.C. and Frank, A.U. , editors, Spatial information theory: a theoretical basis for GIS, Lecture Notes in Computer Sciences 1329, Berlin: SpringVerlag , 121—36.
87.
Quinn, P.F. , Beven, K.J. , Chevallier, P. and Planchon, O.1991: The prediction of hillslope flow paths for distributed hydrological modeling using digital terrain models . Hydrological Processes5, 59—79 .
88.
Quinn, P.F. , Beven, K.J. and Lamb, R.1995: The ln(α/tanβ ) index: how to calculate it and how to use it within the TOPMODEL framework . Hydrological Processes9, 162—82 .
89.
Running, S.W. and Thornton, P.E.1996: Generating daily surfaces of temperature and precipitation over complex topography. In Goodchild, M.F. , Steyaert, L.T. , Parks, B.O. , Johnston, C. , Maidment, D. , Crane, M. and Glendinning, S. , editors, GIS and environmental modelling: progress and research issues , Fort Collins, CO: GIS World Books , 93—98.
90.
Running, S.W. , Nemani, R.R. and Hungerford, R.D.1987: Extrapolation of synoptic meteorological data in mountainous terrain and its use for simulating forest evapotranspiration and photosynthesis . Canadian Journal of Forest Research, 17, 472—83 .
91.
Schmidt, J. and Andrew, R.2005: Multi-scale landform characterization . Area37, 341—50 .
92.
Schmidt, J. and Dikau, R.1999: Extracting geomorphometric attributes and objects from digital elevation models — semantics, methods, and future needs. In Dikau, R. and Sourer, H. , editors, GIS for earth surface systems: analysis and modelling of the natural environment, Berlin: Gebrüder Borntraeger , 153—73.
93.
Schmidt, J. and Hewitt, A.2004: Fuzzy land element classification from DTMs based on geometry and terrain position . Geoderma121, 243—56 .
94.
Schmidt, J. , Evans, I.S. and Brinkmann, J.2003: Comparison of polynomial models for land surface curvature calculation . International Journal of Geographical Information Science17, 797—814 .
95.
Schneider, B.2001a: On the uncertainty of local shape of lines and surfaces . Cartography and Geographic Information Science28, 237—47 .
96.
— 2001b: Phenomenon-based specification of the digital representation of terrain surfaces . Transactions in GIS5, 39—52 .
97.
Smith, B.1998: Basic concepts of formal ontology. In Guarino, N. , editor, Formal ontology in information systems, Amsterdam: IOS Press , 19—28.
98.
Smith, B. and Mark, D.M.2003: Do mountains exist? Ontology of landforms and topography . Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design30, 411—27 .
99.
Tague, C.L. and Band, L.E.2004: RHESSys: Regional Hydro-ecologic Simulation System — an object-oriented approach to spatially distributed modelling of carbon, water, and nutrient cycling . Earth Interactions8, 1—42 .
100.
Thompson, J.A. , Bell, J.C. and Butler, C.A.2001: Digital elevation model resolution: effects on terrain attribute calculation and quantitative soil-landscape modelling . Geoderma100, 67—89 .
101.
Thornton, P.E. , Running, S.W. and White, M.A.1997: Generating surfaces of daily meteorological variables over large areas of complex terrain. Journal ofHydrology190, 214—51 .
102.
Usery, E.L.1996: A conceptual framework and fuzzy set implementation for geographic features. In Burrough, P.A. and Frank, A.U. , editors, Geographic objects with indeterminate boundaries, London: Taylor and Francis , 71—86.
103.
Vogt, J.V. , Colombo, R. and Bertolo, F.2003: Deriving drainage networks and catchment boundaries: a new methodology combining digital elevation data and environmental characteristics . Geomorphology53, 281—98 .
104.
Wilson, J.P. and Burrough, P.A.1999: Dynamic modelling, geostatistics, and fuzzy classifications: new sneakers for a new geography?Annals of Association of American Geographers89, 736—46 .
105.
Wilson, J.P. and Gallant, J.C.2000a: Digital terrain analysis. In Wilson, J.P. and Gallant, J.C. , editors, Terrain analysis: principles and applications, New York: Wiley , 1—27.
106.
— 2000b: Terrain analysis: principles and applications, New York: Wiley .
107.
— 2000c: Secondary terrain attributes. In Wilson, J.P. and Gallant, J.C. , editors, Terrain analysis: principles and applications, New York: Wiley , 87—132.
108.
Wilson, J.P. , Lam, C.S. and Deng, Y.X.2007: Comparison of flow routing algorithms used in geographic information systems . Hydrological Processes20, DOI: 10.1002/hyp:6277.
109.
Wolock, D.M. and McCabe, G.J.2000: Differences in topographic characteristics computed from 100- and 1000-m resolution digital elevation model data . Hydrological Processes15, 2223—36 .
110.
Wood, E.C. , Sivapalan M. , Beven K.J. and Band L.E.1988: Effects of spatial variability and scale with implications to hydrologic modelling. Journal ofHydrology102, 29—47 .
111.
Wood, J.1996: Scale-based characterization of digital elevation models . In Parker, D. , editor, Innovations in GIS 3, London: Taylor and Francis , 163—75.
112.
— 1998: Activating scale-based uncertainty in digital elevation models. In Goodchild, M.F. and Jeansoulin, R. , editors, Data quality in geographic information: from error to uncertainty, Paris: Hermes , 81—96.
113.
— 2004: A new method for the identification of peaks and summits in surface models . In Proceedings of GIScience 2004 — The Third International Conference on Geographic Information Science, Maryland, Adelphi, 227—30.
114.
Zhang, W.H. and Montgomery, D.R.1994: Digital elevation model grid size, landscape representation, and hydrologic simulations . Water Resources Research30, 1019—28 .
115.
Zhu, A.X.1997: A similarity model for representing soil spatial information . Geoderma77, 217—42 .
