An extended family of spatial interaction models

Abstract

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alonso, W. 1978: A theory of movement. In Hansen, N.M. , editor, Human settlement systems. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger, 197-211.

Anselin, L. 1984: Specification tests and model selection for aggregate spatial interaction: an empirical comparison. Journal of Regional Science 24, 1-15.

Asami, Y. and Isard, W. 1989: Imperfect information, uncertainty and optimal sampling in location theory: an initial re-examination of Hotelling, Weber and Von Thunen. Journal of Regional Science 29, 507-21.

Ashtakala, B. 1987: Generalized power model for trip distribution. Transportation Research 21B, 59-67.

Barber, G.M. and Milne, W.J. 1988: Modelling internal migration in Kenya: an econometric analysis with limited data. Environment and Planning A 20, 1185-96.

Batty, M. , Hay, A.M. and Wilson, A.G. 1991: Classics in human geography revisited: a statistical theory of spatial distribution models. Progress in Human Geography 15, 433-36.

Batty, M. and Sikdar, P.K. 1982a: Spatial aggregation in gravity models: 1. An information-theoretic framework. Environment and Planning A 14, 377-405.

— 1982b: Spatial aggregation in gravity models: 4. Generalizations and large-scale applications. Environment and Planning A 14, 795-822.

Baxter, M.J. 1983a: Estimation and inference in spatial interaction models . Progress in Human Geography 7,40-59.

10.

— 1983b: Model misspecification and spatial structure in spatial-interaction models. Environment and Planning A 15, 319-27.

11.

Baxter, M.J. and Ewing, G.O. 1979: Calibration of production-constrained trip distribution models and the effect of intervening opportunities. Journal of Regional Science 19, 319-30.

12.

Baxter, R.S. 1976: Computer and statistical techniques for planners. London: Methuen.

13.

Bennett, R.J. , Haining, R.P. and Wilson, A.G. 1985: Spatial structure, spatial interaction, and their integration: a review of alternative models. Environment and Planning A 17, 625-36.

14.

Blechman, I. 1987: Regularities and a descriptive algorithm of the trip to work distribution. Transportation Research 21B, 359-93.

15.

Boots, B.N. and Kanaroglou, P. 1988: Incorporating the effects of spatial structure in discrete choice models of migration. Journal of Regional Science 28, 495-509.

16.

Borgers, A. and Timmermans, H. 1988: A context-sensitive model of spatial choice behaviour . In Golledge, R.G. and Timmermans, H. , editors, Behavioural modelling in geography and planning. London: Croom Helm, 159-78.

17.

Bröcker, J. 1989: How to eliminate certain defects of the potential formula . Environment and Planning A 21,817-30.

18.

Bussière, R. and Snickars, F. 1970: Derivation of the negative exponential model by an entropy maximizing method. Environment and Planning 2, 295-301.

19.

Charnes, A. , Raike, W. and Bettinger, C.O. 1972: An extremal and information-theoretic characterization of some interzonal transfer models. Socio-Economic Planning Sciences 6, 531-37.

20.

Cremer, M. and Keller, H. 1987: A new class of dynamic methods for the identification of origin-destination flows. Transportation Research 21B, 117-32.

21.

Crouchley, R. 1987: An examination of the equivalence of three alternative mechanisms for establishing the equilibrium solutions of the production-constrained spatial interaction model. Environment and Planning A 19, 861-74.

22.

Dacey, M.P. and Norcliffe, A. 1977: A flexible doubly-constrained trip distribution model . Transportation Research 11, 203-204.

23.

Dorigo, G. and Tobler, W. 1983: Push-pull migration laws. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 73, 1-17.

24.

Duffus, L.N. , Alfa, A.S. and Soliman, A.H. 1987: The reliability of using the gravity model for forecasting trip distribution. Transportation 14, 175-92.

25.

Erlander, S. 1980: Optimal spatial interaction and the gravity model. Berlin: Springer.

26.

— 1985: Remarks on spatial distribution modelling. Environment and Planning A 17, 699-703.

27.

Erlander, S. and Stewart, N.F. 1990: The gravity model in transportation analysis: theory and extensions. Utrecht: VSP.

28.

Evans, A.W. 1971: The calibration of trip distribution models with exponential or similar cost functions. Transportation Research 5, 15-38.

29.

Evans, N.J. and Pooler, J. 1987: Distance deterrence effects in constrained spatial interaction models of interprovincial migration. Canadian Journal of Regional Science 10, 259-79.

30.

Evans, S. 1973: A relationship between the gravity model for trip distribution and the transportation program in linear programming. Transportation Research 7, 39-61.

31.

Ewing, G. 1986: Spatial pattern in distance-deterrence parameters and Fotheringham's theory of competing destinations. Environment and Planning A 18, 547-52.

32.

Fik, T.J. 1988: Hierarchical interaction: the modelling of a competing central place system. The Annals of Regional Science 22, 48-69.

33.

Fik, T.J. and Mulligan, G.F. 1990: Spatial flows and competing central places: towards a general theory of hierarchical interaction. Environment and Planning A 22, 527-50.

34.

Fischer, M.M. 1991: Spatial interaction and choice. Environment and Planning A 23, 1233-35.

35.

Fischer, M.M. and Nijkamp, P. 1985: Developments in explanatory discrete spatial data and choice analysis. Progress in Human Geography 9, 515-51.

36.

Fisk, C. 1985a: Entropy and information theory: are we missing something? Environment and Planning A 17,679-87.

37.

— 1985b: Response to authors' comments: 'entropy and information theory'. Environment and Planning A 17, 708-710.

38.

Flowerdew, R. and Lovett, A. 1988: Fitting constrained Poisson regression models to interurban migration flows. Geographical Analysis 20, 297-307.

39.

Fotheringham, A.S. 1983a: A new set of spatial-interaction models: the theory of competing destinations. Environment and Planning A 15, 15-36.

40.

— 1983b: Some theoretical aspects of destination choice and their relevance to production-constrained gravity models. Environment and Planning A 15, 1121-32.

41.

— 1986: Modelling hierarchical destination choice. Environment and Planning A 18, 401-18.

42.

— 1988: Consumer store choice and choice set definition. Marketing Science 7, 299-310.

43.

Fotheringham, A.S. and Dignan, T. 1984: Further contributions to a general theory of movement . Annals of the Association of American Geographers 74, 620-33.

44.

Fotheringham, A.S. and O'Kelly, M.E. 1989: Spatial interaction models: formulations and applications . Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers .

45.

Getis, A. 1984: Interaction modelling using second-order analysis. Environment and Planning A 16, 173-83.

46.

— 1991: Spatial interaction and spatial autocorrelation: a cross-product approach. Environment and Planning A 23, 1269-78.

47.

Getis, A. and Ord, J.K. 1992: The analysis of spatial association by use of distance statistics. Geographical Analysis 24, 189-206.

48.

Ghosh, A. and McLafferty, S.L. 1987: Location strategies for retail and service firms. Lexington, MA: D. C. Heath.

49.

Golledge, R. and Stimson, R.J. 1987: Analytical behavioural geography. London: Croom Helm.

50.

Golledge, R. and Timmermans, H. 1990: Application of behavioural research on spatial problems: I. Cognition. Progress in Human Geography 14, 57-99.

51.

Gonçalves, M.B. and Ulysséa-Neto, I. 1993: The development of a new gravity-opportunity model for trip distribution. Environment and Planning A 25, 817-26.

52.

Gordon, I.R. 1985: Economic explanations of spatial variation in distance deterrence. Environment and PlanningA 17, 59-72.

53.

Guiasu, S. and Vermot-Desroches, B. 1983: Some remarks on Wilson's gravity model and a slight generalization of it. Transportation Research 17B, 333-37.

54.

Guy, C.M. 1991: Spatial interaction modelling in retail planning practice: the need for robust statistical methods. Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design 18, 191-203.

55.

Hallefjord, A. and Jörnsten, K. 1985: A note on relaxed gravity models. Environment and Planning A 17,597-604.

56.

Haynes, K.E. and Fotheringham, A.S. 1984: Gravity and spatial interaction models (volume 2). Scientific Geography Series. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.

57.

— 1991: The impact of space on the application of discrete choice models. Review of Regional Science 20, 39-49.

58.

Haynes, K.E. and Phillips, F.Y. 1987: The cost constraint in the maximum-entropy trip distribution model: a research note. Geographical Analysis 19, 90-93.

59.

Horowitz, J.L. 1991: Modelling the choice of choice set in discrete-choice random-utility models. Environment and Planning A 23, 1237-46.

60.

Hua, Chang-i and Porell, F. 1979: A critical review of the development of the gravity model . International Regional Science Review 4, 97-126.

61.

Huff, J.O. 1976: A hierarchical migration model of population redistribution within a central place hierarchy. Geographical Analysis 8, 231-54.

62.

Huriot, J-M. , Smith, T.E. and Thisse, J-F. 1989: Minimum-cost distances in spatial analysis. Geographical Analysis 21, 294-315.

63.

Ishikawa, Y. 1987: An empirical study of the competing destinations model using Japanese interaction data. Environment and Planning A 19, 1359-73.

64.

Janson, B.N. and Southworth, F. 1992: Estimating departure times from traffic counts using dynamic assignment. Transportation Research 26B, 3-16.

65.

Jayet, H. 1990a: Spatial search processes and spatial interaction: 1. Sequential search, intervening opportunities, and spatial search equilibrium . Environment and Planning A 22, 583-99.

66.

— 1990b: Spatial search processes and spatial interaction: 2. Polarization, concentration, and spatial search equilibrium. Environment and Planning A 22, 719-32.

67.

Jefferson, T.R. and Scott, C.H. 1979: The analysis of entropy models with equality and inequality constraints. Transportation Research 13, 123-32.

68.

Johnston, R.J. 1985: The geography of English politics. Andover: Croom Helm.

69.

Johnston, R.J. and Hay, A.M. 1982: On the parameters of uniform swing in single-member constituency electoral systems. Environment and Planning A 14, 61-74.

70.

Johnston, R.J. and Pattie, C.J. 1991: Evaluating the use of entropy-maximizing procedures in the study of voting patterns: 1. Sampling and measurement error in the flow-of-the-vote matrix and the robustness of estimates. Environment and Planning A 23, 411-20.

71.

Johnston, R.J. , Pattie, C.J. and Johnston, L.C. 1989: The role of ecological analysis in electoral geography . Geografiska Annaler Series B 70, 307-24.

72.

Jörnsten, K.O. , Larsson, T. , Lundgren, J.T. and Migdalas, A. 1990: An entropy model with variable target. Environment and Planning A 22, 493-506.

73.

Knudsen, D.C. 1990: A dynamic analysis of interaction data: US rail freight flows, 1972-81. Geographical Analysis 22, 259-69.

74.

Knudsen, D.C. and Fotheringham, A.S. 1986: Matrix comparison, goodness-of-fit, and spatial interaction modeling. International Regional Science Review 10, 127-47.

75.

Kohsaka, H. 1989: A spatial search-location model of retail centres. Geographical Analysis 21, 338-49.

76.

Kullback, S. 1959: Information theory and statistics. New York: Wiley.

77.

Ledent, J. 1985: The doubly constrained model of spatial interaction: a more general formulation. Environment and Planning A 17, 253-62.

78.

Lo, L. 1991: Spatial structure and spatial interaction: a simulation approach. Environment and Planning A 23, 1279-300.

79.

Maier, G. 1991: Modelling search processes in space. Papers in Regional Science 70, 133-47.

80.

March, L. 1971: Urban systems: a generalized distribution function. In Wilson, A.G. , editor, Urban and regional planning. London: Pion , 157-70.

81.

March, L. and Batty, M. 1975: Generalized measures of information, Bayes' likelihood ratio and Jaynes' formalism. Environment and Planning B 2, 99-105.

82.

Mayhew, L.D. , Gibberd, R.W. and Hall, H. 1986: Predicting patient flows and hospital case-mix. Environment and Planning A 18, 619-38.

83.

Miller, H.J. and O'Kelly, M.E. 1991: Properties and estimation of a production-constrained Alonso model. Environment and Planning A 23, 127-38.

84.

Mulligan, G.F. 1984: Central place populations: some implications of consumer shopping behavior. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 74, 44-56.

85.

Nijkamp, P. and Reggiani, A. 1988a: Entropy, spatial interaction models and discrete choice analysis: static and dynamic analogies. European Journal of Operational Research 36, 186-96.

86.

— 1988b: Dynamic spatial interaction models: new directions. Environment and Planning A 20, 1449-60.

87.

Norcliffe, A. 1985: Short comment: 'entropy and information theory'. Environment and Planning A 17, 707.

88.

Okabe, A. 1976: A theoretical comparison of the opportunity and gravity models. Regional Science and Urban Economics 6, 381-97.

89.

Openshaw, S. 1983: From data crunching to model crunching: the dawn of a new era. Environment and PlanningA 15, 1011-33.

90.

— 1988: Building an automated modelling system to explore a universe of spatial interaction models. Geographical Analysis 20, 31-46.

91.

Oppewal, H. and Timmermans, H. 1991: Context effects and decompositional choice modelling. Papers in Regional Science 70, 113-31.

92.

Paulov, J. 1991: The zone-size-dependent entropy formula and spatial interaction modelling: a note on some implications. Environment and Planning A 23, 557-70.

93.

Phillips, F.Y. , White, G.M. and Haynes, K.E. 1976: Extremal approaches to estimating spatial interaction . Geographical Analysis 8, 185-200.

94.

Plane, D. 1981: Estimation of place-to-place migration flows from net migration totals: a minimum information approach. International Regional Science Review 6, 33-51.

95.

Pooler, J.A. 1983: Information theoretic methods of spatial model building: a guide to the unbiased estimation of the form of probability distributions . Socio-Economic Planning Sciences 17, 153-64.

96.

— 1985: Derivation of a generalized family of spatial interaction models; an information theoretic approach. Modelling and Simulation 16, 199-207.

97.

— 1987a: Measuring geographical accessibility: a review of current approaches and problems in the use of population potentials. Geoforum 18, 269-89.

98.

— 1987b: Modelling interprovincial migration using entropy-maximizing methods. Canadian Geographer 31,57-64.

99.

— 1988: Spatial interaction models incorporating serial dependency effects. In Coffey, W.J. , editor, Geographical systems and systems of geography: essays in honour of William Warntz. London, Ontario: University of Western Ontario, 89-100.

100.

— 1992: Spatial uncertainty and spatial dominance in interaction modelling: a theoretical perspective on spatial competition. Environment and Planning A 24, 995-1008.

101.

— 1993: Structural spatial interaction. The Professional Geographer 45, 297-305.

102.

— 1994: A family of relaxed spatial interaction models. The Professional Geographer (forthcoming).

103.

Pumain, D. and Haag, G. 1991: Urban and regional dynamics - towards an integrated approach . Environment and Planning A 23, 1301-14.

104.

Rich, D.C. 1980: Potential models in human geography. Concepts and techniques in modern geography no. 26 (Geo Abstracts). Norwich: University of East Anglia.

105.

Roy, J.R. 1985: On forecasting choice among dependent spatial alternatives . Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design 12, 479-92.

106.

— 1987: An alternative information theory approach for modelling spatial interaction. Environment and PlanningA 19, 385-94.

107.

— 1990: Spatial interaction modelling: some interpretations and challenges. Environment and Planning A 22, 712-15.

108.

Roy, J.R. and Batten, D.F. 1985: Invited comment: 'entropy and information theory'. Environment and PlanningA 17, 704-706.

109.

Roy, J.R. and Flood, J. 1992: Interregional migration modelling via entropy and information theory. Geographical Analysis 24, 16-34.

110.

Roy, J.R. and Lesse, P.F. 1981: On appropriate microstate descriptions in entropy modelling . Transportation Research 15B, 85-96.

111.

— 1985: Entropy models with entropy constraints on aggregated events. Environment and Planning A 17, 1669-74.

112.

Senior, M.L. 1979: From gravity modelling to entropy maximizing: a pedagogic guide. Progress in Human Geography 3, 175-210.

113.

Shannon, C.E. and Weaver, W. 1949: The mathematical theory of communication. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press.

114.

Sheppard, E.S. 1976: Entropy, theory construction and spatial analysis. Environment and Planning A 8, 741-52.

115.

Slater, P.B. 1992: Equilibrium and nonequilibrium statistical thermodynamical approaches to modelling spatial interaction dynamics. Environment and Planning A 24, 441-46.

116.

Smith, S.L.J. 1980: Intervening opportunities and travel to urban recreation centres. Journal of Leisure Research 12, 296-308.

117.

Smith, T.E. 1985: Remarks on the most-probable-state approach to analysing probabilistic theories of behaviour. Environment and Planning A 17, 688-95.

118.

— 1991: A simple decision theory of spatial interaction: the Alonso model revisited. Environment and Planning A 23, 1247-68.

119.

Snickars, F. and Weibull, J.W. 1977: A minimum information principle; theory and practice. Regional Science and Urban Economics 7, 137-68.

120.

Spiess, H. 1987: A maximum likelihood model for estimating origin-destination matrices. Transportation Research 21B, 395-412.

121.

Theil, H. 1972: Statistical decomposition analysis. Amsterdam: North-Holland.

122.

Thill, J-C. 1992: Choice set formation for destination choice modelling . Progress in Human Geography 16, 361-82.

123.

Thill, J-C. and Thomas, I. 1987: Toward conceptualizing trip-chaining behaviour: a review . Geographical Analysis 19, 1-17.

124.

Timmermans, H. and Golledge, R. 1990: Application of behavioural research on spatial problems: II. Preference and choice. Progress in Human Geography 14,311-54.

125.

Timmermans, H. , Van Der Hagen, X. and Borgers, A. 1992: Transportation systems, retail environments and pedestrian trip chaining behaviour: modelling issues and applications. Transportation Research 26B, 45-59.

126.

Tobler, W. 1983: An alternative formulation for spatial-interaction modelling . Environment and Planning A 15, 693-703.

127.

— 1988: The quadratic transportation problem as a model of spatial interaction patterns. In Coffey, W.J. , editor, Geographical systems and systems of geography: essays in honour of William Warntz. London, Ontario: University of Western Ontario, 75-88.

128.

Tribus, M. 1969: Rational descriptions, decisions and designs. New York: Pergamon.

129.

Webber, M.J. 1976: Elementary entropy maximizing probability distributions: analysis and interpretation. Economic Geography 52, 218-27.

130.

— 1979: Information theory and urban spatial structure London: Croom Helm.

131.

Weber, J. 1987: Elasticities of constrained gravity models. Journal of Regional Science 27, 621-40.

132.

Weibull, J.W. 1985: Classical statistics versus information theory. Environment and Planning A 17, 696-98.

133.

Weisbrod, G.E. , Parcells, R.J. and Kern, C. 1984: A disaggregate model for predicting shopping area market attraction. Journal of Retailing 60, 65-83.

134.

Williams, P.A. and Fotheringham, A.S. 1984: The calibration of spatial interaction models by maximum likelihood estimation with program SIMODEL. Geographic Monograph Series 7. Indiana University, Department of Geography, Bloomington, Indiana.

135.

Wills, M.J. 1986: A flexible gravity-opportunities model for trip distribution . Transportation Research 20B, 89-111.

136.

Wilson, A.G. 1967: A statistical theory of spatial distribution models. Transportation Research 1, 253-69.

137.

— 1970: Entropy in urban and regional modelling. London: Pion.

138.

— 1971: A family of spatial interaction models, and associated developments. Environment and Planning 3, 1-32.

139.

— 1974: Urban and regional models in geography and planning New York: Wiley.

140.

— 1983: Tobler's 'an alternative formulation for spatial-interaction modelling': an observation. Environment and Planning A 15, 705-706.

141.

Wilson, A.G. and Bennett, R.J. 1985: Mathematical methods in human geography and planning. Chichester: Wiley.

142.

Zielinski, K. 1979: Experimental analysis of eleven models of urban population density. Environment and Planning A 11, 629-41.

143.

— 1980: The modelling of urban population density: a survey. Environment and Planning A 12, 135-54.