The idea of progress disconcerts. While it is enshrined as an object in our research audit culture, its very existence is queried in many groves of the modern academy. Here I contend that the idea of ‘progress in geography’ has meant different things, at different times, in different places, and that it has been put to different cultural and political uses. The realization that ‘progress in geography’has its own geography might lead us in the direction of destabilizing the notion to the point of undermining it altogether. I believe that to be mistaken. Instead I argue for the retrieval of a chastened form of the idea of progress as a regulative ideal both epistemologically and morally.
Bagehot, W.1872: Physics and politics. London: Henry S. King .
2.
Barnes, T.J.2004: Placing ideas: genius loci, heterotopia and geography's quantitative revolution . Progress in Human Geography28, 565–595 .
3.
Barzun, J.1968: The American university. New York: Harper and Row .
4.
Bassett, K.1999: Is there progress in human geography? The problem of progress in the light of recent work in the philosophy and sociology of science . Progress in Human Geography23, 2–47 .
5.
Bauman, Z.1993: Racism, anti-racism, and moral progress . Arena Journal1, 9–21 .
6.
Bock, K.1978: Theories of progress development, evolution. In Bottomore, T. and Nisbet, R. , editors, A history of sociological analysis, London: Heinemann , 39–79.
7.
Bowler, P.J.1989: The invention of progress: the Victorians and the past. Oxford: Blackwell .
8.
Braudrillard, J.1992: Revolution and the end of Utopia. In Stearns, W. and Chaloupka, W. , editors, Jean Braudrillard: the disappearance of art and politics, London: Macmillan , 233–242.
9.
Brookfield, H.C.1969: On the environment as perceived . Progress in Geography1, 51–80 .
10.
Brückner, M.1999: Lessons in geography: maps, spellers, and other grammars of nationalism in the early republic . American Quarterly51, 311–343 .
11.
Bury, J.B.1920: The idea of progress: an inquiry into its origin and growth. London: Macmillan .
12.
Cloke, P.2004: Deliver us from evil? Prospects for living ethically and acting politically in human geography. In Cloke, P. , Crang, P. and Goodwin, M. , editors, Envisioning human geographies, London: Arnold , 210–228.
13.
Conversi, D.2000: Cosmopolitanism and nationalism. In Leoussi, A. , editor, Encyclopaedia of nationalism, Oxford: Transaction Books , 34–39.
14.
Cox, K.R.1969: The voting decision in a spatial context . Progress in Geography1, 81–117 .
15.
DeRogatis, A.2003: Moral geography: maps, missionaries, and the American frontier. New York: Columbia University Press .
16.
Dodds, E.R.1973: Progress in classical antiquity. In Wiener, P.P. , editor in chief, Dictionary of the history of ideas, volume 3, New York: Scribner's , 623–633.
17.
Douglas, M. and Ney, S.1998: Missing persons: a critique of the social sciences. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press .
18.
Drayton, R.2000: Nature's government: science, imperial Britain, and the ‘improvement’ of the world. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press .
19.
Driver, F.1988: Moral geographies: social science and the urban environment in mid-nineteenth century England . Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers NS13, 275–287 .
20.
Eagleton, T.2004: After theory. London: Penguin .
21.
Edelstein, L.1967: The idea of progress in classical antiquity. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press .
22.
Entrikin, J.N.2002: Perfectibility and democratic place-making. In Sack, R.D. , editor, Progress: geographical essays, London: The Johns Hopkins University Press , 97–112.
23.
Gallie, W.B.1956: Essentially contested concepts . Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society56, 167–198 .
24.
Gilmore, W.J.1989: Reading becomes a necessity of life: material and cultural life in rural New England, 1780–1835. Knoxville, TN: University of Tennessee Press .
25.
Ginsberg, M.1953: The idea of progress: a revaluation. London: Methuen .
26.
Ginsberg, M.1973: Progress in the modern era. In Wiener, P.P. , editor in chief, Dictionary of the history of ideas, volume 3, New York: Scribner's , 633–650.
27.
Gould, P.R.1969: Methodological developments since the fifties . Progress in Geography1, 1–49 .
28.
Gould, S.J.1988: On replacing the idea of progress with an operational notion of directionality. In Nitecki, M.H. , editor, Evolutionary progress, Chicago: University of Chicago Press , 319–338.
29.
Graham, E.2005: Key thinkers, disciplines and knowledge productions . Environment and Planning A37, 181–183 .
30.
Graham, G.1997: The shape of the past: a philosophical approach to history. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
31.
Haack, S.1998: Manifesto of a passionate moderate: unfashionable essays. Chicago: University of Chicago Press .
32.
Harvey, D.2000: Cosmopolitanism and the banality of geographical evils . Public Culture12, 529–564 .
33.
Heffernan, M.1999: Historical geographies of the future: three perspectives from France, 1750–1825. In Livingstone, D.N. and Withers, C.W.J. , editors, Geography and enlightenment, Chicago: University of Chicago Press , 125–164.
34.
Herbert, D.T. and Johnston, R.J.1978: Geography and the urban environment. In Herbert, D.T. and Johnston, R.J. , editors, Geography and the urban environment: progress in research and applications, volume 1, Chichester: Wiley , 1–33.
35.
Huxley, T.H.1888: The struggle for existence in human society . The Nineteenth Century23, 161–180 .
36.
Jacques, T.C.1997: From savages and barbarians to primitives: Africa, social typologies, and history in eighteenth-century French philosophy . History and Theory36, 190–215 .
37.
Kidd, C.1999: British identities before nationalism: ethnicity and nationhood in the atlantic world, 1600–1800. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
38.
Kobayashi, A. and Proctor, J.D.2004: How far have we cared? Recent developments in the geography of values, justice and ethics. In Galie, G. and Willmott, C. , editors, Geography in America, Oxford: Oxford University Press , 723–731.
39.
Kohn, H.1956: The idea of nationalism: a study in its origins and background. New York: Macmillan .
40.
Kropotkin, P.1882: Charles Darwin. Le Révolté 29 April.
41.
Kropotkin, P.1885: What geography ought to be . The Nineteenth Century18, 940–956 .
42.
Kropotkin, P.1910: Anarchism. Entry in The Encyclopedia Britannica, 11th edition, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
43.
Kropotkin, P.1939: Mutual aid. London: Penguin (originally published 1902).
44.
Kuhn, T.1962: The structure of scientific revolutions. Chicago: University of Chicago Press .
45.
Latour, B.2004: The last critique . Harper's Magazine April, 15–20 .
46.
Laudan, L.1977: Progress and its problems: toward a theory of scientific growth. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul .
47.
Ley, D.2003: Forgetting postmodernism? Recuperating a social history of local knowledge . Progress in Human Geography27, 537–560 .
48.
Livingstone, D.N.2002: Race, space and moral climatology: notes towards a genealogy . Journal of Historical Geography28, 159–180 .
49.
Livingstone, D.N.2005: ‘Risen into empire’: moral geographies of the American republic. In Livingstone, D.N. and Withers, C.W.J. , editors, Geography and revolution, Chicago: University of Chicago Press , 304–335.
50.
Livingstone, D.N. and Withers, C.W.J. , editors 1999: Geography and Enlightenment. Chicago: University of Chicago Press .
51.
May, J.A.1970: Kant's concept of geography and its relation to recent geographical thought. Toronto: University of Toronto Press .
52.
Mayhew, R.J.2000: Enlightenment geography: the political languages of British geography, 1650–1850. London: Macmillan .
53.
Miller, R.W.1992: Moral differences: truth, justice and conscience in a world of conflict. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press .
54.
Morse, J.1792: The American geography; or, a view of the present situation of the United States of America(second edition). London: Stockdale .
55.
Morse, J.1822: A report to the secretary of war of the United States on Indian affairs. New Haven, CT: S. Converse .
56.
Moss, R.J.1995: The life of Jedidiah Morse: a station of peculiar exposure. Knoxville, TN: University of Tennessee Press .
57.
Murray, C.2001: The idea of progress: once again, with feeling. Hoover Digest: Research and Opinion on Public Policy 3. Retrieved 11 July 2006 from http://www.hooverdigest.org/013/murray.html
58.
Neiman, S.2002: Evil. An alternative history of philosophy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press .
59.
Nisbet, R.1980: History of the idea of the progress. New York: Basic Books .
60.
Nussbaum, M.C.1997: Kant and Stoic cosmopolitanism . Journal of Political Philosophy5, 1–25 .
61.
O'Neill, O.2002: A question of trust. The BBC Reith lectures 2002. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
62.
Passmore, J.1970: The perfectibility of man. London: Duckworth .
63.
Philo, C.1991: De-limiting human geography: new social and cultural perspectives. In Philo, C., compiler, New words, new worlds: reconceptualizing social and cultural geography, Lampeter: Department of Geography, St David's University College , 14–27.
64.
Pinkerton, J. 1787: Dissertation on the origin and progress of the Scythians or Goths, Being an introduction to the ancient and modern history of Europe. London: Nicol.
65.
Pinkerton, J.1807: Modern geography. a description of the empires, kingdoms, states, and colonies; with the oceans, seas, and isles; in all parts of the world: including the most recent discoveries, and political alterations. Digested on a new plan (three volumes). London: T. Cadell and W. Davies .
66.
Pocock, J.G.A.1999: Barbarism and religion: narratives of civil government. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
67.
Popkin, R.H.1977–78: Hume's racism . The Philosophical Forum9, 211–226 .
68.
Power, M.1999: The audit society: rituals of verification. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
69.
Proctor, J.D.1998: Ethics in geography: giving moral form to the geographical imagination . Area30, 8–18 .
70.
Reynolds, J.2004: Derrida and Deleuze on time, the future, and politics . borderlands e-journal3(1).
71.
Rorty, R.1998: Truth and progress. Philosophical papers, volume 3. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
72.
Roszak, T.1969: The making of a counter culture. reflections on the technocratic society and its youthful opposition. Garden City, NY: Anchor Books .
73.
Ruse, M.1993: Evolution and progress . Trends in Ecology and Evolution8(2), 55–59 .
74.
Ruse, M.1996: From monad to man: the concept of progress in evolutionary biology. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
75.
Sack, R.D.1999: A sketch of a geographic theory of morality . Annals of the Association of American Geographers55, 26–44 .
76.
Sack, R.D.2002: Geographical progress toward the real and the good. In Sack, R.D. , editor, Progress: geographical essays, London: The Johns Hopkins University Press , 113–130.
77.
Sack, R.D.2003: A geographical guide to the real and the good. London: Routledge .
78.
Sahlins, M.1974: Stone age economics. London: Tavistock .
79.
Sebastiani, S.2003: Race and national characters in eighteenth-century Scotland: the polygenetic discourses of Kames and Pinkerton . Cromohs8, 1–14 .
80.
Shapin, S.1994: A social history of truth: civility and science in seventeenth-century England. Chicago: University of Chicago Press .
81.
Smith, D.M.1973: An introduction to welfare geography. Department of Geography and Environmental studies, Occasional Paper 11. Johannesburgh: University of the Witwatersrand .
82.
Smith, D.M.2000: Moral progress in human geography: transcending the place of good fortune . Progress in Human Geography24, 1–18 .
83.
Smith, D.M.2004: Morality, ethics and social justice. In Cloke, P. , Crang, P. and Goodwin, M. , editors, Envisioning human geographies, London: Arnold , 195–209.
84.
Smith, N.1997: Satanic geographies of globalization . Public Culture10, 169–189 .
85.
Stent, G.S.1971: The coming of the golden age: a view of the end of progress. New York: Museum of Natural History .
86.
Stoddart, D.R.1966: Darwin's impact on geography . Annals of the Association of American Geographers56, 683–698 .
87.
Stoddart, D.R.1969: Climatic geomorphology: review and re-assessment . Progress in Geography1, 159–222 .
88.
Todes, D.P.1989: Darwin without Malthus: the struggle for existence in Russian evolutionary thought. New York: Oxford University Press .
89.
Tuan, Y.-F.2002: Progress and anxiety. In Sack, R.D. , editor, Progress: geographical essays, London: The Johns Hopkins University Press , 78–96.
90.
Tuvesan, E.1993: Progress. In Outhwaite, W. and Bottomore, T. , editors, The Blackwell dictionary of twentieth century social thought, Oxford: Blackwell , 515–517.
91.
Williams, B.2002: Truth and truthfulness: an essay in genealogy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press .
92.
Withers, C.W.J.2001: Geography, science and national identity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
