This paper is written in response to the recent articles of Malcolm Clark and William Dever in Westminster Press's new Israelite and Judaean
History. Part I attempts to clarify my position giving an Iron Age post quem dating for the origin of the Genesis narratives. Part II discusses the sociologically descriptive term "dimorphic" as used by Dever in his article, and as it has been variously used in the writing of Mesopotamian history. Part III discusses the limitations of the use to which such parallels or analogues can be put in developing a history of Palestine. Part IV uses the EB IV/MB I period as an example of the effect of sociological and anthropological questions on the writing of a history of Palestine. Part V discusses the complexity of settlement patterns in Bronze Age Palestine, and the variety of political structures implied by these patterns, as well as the impact of such observations on the history of the Late Bronze and Early Iron Ages in Palestine.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adams, R.McC. "Development Stages in Ancient Mesopotamia", 1971a Prehistoric Agriculture , ed. by S. Struever ( Nat Hist Press, Garden City), 572-590.
2.
1971 b "Early Civilizations, Subsistence, and Environment", Prehistoric Agriculture, ed. by S. Struever (Nat Hist Press, Garden City), 591-614.
3.
1972 "Patterns of Urbanization in Early Southern Mesopotamia", Man, Settlement, and Urbanism, ed. G.W. Dimbleby et alii (Duckworth, London), 735-749.
4.
Albright, W.F.From the Stone Age to Christianity (Anchor, 1957Garden City).
5.
Allan, W. "Ecology, Techniques, and Settlement Patterns", 1972 Man, Settlement and Urbanism, ed. by G.W. Dimbieby et alii (Duckworth, London), 211-226.
6.
Binford,L.R. & S.R. New Perspectives in Archaeology (Aldine Press, 1968Chicago).
7.
Butzer, K.W. "Agricultural Origins in the Near East as a 1971 Geographical Problem", Prehistoric Agriculture, ed. by S. Struever (Nat Hist Press, Garden City ), 209-235.
8.
Clark, W.M. "The Patriarchal Traditions. 2: The Biblical 1977 Traditions", Israelite and Judaean History, ed. by J.H. Hayes and J.M. Miller ( Westminster, Philadelphia), 120-148.
9.
Cranstone, B.A.L. "Environment and Choice in Dwelling and 1972 Settlement: an Ethnographical Survey", Man Settlement, and Urhanism, ed. by G.W. Dimbleby et alii (Duckworth, London), 487-504.
10.
Dever, W.G. "The Patriarchal Traditions. 1: Palestine in the 1977 Second Millennium BCE. The Archaeological Picture", Israelite and Judaean History, ed. by J.H. Hayes and J.M. Miller (Westminster, Philadelphia), 70-120.
11.
Flannery, K.V. "The Origins of the Village as a Settlement Type 1972 in Mesopotamia and the Near East: a Comparative Study", Man, Settlement, and Urbanism, ed. by G.W. Dimbleby et alii (Duckworth, London), 23-54.
12.
Frick F.S. & "The Social World of Ancient Israel", Society Gottwald, N.K. of Biblical Literature, Seminar Papers I1975 (Scholars Press, Missoula), 165-178.
13.
Fronzaroli, P. "West Semitic Toponomy in Northern Syria in the 1977 Third Millennium, B.C", JSS22, 145-166.
14.
de Geus, C.H.J. "The Amorites in the Archaeology of Palestine", 1971 UF 3, 41-60.
15.
1975 "The Importance of Archaeological Research into the Palestinian Agricultural Terraces, with an Excursus on the Hebrew Word gbi", PEQ107, 65-74.
16.
1976The Tribes of Israel: An Investigation into Some of the Presuppositions of Martin Noth's Amphictyony Hypothesis, Studia Semitica Neerlandica18 ( Van Gorcum, Assen/Amsterdam ).
17.
Gottwald, N.K. &. "The Social World of Ancient Israel", Society Frick, F.S. of Biblical Literature, Seminar Papers I 1975 ( Scholars Press, Missoula), 165-178.
18.
Gottwald,N.K. "The Hypothesis of the Revolutionary Origins of 1978 Ancient Israel: A Response to Hauser and Thompson", JSOT7, 37-52.
19.
Haldar, A.Who were the Amorites? Monographs of the Ancient 1971 Near East I (E.J. Brill, Leiden).
20.
Harris, D.R. "Swidden Systems and Settlement", Man, Settle-1972 ment and Urbanism , by G.W. Dimbleby et alii ( Duckworth, London), 245-262.
21.
Irvin, D. & "The Joseph and Moses Narratives. 4: The Thompson, Th.L. Narratives about the Origin of Israel", 1977Israelite and Judaean History, ed. by J.H. Hayes and J.M. Miller (Westminster Press, Philadelphia) 210-212.
22.
Irvin, D. "The Joseph and Moses Narratives. 3: The Joseph 1977 and Moses Stories as Narrative in the light of Ancient Near Eastern Narrative", Israelite and Judaean History, ed. by J.H. Hayes and J.M. Miller (Westminster Press, Philadelphia), 180-209.
23.
1978 Mytharion. The Comparison of Tales from the Old Testament and the Ancient Near East, AOAT 32 (NeukirchenerVerlag, Neukirchen).
24.
Kenyon, K.Amorites and Canaanites (Oxford U. Press, 1966London).
25.
Klengel, H.Benjaminiter und Hanäer zur Zeit der Könige von 1958 Mari (Dissertation, Berlin).
26.
1962 "Zu einigen Problemen des altvorderasiatischen Nomadentums ", ArOr30, 585-596.
27.
1972Zwischen Zelt und Palast (Schroll, Vienna).
28.
1977 "Nomaden und Handel", Iraq39, 163-169.
29.
Kochavi M.(ed.) Judaea, Samaria, and the Golan: Archaeological 1972 Survey 1967-1968 (Carta Jerusalem, Jerusalem).
30.
Kupper, J.R.Les Nomades en Mésopotamie au temps des rois de 1957 Mari, Bibliothèque de la Faculté de Philosophie et Lettres de l'Université de Liege, fasc. 142.
31.
Layton, R. "Settlement and Community", Man, Settlement and 1972 Urbanism, ed. by G.W. Dimbleby et alii ( Duckworth, London), 377-382.
32.
Liverari, M. "The Amorites", POTT, 100-133. 1973
33.
1976 a Review of H. Klengel, Zwischen Zelt and Palast, OrAn 15, 68-73.
34.
1976 b Review of R. de Vaux, L'Histoire ancienne d'Israël I.II, OrAn 15, 145-149.
35.
Luke, J.T.Pastoralism and Politics in the Mari Period: A 1965 Re-examination of the Character and Political Significance of the Major West Semitic Tribal Groups on the Middle Euphrates, ca. 1828-1758. (Dissertation, U. of Michigan).
36.
Martin, M.E.The Appraisal of Argument in Biblical Archaeology1976 (Dissertation, Leiden).
37.
Marx, E.Bedouin of the Negev (Manchester U. Press, 1967Manchester).
38.
Mazar, B. "The Historical Background of the Book of 1969 Genesis", JNES28, 73-83.
39.
Mendenhall G.E. "The Hebrew Conquest of Palestine", BA25, 196266-87.
40.
1969Review of M. Weippert, Die Landnahme, Bib 50, 432-6.
41.
Meyers, E.M.Jewish Ossuaries and Secondary Burials in their 1969 Ancient Near Eastern Setting (Dissertation, Harvard).
42.
Moscati, S. I Predecessori d'Israele, Studi Orientali 1956 publicati a cura della scuola orientale, IV (Rome)
43.
Noth, M. "Mari und Israel. Eine Personennamenstudie", 1953 Festschrift A.Alt, 127-152 (Aufsätze II, 213-233)
44.
Oren, E. "The Overland Route Between Egypt and Canaan in 1973 the Early Bronze Age", IEJ23, 198-205.
45.
Parr, P.J. "Settlement Patterns and Urban Planning in the 1972 Ancient Levant: the Nature of the Evidence", Man, Settlement, and Urbanism , ed. by G.W. Dimbleby et alii (Duckworth, London, 1972 ), 805-810.
46.
Prag, K. "The Intermediate Early Bronze - Middle Bronze 1974 Age: An Interpretation of the Evidence from Transjordan, Syria, and Lebanon", Levant6, 69-116.
47.
Pritchard, J.B.The Ancient Near East,II (Princeton U.Press, 1975Princeton).
48.
Rendtorff, R.Das überlieferungsgeschichtliche Problem des 1977 Pentateuch, BZAW 147 (de Gruyter, Berlin).
49.
Renger, J. "Who Are All Those People?", Orientalia42, 1973259-273.
50.
Ron, Z. " Agricultural Terraces in the Judaean Mountains", 1966 IEJ 16, 33-49 and 111-122.
51.
Rowton, M.B. "The Physical Environment and the Problem of the 1967 Nomads", RAI15, 109-121.
52.
1973a "Autonomy and Nomadism in Western Asia", Orientalia42, 247-258.
53.
1973b "Urban Autonomy in a Nomadic Environment", JNES32, 201-215.
54.
1976 a "Dimorphic Structure and Topology", OrAn 15, 17-31.
55.
1976b "Dimorphic Structure and the Problem of the 'Apirû - 'Ibrîm ", JNES35, 13-20.
56.
Schmid, H.H.Der sogenannte Jahwist: Beobachtungen und Fragen 1976 zur Pentateuchforschung ( Theologischer Verlag, Zurich).
57.
Seters, J. Van Abraham in History and Tradition (Yale U. Press, 1975New Haven).
58.
Smith, M. "The Present State of Old Testament Studies", 1969 JBL 88, 19-35.
59.
Smith, P.E L. "Land-Use, Settlement Patterns, and Subsistence 1972 Agriculture: a Demographic Perspective ", Man, Settlement and Urbanism, ed. G.W. Dimbleby et alii (Duckworth, London), 409-426.
60.
Thompson, Th.L. "The Joseph and Moses Narratives. 4: The & Irvin, D. Narratives about the Origin of Israel", Israel-1977 ite and Judaean History, ed. by J.H. Hayes and J.M. Miller (Westminster Press, Philadelphia), 210-212.
61.
Thompson, Th.L.The Historicity of the Patriarchal Narratives: 1974 the Quest for the Historical Abraham, BZAW133 ( de Gruyter, Berlin).
62.
1975 The Settlement of Sinai and the Negev in the Bronze Age, BTAVO, Reihe B, Nr. 8 (Dr. Reichert Verlag, Wiesbaden).
63.
1977 a "The Joseph and Moses Narratives. 1: Historical Reconstructions of the Narratives", Israelite and Judaean History, ed. by J.H. Hayes and J.M. Miller (Westminster Press, Philadelphia ), 149-166.
64.
1977 b "The Joseph and Moses Narratives. 2: The Joseph-Moses Traditions and Pentateuchal Criticism", Israelite and Judaean History , ed. by J.H. Hayes and J.M. Miller (Westminster Press, Philadelphia), 167-180.
65.
1978a "A new Attempt to Date the Patriarchal Narratives", JAOS98, 76-84.
66.
1978b "Historical Notes on 'Israel's Conquest of Palestine: A Peasant Rebellion'", JSOT7, 20-27.
67.
1978c The Settlement of Palestine in the Bronze Age, BTAVO, Riehe B (Dr. Reichert Verlag, Wiesbaden), in press.
68.
1979 "The Jacob-Esau Conflict Narratives", Semeia, in press.
69.
Tringham, R. "Introduction: Settlement Patterns and Urban-1972 ization", Man, Settlement, and Urbanism, ed. by G.W. Dimbleby et alii (Duckworth, London), xix-xxviii.
70.
de Vaux, R.Histoire ancienne d'Israël I, II (Gabalda, 1971/ 1974Paris).
71.
Weidmann, H.Die Patriarchen und ihre Religion im Licht der 1968 Forschung seit Julius Wellhausen, FRLANT 94.
72.
Weippert, M.Die Landnahme der israelitischen Stämme in der 1967 neueren wissenschaftlichen Diskussion (Vandenhoeck and Ruprecht, Göttingen)- Engl: The Settlement of the Israelite Tribes in Palestine: A Critical Study of Recent Scholarly Debate, SBT II/21, 1971.
73.
Wittfogel, K.A. "Developmental Aspects of Hydraulic Societies", 1971Prehistoric Agriculture, ed. by S. Struever (Nat Hist Press, Garden City), 557-571.
74.
Young T.C. Jr. "Population Densities and Early Mesopotamian 1972 Urbanism", Man, Settlement, and Urbanism ed. G.W. Dimbleby et alii (Duckworth, London), 827-842.
