This study applies one phase of the structural semiotic analysis refined by J.
Calloud from the work of A. Greimas to the story of Judah and Tamar in Genesis 38.
The work focuses on the analytical steps making up the morphological analysis of the
text, addressing the patterns, or structures, underlying the level of narrative
plot. Morphological analysis is concerned with finding the tension between the
positive and negative narrative programs embodiedin the text, thereby revealing
cultural values embedded in the narrative.Aspects of the biblical view of coercion
are thus revealed by this analysis.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Ackerman, J.S.1982‘Joseph, Judah, and Jacob’, in
K.R. Gros Louis
and
J.S. Ackerman
(eds.), Literary Interpretations of Biblical Narratives (2 vols.;
The Bible in Literature Courses;
Nashville: Abingdon Press
): II, 85-113.
2.
Alter, R.1981The Art of Biblical Narrative (
New York: Basic Books
).
3.
Alter, R.1983‘How Convention Helps Us Read: The Case of the Bible’s
Annunciation Type-Scene’
, Prooftexts3 (May):
115-130
.
4.
Alter, R.1985The Art of Biblical Poetry (
New York: Basic Books
).
5.
Alter, R.
(trans.) 1996Genesis (
New York: W.W. Norton
).
6.
Bal, M.1987Lethal Love: Literary Feminist Interpretations of Biblical Love-Stories (
Bloomington: Indiana University Press
).
7.
Bal, M.1988aDeath and Dissymmetry: The Politics of Coherence in the Book of Judges (
Chicago: Chicago University Press
).
8.
Bal, M.1988bNarratology: Introduction to the Theory of Narrative (
Toronto: University of Toronto Press
).
9.
Bal, M.1992a‘Lots of Writing’
, Semeia54:
77-102
.
10.
Bal, M.1992bMurder and Difference: Gender, Genre, and Scholarship on Sisera’s
Death (trans. M. Gumpert;
Bloomington: Indiana University Press
).
11.
Bal, M.
(ed.) 1989Anti-Covenant: Counter-Reading Women’s Lives in the Hebrew
Bible (JSOTSup, 81; Bible and Literature Series, 22;
Sheffield: Almond Press
).
12.
Baldick, C.1990The Concise Oxford Dictionary of Literary Terms (
Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press
): 112-112.
13.
Bird, P.1989‘“To Play the Harlot”: An Inquiry into an Old
Testament Metaphor’, in
P.L. Day
(ed.), Gender and Difference in Ancient Israel (
Minneapolis: Augsburg/Fortress Press
): 75-94.
14.
Bodine, W.R.
(ed.) 1995Discourse Analysis of Biblical Literature: What It is and What It Offers
(Society of Biblical Literature Semeia Studies;
Atlanta: Scholars Press
).
15.
Bowman, R.G.
, and
R.W. Swanson1997‘Samson and the Son of God, or Dead Heroes and Dead Goats:
Ethical Readings of Narrative Violence in Judges and Matthew’
, Semeia77:
59-73
.
16.
Brenner, A.
, and
C. Fontaine
(eds.) 1997A Feminist Companion to Reading the Bible: Approaches, Methods and
Strategies (Feminist Companion to the Bible, 11;
Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press
).
17.
Brettler, M.Z.1995The Creation of History in Ancient Israel (
London: Routledge
).
18.
Burgess, P.G.1968‘The Rhetoric of Black Power; A Moral Demand?’
, The Quarterly Journal of Speech54 (April):
122-133
.
19.
Burgess, P.G.1970‘The Rhetoric of Moral Conflict: Two Critical Dimensions’
, The Quarterly Journal of Speech56 (April):
120-130
.
20.
Burgess, P.G.1973‘Crisis Rhetoric: Coercion Vs. Force’
, The Quarterly Journal of Speech59 (February):
61-73
.
21.
CADIR (Centre pour l’Analyse du Discours Religieux) 1979
Analyse Semiotique Des Textes: Introduction, Theorie, Pratique (Lyon:
Presses Universitaires de Lyon).
22.
Calloud, J.1976Structural Analysis of Narrative (trans. D. Patte;
Philadelphia: Fortress Press
).
23.
Calloud, J.1979‘A Few Comments on Structural Semiotics: A Brief Review of a
Method and Some Explanation of Procedures’
(trans. J.C. Kirby), Semeia15:
51-83
.
24.
Cazelles, H.1962‘Connexions et Structure de Gen XV’
, RB69:
321-349
.
25.
Colapietro, V.M.1993Glossary of Semiotics (
New York: Paragon House
).
26.
Crownfield, D.
(ed.) 1992Body/Text in Julia Kristeva: Religion, Women, and Psychoanalysis (
Albany: tate University of New York Press
).
27.
Eco, U.1979A Theory of Semiotics (Advances in Semiotics;
Bloomington: Indiana University Press
[first published 1976]).
28.
Eisenbaum, P.1997The Jewish Heroes of Christian History (SBLMS;
Atlanta: Scholars Press
).
29.
Enelow, H.G.
(ed.) 1933The Mishnah of Rabbi Eliezer, or the Midrash of Thirty-Two Hermeneutic
Rules (
New York: Block Publishing
) (in Hebrew, with an English introduction).
30.
Exum, J.C.
, and
D.J.A. Clines
(eds.) 1993The New Literary Criticism and the Hebrew Bible (JSOTSup, 143;
Sheffield: JSOT Press
).
31.
Fewell, D.N.1987‘Feminist Reading of the Hebrew Bible: Affirmation, Resistance
and Transformation’
, JSOT39:
77-87
.
32.
Fewell, D.N.
(ed.) 1992Reading Between Texts: Intertextuality and the Hebrew Bible (Literary
Currents in Biblical Interpretation;
Louisville, KY: Westminster/John Knox Press
).
33.
Fewell, D.N.
, and
D.M. Gunn1990Compromising Redemption: Relating Characters in the Book of Ruth
(Literary Currents in Biblical Interpretation;
Louisville, KY: Westminster/John Knox Press
).
34.
Fewell, D.N.
, and
D.M. Gunn1993Gender, Power and Promise: The Subject of the Bible’s First
Story (
Nashville: Abingdon Press
).
35.
Fishbane, M.1985Biblical Interpretation in Ancient Israel (
Oxford: Oxford University Press
).
36.
Fokkelman, J.P.1996‘Genesis 37 and 38 at the Interface of Structural Analysis and
Hermeneutics’, in
L. de Regt
,
J. de Waard
and
J.P. Fokkelman
(eds.), Literary Structure and Rhetorical Strategies in the Hebrew
Bible (
Assen: Van Gorcum
):152-187.
37.
Friedman, M.A.1990‘Tamar, A Symbol of Life: The “Killer Wife”
Superstition in the Bible and Jewish Tradition’
, AJS Review15 (Spring):
23-61
.
38.
Ginsberg, H.L.1969‘A Strand in the Cord of Hebrew Hymnody’,
Eretz-Israel (The Albright Volume): 45-50.
39.
Granowski, J.J.1992‘Jehoiachin at the King’s Table: A Reading of the Ending of
the Second Book of Kings’, in
Fewell
(ed.) 1992: 173-188.
40.
Greenspahn, F.E.1994When Brothers Dwell Together: The Preeminence of Younger Siblings in the Hebrew
Bible (
New York: Oxford University Press
).
41.
Greenstein, E.L.1990‘The Formation of the Biblical Narrative Corpus’
, AJS Review15.2:
151-178
.
42.
Greenstein, E.L.1998‘“An Eye for an Eye, a Tooth for a Tooth”:
Peshat, Derash and the Question of their Connection’
, Resling5 (Summer):
31-34
(Hebrew).
43.
Greenstein, E.L.2000‘Recovering “The Women Who Served at the
Entrance”’, in
Gershon Galil and Moshe Weinfeld
(eds.), Studies in Historical Geography and Biblical Historiography,
Presented to Zecharia Kalli (
Leiden: E.J. Brill
): 165-173.
44.
Greimas, A.J.1983Structural Semantics: An Attempt at a Method (Introduction D. McDowell;
trans. R. Schleifer and D. McDowell;
Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press
).
45.
Greimas, A.J.1987On Meaning: Selected Writings in Semiotic Theory (introduction by P.J.
Perron; foreword by F. Jameson; trans. P.J. Perron and F.H. Collins; Theory and
History of Literature, 38;
Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press
).
46.
Greimas, A.J.
, and
J. Courtés 1982 Semiotics and Language: An Analytical Dictionary
(trans. L. Crist et al.; Advances in Semiotics;
Bloomington: Indiana University Press
).
47.
Gunn, D.M.1974‘Narrative Patterns and Oral Tradition in Judges and Samuel’
, VT24:
286-317
.
48.
Gunn, D.M.1976‘Traditional Composition in the “Succession Narrative”’
, VT26:
214-229
.
49.
Gunn, D.M.1978The Story of King David: Genre and Interpretation (JSOTSup, 6;
Sheffield: The University of Sheffield Press
).
50.
Gunn, D.M.1980The Fate of King Saul (JSOTSup, 14;
Sheffield: JSOT Press
).
51.
Hartman, G.H.
, and
S. Budick
(eds.) 1986Midrash and Literature (
New Haven: Yale University Press
).
52.
Hawthorn, J.1992A Concise Glossary of Contemporary Literary Theory (
London: Edward Arnold
).
53.
Jobling, D.1980‘“The Jordan a Boundary”: A Reading of Numbers
32 and Joshua 22’, in
P.J. Achtemeier
(ed.), Society of Biblical Literature 1980 Seminar Papers (
Chico, CA: Society of Biblical
Literature/Scholars Press
): 183-207.
54.
Jobling, D.1987The Sense of Biblical Narrative: Structural Analyses in the Hebrew Bible,
II (JSOTSup, 39;
Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press
).
55.
Jobling, D.1995‘Structuralist Criticism: The Text’s World of
Meaning’, in
G.A. Yee
(ed.), Judges and Method: New Approaches in Biblical Studies (
Minneapolis:Fortress Press
): 91-118.
56.
Johnson, M.1969The Purpose of the Biblical Genealogies with Special Reference to the Setting
of the Genealogies of Jesus (NTSMS, 8;
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
).
57.
Kessler, G.L.1994‘Intersexuality and the Reading of Talmudic Culture: [Review of]
Daniel Boyarin, Carnal Israel: Reading Sex in Talmudic Culture’
, Arachnē1.2:
238-252
.
58.
Koehler, L.
, and
W. Baumgartner1994–2000The Hebrew and Aramaic Lexicon of the Old Testament (trans. M.
Richardson; 5 vols.;
Leiden: E.J. Brill
).
59.
Kristeva, J.1986‘Word, Dialogue and Novel’, in
T. Moi
(ed.), The Kristeva Reader (
New York: Columbia University Press
): 34-61.
60.
Kunin, S.D.1995The Logic of Incest: A Structuralist Analysis of Hebrew Mythology
(JSOTSup, 185;
Sheffield: JSOT Press
).
61.
Landes, A.1980‘New Light on the Patriarchal Narratives’, in
Samuel Friedland Lectures, 1975–1980 (
New York: Jewish Theological Seminary of America
): 31-42.
62.
Levenson, J.D.1993The Death and Resurrection of the Beloved Son: The Transformation of Child
Sacrifice in Judaism and Christianity (
New Haven: Yale University Press
).
63.
Lévi-Strauss, C.1972‘The Structural Study of Myth’, in
T.A. Sebeok
(ed.), Myth: A Symposium (
Bloomington: Indiana University Press
[first published 1955]): 81-106.
64.
Marcus, D.1986‘David the Deceiver and David the Dupe’
, Prooftexts6:
163-171
.
65.
Meyers, C.1988Discovering Eve: Ancient Israelite Women in Context (
New York: Oxford University Press
).
66.
Niditch, S.1979‘The Wronged Woman Righted: An Analysis of Genesis 38’
, HTR72:
143-149
.
67.
Olrik, A.1965‘Epic Laws of Folk Narrative’, in
A. Dundes
(ed.), The Study of Folklore (
Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice–Hall
): 129-141.
68.
O’Neill, P.1996Fictions of Discourse: Reading Narrative Theory (
Toronto: University of Toronto Press
, repr. [1994]).
69.
Patte, D.1990The Religious Dimensions of Biblical Texts: Griemas’s Structural
Semiotics and Biblical Exegesis (Society of Biblical Literature Semeia Studies;
Atlanta: Scholars Press
).
70.
Patte, D.
(ed.) 1998Thinking in Signs: Semiotics and Biblical Studies: Thirty Years After
(Semeia, 81;
Atlanta: Society of Biblical Literature
).
71.
Polzin, R.1989Samuel and the Deuteronomist: A Literary Study of the Deuteronomic History,
Part Two: I Samuel (
New York: Harper & Row
).
72.
Propp, V.1968Morphology of the Folktale (ed. and Preface
L.A. Wagner
; trans. L. Scott; Introduction S. Pirkova-Jakobson; New Introduction A.
Dundes;
Austin:University of Texas Press
, 2nd edn).
73.
Prouser, O.H. 1991 ‘The Phenomenology of the Lie in Biblical
Narrative’ (PhD dissertation, Graduate School of the Jewish Theological
Seminary of America).
74.
Rendsburg, G.1986‘David and His Circle in Genesis 38’
, VT36:
438-446
.
75.
Savran, G.1988Telling and Retelling: Quotation in Biblical Narrative (Indiana Studies
in Biblical Literature;
Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana
University Press
).
76.
Savran, G.1994‘Beastly Speech: Intertextuality, Balaam’s Ass and the
Garden of Eden’
, JSOT64:
33-55
.
77.
Sharon, D.M.2002Patterns of Destiny: Narrative Structures of Foundation and Doom in the Hebrew
Bible (
Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns
).
78.
Swartley, W.M.1994Israel’s Scripture Traditions and the Synoptic Gospels: Story Shaping
Story (
Peabody, MA: Hendrickson
).
79.
Syren, R.1993The Forsaken First-Born: A Study of a Recurrent Motif in the Patriarchal
Narratives (JSOTSup, 133;
Sheffield: JSOT Press
).
80.
Trask, R.L.1993A Dictionary of Grammatical Terms in Linguistics (
London: Routledge
).
81.
Trible, P.1978God and the Rhetoric of Sexuality (Overtures to Biblical Theology;
Philadelphia: Fortress Press
).
82.
Wander, N.1973‘Structure, Contradiction and “Resolution” in
Mythology: Father’s Brother’s Daughter Marriage and the
Treatment of Women in Genesis 11–50’
,JANESCU5:
75-99
.
83.
Wolde, E. van1989A Semiotic Analysis of Genesis 2–3: A Semiotic Theory and Method of
Analysis Applied to the Story of the Garden of Eden (Studia Semitica
Neerlandica;
Assen: Van Gorcum
).
84.
Zakovitch, Y.1991‘And You Shall Tell Your Son…’: The Concept of
the Exodus in the Bible (
Jerusalem: Magnes Press
).
