Quantitative and qualitative outcomes of Non-Violent Resistance interventions for children and adolescents with emotional and behavioural difficulties and their caregivers

Abstract

Background

Non-Violent Resistance (NVR) is an approach of parent training developed to respond to child behavioural difficulties including aggression and risk-taking behaviours. NVR is offered in child and adolescent mental health services across Europe. There has been no published systematic review exploring the effectiveness of this intervention to date. We therefore aimed to examine the outcomes of NVR training for children, adolescents and their caregivers.

Methods

A systematic literature search was conducted using multiple databases. Critical appraisal skills programme checklists were used to appraise the quality of studies.

Results

We identified five randomised controlled trials, two simple ‘before and after’ studies, two qualitative studies, one study reporting mixed outcomes and nine articles including case reports. A range of different outcome measures were reported. Overall, the review suggests that NVR shows promise in improving parent-reported child behavioural difficulties, such as externalising symptoms. There is also evidence of improvement in areas of parents’ helplessness, stress and behaviours. However, it is unclear if these outcomes are maintained in the longer term.

Conclusions

Overall, the evidence base for NVR is relatively limited, especially for informing service provision and commissioning decisions. Further research with RCTs, larger sample sizes and longer follow-up is required to enhance the evidence base.

Plain language summary

Non-Violent Resistance (NVR) is a parent training programme that was developed to enable parents and carers to respond constructively towards their child’s challenging behaviours. NVR is offered by some child and adolescent mental health services across Europe. There have been no published reviews of literature exploring the benefits of this intervention so far. In our research, we have analysed the outcomes of NVR training for parents and other carers, such as foster carers. A systematic literature search was completed, and 19 published articles were included in the review. The outcomes from the review were variable. Overall, the review suggests that NVR shows promise in improving parent-reported child behavioural difficulties, such as aggression and self-harm. There is also evidence of improvement in areas of parents’ feelings of helplessness and levels of stress. However, it is unclear if these improvements are maintained over the years. Overall, the existing research for NVR is relatively limited, especially in regard to designing service delivery and interventions. Further research with robust methodology, larger sample sizes and longer follow-up is required to enhance the evidence base.

Keywords

non-violent non-violent resistance NVR CAMHS new authority

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adoption UK (2019) The Adoption Barometer . Banbury: Adoption UK.

Attwood

Butler

Rogers

Batterham

Cousins

Wilson

(2020) Non Violent Resistance parent training and adolescent substance misuse. Journal of Family Therapy 42(2): 222–251.

Barlow

Coren

(2018) The effectiveness of parenting programs: A review of Campbell reviews. Research on Social Work Practice 28(1): 99–102.

Brennan

Burnley

Cutmore

, et al (2022) Comprehensive Needs Assessment of Child/Adolescent to Parent Violence and Abuse in London: Final report. London's Violence Reduction Unit.

Carr

(2014) The evidence base for family therapy and systemic interventions for child-focused problems. Journal of Family Therapy 36(2): 107–157.

Cohen-Yeshurun

(2001) The Relationship Between Parental Helplessness, Parental Self-Efficacy and Parental Authority Styles . Unpublished master’s thesis (in Hebrew), Tel Aviv University.

Coogan

(2014) Responding to child-to-parent violence: Innovative practices in child and adolescent mental health. Health & Social Work 39(2): 1–9.

Coogan

(2018) Child to Parent Violence and Abuse: Family interventions with non-violent resistance. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.

Coogan

Lauster

(2014) Restoring competence and confidence – non-violent resistance as a response to child-to-parent violence in Ireland. Context – Magazine for Family Therapy and Systemic Practice in the UK 132(April): 29–31.

10.

Coogan

Lauster

(2015) Non Violent Resistance Handbook for Practitioners: Responding to child to parent violence in practice. Galway: National University of Ireland.

11.

Crijnen

Alfons AM

Achenbach

Verhulst

Frank C

(1999) Problems reported by parents of children in multiple cultures: The Child Behavior Checklist syndrome constructs. American Journal of Psychiatry 156(4): 569–574.

12.

Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP) (2024) CASP Checklists. Available at: casp-uk.net/casp-tools-checklists/

13.

Dalrymple

McKenna Maxwell

Russell

Duthie

(2020) NICE guideline review: Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder: Diagnosis and management (NG87). Archives of Disease in Childhood – Education & Practice Edition 105(5): 289–293.

14.

Dean

Myors

Evans

(2003) Community-wide implementation of a parenting program: The south east Sydney positive parenting project. Australian e-Journal for the Advancement of Mental Health 2(3): 179–190.

15.

Dyrborg

Warborg Larsen

Nielsen

Byman

Buhl Nielsen

Gautre-Delay

(2000) The Children's Global Assessment Scale (CGAS) and Global Assessment of Psychosocial Disability (GAPD) in clinical practice – Substance and reliability as judged by intraclass correlations. European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry 9(3): 195–201.

16.

Freedland

Mohr

Davidson

Schwartz

(2011) Usual and unusual care: Existing practice control groups in randomized controlled trials of behavioral interventions. Psychosomatic Medicine 73(4): 323–335.

17.

Gallego

Novo

Fariña

Arce

(2018) Child-to-parent violence and parent-to-child violence: A meta-analytic review. The European Journal of Psychology Applied to a Legal Context 11(2): 51–59.

18.

Gandhi

(2004) Nonviolence as a comprehensive philosophy. Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psychology 10(1): 87–90.

19.

Gershy

Meehan

Omer

Papouchis

Sapir

(2017) Randomized clinical trial of mindfulness skills augmentation in parent training. Child & Youth Care Forum 46(6): 783–803.

20.

Jakob

(2011) Re-connecting parents and young people with serious behaviour problems: Child-focused practice and reconciliation work in nonviolent resistance therapy. New Authority Network International. Zugriff am 31(12): 2012–2050.

21.

Kelly

Coogan

(2020) Restoring the parental position in the face of emerging childhood challenges with non-violent resistance. Journal of family Therapy Association of Ireland (Winter 2020): 65–82.

22.

Lauster

Quinn

Brosnahan

Coogan

(2014) Practical strategies for coping with child-to-parent violence: The non-violent resistance programme in practice. Irish Probation Journal 11: 208–221.

23.

Lavi-Levavi

Shachar

Omer

(2013) Training in nonviolent resistance for parents of violent children: Differences between fathers and mothers. Journal of Systemic Therapies 32(4): 79–93.

24.

Mulder

Singh

Hamilton

Das

Outhred

Morris

Bassett

Baune

Berk

Boyce

Lyndon

(2018) The limitations of using randomised controlled trials as a basis for developing treatment guidelines. Evidence-Based Mental Health 21(1): 4–6.

25.

Newman

Fagan

Webb

(2014) Innovations in practice: The efficacy of nonviolent resistance groups in treating aggressive and controlling children and young people: A preliminary analysis of pilot NVR groups in Kent. Child and Adolescent Mental Health 19(2): 138–141.

26.

Ollefs

Von Schlippe

Omer

Kriz

(2009) Jugendliche mit externalem problemverhalten: Effekte von elterncoaching. Familiendynamik 34(3): 256–265.

27.

Omer

(n.d.) The NVR Approach. Available at: www.haimomer-nvr.com/nvr-approach

28.

Omer

(2001) Helping parents deal with children’s acute disciplinary problems without escalation: The principle of nonviolent resistance. Family Process 40(1): 53–66.

29.

Omer

(2021) Non-Violent Resistance: A new approach to violent and self-destructive children. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

30.

Omer

Lebowitz

(2016) Nonviolent resistance: Helping caregivers reduce problematic behaviors in children and adolescents. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy 42(4): 688–700.

31.

Omer

Schorr-Sapir

Weinblatt

(2008) Non-violent resistance and violence against siblings. Journal of Family Therapy 30(4): 450–464.

32.

Page

McKenzie

Bossuyt

Boutron

Hoffman

Mulrow

Shamseer

Tetzlaff

et al. (2021) The PRISMA 2020 statement: An updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. International Journal of Surgery 88: article no. 105906.

33.

Partnership Projects (n.d.) Homepage. Available at: www.partnershipprojectsuk.com/

34.

Patterson

(1980) Mothers: The unacknowledged victims. Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development 45(5): 1–64.

35.

Samuel

Holdaway

Vella

(2022) How do adoptive mothers make sense of their experiences of using non-violent resistance therapy with their children? An interpretative phenomenological analysis. Adoption & Fostering 46(3): 247–267.

36.

Schorr-Sapir

Gershy

Apter

Omer

(2022) Parent training in non-violent resistance for children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder: A controlled outcome study. European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry 31(6): 929–938.

37.

Sharp

(1973) The Politics of Nonviolent Action: Vol. 1–3. Boston, MA: Profiter Sargent.

38.

Sharp

Paulson

(2005) Waging Nonviolent Struggle: 20th century practice and 21st century potential. Boston, MA: Extending Horizon Books.

39.

Shimshoni

Omer

Lebowitz

(2022) Non-violent resistance and family accommodation: A trans-diagnostic solution to a highly prevalent problem. Family Process 61(1): 43–57.

40.

Van Holen

Vanderfaeillie

Omer

(2016) Adaptation and evaluation of a nonviolent resistance intervention for foster parents: A progress report. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy 42(2): 256–271.

41.

Van Holen

Vanderfaeillie

Omer

Vanschoonlandt

(2018) Training in nonviolent resistance for foster parents: A randomized controlled trial. Research on Social Work Practice 28(8): 931–942.

42.

Van Leeuwen

Vermulst

(2004) Some psychometric properties of the Ghent Parental Behavior Scale. European Journal of Psychological Assessment 20(4): 283–298.

43.

Weinblatt

Omer

(2008) Nonviolent resistance: A treatment for parents of children with acute behavior problems. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy 34(1): 75–92.

44.

Wels

Robbroeckx

LMH

(1996) Nijmeegse vragenlijst voor de opvoedingssituatie: NVOS. Lisse, Zuid-Holland: Swets & Zeitlinger.

45.

Wilson

Smith

(2014) The unmet needs of the child in non-violent resistance: Integrating developmental-dyadic-psychotherapy approaches – lessons from working with adoptive families. Context – Magazine for Family Therapy and Systemic Practice in the UK 132(April): 22–26.

46.

Wolraich

Hagan Jr

Allan

Chan

Davison

Earls

Evans

Flinn

et al. (2019) Clinical practice guideline for the diagnosis, evaluation, and treatment of attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder in children and adolescents. Pediatrics 144(4): article no. e20192528.

47.

Zarakoviti

Shafran

Papadimitriou

Bennett

(2021) The efficacy of parent training interventions for disruptive behavior disorders in treating untargeted comorbid internalizing symptoms in children and adolescents: A systematic review. Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review 24(3): 542–552.

Quantitative and qualitative outcomes of Non-Violent Resistance interventions for children and adolescents with emotional and behavioural difficulties and their caregivers – A systematic review

Abstract

Background

Methods

Results

Conclusions

Plain language summary

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References