Financializing urban infrastructure? The speculative state-spaces of ‘public-public partnerships’ in Jakarta

Abstract

Mega city-regions in the global South facing challenges posed by rapid urbanization have turned to infrastructural solutions, steeped in speculative ‘global-city’ imaginaries and national developmental aspirations, in order to unclog catch-up growth. This infrastructural imperative for growth reflects a broader infrastructure fix, as creditor states and development banks with geopolitical and geoeconomic interests advance competing market-based and state-led models to finance and develop infrastructure. In Jakarta, Indonesia, I examine the coming together of these models as they articulate with the political-economies of city and state, and their path-dependent restructuring following the 1997 Asian Financial Crisis. In Jakarta's speculative state-space political interests and developmental objectives of state and city governments are entangled with the capital accumulation strategies of State-Owned Enterprises. With a number of rail transit projects in the city-region driving a boom in Transit-Oriented Development, State-Owned Enterprises speculate on market conditions and the ‘world-class city’ dreams of middle-class residents to leverage their property assets. This financial speculation is equally premised on political speculation around the planning and execution of infrastructure projects, framed by the developmental politics of affordability and accessibility to the city. I examine how these strategies, practices and tensions come together to produce innovative governance arrangements in the provision and management of transport and housing through Public-Public Partnerships.

Keywords

Speculative urbanism infrastructure state-spaces financialization state-capitalism

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adhi

Karya

(2009) Laporan Keuangan Konsolidasian PT Adhi Karya. Available at: https://adhi.co.id/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/fr-adhi-1q10_5a31aee433bd15b27afad6921f7d1d77842d0c44.pdf (accessed 9 March 2021).

Adhi

Karya

(2021) Continuous value creation for the nation amid the challenges: annual report. Available at: https://adhi.co.id/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/AR_ADHI_2021.pdf (accessed 1 July 2022).

Alami

Dixon

Mawdsley

(2021) State capitalism and the new global D/development regime. Antipode 53(5): 1294–1318.

Altshuler

Luberoff

(2003) Mega-Projects: The Changing Politics of Urban Public Investment. Washington D.C: Brookings Institution Press.

Amianti

Amin

(2015) State banks secure $3b from China Development Bank. The Jakarta Post Available at: https://www.thejakartapostcom/news/2015/09/17/state-banks-secure-3b-china-development-bank.html (accessed 9 March 2021).

Anguelov

(2021) Banking development: The geopolitical-economy of infrastructure financing. Area Development and Policy 6(3): 271–295.

Anguelov

Leitner

Sheppard

(2018) Engineering the financialization of urban entrepreneurialism: The JESSICA urban development initiative in the European Union. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 42(4): 573–593.

Asian Development Bank (2009) Proposed loan and equity investment republic of indonesia: indonesian infrastructure financing facility company project.

Aspinall

(2013) A nation in fragments: Patronage and neoliberalism in contemporary Indonesia. Critical Asian Studies 45(1): 27–54.

10.

Aspinall

(2016) The new nationalism in Indonesia. Asia and the Pacific Policy Studies 3(1): 72–82.

11.

Baindur

Kamath

(2009) Reengineering urban infrastructure: how the world bank and asian development bank shape urban infrastructure finance and governance in India. World Bank 53.

12.

Brenner

(2004) New State Spaces. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

13.

Brenner

Peck

Theodore

(2010) Variegated neoliberalization: Geographies, modalities. Pathways. Global Networks 10(2): 182–222.

14.

Carroll

(2010) Delusions of Development: The World Bank and the Post-Washington Consensus in Southeast Asia. London: Palgrave Macmillan.

15.

Carroll

Jarvis

(eds) (2014) The Politics of Marketising Asia. London, Palgrave Macmillan. 10.1057/9781137001672

16.

Davidson

(2015) Indonesia’s Changing Political Economy: Governing the Roads. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

17.

Doshi

(2019) The redevelopmental state: Governing surplus life and land in the ‘urban age.’. Development and Change 50(3): 679–706.

18.

Doucette

Park

B-G

(2018) Urban developmentalism in East Asia: Geopolitical economies, spaces of exception, and networks of expertise. Critical Sociology 44(3): 395–403.

19.

Dubash

Morgan

(2013) The Rise of the Regulatory State of the South: Infrastructure and Development in Emerging Economies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

20.

Febrina

, 2009. Actors and technology in the shaping of urban transport network in Jakarta, Indonesia . Technische Universität Berlin, Germany: Master Thesis.

21.

Girianna

, 1995. Privatization of Jabotabek mass rapid transit project . Unpublished Thesis. Massachusetts Institute of Technology.

22.

Goldman

(2011) Speculative urbanism and the making of the next world city: Speculative urbanism in Bangalore.”. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 35(3): 555–581.

23.

Graham

Marvin

(2001) Splintering Urbanism: Networked Infrastructures, Technological Mobilities and the Urban Condition. London: Routledge.

24.

Haila

(2016) Urban Land Rent: Singapore as a Property State. Oxford: Wiley Blackwell.

25.

Hall

Jonas

(2014) Urban fiscal austerity, infrastructure provision and the struggle for regional transit in ‘motor city.’. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society 7(1): 189–206.

26.

Harvey

(1985) The Urbanization of Capital. Oxford: Johns Hopkins Press.

27.

Harvey

(1989) From managerialism to entrepreneurialism: The transformation in urban governance in late capitalism. Geografiska Annaler. Series B, Human Geography. 71(1): 3–17.

28.

Herlambang

Leitner

Ju Tjung

, et al. (2019) Jakarta’s great land transformation: Hybrid neoliberalisation and informality. Urban Studies 56(4): 627–648.

29.

Hill

Park

Saito

(2012) Introduction: Locating neoliberalism in East Asia. In: Park

Hill

Saito

(eds) Locating neoliberalism in East Asia: neoliberalizing spaces in developmental states. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, pp.1–26.

30.

Horn

(2013) Jakarta’s airport rail link: Clyde & Co on the key issues coming down the line. Clyde & Co . Available at: https://www.clydeco.com/clyde/media/fileslibrary/Admin/Jakartas_Airport_Rail_Link_-_full_report_2.pdf (accessed 9 March 2021).

31.

Huat

(2016) State-owned enterprises, state capitalism and social distribution in Singapore. The Pacific Review 29(4): 499–521.

32.

Hudson

(2016) Rising powers and the drivers of uneven global development. Area Development and Policy 1(3): 279–294.

33.

The Jakarta Post (1996) Bimantara boss joins US$1.5b MRT project. Available at: https://jawawa.id/newsitem/bimantara-boss-joins-us15b-mrt-project-1447893297 (accessed 9 March 2021).

34.

The Jakarta Post (2003a) Mahathir supports monorail: Sutiyoso. Available at: https://jawawa.id/newsitem/mahathir-supports-monorail-sutiyoso-1447893297 (accessed 9 March 2021).

35.

The Jakarta Post (2003b) Performance bond dispute may thwart monorail. Available at: http://jawawa.id/index.php?id=1358754&topic=372754 (accessed 9 March 2021).

36.

The Jakarta Post (2003c) Sutiyoso to pursue US$400m monorail project. Available at: http://jawawa.id/index.php?id=1361141&topic=375141 (accessed 9 March 2021).

37.

The Jakarta Post (2004) City government mulls delaying monorail project. Available at: http://jawawa.id/index.php/newsitem/city-government-mulls-delaying-monorail-project-1447893297 (accessed 9 March 2021).

38.

The Jakarta Post (2005a) Internal disagreement stalls monorail project. Available at: http://jawawa.id/index.php/newsitem/internal-disagreement-stalls-monorail-project-1447893297 (accessed 9 March 2021).

39.

The Jakarta Post (2005b) Quo vadis, Jakarta monorail? Available at: https://jawawa.id/index.php/newsitem/quo-vadis-jakarta-monorail-1447893297 (accessed 9 March 2021).

40.

The Jakarta Post (2005c) Monorail project not viable now: Activists. Available at: http://jawawa.id/index.php?id=1166103&topic=180103 (accessed 9 March 2021).

41.

The Jakarta Post (2005d) Jakarta talks up long-stalled MRT project. Available at: https://jawawa.id/newsitem/jakarta-talks-up-long-stalled-mrt-project-1447893297 (accessed 9 March 2021).

42.

The Jakarta Post (2005e) Omnico quits monorail consortium, Sutiyoso says. Available at: http://jawawa.id/index.php?id=1157519&topic=171519 (accessed 9 March 2021).

43.

The Jakarta Post (2005f) Jakarta Monorail struggles to reach deal before deadline. Available at: http://jawawa.id/index.php/newsitem/jakarta-monorail-struggles-to-reach-deal-before-deadline-1447893297 (accessed 9 March 2021).

44.

Jaweng

(2014) Overcoming problems in new autonomy era. The Jakarta Post Available at: https://www.thejakartapostcom/news/2014/12/22/overcoming-problems-new-autonomy-era.html (accessed 9 March 2021).

45.

Jonas

Goetz

Brady

(2019) The global infrastructure public-private partnership and the extra-territorial politics of collective provision: The case of regional rail transit in Denver. USA. Urban Studies 56(7): 1426–1447.

46.

Jonas

Moisio

(2018) City regionalism as geopolitical processes: A new framework for analysis. Progress in Human Geography 42(3): 350–370.

47.

Jonas

Wilson

(2001) The Urban Growth Machine: Critical Perspectives Two Decades Later.

48.

Jones

Bloomfield

(2020) PPPs in China: Does the growth in Chinese PPPs signal a liberalising economy? New Political Economy 25(5): 829–847.

49.

Jones

(1998) Spatial selectivity of the state? The regulationist enigma and local struggles over economic governance. Environment and Planning A 29: 831–864.

50.

Kirkpatrick

Smith

(2011) The infrastructural limits to growth: Rethinking the urban growth machine in times of fiscal crisis: The urban growth machine in times of fiscal crisis. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 35(3): 477–503.

51.

Leitner

(1990) Cities in pursuit of economic growth. Political Geography Quarterly 9(2): 146–170.

52.

Leitner

Sheppard

(2016) Provincializing critical urban theory: Extending the ecosystem of possibilities. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 40(1): 228–235.

53.

Leitner

Sheppard

(2018) From kampungs to condos: Contested accumulations through displacement in Jakarta. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 50(2): 437–456.

54.

Lin

Smart

, et al. (2019) Financializing Chinese cities: State–capital nexus and the uneven geography of housing speculation. Area Development and Policy 4(4): 435–453.

55.

LRT City (2019) “We are not only building the LRT, but also developing the community” Available at: https://www.lrtcity.com/about (accessed 9 March 2021).

56.

Ministry of Finance (2011) Kajian Good governance Proyek-Proyek Infrastruktur. Available at: https://www.kemenkeu.go.id/sites/default/files/kajian%20good%20governance%20proyek-proyek%20infrastruktur.pdf (accessed 9 March 2021).

57.

Molotch

(1976) The city as a growth machine: Toward a political economy of place. American Journal of Sociology 82(2): 309–332.

58.

MRT Jakarta (2013) Shaping the milestone in Indonesian infrastructure the first of its kind. Annual Report. Available at: https://jakartamrt.co.id/sites/default/files/2020-07/Annual-Report-MRT-Jakarta-2013.pdf (accessed 9 March 2021).

59.

O’Brien

Pike

Tomaney

(2018) Governing the ‘ungovernable’? Financialisation and the governance of transport infrastructure in the London ‘global city-region’. Progress in Planning 132: 1–33.

60.

O’Neill

(2010) Infrastructure financing and operation in the contemporary city. Geographical Research 48(1): 3–12.

61.

Oxford Business Group (2007) Back on track? Available at: https://new.oxfordbusinessgroup.com/economic-articles/back-on-track-2/ (accessed 9 March 2021).

62.

Patunru

(2018) Rising economic nationalism in Indonesia. Journal of Southeast Asian Economies 35(3): 335–354.

63.

Peck

Theodore

(2007) Variegated capitalism Progress in Human Geography 31(6): 731–772.

64.

Peck

Zhang

(2013) A variety of capitalism … with Chinese characteristics? Journal of Economic Geography 13(3): 357–396.

65.

Pike

O’Brien

Strickland

, et al. (2019) Financializing city statecraft and infrastructure. Chelthenham: Edward Elgar.

66.

Rahardyan

(2020) Mantan direktur MRT jakarta pimpin perusahaan patungan PT MITJ. Bisnis.com . Available at: https://ekonomi.bisnis.com/read/20200311/98/1212184/mantan-direktur-mrt-jakarta-pimpin-perusahaan-patungan-pt-mitj (accessed 9 March 2021).

67.

Rahman

(2020) State-owned enterprises scramble to repay debts in time. The Jakarta Post Available at: https://www.thejakartapostcom/news/2020/05/14/state-owned-enterprises-scramble-to-repay-debts-in-time.html (accessed 9 March 2021).

68.

Robison

Hadiz

(2005) Reorganizing Power in Indonesia: The Politics of Oligarchy in an Age of Markets. London: Routledge.

69.

Roy

(2009) The 21st-century metropolis: New geographies of theory. Regional Studies 43(6): 819–830.

70.

Roy

(2011) Urbanisms, worlding practices and the theory of planning. Planning Theory 10(1): 6–15.

71.

Roy

(2014) Slum-Free cities of the Asian century: Postcolonial government and the project of inclusive growth. Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography 35(1): 136–150.

72.

Rukmana

(2015) The change and transformation of Indonesian spatial planning after Suharto’s new order regime: The case of the Jakarta metropolitan area. International Planning Studies 20(4): 350–370.

73.

Schindler

DiCarlo

Paudel

(2022) The new cold war and the rise of the 21st-century infrastructure state. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 47(2): 331–346.

74.

Schindler

Kanai

(2021) Getting the territory right: Infrastructure-led development and the re-emergence of spatial planning strategies. Regional Studies 55(1): 40–51.

75.

Shari

(1997) Icahn, Pickens, Goldsmith…Widjaja? A corporate maverick roils Jakarta with hostile takeovers. Bloomberg . Available at: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/1997-02-09/icahn-pickens-goldsmith-dot-dot-dot-widjaja-intl-edition (accessed 9 March 2021).

76.

Shatkin

(2014) Reinterpreting the meaning of the ‘Singapore model’: State capitalism and urban planning: The ‘Singapore model’ of state capitalism.”. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 38(1): 116–137.

77.

Shatkin

(2016) The real estate turn in policy and planning: Land monetization and the political economy of peri-urbanization in Asia. Cities (London, England) 53: 141–149.

78.

Shatkin

(2019) Financial sector actors, the state, and the rescaling of Jakarta’s extended urban region. Land Use Policy 112: 104159.

79.

Sheppard

(2011) Geographical political economy. Journal of Economic Geography 11(2): 319–331.

80.

Sheppard

(2015) Globalizing capitalism and southern urbanization. In: Parnell S and Oldfield S (eds) The Routledge Handbook on Cities of the Global South. London: Routledge, pp.143–154. 10.4324/9780203387832.ch15.

81.

Sheppard

(2019) Globalizing capitalism’s raggedy fringes: Thinking through Jakarta.”. Area Development and Policy 4(1): 1–27.

82.

Sheppard

Leitner

Peck

(2020) Doing urban studies: The methodological terrain. In: Leitner

Sheppard

Peck

(eds) Urban Studies Inside/Out: Theory, Method, Practice. London: Sage, pp.21–44.

83.

Shin

Kim

S-H

(2016) The developmental state, speculative urbanisation and the politics of displacement in gentrifying Seoul. Urban Studies 53(3): 540–559.

84.

Siemiatycki

(2013) The global production of transportation public–private partnerships. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 37(4): 1254–1272.

85.

Sikumbang

(2015) Kronologi pinjaman dari Tiongkok untuk 3 Bank BUMN. Antara News . Available at: https://www.antaranews.com/berita/520748/kronologi-pinjaman-dari-tiongkok-untuk-3-bank-bumn (accessed 9 March 2021).

86.

State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia (2014) Law of the Republic of Indonesia number 23 year 2014 about local government. Available at: https://peraturan.go.id/common/dokumen/ln/2014/uu23-2014bt.pdf (accessed 9 March 2021).

87.

Talitha

Firman

Hudalah

(2019) Welcoming two decades of decentralization in Indonesia: A regional development perspective. Territory, Politics. Governance 8(5): 1–19.

88.

Torrance

(2008) Forging glocal governance? Urban infrastructures as networked financial products. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 32(1): 1–21.

89.

United Nations. (2015). Addis Ababa Action Agenda. Third International Conference on Finance for Development. Available at: https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/2051AAAA_Outcome.pdf (accessed 9 March 2021).

90.

Van Klinken

Aspinall

(2011) Building relations: Corruption, competition and cooperation in the construction industry. In: Aspinall

Van Klinken

(eds) The State and Illegality in Indonesia. Leiden: KITLV Press, pp.139–163.

91.

Warburton

(2016) Jokowi and the new developmentalism. Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies 52(3): 297–320.

92.

Warburton

(2018) A new developmentalism in Indonesia? Journal of Southeast Asian Economies 35(3): 355–368.

93.

Wibowo

, 2015. A study on the implementation of Public-Private Partnership (PPP) in the socio-economic, political, cultural and Islamic context of Indonesia . PhD Thesis. Durham University.

94.

Wickasono

(2008) Indonesian State-Owned enterprises: The challenge of reform. Southeast Asian Affairs 2008(1): 146–167.

95.

Wijaya

Camba

(2021) The politics of public–private partnerships: state–capital relations and spatial fixes in Indonesia and the Philippines. Territory, Politics, Governance.

96.

Winarso

Firman

(2002) Residential land development in Jabotabek, Indonesia: Triggering economic crisis? Habitat International 26(4): 487–506.

97.

World Bank (2018) Infrastructure Sector Assessment Program, Indonesia 2018.

98.

(2018) Planning centrality, market instruments: Governing Chinese urban transformation under state entrepreneurialism. Urban Studies 55(7): 1383–1399.

99.

Lin

(2016) Reproducing the city of the spectacle: Mega-events, local debts, and infrastructure-led urbanization in China. Cities (London, England) 53: 51–60.

100.

Yeung

(2004) Chinese Capitalism in a Global Era: Towards hybrid capitalism. Routledge: New York.

101.

Yeung

(2017) Rethinking the east Asian developmental state in its historical context: Finance, geopolitics and bureaucracy. Area Development and Policy 2(1): 1–23.

102.

Younger

(2009) The monorail saga. GlobeAsia 193-194. Available at: http://glendalepartners.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/420646Article_S_Y_Globe-Asia_The-Monorail-Saga_-June-2009_.pdf (accessed 9 March 2021).