This paper explores the relationship between rescaling and the neoliberalization of water governance in the South–North Water Transfer Project. It demonstrates that the Chinese government has selectively adopted some neoliberal tools while rejecting others and dismissing the ideology of neoliberalism. These elements of neoliberalism are sometimes associated with the rescaling of water governance upward, downward, outward and inward. Rescaling has evolved expediently rather than through planned design, reflecting both the exigencies of practical problems and the legacies of bureaucratic power struggles. Market-friendly reforms enable more actors to bring environmental interests into state and market institutions, to form a closed network with policy-makers. The distinctive conflict between the actual existing selective neoliberalization and official discourses of anti-neoliberalization reflect the particularities of neoliberalization in China’s hydro-politics.
ApostolopoulouEBormpoudakisDPaloniemiR, et al. (2014)
Governance rescaling and the neoliberalization of nature: The case of biodiversity conservation in four EU countries.International Journal of Sustainable Development and World Ecology21: 481–494.
2.
Asian Development Bank (2006) Project Agreement for Henan Wastewater Management and Water Supply Sector Project between People’s Republic of China and ADB Dated 23 February 2006.
Manila:
Asian Development Bank.
3.
Asian Development Bank (2012) Project Agreement for Hai River Estuary Area Pollution Control and Ecosystem Rehabilitation Project.
Manila:
Asian Development Bank.
4.
AyersAJSaad-FilhoA (2015)
Democracy against neoliberalism: Paradoxes, limitations, transcendence.Critical Sociology41: 597–618.
5.
BakkerK (2005)
Neoliberalizing nature? Market environmentalism in water supply in England and Wales.Annals of the Association of American Geographers95: 542–565.
6.
BarnettJRogersSWebberM, et al. (2015)
Sustainability: Transfer project cannot meet China’s water needs.Nature527: 295–297.
7.
BayirbağMK (2013)
Continuity and change in public policy: Redistribution, exclusion and state rescaling in Turkey.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research37: 1123–1146.
8.
BiebricherT (2015)
Neoliberalism and democracy.Constellations22: 255–266.
9.
BoelensRHoogestegerJBaudM (2015)
Water reform governmentality in Ecuador: Neoliberalism, centralization, and the restraining of polycentric authority and community rule-making.Geoforum64: 281–291.
10.
BottelierP (2007)
China and the World Bank: How a partnership was built.Journal of Contemporary China16: 239–258.
11.
BradyAM (2017) China as A Polar Great Power.
Cambridge, UK:
Cambridge University Press.
12.
BrennerN (2004)
Urban governance and the production of new state spaces in Western Europe, 1960–2000.Review of International Political Economy11: 447–488.
13.
BrennerN (2009)
Open questions on state rescaling.Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society2: 123–139.
14.
BrennerNTheodoreN (2002)
Preface: From the “new localism” to the spaces of neoliberalism.Antipode34: 341–347.
15.
BrennerNPeckJTheodoreN (2010)
Variegated neoliberalization: Geographies, modalities, pathways. Global Networks10: 182–222.
16.
BrownW (2003)
Neo-liberalism and the end of liberal democracy. Theory & Event7: 1.
17.
BruffI (2014)
The rise of authoritarian neoliberalism.Rethinking Marxism26: 113–129.
18.
BuddsJHinojosaL (2012)
Restructuring and rescaling water governance in mining contexts: The co-production of waterscapes in Peru. Water Alternatives5: 119.
19.
BurnsSLKrottMSayadyanH, et al. (2017)
The World Bank improving environmental and natural resource policies: Power, deregulation, and privatization in (post-Soviet) Armenia.World Development92: 215–224.
20.
CahillDCooperMKoningsM, et al. (2018) The SAGE Handbook of Neoliberalism.
Thousand Oaks, CA:
SAGE.
21.
Caijing (2014) Who will operate the South-North Water Transfer Project: The Ministry of Water Resources and the Construction Committee Office of SNWTP Office have different opinions (南水北调谁来运营管理：水利部和南水北调办意见不一). Caijing (财经). Available at: http://finance.sina.com.cn/china/20140707/103419626950.shtml (accessed 29 July 2019).
22.
CashDAdgerWNBerkesF, et al. (2006)
Scale and cross-scale dynamics: Governance and information in a multilevel world.Ecology and Society11: 8.
23.
CastreeN (2003)
Commodifying what nature?Progress in Human Geography27: 273–297.
24.
CastreeN (2006)
From neoliberalism to neoliberalisation: Consolations, confusions, and necessary illusions.Environment and Planning A38: 1–6.
China Securities Journal (2014) The mode of public–private partnerships in SNWTP is worth promoting (南水北调投资PPP模式值得推广). China Securities Journal (中国证券报). Available at: http://cs.com.cn/sylm/zjyl_1/201412/t20141215_4589453.html (accessed 29 July 2019).
27.
Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (2016) The Critical Anthology for Neoliberalism by the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (中国社会科学院新自由主义批判文选).
Beijing:
China Social Sciences Press (中国社会科学出版社).
28.
Clarke-SatherA (2015) Hydrosocial governance and agricultural development in semi-arid northwest China. In: CookCNormanESCohenA (eds) Negotiating Water Governance: Why the Politics of Scale Matter.
Oxford, UK:
Routledge, p.247.
29.
Clarke-SatherAESolomonBD (2012)
Grantocracy: Conservation grant-making and the territorialization of neoliberalism in Michigan’s Keweenaw Peninsula.Geoforum43: 68–80.
30.
CohenA (2012)
Rescaling environmental governance: Watersheds as boundary objects at the intersection of science, neoliberalism, and participation.Environment and Planning A44: 2207–2224.
31.
CohenABakkerK (2014)
The eco-scalar fix: Rescaling environmental governance and the politics of ecological boundaries in Alberta, Canada. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space32: 128–146.
32.
CohenAMcCarthyJ (2014)
Reviewing rescaling.Progress in Human Geography39: 3–25.
33.
CongRGWeiYM (2010)
Potential impact of (CET) carbon emissions trading on China’s power sector: A perspective from different allowance allocation options.Energy35: 3921–3931.
34.
CPC Central Committee (2018) Circular of the Central Committee of the Chinese Communist Party on Issuing the Plan for Deepening the Party and State Institutional Reform (中共中央关于印发深化党和国家机构改革方案的通知).
Beijing:
CPC Central Committee.
35.
CPC Central Committee and State Council (2016) Opinions of the CPC Central Committee and the State Council on deepening the reform of investment and financing system (中共中央、国务院关于深化投融资体制改革的意见) (Official communication 中发[2016]18号).
Beijing:
CPC Central Committee and State Council.
36.
Crow-MillerB (2015)
Discourses of deflection: The politics of framing China’s South-North Water Transfer Project. Water Alternatives8: 173–192.
37.
Crow-MillerBWebberM (2017)
Of maps and eating bitterness: The politics of scaling in China’s South-North Water Transfer Project.Political Geography61: 19–30.
38.
Crow-MillerBWebberMRogersS (2017)
The techno-politics of big infrastructure and the Chinese water machine. Water Alternatives10: 233–249.
39.
DongZFWangJN (2011)
Quantitative standard of eco-compensation for the water source area in the middle route of the South-to-North Water Transfer Project in China.Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering in China5: 459–473.
40.
DuncanR (2017)
Rescaling knowledge and governance and enrolling the future in New Zealand: A co-production analysis of Canterbury’s water management reforms to regulate diffuse pollution.Society & Natural Resources30: 436–452.
41.
GallagherME (2002)
“Reform and openness”: Why China’s economic reforms have delayed democracy.World Politics54: 338–372.
42.
General Office of State Council (2003) Circular of the General Office of the State Council on issuing the regulations on the main responsibilities, internal institutions and staffing of the Construction Committee Office of the South-North Water Transfer Project of the State Council (国务院办公厅关于印发国务院南水北调工程建设委员会办公室主要职责内设机构和人员编制规定的通知) (Official communication 国办发(2003)71号).
Beijing:
General Office of the State Council.
43.
General Office of State Council (2013) Circular of the General Office of State Council on adjusting the composition of the State Council Construction Committee for South-North Water Transfer Project (国务院办公厅关于调整国务院南水北调工程建设委员会组成人员的通知) (Official communication 国办发(2013)65号).
Beijing:
General Office of State Council.
44.
General Office of State Council (2014) Opinions of the General Office of State Council on further promoting the pilots of emissions trading and paid use (国务院办公厅关于进一步推进排污权有偿使用和交易试点工作的指导意见) (Official communication 国办发[2014]38号).
Beijing:
General Office of State Council.
45.
GoldmanM (2007)
How “Water for All!” policy became hegemonic: The power of the World Bank and its transnational policy networks.Geoforum38: 786–800.
46.
GuerreroABodinÖMcAllisterR, et al. (2015)
Achieving social-ecological fit through bottom-up collaborative governance: An empirical investigation.Ecology and Society20: 41.
47.
HarrisLM (2009)
Gender and emergent water governance: Comparative overview of neoliberalized natures and gender dimensions of privatization, devolution and marketization.Gender, Place and Culture16: 387–408.
48.
HarveyD (1989)
From managerialism to entrepreneurialism: The transformation in urban governance in late capitalism.Geografiska Annaler. Series B, Human Geography71: 3–17.
49.
HarveyD (2007) A Brief History of Neoliberalism.
New York:
Oxford University Press.
Hebei Provincial Construction Committee of SNWTP (2010) Circular of the Hebei Provincial Construction Committee of SNWTP on accelerating the construction of auxiliary projects of SNWTP in Hebei Province (河北省南水北调工程建设委员会关于加快我省南水北调配套工程建设的通知) (Official communication 冀调委字[2010]3号). Shijiazhuang, Hebei Province: Hebei Provincial Construction Committee of SNWTP.
52.
Henan Provincial Department of Water Resources (2015) Regulation for the water transactions of SNWTP in Henan Province (河南省南水北调水量交易管理办法) (Official communication 豫水政资[2015]6号). Zhengzhou, Henan: Henan Provincial Department of Water Resources.
53.
Hongqi Wengao (2014)
Be alert to neoliberal discourse traps in reform (在改革中要警惕新自由主义的话语陷阱). Hongqi Wengao (红旗文稿)20: 16–18.
54.
Hongqi Wengao (2015)
The true face of neoliberalism (新自由主义思潮的真实面目). Hongqi Wengao (红旗文稿)5: 8–12.
55.
HoreshNLimKF (2017)
China: An East Asian alternative to neoliberalism?The Pacific Review30: 425–442.
LiYWuF (2012)
The transformation of regional governance in China: The rescaling of statehood.Progress in Planning78: 55–99.
64.
LieberthalKOksenbergM (1988) Policy Making in China: Leaders, Structures, and Processes.
Princeton, NJ:
Princeton University Press.
65.
LimKF (2014)
‘Socialism with Chinese characteristics’ Uneven development, variegated neoliberalization and the dialectical differentiation of state spatiality.Progress in Human Geography38: 221–247.
66.
LimKF (2017)
State rescaling, policy experimentation and path dependency in post-Mao China: A dynamic analytical framework.Regional Studies51: 1580–1593.
67.
LindA (2002)
Making feminist sense of neoliberalism: The institutionalization of women’s struggles for survival in Ecuador and Bolivia.Contributions to Asian Studies18: 228–258.
68.
MaL (2009)
China’s authoritarian capitalism: Growth, elitism and legitimacy.International Development Planning Review31: i–xii.
69.
MaYJLiXYWilsonM, et al. (2016)
Water loss by evaporation from China’s South-North Water Transfer Project.Ecological Engineering95: 206–215.
70.
McCarthyJ (2005)
Devolution in the woods: Community forestry as hybrid neoliberalism.Environment and Planning A37: 995–1014.
71.
MarstonSAJonesJPIIIWoodwardKJ (2005)
Human geography without scale.Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers30: 416–432.
72.
MerthaA (2009)
“Fragmented authoritarianism 2.0”: Political pluralization in the Chinese policy process.The China Quarterly200: 995–1012.
73.
Ministry of Water Resources (2002) South-North Water Transfer Project Masterplan (Summary) (南水北调工程总体规划(简要本)).
Beijing:
Ministry of Water Resources.
74.
Ministry of Water Resources (2017) The Ministry of Water Resources deploys further deepening devolution reform on water governance (水利部研究部署进一步深化水利”放管服”改革). Ministry of Water Resources. Available at: http://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2017-06/28/content_5206307.htm (accessed 29 July 2019).
75.
MolAPCarterNT (2006)
China’s environmental governance in transition.Environmental Politics15: 149–170.
76.
MooreS (2014a)
Hydropolitics and inter-jurisdictional relationships in China: The pursuit of localized preferences in a centralized system.The China Quarterly219: 760–780.
77.
MooreSM (2014b)
Modernisation, authoritarianism, and the environment: The politics of China’s South–North Water Transfer Project.Environmental Politics23: 947–964.
78.
NathanAJ (2003)
Authoritarian resilience.Journal of Democracy14: 6–17.
79.
National Development and Reform Commission (2014a) Circular of the National Development and Reform Commission on the water supply price policy for the initial operation of the first phase of SNWTP-ER (国家发展改革委关于南水北调东线一期主体工程运行初期供水价格政策的通知) (Official communication 发改价格[2014]30号).
Beijing:
National Development and Reform Commission.
80.
National Development and Reform Commission (2014b) Circular of the National Development and Reform Commission on the water supply price policy for the initial operation of the first phase of SNWTP-MR (国家发展改革委关于南水北调中线一期主体工程运行初期供水价格政策的通知) (Official communication 发改价格[2014]2959号).
Beijing:
National Development and Reform Commission.
81.
National Development and Reform Commission (2016) Circular of the National Development and Reform Commission on promoting on public-private partnerships in the field of traditional infrastructure (国家发展改革委关于切实做好传统基础设施领域政府和社会资本合作有关工作的通知) (Official communication 发改投资[2016]1744号).
Beijing:
National Development and Reform Commission.
82.
NewellP (2011)
The elephant in the room: Capitalism and global environmental change. Global Environmental Change21: 4–6.
83.
NormanESBakkerKCookC (2012)
Introduction to the themed section: Water governance and the politics of scale. Water Alternatives5: 52–61.
PeckJBrennerNTheodoreN (2018) Actually existing neoliberalism. In: CahillDCooperMKoningsM, et al. (eds) The SAGE Handbook of Neoliberalism.
Thousand Oaks, CA:
SAGE, pp.3–15.
86.
People’s Daily (2013a) Chi Fulin’s Interpretation: Decentralization to the market, the society, and the local governments (迟福林解读：向市场放权向社会放权向地方放权). People’s Daily (人民日报). Available at: http://theory.people.com.cn/n/2013/0311/c40531-20744048.html (accessed 29 July 2019).
PerreaultT (2005)
State restructuring and the scale politics of rural water governance in Bolivia.Environment and Planning A37: 263–284.
94.
PohlnerH (2016)
Institutional change and the political economy of water megaprojects: China’s south-north water transfer.Global Environmental Change38: 205–216.
95.
PolanyiKMacIverRM (1957) The Great Transformation.
Boston, MA:
Beacon Press.
96.
PolanyiKArensbergCMPearsonHW (1957) Trade and Market in the Early Empires: Economies in History and Theory.
New York:
Free Press.
97.
ProvanKGKenisP (2008)
Modes of network governance: Structure, management, and effectiveness.Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory18: 229–252.
98.
ProvanKGFishASydowJ (2007)
Interorganizational networks at the network level: A review of the empirical literature on whole networks.Journal of Management33: 479–516.
99.
Qiushi (2009) World Bank and China’s reform and opening up (世界银行与中国的改革开放). Qiushi (求是) 15: 59–61.
100.
Qiushi (2016)
We must not deconstruct reform with neoliberalism (决不能用新自由主义解构改革). Qiushi (求是)10: 19–21.
101.
ReedMGBruyneelS (2010)
Rescaling environmental governance, rethinking the state: A three-dimensional review.Progress in Human Geography34: 646–653.
102.
RicartSRicoAKirkN, et al. (2018) How to improve water governance in multifunctional irrigation systems? Balancing stakeholder engagement in hydrosocial territories. International Journal of Water Resources Development 35: 1–34.
103.
RobertsonMM (2004)
The neoliberalization of ecosystem services: Wetland mitigation banking and problems in environmental governance.Geoforum35: 361–373.
104.
Rodríguez-de-FranciscoJCBoelensR (2016)
PES hydrosocial territories: De-territorialization and re-patterning of water control arenas in the Andean highlands.Water International41: 140–156.
105.
RogersSBarnettJWebberM, et al. (2016)
Governmentality and the conduct of water: China’s South-North Water Transfer Project.Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers41: 429–441.
106.
Securities Daily (2017) This year’s construction investment in the water sector will reach 1 trillion yuan, and PPP is expected to drive huge investment (今年水利在建投资剑指一万亿元 PPP有望撬动巨大投资空间). Securities Daily (证券日报). Available at: http://env.people.com.cn/n1/2018/0420/c1010-29938231.html (accessed 29 July 2019).
107.
ShengJWebberM (2017)
Incentive-compatible payments for watershed services along the Eastern Route of China’s South-North Water Transfer Project.Ecosystem Services25: 213–226.
108.
ShihV (2007)
Partial reform equilibrium, Chinese style: Political incentives and reform stagnation in Chinese financial policies.Comparative Political Studies40: 1238–1262.
109.
ShinHParkSHSonnJW (2015)
The emergence of a multiscalar growth regime and scalar tension: The politics of urban development in Songdo New City, South Korea. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy33: 1618–1638.
110.
SørensenETorfingJ (2005)
The democratic anchorage of governance networks.Scandinavian Political Studies28: 195–218.
111.
SørensenETorfingJ (2009)
Making governance networks effective and democratic through metagovernance.Public Administration87: 234–258.
112.
State Council (2003) Circular of Sate Council on the founding of the State Council’s Construction Committee for the South-North Water Transfer Project (国务院关于成立国务院南水北调工程建设委员会的通知) (Official communication 国发(2003)17号).
Beijing:
State Council.
113.
State Council (2013) Report on the construction of ecological compensation scheme (国务院关于生态补偿机制建设工作情况的报告).
Beijing:
State Council.
114.
State Council (2014) Regulations on water supply and water use for South-North Water Transfer Project (南水北调工程供用水管理条例) (Official communication 中华人民共和国国务院令第647号).
Beijing:
State Council.
115.
State Council Construction Committee of SNWTP (2003) Circular of the State Council Construction Committee of SNWTP on issuing the formation plan of the project legal persons of SNWTP (国务院南水北调工程建设委员会关于印发南水北调工程项目法人组建方案的通知) (Official communication 国调委发[2003]2号).
Beijing:
State Council Construction Committee of SNWTP.
116.
State Council Construction Committee of SNWTP (2004) Circular of the State Council Construction Committee of SNWTP on issuing several opinions on the SNWTP construction and management (国务院南水北调工程建设委员会关于关于印发南水北调工程建设管理的若干意见的通知) (Official communication 国调委发[2004]5号).
Beijing:
State Council Construction Committee of SNWTP.
117.
SuX (2012)
Transnational regionalization and the rescaling of the Chinese state.Environment and Planning A44: 1327–1347.
118.
SubramaniamM (2014)
Neoliberalism and water rights: The case of India.Current Sociology62: 393–411.
119.
SwyngedouwE (2000)
Authoritarian governance, power, and the politics of rescaling.Environment and Planning D: Society and Space18: 63–76.
120.
SwyngedouwE (2004)
Globalisation or ‘glocalisation’? Networks, territories and rescaling.Cambridge Review of International Affairs17: 25–48.
121.
SwyngedouwE (2005a)
Dispossessing H2O: The contested terrain of water privatization.Capitalism Nature Socialism16: 81–98.
122.
SwyngedouwE (2005b)
Governance innovation and the citizen: The Janus face of governance-beyond-the-state.Urban Studies42: 1991–2006.
123.
SwyngedouwE (2007)
Technonatural revolutions: The scalar politics of Franco’s hydro‐social dream for Spain, 1939–1975. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers32: 9–28.
124.
SwyngedouwE (2009)
The political economy and political ecology of the hydro‐social cycle.Journal of Contemporary Water Research & Education142: 56–60.
125.
TsangS (2009)
Consultative Leninism: China’s new political framework.Journal of Contemporary China18: 865–880.
126.
UitermarkJ (2002)
Re-scaling, ‘scale fragmentation’ and the regulation of antagonistic relationships.Progress in Human Geography26: 743–765.
127.
WangHDongZXuY, et al. (2016)
Eco-compensation for watershed services in China.Water International41: 271–289.
128.
WarnerJFFliervoetJMSmitsAJ (2016) Towards a joint maintenance approach for floodplain management in the Netherlands: Tensions and possibilities. In: MargerumRDRobinsonCJ (eds) The Challenges of Collaboration in Environmental Governance: Barriers and Responses.
Cheltenham:
Edward Elgar Publishing, pp.290–313.
129.
WebberM (2012)
The political economy of the Three Gorges Project.Geographical Research50: 154–165.
130.
WebberMCrow-MillerBRogersS (2017)
The South–North Water Transfer Project: Remaking the geography of China.Regional Studies51: 370–382.
131.
WeberI (2018) China and neoliberalism: Moving beyond the China is/is not neoliberal dichotomy. In: CahillDCooperMKoningsM, et al. (eds) The SAGE Handbook of Neoliberalism.
Thousand Oaks, CA:
SAGE, p.219.
WesselinkAPaavolaJFritschO, et al. (2011)
Rationales for public participation in environmental policy and governance: Practitioners’ perspectives.Environment and Planning A43: 2688–2704.
134.
WeylandK (2004)
Neoliberalism and democracy in Latin America: A mixed record.Latin American Politics and Society46: 135–157.
135.
World Bank (2008) Project Agreement, L7517-CN Conformed.
Washington, DC:
World Bank.
136.
World Bank (2010) Project Agreement for Loan 7938-CN Conformed.
Washington, DC:
World Bank.
137.
WuF (2016)
China’s emergent city‐region governance: A new form of state spatial selectivity through state‐orchestrated rescaling.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research40: 1134–1151.
XieGCaoSLuC, et al. (2015)
Current status and future trends for eco-compensation in China. Journal of Resources and Ecology6: 355–362.
140.
XuC (2011)
The fundamental institutions of China’s reforms and development.Journal of Economic Literature49: 1076–1151.
141.
YoungB (2018) Contemporary Anglo-Saxon neoliberalism is not German ordoliberalism. In: CahillDCooperMKoningsM, et al. (eds) The SAGE Handbook of Neoliberalism.
Thousand Oaks, CA:
SAGE Publications.
142.
YuXChenHLiC (2019)
Evaluate typhoon disasters in 21st century maritime silk road by super-efficiency DEA.International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health16: 1614.
143.
ZhangQXuZShenZ, et al. (2009)
The Han River watershed management initiative for the South-to-North Water Transfer project (Middle Route) of China.Environmental Monitoring and Assessment148: 369–377.
144.
ZhongLMolAP (2010)
Water price reforms in China: Policy-making and implementation.Water Resources Management24: 377–396.
145.
ZhongLMolAPFuT (2008)
Public-private partnerships in China’s urban water sector.Environmental Management41: 863–877.
146.
ZhouYLinGCZhangJ (2019)
Urban China through the lens of neoliberalism: Is a conceptual twist enough?Urban Studies56: 33–43.
