Based on a case-study of the governance of health facilities in Niger, the paper examines how emotions can be used as a method to explore meaning-making activities in bureaucratic settings where public servants’ behaviours follow practical norms that deviate from both official norms and social norms. As a supplement to other techniques associated with long-term field research, the use of obtrusive participant-observation is arguably a relevant and fruitful methodological tactic. The author argues that giving space to the ethnographer’s empathy while doing participant-observation enables a deeper understanding of bureaucratic behaviours by bringing emotions back into the analysis of empirical findings and deepening reflexivity. Whereas the paper examines some ethical issues associated with this method in contexts where the ethnographer is confronted with abuse of power in health bureaucracies, the author suggests that emotions as method can be a fruitful approach to bureaucratic ethnography at large.
AbramsP (1988)
Notes on the Difficulty of Studying the State (1977). Journal of Historical Sociology1(1): 58–89.
2.
AllanH (2006)
Using participant observation to immerse oneself in the field: The relevance and importance of ethnography for illuminating the role of emotions in nursing practice. Journal of Research in Nursing11(5): 397–407.
3.
AllanHT (2001)
Nursing the clinic and managing emotions in a fertility unit: Findings from an ethnographic study. Nursing Inquiry8: 51–60.
4.
AndersenHM (2004)
‘Villagers’: Differential treatment in a Ghanaian Hospital. Social Science & Medicine59: 2003–2012.
5.
ArendtH (1963) Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of Evil.
New York, NY:
The Viking Press.
6.
Becker HowardS (1971)
Reply to Riley’s ‘Partisanship and Objectivity’. American Sociologist6(1): 13–13.
7.
BernardHR (1994) Research Methods in Anthropology: Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches. 2nd ed.
Walnut Creek, CA:
AltaMira Press.
8.
BeverleyJ (2004) Testimonio: On the Politics of Truth.
Minneapolis, MN:
University of Minnesota Press.Bierschenk T. & Olivier de Sardan J.-P. (2019) How to study bureaucracies ethnographically?, Critique of Anthropology, June 2019
9.
BlundoGGlasmanJ (2013)
Introduction: Bureaucrats in uniform. Sociologus63(1-2): 1–9.
10.
BodemannYM (1978)
A problem of sociological praxis. The case for interventive observation in field work. Theory and Society5(4): 387–420.
11.
BrownlieJ (2011) ‘
Being there’: Multidimensionality, reflexivity and the study of emotional lives. The British Journal of Sociology62(3): 462–481.
12.
de JongMKamsteegFYbemaS (2013)
Ethnographic strategies for making the familiar strange: Struggling with ‘distance’ and ‘immersion’ among Moroccan-Dutch students. Journal of Business Anthropology2(2): 168–186.
13.
DeWaltKMDeWaltBR (2011) Participant Observation: A Guide for Fieldworkers. 2nd ed.Walnut Creek, CA:
AltaMira Press.
14.
Dickson-SwiftVJamesELKippenS, et al. (2006)
Blurring boundaries in qualitative health research on sensitive topics. Qualitative Health Research16(6): 853–871.
15.
EmersonRMFretzRIShawLL (1995) Writing Ethnographic Fieldnotes.
Chicago, IL:
University of Chicago Press, pp. 17–38.
16.
FassinD (2008)
The elementary forms of care. An empirical approach of ethics in a South African hospital. Social Science & Medicine67(2): 262–270.
17.
GoffmanE (1989) ‘
On Fieldwork’. Journal of Contemporary Ethnography18(2): 123–132.
18.
GolemanD (1995) Emotional Intelligence.
New York, NY:
Bantam Books.
19.
GrahamM (2002)
Emotional bureaucracies: Emotions, civil servants, and immigrants in the Swedish welfare state. Ethos30(3): 199–226.
20.
HahonouE (2001) Les interactions entre agents de santé et patients: Le cas du service des urgences de l’Hopital National de Niamey (Working Papers on African Societies, 51).
Berlin:
Das Arabische Buch.
21.
HahonouE (2015) Juggling with the norms. Everyday practice in an emergency service in Niger. In: De HerdtTOlivier de SardanJ-P (eds) Real Governance and Practical Norms in Sub-Saharan Africa.
Abingdon:
Routledge, pp. 123–141.
22.
HarringtonB (2002)
Obtrusiveness as strategy in ethnographic research. Qualitative Sociology25(1): 49–61.
23.
HeymanJ (2012)
Deepening the anthropology of bureaucracy. Anthropological Quarterly85(4): 1269–1277.
24.
Hordge-FreemanE (2018)
Bringing your whole self to research. International Journal of Qualitative Methods17: 1–9.
25.
JewkesRAbrahamsNMvoZ (1998)
Why do nurses abuse patients. Reflections from South African obstetric services. Social Science Medicine47(11): 1781–1795.
26.
KleinmanA (2013)
How we endure. Lancet (London, England)383: 119–120.
27.
KleinmanSCoppMA (1993) Emotions and Fieldwork.
Newbury Park, CA:
Sage.
28.
LipskyM (1980) Street Level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Service (30th Anniversary Expanded Edition in 2010).
New York, NY:
Russell Sage Foundation.
29.
Le Marcis F and Grard J (2015) Ethnography of everyday ethics in a South African medical ward. In Herdt, Tom De, & Olivier de Sardan, Jean-Pierre (eds) Real governance and practical norms in sub-Saharan Africa, the game of rules (Routledge studies in African politics and International relations). Abingdon: Routledge, pp.160--185.
30.
LivingstonJ (2012) Improvising Medicine: An African Oncology Ward in an Emerging Cancer Epidemic.
Durham, NC:
Duke University Press.
31.
LucasMStevensonD (2006)
Violence and abuse in psychiatric in-patient institutions: A South African perspective. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry29(1): 205–213.
32.
MalinowskiB (1922) Argonauts of the Western Pacific: An Account of Native Enterprise and Adventure in the Archipelagoes of Melanesian New Guinea (Studies in Economics and Political Science).
London.
33.
MarkowitschHJRoettger-RoesslerB (2009) Emotions as Bio-Cultural Processes.
New York, NY:
Springer US.
34.
MartinHM (2009) Nursing Contradictions, Ideals and Improvisation in Uganda (Health, Culture and Society).
Diemen:
AMB.Martin T.M. (2019) The ethnographer as accomplice – edifying qualms of bureaucratic fieldwork in Kafka’s Penal Colony, Critique of Anthropology, June 2019
35.
MarzanoM (2012) Ethics and social conflict: A framework for social research. In: LoveK (ed)Ethics in Social Research. Vol. 12.
Bingley:
Emerald, pp. 73–90.
36.
MetcalfP (2002) They Lie, We Lie: Getting on with Anthropology.
London:
Routledge.
37.
MolyneuxSWenzel GeisslerP (2008)
Ethics and the ethnography of medical research in Africa. Social Science & Medicine67: 685–695.
38.
MpabulungiL (1995) The role of the family in institutional health care: A study of Jinja Hospital. BA Dissertation, Makerere University, Kampala.
39.
OkelyJ (2007)
Fieldwork embodied. The Sociological Review55(1): 65–79.
40.
Olivier de SardanJP (2003) Pourquoi le malade anonyme est-il si mal traité? In: JaffréYOlivier de SardanJP (eds) Une Médecine Inhospitalière: Les Difficiles Relations Entre Soignants et Soignés Dans Cinq Capitales D’Afrique de L’Ouest.
Paris:
Karthala & APAD, pp. 165–184.
41.
OwensP (2012) How dangerous it can be to be innocent? War and the law in the thought of Hannah Arendt. In: GoldoniMMcCorkindaleC (eds) Hannah Arendt and the Law (Law and Practical Reason, 4).
Bloomsbury:
Hart Publishing, pp. 251–270.
42.
PapermanPLaugierS (2005) Le Souci Des Autres. Éthique et Politique du Care.
Paris:
Editions de l’École des Hautes Études en Sciences Sociales.
SchwalbeM (1996) Unlocking the Iron Cage: The Men's Movement, Gender Politics, and American Culture.
New York, NY:
Oxford University Press.
46.
SharkeySLarsenJA (2005) Ethnographic exploration: Participation and meaning in everyday life. In: HollowayI (ed) Qualitative Research in Health Care.
Maidenhead:
Open University Press, pp. 168–190.
47.
StoddartK (1986)
The presentation of everyday life: Some textual strategies for ‘adequate ethnography’. Urban Life15: 103–121.
48.
StreetA (2016)
Making people care. Lancet387(10016): 333–334.
49.
TaylorSJBogdanR (1984) Introduction to Qualitative Research: The Search for Meanings. 2nd ed.
New York, NY:
John Wiley.
Van der GeestSFinklerK (2004)
Hospital ethnography: Introduction. Social Science Medicine59(10): 1995–2001.
52.
VivianLMHNaiduCSKeikelameMJ, et al. (2011)
Medical students’ experiences of professional lapses and patient rights abuses in a South African health sciences faculty. Academic Medicine86(10): 1–6.
53.
WattsJH (2011)
Ethical and practical challenges of participant observation in sensitive health research. International Journal of Social Research Methodology14(4): 301–312.
54.
Wendland C (2012) Moral Maps and Medical Imaginaries: Clinical Tourism at Malawi's College of Medicine. American Anthropologist 114(1): 108--122.
