This article analyses the effects of slum upgrading on the lives of slum dwellers, especially on their position in society and their relation with the state. It zooms in on the implementation of Prometrópole, a World Bank-funded slum upgrading project in Recife that removes the population from shacks close to rivers to new housing estates. In this project, the state embraces participatory democracy and stresses the growing inclusion of the poor as citizens of the Brazilian nation-state. The question that inspired the article is: ‘How does the “citizenship agenda” employed by the Brazilian state relate to practices of political belonging in the urban periphery, characterized by social exclusion and violence?’ On the basis of ethnographic research, the article concludes that the upgrading of poor neighbourhoods indeed increases feelings of belonging and inclusion among the poor population. At the same time, however, the stress on the responsible citizen and the empty participatory procedures in the project have the perverse effects of side-lining the poor and reinforcing clientelist politics.
BitounJCostaJSilvaEB (2002) Orcamento participativo em Recife: Gestão do planejamento, exercicio de cidadania, Recife: FASE Pernambuco.
2.
CabralA (2004) Os gestores públicos e suas ações no bairro de Campina do Barreto: O vivido e o instituído, Recife, UFPE: MSc thesis.
3.
CaldeiraT(2006) “I came to sabotage your reasoning!” Violence and resignifications of justice in Brazil. In: ComaroffJComaroffJ (eds) Law and Disorder in the Postcolony, Chicago: University of Chicago Press, pp. 102–149.
4.
ChatterjeeP (2004) The Politics of the Governed: Reflections on Popular Politics in Most of the World, New York: Columbia University Press.
5.
CollinsJ (2008) Public health, patronage and national culture: the resuscitation and commodification of community origins in neoliberal Brazil. Critique of Anthropology28(2): 237–255.
6.
CruikshankB (1999) The Will to Empower, Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press.
7.
DagninoE (2007) Dimensions of citizenship in contemporary Brazil. Fordham Law Review75(6): 2470–2482.
8.
DalsgaardA (2004) Matters of Life and Longing: Female Sterilisation in Northeast Brazil, Copenhagen: Museum Tusculanum press.
9.
Etapas (2003) Gestão participativa no Recife: do Prezeis ao Orçamento Participativo: 1° encontro da RPA6. Recife: H3 ComunicaçãoVisual Ltda.
10.
GarmanyJ (2009) The embodied state: governmentality in a Brazilian favela. Social and Cultural Geography10(7): 721–739.
11.
GayR (1999) The broker and the thief: a parable (reflections on popular politics in Brazil). Luso-Brazilian Review36(1): 49–70.
12.
Gledhill J and Hita M (2009) New Actors, New Political Spaces, Same Divided City? Reflections on Poverty and the Politics of Urban Development in Salvador, Bahia. Paper presented at LASA, Rio de Janeiro, June 11–14, 2009.
13.
(2007) Citizenship beyond the state: thinking with early modern citizenship in the contemporary world. In: GordonAStackT (eds) Citizenship Studies11(2): 117–133.
14.
Hindess(2005) Citizenship and empire. In: HansenTStepputatF (eds) Sovereign Bodies, Princeton: Princeton University Press, pp. 241–256.
15.
HolstonJ (1991) Autoconstruction in working-class Brazil. Cultural Anthropology6(4): 447–465.
16.
HolstonJ (2008) Insurgent Citizenship: Disjunctions of Democracy and Modernity in Brazil, Princeton and Oxford: Princeton University Press.
17.
HolstonJAppaduraiA (1996) Cities and citizenship. Public Culture8: 187–204.
IndaJX(2005) Analytics of the modern: an introdcution. In: Inda (eds) Anthropologies of Modernity: Foucault, Governmentality and Life Politics, Oxford: Blackwell, pp. 1–22.
20.
Koster M (2009) In Fear of Abandonment: Slum Life, Community Leaders and Politics in Recife, Brazil. PhD Thesis, Wageningen University, Wageningen.
21.
KosterMNuijtenM (2012) From preamble to post-project frustrations: the shaping of a slum upgrading project in Recife, Brazil. Antipode44(1): 175–196.
22.
LazarS (2004) Education for credit: development as citizenship project in Bolivia. Critique of Anthropology24(3): 301–319.
23.
Lopes de SouzaM (2008) Fobopole; o medo generalizado e a militarizacao da questão urbana, Rio de Janeiro: Bertrand Brasil.
24.
MiguelL (2006) From equality to opportunity: transformations in the discourse of the Workers’ Party in the 2002 elections. Latin American Perspectives33(4): 122–143.
25.
Mouffe Ch (2005) On the Political, Oxford: Routledge.
26.
NuijtenM (2003) Power, Community and the State: The Political Anthropology of Organisation in Mexico, London: Pluto Press.
27.
Nuijten M, Koster M and Vries P. de (2012) Regimes of spatial ordering in Brazil: the merging of neoliberalism, leftist populism and modernist visions in slum upgrading in Recife. Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography 33: 157–170.
28.
Ong A (2009) Political citizenship in the midst of transnational regimes of virtue. Power and Social Theory 20: 301–307.
29.
Owensby b (2005) Toward a history of Brazil’s “Cordial racism”: race beyond liberalism. Comparative Study of Society and History47(2): 318–347.
30.
PerlmanJ (1979) The Myth of Marginality: Urban Poverty and Politics in Rio de Janeiro, Berkeley, Los Angeles, London: University of California Press.
31.
Prometropole (2006) Plano de acompanhamento social de obras.
32.
SantosM (2007) Por Uma Outra Globalização: Do Pensamento Único a Consciência Universal, Rio de Janeiro: Record.
33.
Scheper-HughesN(2006) Death squads and democracy in Northeast Brazil. In: ComaroffJComaroffJ (eds) Law and Disorder in the Postcolony, Chicago: University of Chicago Press, pp. 150–187.
34.
ScottJ (1998) Seeing Like a State; How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed, New Haven and London: Yale University Press.
35.
StepputatF(2001) Urbanizing the countryside: armed conflict, state formation, and the politics of place in contemporary Guatemala. In: HansenTStepputatF (eds) States of Imagination: Ethnographic Explorations of the Postcolonial State, Durham and London: Duke University Press, pp. 284–312.
36.
Winkelhoff M van (2011) Factory of dreams: Experiences and expectations around slum upgrading in Recife. MSc Thesis, Wageningen University.
37.
World Bank (2003) Project appraisal document on a proposed loan for the Recife upgrading project, April 1.
38.
World Bank (2006) Project information document (PID) Appraisal stage. Recife Urban development and social inclusion project.
