A case is argued for the constitutive role of commodity value (use + exchange +
symbolic), and its shifting triangulations, in Mesoamerican and Mexican indigenous
culture. This role cross-cuts historical epochs but assumes more pervasive influence
historically in proportion to the spread of integrative markets and monetization.
Given their commodity value matrix, indigenous direct-producing subjects, yesterday
and today, are assumed to economize, regardless of the nature and destination of
their labor or products or the particular social relations organizing the
latter's disposition. Particular forms of commodity value triangulation
require empirical determination at specific spatial/temporal coordinates. Critical
evaluations of work by Karl Marx, Guillermo Bonfil, Alejandro Marroquín,
Manuel Gamio and Arturo Warman, together with ethnographic material, are used to
support the case for the commodity value approach.
Aguirre-Beltrán, Gonzalo
(1967) Regiones de refugio.
Mexico City: Ediciones Especiales 46, Instituto
Indigenista Interamericano
.
2.
Appadurai, Arjun
(1986) ‘Introduction: Commodities and the
Politics of Value’, in
Arjun Appadurai
(ed.) The Social Life of Things: Commodities in Cultural
Perspective.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
3.
Bartra, Roger
(1974) Estructura agraria y clases sociales en
México.
Mexico City: Ediciones Era
.
4.
Bartra, Roger
(1978) El poder despótico
burgués.
Mexico City: Ediciones Era
.
5.
Baskes, Jeremy
(1996)
‘Coerced or Voluntary? The Repartimientoand Market Participation
of Peasants in Late Colonial Oaxaca’
, Journal of Latin American Studies28:
1–28
.
6.
Baskes, Jeremy
(2000) Indians, Merchants and Markets: A Reinterpretation of
the Repartimiento and Spanish–Indian Economic Relations in Colonial
Oaxaca, 1750–1821.
Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press
.
7.
Beals, Ralph L.
(1975) The Peasant Marketing System of Oaxaca, Mexico.
Berkeley: University of California Press
.
8.
Berdan, Frances F.
(1985) ‘Markets in the Economy of Aztec
Mexico’, in
Stuart Plattner
(ed.) Markets and Marketing, pp.
339–367.
Society for Economic Anthropology, vol. 4. Lanham, MD:
University Press of America
.
9.
Berdan, Frances F.
(1989) ‘Trade and Markets in Precapitalist
States’, in
Stuart Plattner
(ed.) Economic Anthropology, pp.
78–107.
Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press
.
Bonfil Batalla, Guillermo
(1996) México Profundo: Reclaiming a
Civilization.
Austin: University of Texas Press
.
12.
Burma, John
(1971) ‘Introduction to the Dover
Edition’, in
Manuel Gamio
, Mexican Immigration to the United States: A Study of Human Migration
and Adjustment, pp. v–viii.
New York: Dover Publications
. (First published by the University of Chicago Press, 1930.)
13.
Bustamante, Jorge
(1978) ‘Commodity Migrants: Structural Analysis
of Mexican Immigration to the United States’, in
Stanley Ross
(ed.) Views across the Border: The United States and Mexico, pp.
183–203.
Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press
.
14.
Caso, Alfonso, Silvio Zavala, José Miranda, Moisés
González Navarro, Gonzalo Aguirre Beltrán and Ricardo Pozas
(1954) Métodos y resultados de la política indigenista en
México. Memorias del Instituto Nacional Indigenista, vol. VI. Mexico
City: Ediciones del Instituto Nacional Indigenista.
15.
Clarke, Colin
(2000) Class, Ethnicity, and Community in Southern Mexico:
Oaxaca's Peasantries.
Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press
.
16.
Coello, Manuel
(1975)
‘Caracterización de la pequeña
producción mercantil campesina’
, Historia y Sociedad8:
3–19
.
17.
Contreras, Ariel J.
(1976)
‘Economía pequeño mercantil y mercado capitalista’
, Historia y Sociedad12:
66–77
.
18.
Cook, Scott
(1976)
‘Value, Price and Simple Commodity Production: The Case of the
Zapotec Stoneworkers’
, Journal of Peasant Studies3(4):
395–427
.
19.
Cook, Scott
(1978)
‘Petty Commodity Production and Capitalist Development in the
Central Valleys Region of Oaxaca, Mexico’
, Nova Americana1:
285–318
.
20.
Cook, Scott
(1982) Zapotec Stoneworkers: The Dynamics of Rural Simple
Commodity Production in Modern Mexican Capitalism.
Lanham, MD: University Press of America
.
21.
Cook, Scott
(1984a)
‘Peasant Economy, Rural Industry and Capitalist Development in
the Oaxaca Valley, Mexico’
, Journal of Peasant Studies12(1):
3–40
.
22.
Cook, Scott
(1984b)
‘Rural Industry, Social Differentiation and the Contradictions of
Provincial Mexican Capitalism’
, Latin American Perspectives11(4):
60–85
.
23.
Cook, Scott
(1995)
‘B. Traven and the Paradox of Artisanal Production in Capitalism:
Traven's Oaxaca Tale in Economic Anthropological Perspective’
, Mexican Studies/Estudios Mexicanos11(1):
75–111
.
24.
Cook, Scott
(2003)
‘Struggling to Understand Complexity: The Sociocultural
Anthropology of Mexico at the Beginning of the Twenty-first Century’
, Mexican Studies/Estudios Mexicanos19(1):
203–241
.
25.
Cook, Scott
(2004) Understanding Commodity Cultures: Explorations in
Economic Anthropology with Case Studies from Mexico.
Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield
.
26.
Cook, Scott
and
Leigh Binford
(1990) Obliging Need: Rural Petty Industry in Mexican
Capitalism.
Austin: University of Texas Press
.
27.
Díaz del Castillo, Bernal
(1956) The Discovery and Conquest of Mexico.
New York: Grove Press
.
28.
Díaz Polanco, Hector
(1977) Teoría marxista de la economía
campesina.
Mexico City: Juan Pablos Editor
.
29.
Foster, George M.
(1982 [1942]) A Primitive Mexican Economy. Reprint of
American Ethnological Society monograph no. 5.
Westport, CT: Greenwood
.
30.
Frank, Andre Gunder
(1966)
‘The Development of Underdevelopment’
, Monthly Review18:
17–31
.
31.
Gamio, Manuel
(1971) Mexican Immigration to the United States: A Study of
Human Migration and Adjustment.
New York: Dover Publications
. (First published by the University of Chicago Press, 1930.)
32.
Gell, Alfred
(1992) ‘Inter-tribal Commodity Barter and
Reproductive Gift-exchange in Old Melanesia’, in
Caroline Humphrey
and
Stephen Hugh-Jones
(eds) Barter, Exchange and Value.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
33.
Good, Catherine
(2000) ‘Indigenous Peoples in Central and
Western Mexico’, in
John D. Monaghan
(ed.) Ethnology. Vol. 6, Supplement to the Handbook of Middle
American Indians, pp. 120–149.
Austin: University of Texas Press
.
34.
Gregory, Chris
(1997) Savage Money: The Anthropology and Politics of
Commodity Exchange.
Australia: Harwood Academic Publishers
.
35.
Hart, John Mason
(2002) Empire and Revolution: The Americans in Mexico since
the Civil War.
Berkeley: University of California Press
.
36.
Heller, Agnes
(1974) The Theory of Need in Marx.
London: Allison and Busby
.
37.
Hernández Díaz, Jorge
(2001a)
‘Elecciones municipales y conflictos postelectorales: una
preocupación permanente’
, En Marcha31:
16–17
.
38.
Hernández Díaz, Jorge
(2001b) Reclamos de la identidad: la formación de
las organizaciones indígenas en Oaxaca.
Mexico City: Universidad Autónoma
Benito Juárez de Oaxaca
.
39.
Hewitt de Alcántara, Cynthia
(1984) Anthropological Perspectives on Rural Mexico.
London: Routledge and Kegan Paul
.
40.
Hindess, Barry
and
Paul Q. Hirst
(1975) ‘The “Asiatic” Mode
of Production’, in
Barry Hindess and Paul Hirst
(eds) Pre-capitalist Modes of Production, pp.
178–220.
London: Routledge and Kegan Paul
.
41.
Katz, Friedrich
(1958)
‘The Evolution of Aztec Society’
, Past and Present13(April):
14–25
.
42.
Kearney, Michael
(1996) Reconceptualizing the Peasantry: Anthropology in
Global Perspective.
Boulder, CO: Westview Press
.
43.
Kearney, Michael
(2002)
‘Transnational Migration from Oaxaca, the Agrarian Question and
the Politics of Indigenous Peoples’
, Osterreichische Zeitschrift für Geschichtswissenschaften13(4):
7–21
.
44.
Kirchhoff, Paul (1967) Mesoamerica: sus límites
geográficas, composición etnica y caracteres culturales, 3rd
edn. Suplemento de la revista Tlatoani. Mexico City: Escuela Nacional de
Antropología e Historia, Sociedad de Alumnos. (First edn: Acta Americana,
vol. 1, no. 1, 1943).
45.
Kirchhoff, Paul
(1968) ‘Mesoamerica: Its Geographic Limits,
Ethnic Composition and Cultural Characteristics’, in
Sol Tax
(ed.) Heritage of Conquest: The Ethnology of Middle America, pp.
17–30.
New York: Cooper Square Publishers
. (First published by the Macmillan Company, New York, 1952.)
46.
Krader, Lawrence
(1975) The Asiatic Mode of Production.
Assen: Van Gorcum
.
47.
Lomnitz, Claudio
(2001) Deep Mexico, Silent Mexico: An Anthropology of
Nationalism.
Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press
.
48.
Malinowski, Bronislaw and Julio de la Fuente (1957) La economía de
un sistema de mercados en México. Acta Antropológica, epoca 2,
vol. 1, no. 2. Mexico City: Escuela Nacional de Antropología, Sociedad de Alumnos.
49.
Marroquín, Alejandro (1957a) ‘Introducción al
mercado indígena mexicano’, Ciencias Políticas y
Sociales 3(8).
50.
Marroquín, Alejandro
(1957b) La ciudad mercado (Tlaxiaco).
Mexico City: Imprenta Universitaria
.
51.
Marroquín, Alejandro
(1978) La ciudad mercado (Tlaxiaco).
Mexico City: Instituto Nacional Indigenista
. (First published by Imprenta Universitaria, 1957).
52.
Marx, Karl
(1967) Capital, vol. 1.
New York: International Publishers
.
53.
Marx, Karl
(1965) Pre-capitalist Economic Formations.
New York: International Publishers
.
54.
Marx, Karl
(1973) Grundrisse: Foundations of a Critique of Political
Economy.
Baltimore, MD: Penguin Books
.
55.
Medina, Andrés
(1996) Recuentos y figuraciones: ensayos de
antropología mexicana.
Mexico City: UNAM/Instituto de Investigaciones Antropológicas
.
56.
Monaghan, John D.
(2000) ‘Introduction’, in
John D. Monaghan
(ed.) Ethnology, vol. 6, Supplement to the Handbook of Middle
American Indians.
Austin: University of Texas Press
.
57.
Nash, June
(2001) Mayan Visions: The Quest for Autonomy in an Age of
Globalization.
New York: Routledge
.
58.
Othón de Mendizabal, Miguel
(1946) Obras completas, 6 vols.
Mexico City: Talleres Gráficos de la Nación
.
59.
Palerm, Angel
(1954) ‘Review of Penny Capitalismby Sol
Tax’, Boletín Bibliográfico de
Antropología Americana15–16: 1952–3, part 2: 205–7.
Mexico City: Instituto Panamericano de
Geografía e Historia
.
60.
Palerm, Angel
and
Eric R. Wolf
(1957) ‘Ecological Potential and Cultural
Development in Mesoamerica’, in Studies in Human
Ecology, Social Science Monographs III, pp.
1–38.
Washington, DC: Pan American Union
.
61.
Parry, Jonathan
(1989) ‘On the Moral Perils of
Exchange’, in
Jonathan Parry
and
Maurice Bloch
(eds) Money and the Morality of Exchange.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
62.
Polanyi, Karl
(1968) ‘Anthropology and Economic
Theory’, in
Morton H. Fried
(ed.) Readings in Anthropology, 2nd edn, vol. 2, Cultural
Anthropology, pp. 215–238.
New York: Thomas Y. Crowell
.
63.
Redfield, Robert
(1962 [1939]) ‘Primitive Merchants of
Guatemala’, in
Margaret Park Redfield
(ed.) Human Nature and the Study of Society: The Papers of Robert
Redfield, vol. 1, pp. 200–209.
Chicago: University of Chicago Press
.
64.
Schutz, Alfred
(1967) The Phenomenology of the Social World.
Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press
.
65.
Segura, Jesús Jaime Francisco
(1980) ‘El sistema de cargos en
Teotitlàn del Valle, Oaxaca’, in
Raúl Benítez Zenteno
(ed.) Sociedad y politica en Oaxaca 1980: 15 estudios de caso, pp.
185–202.
Oaxaca: IIS-UABJO
.
66.
Smith, Adam
(1937) The Wealth of Nations.
New York: The Modern Library
.
67.
Stavenhagen, Rodolfo
(1969) Las clases sociales en las sociedades agrarias.
Mexico City: Siglo Veintiuno Editores, SA
.
68.
Stavenhagen, Rodolfo
(1992)
‘Los derechos de los indígenas: algunos problemas conceptuales’
, Nueva Antropología13(43):
83–99
.
69.
Stern, Alexandra
(1999)
‘Buildings, Boundaries, and Blood: Medicalization and
Nation-building on the US–Mexico Border, 1910–1930’
, Hispanic American Historical Review79(1):
41–81
.
70.
Tax, Sol
(1957a)
‘Changing Consumption in Indian Guatemala’
, Economic Development and Cultural Change5(2):
147–158
.
71.
Tax, Sol
(1957b)
‘The Indians in the Economy of Guatemala’
, Social and Economic Studies6:
413–424
.
72.
Tax, Sol
(1963) Penny Capitalism: A Guatemalan Indian Economy.
Chicago: University of Chicago Press
. (First published as Smithsonian Institution Institute of Social
Anthropology Publication no. 16, Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office, 1953.)
73.
Tax, Sol
(1964) El capitalismo del centavo: una economía
indígena de Guatemala.
Guatemala City: Centro Editorial
‘Jose de Pineda Ibarra’ Ministerio de
Educación Pública
.
74.
Tax, Sol
(ed.) (1968 [1952]) Heritage of Conquest: The Ethnology of
Middle America.
New York: Cooper Square Publishers
. (First published by the Macmillan Company, New York, 1952.)
75.
Traven, B.
(1956) ‘Canastitas en serie’,
in Canasta de cuentos mexicanos, pp.
9–28.
Mexico City: Compañia General de
Ediciones, SA
.
76.
Traven, B.
(1966) ‘Assembly Line’, in
The Night Visitor and Other Stories, pp. 73–88.
77.
New York: Hill
and
Wang. Warman, Arturo
(2003) Los indios mexicanos en el umbral del milenio.
Mexico City: Fondo de Cultura Económica
.
78.
Weintraub, Sidney
(1997) NAFTA at Three: A Progress Report.
Washington, DC: Center for Strategic and
International Studies
.
79.
Wittfogel, Karl
(1968) ‘The Theory of Oriental
Society’, in
Morton H. Fried
(ed.) Readings in Anthropology, vol. 2, Cultural Anthropology, pp.
179–198.
New York: Thomas Y. Crowell
.
80.
Wolf, Eric
(1955)
‘Types of Latin American Peasantry: A Preliminary Discussion’
, American Anthropologist57:
452–471
.
81.
Wolf, Eric
(1959) Sons of the Shaking Earth.
Chicago: University of Chicago Press
.
82.
Woolfson, Charles
(1982) The Labour Theory of Culture: A Re-examination of
Engels’ Theory of Human Origins.
London: Routledge and Kegan Paul
.
