This article is a critical assessment of George Stocking's historiography of influence and his genealogy of Boasian anthropology. Specifically, Stocking argues that Gamio and Redfield and the research projects and forms of anthropology associated with them were influenced by Boas and/or manifested and participated in, what his analyses constitute as, the Boasian school, tradition or paradigm. This contribution to the historiography of the field of anthropology has two objectives. First, the article provides a critique of the attribution of influence, in general, and of Boasian influence in relation to the anthropologies of Gamio and Redfield. Second, the article assesses Stocking's argument for the conceptual unity of the Boasian `tradition' and `paradigm', and suggests an alternative concept, that of disciplinary modality. The article concludes with a discussion of Lomnitz's assessment of the mutual interdependency yet studied blindness between the Mexican and Anglo traditions of North American anthropology.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Boas, Franz (1996 [1887]) `The Study of Geography', in G.W. Stocking Jr (ed.) Volksgeist as Method and Ethic, pp. 9-16. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press .
2.
Boon, James (1982) Other Tribes, Other Scribes. Chicago: University of Chicago Press .
3.
Browman, David L. and Douglas R. Givens (1996) `Stratigraphic Excavation: The First “New Archaeology” ` , American Anthropologist98(1): 80-95 .
4.
Bunzl, Matti (1996) `Franz Boas and the Humboldtian Tradition', in G.W. Stocking Jr (ed.) Volksgeist as Method and Ethic, pp. 17-78. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press .
5.
Castañeda, Quetzil E. (1995) `The Progress that Chose a Village' , Critique of Anthropology15(2): 115-147 .
6.
Castañeda, Quetzil E. (n.d.a) `Boas, Gamio, and the Carnegie Institution of Espionage: Contexts of Anthropologist-Spies During World War I' , Manuscript, Journal of Social Archaeology.
7.
Castañeda, Quetzil E. (n.d.b) `The Carnegie “Pan-scientific” Program of “Cooperation in Research”: The Story of Boas, Heathens and Half-breeds', work in progress.
8.
Comas, Juan (1960) `La vida y la obra de Manuel Gio (1883-1960)' , América Indígena20(4): 245-272 .
9.
de la Peña, Guillermo (1996) `Nacionales y extranjeros en la historia de la antropología mexicana', in M. Rutsch (ed.) La historia de la antropología en México, pp. 41-82. México, DF: Plaza y Valdés .
10.
Darnell, Regna (1990) Edward Sapir. Berkeley: University of California Press .
11.
Darnell, Regna (2001) Invisible Genealogies. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press .
12.
Fitting, J.E., ed. (1973) The Development of North American Archaeology. Garden City, NY: Anchor Books .
13.
Gamio, Manuel (1926) `The Indian Basis of Mexican Civilization', in J. Vasconcelos and M. Gamio, Aspects of Mexican Civilization, pp. 105-186. Chicago: University of Chicago Press .
14.
Gamio, Manuel (1942) `Franz Boas en México' , Boletín Bibliográfico de Antropología Americana6: 35-36 .
15.
Gamio, Manuel (1959) In W. Goldschmidt (ed.) The Anthropology of Franz Boas. San Francisco: Howard Chandler Publisher .
Garibay K., Angel María (1960) `La obra de Manuel Gamio' , América Indígena20(4): 279-288 .
18.
Gerholm, Tomas and Ulf Hannerz (1982) `Introduction: The Shaping of National Anthropologies' , Ethnos1-2: 5-35 .
19.
Givens, Douglas R. (1992) Alfred Vincent Kidder and the Development of Americanist Archeology. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press .
20.
Godoy, Roberto (1977) `Franz Boas and his Plans for the International School of American Archeology and Ethnology in México' , Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences13: 228-242 .
21.
Godoy, Roberto (1978) `The Background and Context of Redfield's Tepoztlan' , Journal of the Steward of the Anthropological Society10: 47-79 .
22.
Graham, John A. (1961) `George C. Engerrand in México, 1907-1917' , Bulletin of the Texas Archaeological Society32: 19-31 .
23.
Kehoe, Alice Beck (1998) The Land of Prehistory. New York: Routledge .
24.
Kevles, Daniel J. (1985) In the Name of Eugenics. New York: Knopf .
25.
Kluckhohn, Cylde and Olaf Prufer (1959) `Influences during the Formative Years', in W. Goldschmidt (ed.) The Anthropology of Franz Boas, pp. 4-28. San Francisco: Howard Chandler Publisher .
26.
Knight, Alan (1990) `Racism, Revolution, and Indigenismo: México, 1910-1940', in R. Graham (ed.) The Idea of Race in Latin America, 1870-1940, pp. 71-113. Austin: University of Texas Press .
27.
Kroeber, Alfred L. (1931) `Review of Robert Redfield's Tepoztlan, a Mexican Village` , American Anthropologist33: 286-288 .
28.
Kroeber, Theodora (1970) Alfred Kroeber: A Personal Configuration. Berkeley: University of California Press .
29.
Lewis, Herbert S. (2001) `Boas, Darwin, Science, and Anthropology' , Current Anthropology42(3): 381-406 .
30.
Liss, Julia E. (1996) `German Culture and German Science in the Bildung of Franz Boas', in G.W. Stocking Jr (ed.) Volksgeist as Method and Ethic, pp. 155-184. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press .
31.
Lomnitz, Claudio (2001) `Bordering on Anthropology', in Deep Mexico, Silent Mexico, pp. 228-262. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press .
32.
Massin, Benoit (1996) `From Virchow to Fischer', in G.W. Stocking Jr (ed.) Volksgeist as Method and Ethic, pp. 79-154. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press .
33.
Moreno, Daniel (1960) `El pensamiento socio-económico de don Manuel Gamio' , América Indígena20(4): 305-316 .
34.
Nahmad Sittón, Salomón and Thomas Weaver (1990) `Manuel Gamio, el primer antropólogo aplicado y su relación con la antropología norteamericana' , América Indígena4: 291-322 .
35.
Olivera de Vásquez, Mercedes (1965) `Notas sobre la obra del Doctor Manuel Gamio' , América Indígena25(4): 365-382 .
36.
Patterson, Thomas C. (1995) Toward a Social History of Archaeology in the United States. New York: Harcourt Brace College Publishers .
37.
Price, David H. (2000) `A Private Face of Anthropology: The CIA, the AAA and the Comprehensive Roster of 1952' , paper presented at the Presidential Panel, Meetings of American Anthropological Association, San Francisco, 16 November.
38.
Redfield, Robert (1941) The Folk Culture of Yucatan. Chicago: University of Chicago Press .
39.
Redfield, Robert (1950) A Village that Chose Progress: Chan Kom Revisited. Chicago: University of Chicago Press .
40.
Redfield, Robert, Ralph Linton and Melville J. Herskovits (1936) `Memorandum for the Study of Acculturation' , American Anthropologist38: 149-152 .
41.
Rubenstein, Robert A. (1991) `Introduction: Reflection and Reflexivity in Anthropology', in R.A. Rubenstein (ed.) Fieldwork, pp. 1-35. Boulder, CO: Westview Press .
42.
Schmidt, Arthur (2000) `Mexicans, Migrants, and Indigenous Peoples: The Work of Manuel Gamio in the United States, 1925-1927', in E. Fey and K. Racine (eds) Strange Pilgrimages, pp. 163-178. Wilmington, DE: Scholarly Resources .
43.
Stepan, Nancy (1991) The Hour of Eugenics. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press .
44.
Stock, Chester (1938) `John Campbell Merriam as Scientist and Philosopher', in Cooperation in Research, pp. 765-778. Washington, DC: Carnegie Institition .
45.
Stocking, George W., Jr (1968) `The Scientific Reaction against Cultural Anthropology', in Race, Culture and Evolution, pp. 270-307. New York: Free Press .
46.
Stocking, George W., Jr (1974) `The Basic Assumptions of Boasian Anthropology', in G.W. Stocking Jr (ed.) The Shaping of American Anthropology, 1883-1911, pp. 1-20. New York: Basic Books .
47.
Stocking, George W., Jr (1982) `Afterword: A View from the Center' , Ethnos1-2: 172-186 .
48.
Stocking, George W., Jr (1992) The Ethnographer's Magic. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press .
49.
Strug, David (1971) `Manuel Gamio, la Escuela Internacional y el origen de las excavaciones estratigráfias en las Américas' , América Indígena31(4): 825-844 .
50.
Sullivan, Paul (1989) Unfinished Conversations. New York: Alfred Knopf .
51.
Trigger, Bruce G. (1989) A History of Archaeological Thought. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
52.
Tumin, M. (1945) `Culture, Genuine and Spurious: A Reevaluation' , American Sociological Review10: 199-207 .
53.
Vasconcelos, José (1996) Cosmic Race. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press .
54.
Villa Rojas, Alfonso (1979) `Fieldwork in the Mayan Region of Mexico', in G. Fosteret al. (eds) Long-term Research, pp. 45-64. London: Academic Press .
55.
Vincent, Joan (1990) Anthropology and Politics. Tucson: University of Arizona Press .
56.
Warman, Arturo (1970) `Todos santos y todos difuntos: crítica histórica de la antropología Mexicana', in Arturo Warman (ed.) Eso que llaman la antropología Mexicana, pp. 9-38. México: Nuestro Tiempo .
57.
Walsh, Casey (2001) `Eugenic Acculturation: Manuel Gamio, the SSRC Committee on Human Migration, and the Anthropology of Development in Mexico, 1920-1940' , paper, Meetings of American Anthropological Association, Washington, DC, 1 December.
58.
Weber, Devra (2001) `The Making of Manuel Gamio's “The Life Story of the Mexican Immigrant” ` , paper, Meetings of the American Anthropological Association, Washington, DC, 1 December.
59.
Willey, Gordon R. and Jeremy Sabloff (1974) A History of American Archaeology, 3rd edn. New York: W.H. Freeman .
60.
Wissler, Clark (1923) Man and Culture. New York: Thomas Y. Crowell Co.
61.
Woodbury, R.B. (1973) Alfred V. Kidder. New York: Columbia University Press .
