Legal pluralism is reflected in Papua New Guinea by a system of village courts intended to apply customary law and by a Western-style court system, including a probation service. Village courts have the power to impose penalties for specific "offences," and all courts other than village courts may make probation orders. Women appear before the village court and may be the subject of probation orders by other courts. This article looks at the operation of the village court in relation to female offenders and identifies aspects that tend to disadvantage women charged with village court offences. In contrast, the probation service is identified as assisting women even though it too applies custom in the shaping of probation orders. The conclusion is reached that women offenders believe that they enjoy more sympathetic treatment in the Western-style court system under probation orders than is the case in the customary village court system
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Banks, C. (1993). Women in transition: Social control in Papua New Guinea. Canberra: Australian Institute of Criminology.
2.
Bayne, P. (1985). Village courts in Papua New Guinea. Paper presented at the Aboriginal Criminal Justice Workshop, Australian National University, Canberra.
3.
Bonnell, S. (1997). The impact of compensation and relocation on marriages in Porgera. In S. Toft (Ed.), Compensation for resource development (pp. 145-151). Boroko: Papua New Guinea Law Reform Commission and National Centre for Development Studies Research School of Pacific and Asian Studies, Australian National University.
4.
Borrey, A. (1992). 01 Kalabus Meri: A study of female prisoners in Papua New Guinea. Occasional Paper No. 21, Papua New Guinea Law Reform Commission.
5.
Borrey, A. (1993). Which way to go with prisons: Alternatives for Papua New Guinea. Taim Lain: A Journal of Contemporary Melanesian Studies, 1(1), 64-76.
6.
Bradley, C. (1982). Tolai women and development. Unpublished doctoral thesis, University College, London.
7.
Bradley, C. , & Tovey, S. (1988). Papua New Guinea-"Lo Bilong Famili." Annual Survey of Family Law, Hobart, Tasmania (International Society on Family Law).
8.
Delgoda, J. P. (1993). The use of imprisonment in Papua New Guinea. Taim Lain: A Journal of Contemporary Melanesian Studies, 1(1), 77-81.
9.
Department of Attorney General . (1993). Main programs and subprograms in support of the maintenance of law and order. Unpublished submission, Government of Papua New Guinea.
10.
Dinnen, S. (1993). Public order in Papua New Guinea-Problems and prospects. Crime Studies Division, National Research Institute, Papua New Guinea.
11.
Giddings, L. , & Giddings, R. (1985, March 27). Probation and its possibilities. Paper presented at the I.N.A. Seminar on Law, Order and Development, Port Moresby.
Highlands women have been unfairly treated by village courts. (1991, July 18). Times of PNG, p. 2.
14.
Johnson, D. D. (1979). Aspects of the legal status of women in Papua New Guinea: A working paper. Melanesian Law Journal, 7(1 & 2), 5-81.
15.
Langness, L. L. (1967). Sexual antagonism in the New Guinea Highlands: A Bena Bena example. Oceania, 37(3), 161-177.
16.
Langness, L. L. (1969). Marriage in Bena Bena. In R. M. Glasse & M. J. Meggitt (Eds.), Pigs, pearlshells, and women: Marriage in the New Guinea Highlands (pp. 38-55). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
17.
Langness, L. L. (1974). Ritual, power, and male dominance. Ethos, 2, 189-212.
18.
MacTeine, J. , & Paliwala, A. (1978, August 23-25). Village courts in Simbu. Paper presented at the Australasian Universities Law Schools Association Conference, University of Australia, Perth.
19.
Mitchell, B. (1985). Family law in village courts: The woman's position. In P. King, W. Lee, & V. Warakai (Eds.), From rhetoric to reality: Papua New Guinea `s eight point plan and national goals after a decade (pp. 81-91). Port Moresby: University of Papua New Guinea Press.
20.
National court frees village court "victims." (1991, May 10). Post-Courier.
21.
Paliwala, A. (1977). Village courts in Papua New Guinea: Colonial courts or people's courts? In D. Weisbrot (Ed.), Customary law in Papua New Guinea: A cases and materials source book. Unpublished manuscript, University of Papua New Guinea.
22.
Paliwala, A. (1982). Law and order in the village: Papua New Guinea's village courts. In C. Sumner (Ed.), Crime, justice and underdevelopment (pp. 193-227). London: Heinemann.
23.
Papua New Guinea Justice Department . (1989). Files (SCR No. 2 of 1989) Re: Special Reference Pursuant to Constitution.
24.
Papua New Guinea Probation Service . (1990). Probation service training plan. Waigani: Department of Attorney General.
25.
Papua New Guinea Probation Service. (1992). Annual report. Waigani: Department of Attorney General.
26.
Ranck, S. , & Toft, S. (1986). Domestic violence in an urban context with rural comparisons. In S. Toft (Ed.), Domestic violence in urban Papua New Guinea (Occasional Paper No. 19: 3-51). Port Moresby: Law Reform Commission of Papua New Guinea.
27.
Royal Papua New Guinea Constabulary. (1990). 1990 annual report: Police Department.
28.
Scaglion, R. (1979). Formal and informal operations of a village court in Maprik. Melanesian Law Journal, 7(1 & 2), 116-129.
29.
Scaglion, R. (1990). Legal adaptation in a Papua New Guinea village court. Ethnology, 29, 17-33.
30.
Scaglion, R. , & Whittingham, R. (1985). Female plaintiffs and sex related disputes in rural Papua New Guinea. In S. Toft (Ed.), Domestic violence in Papua New Guinea (Monograph No. 3: 120-133). Port Moresby: Law Reform Commission of Papua New Guinea.
31.
Strathern, M. (1972). Women in between: Female roles in a male world. Mount Hagen, New Guinea. London: Seminar Press.
32.
Strathem, M. (1985). Introduction. In S. Toft (Ed.), Domestic violence in Papua New Guinea (Monograph No. 3: 1-13). Port Moresby: Law Reform Commission of Papua New Guinea.
33.
Toft, S. (Ed.). (1985). Domestic violence in Papua New Guinea (Monograph No. 3). Port Moresby: Papua New Guinea Law Reform Commission.
34.
Toft S. (1986). Domestic violence in Urban Papua New Guinea (Vol. Occasional Paper No. 19). Port Moresby: Papua New Guinea Law Reform Commission.
35.
Toft, S. , & Bonnell, S. (1985). Marriage and domestic violence in Rural Papua New Guinea (Occasional Paper No. 18). Port Moresby: Papua New Guinea Law Reform Commission.
36.
Village Court Records. (1988). Rabaul, ENB.
37.
Village courts discriminate against female-female partner-Woods. (1991, March 7). Times of PNG.
38.
Village Courts Secretariat . (1997). Submission for restructure to secretary, Department of Attorney-General. Unpublished.
39.
Village courts upset by judicial reviews . (1991, May 15). Post-Courier.
40.
Westermark, G. (1985). Family disputes and village courts in the Eastern Highlands. In S. Toft (Ed.), Domestic violence in Papua New Guinea (Monograph No. 3: 104-119). Port Moresby: Law Reform Commission of Papua New Guinea.
