Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

In recent years, fears about the influence of sexual and violent images, a growing concern for the victims of crime and emerging movements against the insulting of religions have widened the range of acceptable restrictions on freedom of expression in the arts. These new non-legal pressures rely on a blurring of the boundaries between representation and enactment or promotion, so that to dramatise is often seen as to condone. The right of consumers not to be offended is now prioritised over the artist’s ability to foster imagination and empathy. At the same time, many advocates of free speech single out Muslims and Sikhs as threats, ignoring the greater power of Christian groups to assert their influence. The author calls for a more complex approach, combining recognition of the value of artistic freedom with an understanding of why disadvantaged communities use the language of religion to protest.

Keywords

Behzti censorship dramatisation freedom of speech offence theatre

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

and ‘Rules of engagement’ , Guardian (22 October 2005).

From 1963-5, Myra Hindley and her boyfriend Ian Brady were responsible for a string of rapes and murders of children and teenagers in greater Manchester, which became known as the Moors murders. Hindley and Brady recorded their victims on tape and buried their bodies in nearby moorland.

James Bulger was a toddler who was abducted from a Merseyside shopping centre and murdered by two ten-year-old boys in 1993.

Gitta Sereny , Cries Unheard: the story of Mary Bell ( London, Macmillan , 1999). Mary Bell was convicted in 1968 of the murders of two boys, Martin Brown (aged four) and Brian Howe (aged three). At the time of the murders, Bell was ten years old.

John Sutherland , Offensive Literature: decensorship in Britain 1960-1982 ( London, Junction Books , 1982), p. 189-189.

Quoted in the Independent on Sunday (29 May 1994).

Evening Standard (27 February 1985).

Guardian (22 December 1993).

Guardian (3 April 1999).

10.

Guardian (8 May 1999).

11.

Sunday Telegraph (14 March 1993).

12.

Anthony Burgess , ‘Stop the clock on violence’ , Observer (21 March 1993).

13.

Guardian (28 October 1997).

14.

Guardian (27 October 1997).

15.

Guardian (28 October 1997).

16.

Independent on Sunday (21 June 1998).

17.

Over a period of twenty years, Fred and Rose West were responsible for the murder of at least twelve young women, many at the couple’s home in Gloucester. The couple were eventually arrested and charged with murder in 1994.

18.

David Edgar , Albert Speer ( London, Nick Hern Books , 2000).

19.

Daily Mail (27 May 2000).

20.

Sunday Telegraph (28 May 2000).

21.

The Times (14 June 2000).

22.

Mail on Sunday (30 July 2000).

23.

Sutherland, op. cit., p. 23.

24.

Guardian (18 June 1997).

25.

Sunday Telegraph (8 November 1998).

26.

Guardian (13 April 1995).

27.

Programme Note ( Royal Exchange Theatre, Manchester , April 2004).

28.

Guardian (28 January 2004).

29.

Guardian (30 July 2001).

30.

and ‘Myra play causes a stir’ , BBC News Online (13 August 1998), available at <http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/entertainment/edinburgh_festival/149756.stm>.

31.

Guardian (12 September 1998).

32.

Daily Express (16 July 2001).

33.

Observer (26 February 2006).

34.

Daily Telegraph (17 February 2006).

35.

Observer (25 September 2005).

36.

Observer (27 November 2005).

37.

In the Sun, quoted in Sunday Telegraph (3 May 1998).

38.

Hannah Arendt , Eichmann in Jerusalem: a report on the banality of evil ( New York, Viking Press , 1994), pp. 47-48.

Shouting fire: art,religion and the right to be offended

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References