The borders between science, ethics and politics are important areas of public life and academic inquiry. One of the most significant border zones are federal advisory bodies tasked with bringing scientific and ethical knowledge to bear on matters of public concern. This paper uses the President's Council on Bioethics during Leon Kass' tenure as Chair as a case study to investigate the norms governing the interface between expert knowledge and democratic decision-making. It first introduces the Kass Council and examines legitimation, politicization and their relationships within federal advisory bodies. The paper then evaluates the Kass Council using the standards derived from this conceptual normative investigation. Three case studies of the Kass Council provide evidence that charges of politicization were sometimes accurate, while at other times they were mischaracterizations.
American Society for Cell Biology (2004) `Cell Biologists Oppose Removal of Top Scientist', Press release (2 March). Available at http://www.ascb.org/index.cfm?navid=121&id=1853&tcode=nws3 (accessed 10 January 2009).
2.
Anderson, Maria (2004) `Bush Dismisses Council Members', The Scientist (3 March). Available at <www.biomedcentral.com/news/20040303/04> ; (accessed 18 March 2008).
3.
Annas, George & Sherman Elias (2004) `Politics, Morals, and Embryos' , Nature431: 19-20.
4.
Annas, Julia (2001) `Moral Knowledge as Practical Knowledge', Social Philosophy and Policy18(2): 236-56. Reprinted in E. Selinger & R. Crease (eds) (2006), The Philosophy of Expertise (New York: Columbia University Press): 280-301.
5.
Arnhart, Larry (2005) `The President's Council on Bioethics', in Carl Mitcham (ed.), The Encyclopedia of Science, Technology, and Ethics (New York: Macmillan).
6.
Blackburn, Elizabeth (2004) `A "Full Range" of Bioethical Views Just Got Narrower' , Washington Post (7 March): B02.
7.
Blackburn, Elizabeth & Janet Rowley (2004) `Reason as our Guide', PLoS Biology2(4): 420-22.
8.
Cameron, Nigel (2002) `Defending Dignity: An Interview with Leon Kass' , American Enterprise13(7): 447-;46.
9.
Caplan, Arthur (2002) `A Council of Clones', Diabetes Daily News (18 January). Available at <www.deabetesdailynews.org/print/print0102/p_0102_11.htm> ; (accessed 18 March 2008).
10.
Carson, Benjamin (1992) Think Big: Unleashing Your Potential for Excellence (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan Publishing House).
11.
Cash, David, William C. Clark, Frank Alcock, Nancy M. Dickson, Noelle Eckley, David H. Guston, et al. (2003) `Knowledge Systems for Sustainable Development' , Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences100(14): 8086-91.
12.
Charo, R. Alta (2004) `Passing on the Right: Conservative Bioethics is Closer than it Appears', Journal of Law, Medicine, and Ethics32: 307-14.
13.
Cohen, Cynthia (2005) `Promises and Perils of Public Deliberation: Contrasting Two National Bioethics Commissions on Embryonic Stem Cell Research', Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal15(3): 269-88.
14.
Cohen, Eric (2004) `Science, Democracy, and Stem Cells', Philosophy Today48(5): 23-29.
15.
Collins, H.M. & Robert Evans (2006) `The Third Wave of Science Studies: Studies of Expertise and Experience', in E. Selinger & R. Crease (eds), The Philosophy of Expertise (New York: Columbia University Press): 39-110.
16.
Cook, Michael (2004) `Ethics as Our Guide', PLoS Biology2(6): 737.
17.
Dahl, Robert (2000) On Democracy (New Haven, CT : Yale University Press).
18.
Deephouse, David L. & Suzanne M. Carter (2005) `An Examination of Differences between Organizational Legitimacy and Organizational Reputation', Journal of Management Studies42(2): 329-60.
19.
Elliott, Carl (2004) `Beyond Politics', MSN Slate Magazine . Available at <http://slate.msn.com/id/2096815> ; (accessed 18 March 2008).
20.
Evans, John (2002) Playing God? Human Genetic Engineering and the Rationalization of Public Bioethical Debate (Chicago, IL : University of Chicago Press).
21.
Executive Order 13237 (2001). Available at <www.bioethics.gov/about/executive.html> (accessed 18 March 2008).
22.
Ezrahi, Yaron (1990) The Descent of Icarus: Science and the Transformation of Contemporary Democracy (London: Harvard University Press).
23.
Federation of American Scientists (2004) `Flying Blind: The Rise, Fall, and Possible Resurrection of Science Policy Advice in the United States'. Available at < www.fas.org/resource/12022004142618.pdf> (accessed 18 March 2008).
24.
Fletcher, John (1994) `On Restoring Public Bioethics', Politics and the Life Sciences13: 84-86.
25.
Fletcher, John & Franklin Miller (1996) `The Promise and Perils of Public Bioethics', in Harold Vanderpool (ed.), The Ethics of Research Involving Human Subjects: Facing the 21st Century (Frederick, MD: University Publishing Group): 155-84.
26.
Fuchs, Michael (2005) National Ethics Councils: Their Backgrounds, Functions, and Modes of Operation Compared (Berlin: Nationaler Ethikrat). Available at <www.ethikrat.org/_english/publications/Fuchs_International_Ethics_Councils.pdf> (accessed 18 March 2008).
27.
Gillespie, Nick (2002) `Anti-Science-Fiction', MSN Slate Magazine. Available at <http://slate.msn.com/id/2060902> ; (accessed 18 March 2008).
28.
Guston, David (1999) Between Politics and Science: Assuring the Productivity and Integrity of Research (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
29.
Hall, Stephen (2002) `President's Bioethics Council Delivers', Science297 (5580): 322-24.
30.
Hilgartner, Stephen (2000) Science on Stage: Expert Advice as Public Drama (Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press).
Hudson, Kathy (2004) `Something Old and Something New', The Hastings Center Report34(4): 14-15.
33.
Jasanoff, Sheila (1990) The Fifth Branch: Science Advisors as Policymakers (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press).
34.
Jonsen, Albert (1998) The Birth of Bioethics (New York: Oxford University Press).
35.
Kass, Leon (2002) Life, Liberty, and the Defense of Dignity: The Challenge for Bioethics (New York: Encounter Books).
36.
Kass, Leon (2004) `We Don't Play Politics with Science', Washington Post (3 March): A27. Available at <www.irbforum.com/forum/read/2/50/50?PHPSESSID=1d59190ff9646536f27b2205acfa397c> (accessed 18 March 2008).
37.
Kass, Leon (2005) `Reflections on Public Bioethics: A View from the Trenches', Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal15(3): 221-50.
38.
Kennedy, Donald (2004) `Just Treat, or Enhance?', Science304(5667): 17.
Kohn, David & Julie Bell (2004) `2 Appointees Defend Place on Bioethics Panel: Bush Critics Say Politics, Not Science, Ruled Choice', Baltimore Sun.com (2 March): 7A.
41.
Michaels, David, Eula Bingham, Les Boden, Richard Clapp, Lynn R. Goldman, Polly Hoppin, et al. (2002) `Advice without Dissent', Science298(5594): 703.
42.
Mooney, Chris (2005) The Republican War on Science ( New York: Basic Books).
43.
Murray, Iain (2005) `Bioethics Panel Illustrates Scientific Ethics' Complexity'. Available at <http://cei.org/gencon/019,04439.cfm> ; (accessed 10 January 2009).
44.
Pearson, Yvette (2004) `Playing Politics with Bioethics: Now That's Repugnant' , Journal of Philosophy, Science, and Law4 (May). Available at <www.6.miami.edu/ethics/jpsl/archives/all/playingPolitics.html> (accessed 18 March 2008).
45.
Pielke, Roger Jr (ed.) (2004) `A Report on the Misuse of Science in the Administrations of George H.W. Bush and William J. Clinton'. Available at <http://sciencepolicy.colorado.edu/admin/publication_files/resource-1935-2004.27.pdf> (accessed 18 March 2008).
46.
Pielke, Roger Jr. (2005) `Defending Kass but Confirming the Conflict'. Available at <http://sciencepolicy.colorado.edu/prometheus/archives/biotechnology/000379defending_kass_but_c.html> ; (accessed 18 March 2008).
47.
Pielke, Roger Jr (2007) The Honest Broker: Making Sense of Science in Policy and Politics (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
48.
Poland, Susan Cartier (1998) `Bioethics Commissions: Town Meetings with a "Blue, Blue Ribbon"', Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal8(1): 91-109.
49.
President's Council on Bioethics (2002a) Transcripts 17 January 2002. Available at < www.bioethics.gov/transcripts/jan02/jan17.html> (accessed 18 March 2008).
50.
President's Council on Bioethics (2002b) Human Cloning and Human Dignity: An Ethical Inquiry. Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office.
51.
President's Council on Bioethics (2003) Beyond Therapy: Biotechnology and the Pursuit of Happiness ( Washington, DC: Government Printing Office ).
52.
President's Council on Bioethics (2004a) Monitoring Stem Cell Research (Washington, DC: Government Printing Office).
53.
President's Council on Bioethics (2004b) Reproduction and Responsibility: The Regulation of New Biotechnologies (Washington, DC: Government Printing Office ).
54.
Sarewitz, Daniel (2004) `How Science Makes Environmental Controversies Worse', Environmental Science and Policy7(5): 385-403.
55.
Singer, Peter (1972) `Moral Experts', Analysis32: 115-17.
56.
Suchman, Mark C. (1995) `Managing Legitimacy: Strategic and Institutional Approaches', Academy of Management Review20(3): 571-610.
57.
Suskind, Ron (2006) The One Percent Doctrine: Deep Inside America's Pursuit of its Enemies since 9/11 (New York: Simon and Schuster).
58.
Turner, Leigh (2004) `Science, Politics, and the President's Council on Bioethics', Nature Biotechnology22: 509-10.
59.
Union of Concerned Scientists (2004) `Scientific Integrity in Policymaking'. Available at < www.ucsusa.org/global_environment/rsi/page.cfm?pageID=1446> ; (accessed 18 March 2008).
60.
United States General Accounting Office (2004 ) Federal Advisory Committees: Additional Guidance Could Help Agencies Better Ensure Independence and Balance. GAO-04-328.
61.
Walzer, Michael (1981) `Philosophy and Democracy', Political Theory9: 379-400.
62.
Waxman, Henry A. (2003) `Politics and Science in the Bush Administration' . Available at <http://oversight.house.gov/documents/20080130103545.pdf> ; (accessed 10 January 2009).
63.
Weiss, Rick (2002) `Bush Unveils Bioethics Council', Washington Post (17 January): A2.
64.
Weiss, Rick (2005) `Conservatives Draft a "Bioethics Agenda" for President' , Washington Post (8 March): A06.
65.
Wilkie, Dana (2002) `The Puzzle of Leon Kass', Crisis Magazine. Available at <www.crisismagazine.com/june2002/feature3.htm> ; (accessed 18 March 2008).
66.
Wilson, James Q. (2005) `On Leon Kass and Bioethics'. Available at <http://web.archive.org/web/20050318060508/http://www.techcentralstation.com/031705G.html> ; (accessed 30 January 2009).
67.
Yoder, Scot (1998) `The Nature of Ethical Expertise', Hastings Center Report28(6): 11-19.
