Product Deletion: A Critical Overview and Empirical Insight into this Process

Abstract

With organisations as diverse as Heinz, Kraft, Polygram and Sony reducing the scope of their product portfolios, it appears that the issue of product deletion is currently exercising managerial minds. Those keen to pursue their interest in this area will find a concise body of work spanning nearly six decades. However, missing from this work is an understanding of the recurring tactical, strategic and cultural variables involved in deletion decision-making. This research sought to alleviate this shortcoming through conducting an in-depth literature review and considering the deletion experiences of three world-renowned organisations. The results of this exploratory study provide an initial insight into the core product deletion variables, providing managers and academics with valuable up-to-date information on this contemporary subject matter.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alexander

R. S.

(1964), ‘The Death and Burial of Sick Products’, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 28, pp. 1–7.

Argouslidis

P. C.

and McLean

(2003), ‘Service Elimination Decision-Making: Analysis of Candidates for Elimination and Remedial Actions’, Journal of Marketing Management, Vol. 19, pp. 307–344.

Avlonitis

G. J.

and James

B. G. S.

(1982), ‘Some Dangerous Axioms of Product Elimination Decision Making’, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 16, No. 1, pp. 36–48.

Avlonitis

G. I.

(1983), ‘The Product-Elimination Decision and Strategies’, Industrial Marketing Management, Vol. 12, pp. 31–43.

Avlonitis

G. J.

(1983a), ‘Ethics and Product Elimination’, Management Decision, Vol. 21, No. 2, pp. 37–45.

Avlonitis

G. J.

(1984), ‘Industrial Product Elimination: Major Factors to Consider’, Industrial Marketing Management, Vol. 13, pp. 77–85.

Avlonitis

G. J.

(1985), ‘The Techno-Economic Ecology of the Product Elimination Process’, International Journal of Research in Marketing, Vol. 2, pp. 175–184.

Avlonitis

G. J.

(1985a), ‘Product Elimination Decision Making: Does Formality Matter?’, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 49, pp. 41–52.

Avlonitis

G. J.

(1986), ‘The Identification of Weak Industrial Products’, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 20, No. 10, pp. 24–42.

10.

Avlonitis

G. J.

(1986a), ‘The Management of the Product Elimination Function: Theoretical and Empirical Analysis’, in: Woodside

, Advances in Business Marketing, Vol. 1, pp. 1–65, Greenwich CT: JAI Press.

11.

Avlonitis

G. J.

(1987), ‘Linking Different Types of Product Elimination Decisions to Their Performance Outcome: Project Dropstrat’, International Journal of Research in Marketing, No. 4, pp. 43–57.

12.

Avlonitis

G. J.

(1989), ‘Project Dropstrat: Product Elimination and the Product Life Cycle Concept’, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 24, No. 9, pp. 55–67.

13.

Avlonitis

G. J.

(1993), ‘Project Dropstrat: What Factors do Managers Consider in Deciding Whether to Drop a Project?’, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 27, No. 4, pp. 35–57.

14.

Avlonitis

G. J.

Hart

S.J.

and Tzokas

N. X.

(2000), ‘An Analysis of Product Deletion Scenarios’, Journal of Product Innovation Management, Vol. 17, Issue 1, pp. 41–56.

15.

Baker

and Bettner

(1997), ‘Interpretive and Critical Research in Accounting: A Commentary on its Absence from Mainstream Accounting Research’, Critical Perspectives on Accounting, Vol. 8, pp. 293–310.

16.

Banville

G. B.

and Pletcher

B. A.

(1974), ‘The Product Elimination Function’, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, Vol. 2, Summer, pp. 432–446.

17.

Bell

Davies

and Howard

(1997), ‘The Changing Structure of Food Retailing in Europe: The Implications for Strategy’, Long Range Planning, Vol. 30, No. 5, pp. 853–861.

18.

Bereson

(1963), ‘Pruning the Product Line’, Business Horizon, No. 6, pp. 63–70.

19.

Bereson

and Mohr-Jackson

(1994), ‘Product Rejuvenation: A Less Risky Alternative to Product Innovation’, Business Horizons, Vol. 37, No. 6, pp. 51–58.

20.

Betts

(2006), ‘Companies Scaling the Barriers with Record Deals’, Financial Times, 28th March,pp. 20.

21.

Blois

K. J.

(1997), ‘Are Business-to-Business Relationships Inherently Unstable?’, Journal of Marketing Management, Vol. 13, pp. 367–382.

22.

Boltin

and Gorneau

(1998), ‘Why You Must Crop Your Products: If You Want to Cultivate Your Bottom Line, Try Trimming Your Product Line’, Financial Executive, Vol. 14, No. 4, pp. 18–23.

23.

Boston Consultancy Group (1972), Perspectives on Experience, Boston: Boston Consultancy Group.

24.

Browne

W.G.

and Kemp

P. S.

(1976), ‘A Three Stage Product Review Process’, Industrial Marketing Management, No. 5, pp. 333–352.

25.

Buckley

(2002), ‘Reconditioned P&G Continues to Shine Consumer Products Restored Focus on Core Brands Adds to Benefits of Restructuring’, Financial Times, 30th October,pp. 27.

26.

Burnes

(2000), Managing Change: A Strategic Approach to Organisational Dynamics (3rd edition), Harlow, Essex: Prentice Hall.

27.

Business Week (1974), ‘The Squeeze on Product Mix’, 5th January, pp. 50–55.

28.

Cannon

J. P.

and Perreault

W. D.

(1999), ‘Buyer-Seller Relationships in Business Marketing’, Journal of Marketing Research, Vol. XXXVI, November, pp. 439–460.

29.

Carlisle

J. A.

and Parker

R. C.

(1989), Beyond Negotiation, Chichester: Wiley.

30.

Carroll

and Johnson

(1990), Decision Research: A Field Guide, London: Sage Publications.

31.

Clayton

H. L.

(1966), ‘The Pruning of Sick Products’, Management Accounting, June, pp. 17–18.

32.

Cooper

Edgett

and Kleinschmidt

(1999), ‘New Product Portfolio Management: Practices and Performance’, Journal of Product Innovation Management, Vol. 16, pp. 333–351.

33.

Corstjens

and Corstjens

(1995), Store Wars: The Battle for Mindspace and Shelfspace, Chichester: Wiley.

34.

Cox

(1999), ‘Power, Value and Supply Chain Management’, Supply Chain Management: An International Journal, Vol. 4, No. 4, pp. 167–175.

35.

Dawson

J. A.

and Shaw

S. A.

(1990), ‘The Changing Character of Retailer-Supplier Relationships’, Retail Distribution Management, pp. 19–39.

36.

Day

(1977), ‘Diagnosing the Product Portfolio’, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 41, April, pp. 29–38.

37.

Dimitratos

McDonald

and Tüselmann

(2003), ‘International Economic and Environmental Changes’, in: Hart

S. J.

Marketing Changes, pp. 8–28, London: Thomson.

38.

Eckles

R. W.

(1971), ‘Product Line Deletion and Simplification’, Business Horizons, October, pp. 71–76.

39.

Easterby-Smith

Thorpe

and Lowe

(1997), Management Research: An Introduction, London: Sage Publications.

40.

Evans

R. H.

(1977), ‘Add Soft Data to Product Elimination Decisions’, Industrial Marketing Management, Vol. 6, May, pp. 91–99.

41.

Fluitman

L.P.

(1973), ‘The Necessity of an Industrial Product Mix Analysis’, Industrial Marketing Management, Vol. 2, pp. 345–352.

42.

Ford

(1982), in: Hakan Hakansson (ed.), International Marketing and Purchasing of Industrial Goods: An Interaction Approach, Chichester: Wiley.

43.

Friedman

H. H.

and Krausz

(1986), A Portfolio Theory Approach to Solve the Product Elimination Problem’, The Mid-Atlantic Journal of Business, Vol. 24, No. 2, pp. 43–48.

44.

Frost

(2004), ‘Forcing Brands into Early Retirement’, www.brandchannel.com, 2nd August.

45.

Goldgehn

and Lagrace

(1983), ‘Giving a New Dimension to Product Portfolio Analysis’, Management Review, April, pp. 57–61.

46.

Grant

(2005), ‘Lafley Learns from Gillette as P&G Moves to Next Level’, Financial Times, December 21st.

47.

Greenley

G. E.

and Bayus

B. L.

(1994), A Comparative Study of Product Launch and Deletion Decisions in UK and US Companies’, European Journal of Marketing, No. 28, pp. 5–29.

48.

Hambrick

D. C.

(1983), ‘An Empirical Typology of Mature Industrial-Product Environments’, Academy of Management Journal, Vol. 26, pp. 213–230.

49.

Hamelman

P. H.

and Mazze

E. M.

(1972), ‘Improving Product Abandonment Decisions’, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 36, pp. 20–26.

50.

Hart

S. J.

(1988), ‘The Causes of Product Elimination in British Manufacturing Companies’, Journal of Marketing Management, Vol. 3, No. 2, pp. 328–343.

51.

Hart

S. J.

(1989), ‘Product Deletion and the Effects of Strategy’, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 23, No. 10, pp. 6–17.

52.

Hart

S. J.

(1990/1991), ‘The Management Setting of the Product Deletion Decision’, Irish Marketing Review, Vol. 5, Part. 3, pp. 41–54.

53.

Hingley

M. K.

(2005), ‘Power to All Friends? Living with Imbalance in Supplier-Retailer Relations’, International Marketing Management, No. 34, pp. 848–858.

54.

Hise

R. T.

and McGinnis

(1975), ‘Product Elimination: Practises, Policies, and Ethics’, Business Horizons, Vol. 18, pp. 25–32.

55.

Hise

R. T.

Parasuraman

and Viswanathan

(1984), ‘Product Elimination: The Neglected Management Responsibility’, Journal of Business Strategy, Vol. 4, No. 4, pp. 56–63.

56.

Hogarth-Scott

and Parkinson

S. T.

(1993), ‘Retailer-Supplier Relationships in the Food Channel: A Suppliers Perspective’, International Journal of Retail and Distribution Management, Vol. 21, No. 8, pp. 11–13.

57.

Houfek

L. J.

(1952), ‘How to Decide which Products to Junk’, Printers Inc, August, pp. 21–33.

58.

Howe

W. S.

(1998), ‘Vertical Marketing Relations in the UK Grocery Trade: Analysis and Government Policy’, International Journal of Retail & Distribution Management, Vol. 26, No. 6, pp. 212–224.

59.

Hurst

(1959), ‘Criteria for Evaluating Existing Products and Product Lines’, in: ‘Analysing and Improving Market Performance’, American Management Association, Management Report, No. 32, pp. 92–101.

60.

Huy

(2002), ‘Emotional Filtering in Strategic Change’, Academy of Management Proceedings ODC, pp. C1–C6.

61.

Jackson

B. B.

and Shapiro

B. P.

(1979), ‘New Way to Make Product Line Decisions’, Harvard Business Review, May-June, pp. 139–49.

62.

Johnson

M. L.

(1975), ‘End of the Line for Weak Products’, Industry Week, 15th September, pp. 25–29.

63.

Kotler

(1965), ‘Phasing Out Weak Products’, Harvard Business Review, pp. 107–118.

64.

Kotler

(1974), ‘Marketing During Periods of Shortage’, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 38, July, pp. 20–29.

65.

Kotler

(1978), ‘Harvesting Strategies for Weak Products’, Business Horizons, August, pp. 15–22.

66.

Kotzab

and Teller

(2003), ‘Value-Adding Partnerships and Co-opetition Models in the Grocery Industry’ International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management, Vol. 33, No. 3, pp. 268–281.

67.

Kratchman

S. H.

Hise

R. T.

and Ulrich

T. A.

(1975), ‘Management’s Decision to Discontinue a Product’, Journal of Accountancy, June, pp. 50–54.

68.

Lambert

D. M.

and Sterling

J. U.

(1985), ‘The Product Abandonment Decision’, Management Accounting, August, Vol. 67, No. 2, pp. 20–21.

69.

Lancaster

(1979), Variety, Equity and Efficiency, New York, Columbia University Press.

70.

Lazer

Luqmani

and Quraeshi

(1984), ‘Product Rejuvenation Strategies’, Business Horizons, November-December, pp. 21–28.

71.

Leidecker

J. K.

and Bruno

A. V.

(1984), ‘Identifying and Using Critical Success Factors’, Long Range Planning, Vol. 17, No. 1, pp. 23–32.

72.

Mantrala

M. K.

Levy

Kahn

B. E.

Fox

E. J.

Gaidarev

Dankworth

and Denish

(2009), ‘Why is Assortment Planning so Difficult for Retailers? A Framework and Research (1987), ‘Eliminating Products Can Aid Overall Sales Picture’, Marketing News, Vol. 21, No. 15, pp. 9–11.

73.

Michael

G. C.

(1971), ‘Product Petrifaction: A New Stage in the Life Cycle Theory’, California Management Review, Vol. 14, Fall, pp. 88–91.

74.

Michaels

(2000), ‘P&Gmaysell Brand of Shampoo’, Financial Times, 9th November, pp. 44.

75.

Mitchell

M. A.

Taylor

R. D.

and Tanyel

(1998), ‘Product Elimination Decisions: A Comparison of American and British Manufacturing Firms’, International Journal of Commerce and Management, Vol. 8, No. 1, pp. 8–27.

76.

Muir

J. J.

(2006), An Investigation into the Application of a Product Deletion Typology and the Impact of Key Contextual Factors, Manchester Business School, Unpublished PhD Dissertation.

77.

Olver

J. M.

and Farris

P. W.

(1989), ‘Push and Pull: A One-Two Punch for Packaged Products’, Sloan Management Review, Fall, pp. 53–61.

78.

Palmer

(2000), ‘Co-operation and Competition: A Darwinian Synthesis of Relationship Marketing’, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 34, No. 5/6, pp. 687–704.

79.

Palmer

(2002), ‘The Role of Selfishness in Buyer-Seller Relationships’, Marketing Intelligence, Vol. 20, Issue 1, pp. 22–27.

80.

Petromilli

Morrison

and Million

(2002), ‘Brand Architecture: Building Brand Portfolio Value’, Strategy and Leadership, Vol. 30, No. 5, pp. 22–28.

81.

Pletcher

B. A.

(1973), The Product Elimination Process in the Small Home Appliance Industry: An Empirical Study, Kent State University, Unpublished DBA Dissertation.

82.

Proctor

and Hassard

(1990), ‘Toward a New Model for Product Portfolio Analysis’, Management Decision, Vol. 28, Part 3, pp. 14–17.

83.

Quelch

J. A.

and Kenny

(1994), ‘Extend Profits, Not Product Lines’, Harvard Business Review, Vol. 72, Sep/Oct, pp. 153–165.

84.

Quelch

J. A.

and Harding

(1996), ‘Brands Versus Private Labels: Fighting to Win’, Harvard Business Review, January-February, pp. 99–109.

85.

Rothe

J. T.

(1970), ‘The Product Elimination Decision’, MSU Business Topics, Vol. 18, Autumn, pp. 45–52.

86.

Salerno

(1982), Processus et Comportements d'Abandon de Produit: Analyse et Implications, Universite de Lille, Mars, These de Doctorat d'Etat de Science de Gestion.

87.

Sanchatha

(2007), ‘Sony Under Fire Over 60Gb PS3 Phase-Out Plans’, Financial Times, Companies and Markets, July 18th, pp. 21.

88.

Sanderson

(2008), ‘Morrisons Boosts UK Grocery Market Share – TNS’, www.Reuters.com, accessed 8th June, 2009.

89.

Schramm

(1971), Notes on Case Studies of Instructional Media Projects, Washington DC, Working Paper, The Academy for Educational Development.

90.

Seth

(2004), ‘The Ingram Partnership: Shelf Preservation Brand Owners Must Ensure Their Product is the One Retailers Have to Stock’, Financial Times, 7th December,pp. 4.

91.

Shapiro

B. B.

(1977), ‘Industrial Product Policy: Managing the Existing Product Line’, Marketing Science Institute Report, September, pp. 77–110.

92.

Simmons

C. J.

Bickart

B. A.

and Buchanan

(2000), ‘Leveraging Equity Across the Brand Portfolio’, Marketing Letters, Vol. 11, No. 3, pp. 210–212.

93.

Snelson

and Hart

S. J.

(1991), ‘Product Policy: Perspectives on Success’, in: Baker

M. J.

(ed.) Perspectives on Marketing Management, Vol. 1, pp. 193–225, Chichester: John Wiley & Sons Ltd.

94.

Sonnecken

E. H.

and Hurst

(1960), ‘How to Audit Your Existing Products – For Profit’, Management Methods, April, pp. 45–47.

95.

Taylor

(2008), ‘Make the Way for the Heros’, The Marketer, April,pp. 13.

96.

Talley

W. J

Jr (1964), ‘Profiting from the Declining Product’, Business Horizons, Vol. 7, Spring, pp. 77–84.

97.

Tomkins

(2000), ‘Brands: The Perennial Conflict Between Producers and Retailers Has Entered a New Phase’, Financial Times, 16th June.

98.

Vyas

N. M.

(1993), ‘Industrial Product Elimination Decisions: Some Complex Issues’, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 27, No. 4, pp. 58–76.

99.

Webster

F. E

Jr (1992), ‘The Changing Role of Marketing in the Corporation’, Journal of Marketing, Oct, Vol. 56, No. 4, pp. 1–17.

100.

Webster

F. E

Jr (2005) ‘Back to the Future: Integrating Marketing as Tactics, Strategy, and Organizational Culture’, pp. 4–6, in: ‘American Renaissance: Opportunities and Imperatives for Improving Marketing Thought, Practice, and Infrastructure’, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 69, pp. 1–25.

101.

Weller

D. G.

and Inst

(1969), ‘Run-Out Strategy – Profits from the Failing Product’, Marketing Forum, November-December, pp. 15–20.

102.

Wind

and Claycamp

H. J.

(1976), ‘Planning Product Line Strategy: A Matrix Approach’, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 40, pp. 2–9.

103.

Wind

and Mahajan

(1981), ‘Designing Product and Business Portfolios’, Harvard Business Review, January-February, pp. 155–165.

104.

Wood

(2009), ‘Relying on Crumbles to Survive the Crunch’, The Observer, March 1st.

105.

Worthing

P. M.

(1975), ‘Improving Product Deletion Decision-Making’, MSU Business Topics, Summer, pp. 29–37.

106.

Yin

R. K.

(2008), Case Study Research: Design and Methods (4th edition), California: Thousand Oaks.