This study investigates the degree to which a conductor's transformational
leadership and orchestral musicians' positive group mood have a beneficial
effect on orchestral performance. The authors study the assertion that there is an
interaction effect of conductor's transformational leadership style and
group mood in the orchestra. In this view, neither the conductor's
transformational leadership nor the musicians' positive group mood alone
foster success; only the interaction between transformational leadership and
positive group mood is effective at promoting orchestral performance. An empirical
study of 208 musicians from 22 German symphony orchestras reveals the assumed
interaction effect of a conductor's leadership style and
musicians' group mood on the artistic quality of the orchestra.
Aiken, L.S.
and
West, S.G.
(1991) Multiple Regression: Testing and Interpreting
Interactions.
Newbury Park, CA: Sage
.
2.
Atik, Y.
(1994)
‘The Conductor and the Orchestra: Interactive Aspects of the
Leadership Process’
, Leadership and Organization Development Journal15(1):
22–2228
.
3.
Auvinen, T.
(2001)
‘Why Is It Difficult to Manage an Opera House? The
Artistic–Economic Dichotomy and its Manifestations in
Organizational Structures of Five Opera Organizations’
, Journal of Arts Management, Law and Society30(4):
268–26282
.
4.
Avolio, B.J.
,
Bass, B.M.
and
Jung, D.I.
(1999)
‘Re-examining the Components of Transformational and
Transactional Leadership using the Multifactor Leadership Questionnaire’
, Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology72:
441–462
.
5.
Barsade, S.G.
and
Gibson, D.E.
(1998) ‘Group Emotion: A View from Top and
Bottom’, in
M.A. Neale
and
E.A. Mannix
(eds) Research on Managing Groups and Teams, pp.
81–102.
Stanford, CA: JAI Press
.
6.
Bartel, C.A.
and
Saavedra, R.
(2000)
‘The Collective Construction of Work Group Moods’
, Administrative Science Quarterly45:
197–231
.
7.
Bliese, P.
(2000) ‘Within-Group Agreement,
Non-independence, and Reliability’, in
K.J. Klein
and
S.W.J. Kozlowski
(eds) Multilevel Theory, Research, and Methods in Organizations,
pp. 349–381.
San Francisco: Jossey-Bass
.
8.
Boerner, S.
(2002) Führungsverhalten und
Führungserfolg–ein Beitrag zu einer Theorie der
Führung am Beispiel des Musiktheaters.
Wiesbaden: Gabler
.
9.
Boerner, S.
(2004)
‘Artistic Quality in an Opera Company–Towards the
Development of a Concept’
, Nonprofit Management and Leadership4(4):
425–436
.
10.
Boerner, S.
and
Gebert, D.
(2005)
‘Organizational Culture and Creative Processes: Comparing German
Theatre Companies and Scientific Institutes’
, Nonprofit Management and Leadership16(2):
209–220
.
11.
Boerner, S.
and
Krause, D.E.
(2002)
‘Führung im Orchester: Kunst ohne künstlerische
Freiheit? Eine empirische Untersuchung’
, Zeitschrift für Personalforschung16(1):
90–106
.
12.
Couch, S.R.
(1983) ‘Patronage and Organizational Structure
in Symphony Orchestras in London and New York’, in
J.B. Kamerman
and
R. Martorella
(eds) Performers & Performances: The Social Organization of
Artistic Work, pp. 109–122.
South Hadlye, MA: Bergin
.
13.
Dahlhaus, C.
(1973) ‘Über musikalische
Werturteile’, in
W. Krützfeld
(ed.) Wertproblematik der Musikdidaktik, pp.
9–18.
Ratingen: Henn
.
14.
De Dreu, C.K.W.
and
Weingart, L.R.
(2002)
‘Task versus Relationship Conflict, Team Performance, and Team
Member Satisfaction: A Meta-Analysis’
, paper presented at the Academy of Management Meeting,
Denver, August.
15.
Faulkner, R.
(1973)
‘Orchestra Interaction: Some Features of Communication and
Authority in an Artistic Organization’
, Sociological Quarterly14:
147–157
.
16.
Fuller, J.B.
,
Patterson, C.E.P.
,
Hester, K.
and
Stringer, D.Y.
(1996)
‘A Quantitative Review of Research on Charismatic Leadership’
, Psychological Reports78:
271–287
.
17.
Gebert, D.
(2002) Führung und Innovation.
Stuttgart: Kohlhammer
.
18.
Gebert, D.
(2004) Innovation durch Teamarbeit–ein kritische
Bestandsaufnahme.
Stuttgart: Kohlhammer
.
19.
Gebert, D.
,
Boerner, S.
and
Kearney, E.
(in press)
‘Crossfunctionality and innovation in new product development
teams: The dynamics of the dilemmatic structure and consequences for the
management of diversity’
. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology.
20.
Hunt, J.G.
,
Stelluto, G.E.
and
Hooijberg, R.
(2004)
‘Toward New-Wave Organization Creativity: Beyond Romance and
Analogy in the Relationship between Orchestra–Conductor Leadership
and Musician Creativity’
, Leadership Quarterly15:
154–162
.
21.
Isen, A.M.
and
Baron, R.A.
(1991) ‘Positive Affect as a Factor in
Organizational Behavior’, in
B.M. Staw
and
L.L. Cummings
(eds) Research in Organizational Behavior, pp.
1–53.
Greenwich, CT: JAI Press
.
22.
Jaccard, J.
and
Turrisi, R.
(2003) Interaction Effects in Multiple Regression.
2nd edn.Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
.
23.
James, L.R.
,
Demaree, R.G.
and
Wolf, G.
(1984)
‘Estimating Within-Group Interrater Reliability With and Without
Response Bias’
, Journal of Applied Psychology69:
85–98
.
24.
Kamerman, J.B.
(1983) ‘Symphony Conducting as an
Occupation’, in
J.B. Kamerman
and
R. Martorella
(eds) Performers & Performances: The Social Organization of
Artistic Work, pp. 43–56.
South Hadlye, MA: Bergin
.
25.
Kozlowski, S.W.
and
Hattrup, K.
(1992)
‘A Disagreement about Within-Group Agreement: Disentangling
Issues of Consistency versus Consensus’
, Journal of Applied Psychology77:
161–167
.
26.
Krause, D.E.
,
Boerner, S.
,
Lanwehr, R.
and
Nachtigall, C.
(2002)
‘Strukturgleichungsmodelle zur Analyse von Macht und
Führungserfolg im Orchester’
, Zeitschrift für Personalpsychologie1:
124–137
.
27.
Lebrecht, N.
(1991) Der Mythos vom Maestro.
Zürich: M&T Verlag
.
28.
Levine, S.
and
Levine, R.
(1996)
‘Why They’re Not Smiling: Stress and Discontent in the
Orchestra Workplace
, Harmony2:
15–25
.
29.
Lowe, K.B.
,
Kroeck, K.G.
and
Sivasubramaniam, N.
(1996)
‘Effectiveness Correlates of Transformational and Transactional
Leadership: A Meta-analytic Review of the MLQ Literature’
, Leadership Quarterly7(3):
385–425
.
30.
McDonald, R.P.
(1999) Test Theory: A Unified Treatment.
Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum
.
31.
Mehta, Z.
(2003)
‘Managing the New York Philharmonic in Today's World’
, International Journal of Arts Management5(3):
4–11
.
32.
Müller, G.F.
and
Bierhoff, H.W.
(2001) ‘Stimmungseinflüsse in
Projektgruppen’, in
R. Fisch
,
D. Beck
and
B. Englich
(eds) Projektgruppen in Organisationen, pp.
323–336.
Göttingen: Verlag für
Angewandte Psychologie
.
33.
Saavedra, R.
,
Earley, P.C.
and
Van Dyne, L.
(1993)
‘Complex Interdependence in Task-Performing Groups’
, Journal of Applied Behavioral Psychology78(1):
61–72
.
34.
Shea, G.P.
and
Guzzo, R.A.
(1987) ‘Groups as Human
Resources’, in
K.M. Rowland
and
G.P. Ferris
(eds) Research in Human Resources and Personal Management, pp.
323–356.
Greenwich, CT: JAI Press
.
35.
Tajfel, H.
(1981) Human Groups and Social Categories: Studies in Social
Psychology.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
36.
Von Streit, C. (2003) ‘Untersuchung zum Arbeitsklima in deutschen
Kulturorchestern–eine bundesweite Fragebogenstudie’, unpublished
master's thesis, Free University of Berlin, Germany.
37.
Wageman, R.
(1995)
‘Interdependence and Group Effectiveness’
, Administrative Science Quarterly40:
145–180
.
38.
Weeks, P.
(1995)
‘A Rehearsal of a Beethoven Passage: An Analysis of Correction Talk’
, Research in Language and Social Interaction29(3):
247–290
.
39.
Weeks, P.
(1996)
‘Synchrony Lost, Synchrony Regained: The Achievement of Musical Co-ordination’
, Human Studies19:
199–228
.
40.
Williamon, A.
and
Davidson, J.W.
(2002)
‘Exploring Co-performer Communication’
, Musicae Scientiae1(1):
53–72
.
41.
Williams, K.Y.
and
O’Reilly
(1998)
‘Demography and Diversity in Organizations’
, Research in Organizational Behavior20:
77–140
.
